| Microtubule Interactions with Chemically Diverse Stabilizing Agents: Thermodynamics of Binding to the Paclitaxel Site Predicts Cytotoxicity Chemistry & Biology, Volume 12, Issue 12, 1 December 2005, Pages 1269-1279 Rubén M. Buey, Isabel Barasoain, Evelyn Jackson, Arndt Meyer, Paraskevi Giannakakou, Ian Paterson, Susan Mooberry, José M. Andreu and J. Fernando Díaz Summary The interactions of microtubules with most compounds described as stabilizing agents have been studied. Several of them (lonafarnib, dicumarol, lutein, and jatrophane polyesters) did not show any stabilizing effect on microtubules. Taccalonolides A and E show paclitaxel-like effects in cells, but they were not able to modulate in vitro tubulin assembly or to bind microtubules, which suggests that other factors are involved in their cellular effects. The binding constants of epothilones, eleutherobin, discodermolide, sarcodictyins, 3,17β-diacetoxy-2-ethoxy-6-oxo-B-homo-estra-1,3,5(10)-triene, and dictyostatin to the paclitaxel site; the critical concentrations of ligand-induced assembly; and their cytotoxicity in carcinoma cells have been measured, and correlations between these parameters have been determined. The inhibition of cell proliferation correlates better with the binding enthalpy change than with the binding constants, suggesting that large, favorable enthalpic contribution to the binding is desired to design paclitaxel site drugs with higher cytotoxicity. Summary | Full Text | PDF (454 kb) |
| Interaction of Epothilone Analogs with the Paclitaxel Binding Site Chemistry & Biology, Volume 11, Issue 2, 1 February 2004, Pages 225-236 Rubén M. Buey, J.Fernando Dı́az, José M. Andreu, Aurora O'Brate, Paraskevi Giannakakou, K.C. Nicolaou, Pradip K. Sasmal, Andreas Ritzén and Kenji Namoto Summary The interactions of epothilone analogs with the paclitaxel binding site of microtubules were studied. The influence of chemical modifications in the C15 side chain and in C12 on binding affinity and microtubule elongation was characterized. Modifications favorable for binding affinity are (1) a thiomethyl group at C21 of the thiazole side chain, (2) a methyl group at C12 in configuration, (3) a pyridine side chain with C15 in configuration, and (4) a cyclopropyl moiety between C12 and C13. The same modification in different ligands has similar effect on affinity, allowing good structure-affinity characterization. The correlation between binding, microtubule stabilization, and cytotoxicity of the compounds has been determined, showing differential effects of the modifications. The binding constants correlate well with IC values, demonstrating that affinity measurements are a useful tool for drug design. Summary | Full Text | PDF (363 kb) |
| Relating Molecular Flexibility to Function: A Case Study of Tubulin Biophysical Journal, Volume 83, Issue 2, 1 August 2002, Pages 663-680 Ozlem Keskin, Stewart R. Durell, Ivet Bahar, Robert L. Jernigan and David G. Covell Abstract Microtubules (MT), along with a variety of associated motor proteins, are involved in a range of cellular functions including vesicle movement, chromosome segregation, and cell motility. MTs are assemblies of heterodimeric proteins, -tubulins, the structure of which has been determined by electron crystallography of zinc-induced, pacilitaxel-stabilized tubulin sheets. These data provide a basis for examining relationships between structural features and protein function. Here, we study the fluctuation dynamics of the tubulin dimer with the aim of elucidating its functional motions relevant to substrate binding, polymerization/depolymerization and MT assembly. A coarse-grained model, harmonically constrained according to the crystal structure, is used to explore the global dynamics of the dimer. Our results identify six regions of collective motion, comprised of structurally close but discontinuous sequence fragments, observed only in the dimeric form, dimerization being a prerequisite for domain identification. Boundaries between regions of collective motions appear to act as linkages, found primarily within secondary-structure elements that lack sequence conservation, but are located at minima in the fluctuation curve, at positions of hydrophobic residues. Residue fluctuations within these domains identify the most mobile regions as loops involved in recognition of the adjacent regions. The least mobile regions are associated with nucleotide binding sites where lethal mutations occur. The functional coupling of motions between and within regions identifies three global motions: torsional and wobbling movements, en bloc, between the - and -tubulin monomers, and stretching longitudinally. Further analysis finds the antitumor drug pacilitaxel (TaxotereR) to reduce flexibility in the M loop of the -tubulin monomer; an effect that may contribute to tightening lateral interactions between protofilaments assembled into MTs. Our analysis provides insights into relationships between intramolecular tubulin movements of MT organization and function. Abstract | Full Text | PDF (2201 kb) |
Copyright © 1996 The Biophysical Society. All rights reserved.
Biophysical Journal, Volume 70, Issue 5, 2408-2420, 1 May 1996
doi:10.1016/S0006-3495(96)79809-0
Research Article
J.F. Diaz, J.M. Andreu, G. Diakun, E. Towns-Andrews and J. Bordas
Centro de Investigationces Biologicas C.S.I.C., Velazquez, Madrid, Spain.
We have studied the self-association reactions of purified GDP-liganded tubulin into double rings and taxoid-induced microtubules, employing synchrotron time-resolved x-ray solution scattering. The experimental scattering profiles have been interpreted by reference to the known scattering profiles to 3 nm resolution and to the low-resolution structures of the tubulin dimer, tubulin double rings, and microtubules, and by comparison with oligomer models and model mixtures. The time courses of the scattering bands corresponding to the different structural features were monitored during the assembly reactions under varying biochemical conditions. GDP-tubulin essentially stays as a dimer at low Mg(2+) ion activity, in either the absence or presence of taxoid. Upon addition of the divalent cations, it associates into either double-ring aggregates or taxoid-induced microtubules by different pathways. Both processes have the formation of small linear (short protofilament-like) tubulin oligomers in common. Tubulin double-ring aggregate formation, which is shown by x-ray scattering to be favored in the GDP- versus the GTP-liganded protein, can actually block microtubule assembly. The tubulin self-association leading to double rings, as determined by sedimentation velocity, is endothermic. The formation of the double-ring aggregates from oligomers, which involves additional intermolecular contacts, is exothermic, as shown by x-ray and light scattering. Microtubule assembly can be initiated from GDP-tubulin dimers or oligomers. Under fast polymerization conditions, after a short lag time, open taxoid-induced microtubular sheets have been clearly detected (monitored by the central scattering and the maximum corresponding to the J(n) Bessel function), which slowly close into microtubules (monitored by the appearance of their characteristic J(0), J(3), and J (n) - (3) Bessel function maxima). This provides direct evidence for the bidimensional assembly of taxoid-induced microtubule polymers in solution and argues against helical growth. The rate of microtubule formation was increased by the same factors known to enhance taxoid-induced microtubule stability. The results suggest that taxoids induce the accretion of the existing Mg(2+)-induced GDP-tubulin oligomers, thus forming small bidimensional polymers that are necessary to nucleate the microtubular sheets, possibly by binding to or modifying the lateral interaction sites between tubulin dimers.