In this study we compared polyamines to various diamines,
and we modeled flexibility as well as hydrophobicity properties of
these molecules to examine possible structural differences that could
explain their external effects on the channels. The natural polyamines
(putrescine, cadaverine, spermidine, spermine) and diamines increasing
in CH2 chain length from C2 to C12 were used to probe maxi
calcium-activated potassium (BK) channels in GH3 pituitary tumor cells
when applied extracellularly. In single-channel recordings we found
polyamines as well as diamines up to 1,10-diaminodecane to be
ineffective in altering channel current amplitudes or kinetics. In
contrast, 1,12-diamino dodecane (1,12-DD) was found to be a reversible
blocker, with a blocking site at an electrical distance (z
) of 0.72 within the channel. It reduced
single-channel current amplitude, mean channel open time, and channel
open probability. In computer simulations structural data, such as
flexibility, hydration, and log D values, were
calculated. 1,12-DD showed the largest flexibility of all diamines
(minimum N-N distance 9.9 Å) combined with a marked hydrophobicity due
to a 4-5 Å hydrophobic intersegment between hydrophilic ends in the
molecule, as confirmed by GRID water probe maps and a log
D value of
1.82 at pH 7.2. We propose that the amount
of hydration of the molecule, more than its flexibility, constitutes an
essential parameter for its ability to act as a channel blocker.
 |
INTRODUCTION |
The major natural polyamines, such as putrescine,
cadaverine, spermidine, and spermine, are ubiquitously present in
procaryotic and eucaryotic cells (Tabor and Tabor, 1984
; Pegg, 1986
).
By their chemical nature, polyamines are aliphatic amines, and are
polybasic and positively charged at physiological pH. Polyamines have
been found to play a role in nerve growth, nerve regeneration, survival of nerve cells, and the regulation of synaptic activity, and they were
found to increase after electrical stimulation of neurons (Pegg and
McCann, 1982
; Bondy and Walker, 1986
; Pajunen et al., 1978
). There is
accumulating evidence that polyamines are involved in modulating or
even regulating receptor- and voltage-operated ion channel activity
(for review see Scott et al., 1993
) and therefore may alter electrical
signaling in the nervous system. When applied to the inside of the cell
membrane, polyamines are responsible for rectification properties of
potassium channels (Fakler et al., 1995
; Ficker et al., 1994
), and we
have recently shown that internal polyamines modulate the activity of
maxi calcium-activated potassium (BK) channels of GH3 cells (Weiger and
Hermann, 1994
). We further found that in neurons of the marine snail
Aplysia californica, polyamines suppress voltage-activated
potassium outward and calcium inward currents when injected into the
cells (Drouin and Hermann, 1994
). If applied to the external side of
the membrane, polyamines modulate NMDA
(N-methyl-D-aspartate) receptor activity
(reviewed in Rock and Macdonald, 1995
), and Gomez and Hellstrand (1995)
reported that spermine and spermidine block voltage-dependent calcium
currents. In contrast to the enhancing effect of polyamines, 1,12-diaminododecane (1,12-DD) and other long-chain diamines that also
interact with NMDA receptors at the polyamine recognition site cause a
voltage-dependent block of the channels. The potency of these blockers
increases as the carbon chain length of the molecules is augmented
(Rock and Macdonalds, 1995
; Romano et al., 1992
). A similar approach
has previously been used to probe the structure of K+
channels by the application of molecules that are variable in chain
length or residues at their ends to the cytoplasmic side (Armstrong,
1971
; Nomura et al., 1990
; for review see Lattore, 1994
). Miller (1982)
probed the sarcoplasmatic reticulum K+-channel from the
trans side by using bis-quaternary ammonium ions and
concluded that long-chain molecules block the channels in a bent-over
configuration.
There is little knowledge about the effects of polyamines when applied
to the extracellular side of BK channels. In this study we used
single-channel recordings to examine the effects of external poly- and
diamines on BK channel activity, and we compared polyamines to various
diamines, in particular to the NMDA reverse agonist, 1,12-diaminododecane. Furthermore, we modeled the flexibility as well
as hydrophilic and hydrophobic properties of these molecules by
computer simulations to examine possible structural differences that
could explain their external effects on the channels.
 |
MATERIALS AND METHODS |
Cell culture
GH3 pituitary tumor cells were obtained from ECACC (European
Collection of Animal Cell Cultures, Salisbury, UK). Cells were cultured
at 37°C and 90% humidity in MEM (minimal essential medium) supplemented with 7% fetal calf serum and 3% horse serum. For experiments cells were split and grown on
poly-D-lysine-coated coverslips used 2-4 days after
seeding.
Electrophysiology and data analysis
Electrophysiological experiments were performed as previously
described in detail (Weiger and Hermann, 1994
). In brief: recordings from outside-out patches were taken by using a List EPC-7, filtered with a three-pole Bessel filter (corner frequency 3 kHz), stored on
digital tape, DTR 1200 (Biologic, France), and off-line sampled at 12 kHz on a personal computer with the help of pClamp software (Axon
Instruments, Foster City, CA). Test solutions were applied via a
perfusion system (NPI electronics, Munich, Germany). Data were analyzed
with pClamp software. Single-channel current amplitudes were calculated
by fitting amplitude histograms to a Gaussian distribution. The channel
open probability was estimated according to Po = [to/ttot]/n,
where Po is the open probability for one channel, to is the sum of open times,
ttot is the total recording time, and
n is the number of individual channels observed in the patch. For analysis of channel open time distributions, samples were
collected from selected bursts exhibiting only one open level. Open
time distributions were fitted to a second-order exponential with
pClamp software. Each experiment was repeated at least three times, and
mean as well as SEM (standard error of the mean) were calculated.
Significance levels were determined by using Student's t-test.
Solutions and chemicals
The standard bath solution contained (in mM) 145 NaCl, 5 KCl, 1 MgCl2, 0.01 CaCl2, 20 glucose, 10 HEPES (pH
7.2). The regular pipette solution contained (in mM) 140 KCl, 2 MgCl2, 20 glucose, 20 HEPES, 1 EGTA, 0.88 CaCl2
(pH 7.2), resulting in a free calcium concentration of 1 × 10
6 M Ca2+, as calculated with Equal software
(Biosoft, Cambridge, UK). Poly- or diamines were added to the bath
solution and the pH was corrected if necessary. For rapid solution
exchange, membrane patches were held in a stream of experimental
solution from a second pipette.
Media for cell culture were from Biochrom (Seromed, Berlin, Germany),
and sera were from PAA (Linz, Austria); all other chemicals were from
Sigma (Vienna, Austria).
Molecular modeling
For computer modeling, molecular mechanics methods were used as
implemented in the computer program SYBYL (Versions 6.0 and 6.1, 1995;
Tripos Associates, St. Louis, MO). Flexibility estimations were
obtained using molecular dynamics simulations measuring distances between N atoms, which can be calculated from conformation changes at
room temperature. Molecules were considered fully protonated for the
simulation unless stated otherwise; atom partial charges were
calculated using the method of Gasteiger and Marsili (1980)
. To start
the simulation process, a 20 ps thermal activation at 2000 K was
applied to the molecules. The following 100 ps was simulated at room
temperature (300 K) with time increments of 1 fs. Data were collected
after stable conditions were reached. Maximum and minimum distances of
the N atoms were calculated, indicating the molecules' flexibility.
Hydrophilicity maps were calculated using the water probe of the GRID
force field (Goodford, 1985
), to explore the amount and dimensions of
hydration shells surrounding the molecules in its fully protonated
state, as is the case in our experimental solutions.
Log D calculation
Log D values (which represent pKa
corrected log P values, i.e., the logarithm of the partition
coefficient of the compound between water and 1-octanol at a defined
pH) of the tested compounds were calculated with the software package
PALLAS (Version 1.2, 1995; CompuDrug Chemistry, Budapest, Hungary).
This program is based on Rekker's (1977)
collection of hydrophobic
fragmental constants derived from an extended "knowledge
engineering" improved set of ~1000 log P values in the
1-octanol/water system.
 |
RESULTS |
Effects of poly- and diamines on BK channels
In outside-out patches, BK channels were recorded and
characterized as reported previously (Weiger and Hermann, 1994
). The channel conductance was 161 ± 6.9 pS (n = 9)
under control conditions. The addition of polyamines (cadaverine,
putrescine, spermidine, or spermine) in concentrations up to 10 mM at a
holding potential of +40 mV, as well as diamines from a carbohydrat
chain length of 2-10 C atoms, did not significantly change the channel
mean open time or the open probability (data not shown). Unitary
current amplitudes were reduced by cadaverine (10% ± 2.3%;
n = 3), spermidine (13% ± 5.1%; n = 3), and spermine (19% ± 5.9%; n = 3) at
concentrations of 10 mM; putrescine had no effect. Of the other
diamines examined (C2-C10), only hexandiamine and diaminopropane were
found to reduce single-channel current amplitudes at a concentration of
10 mM by 9% ± 2.5%, n = 3, and 12% ± 0.8%,
n = 3, respectively. In contrast, 1,12-diaminododecane,
a molecule similar to putrescine (differing only in the carbohydrate
chain length) when applied to the outside of the membrane blocked
channels in a dose-dependent, reversible manner in much lower
concentrations. It reduced the current amplitude as well as the mean
channel open time and open probability (Fig. 1). The dose-response curve could be
fitted to the equation
|
(1)
|
where Y is the normalized response, c is the
concentration, n is the Hill coefficient, and
EC50 is the half-maximum concentration of the drug. At a
holding potential of 0 mV, the EC50 for the reduction of
the single-channel current amplitude was 4.8 mM, with a Hill
coefficient of 0.8 (Fig. 2). At +40
mV, EC50 was 0.87 mM for the block of the mean channel open
time, with a Hill coefficient of 1.38, and 0.41 mM for the reduction of
the channel open probability, with a Hill coefficient of 2.22. The data
indicate a one-to-one interaction in terms of channel current amplitude
and mean open time between the blocking molecule and the channel. The
reduction of the current amplitude implicates a fast blocking mechanism due to a limited frequency response of the recording system as described originally by Fitzhugh (1983)
. To estimate block and unblock
rates, all-point amplitude histograms were generated from current
traces of 50-100 ms duration. The reduction of the single-channel current amplitude can be described by a two-state process where the
open channel is seen to flicker rapidly between a blocked and an
unblocked state with a unblocking rate
and a blocking rate
. If
the current signal is passed through a first-order filter with a time
constant
, the amplitude distribution of the filtered output is a
-distribution that can be described by
|
(2)
|
where a =
/
and b = 
,
the effective time constant
= 0.228/fc,
where fc is the
3 dB frequency of a three-pole
Bessel filter (3 kHz in our case), and the
-function is given by
|
(3)
|
All-point amplitude histograms from experiments with 1 mM 1,12-DD
at a holding potential of +40 mV were normalized to their corresponding
control values and corrected for baseline shifts. Corrected histograms
were fitted to a
-distribution with the help of Prism software
(Graphpad Inplot, San Diego, CA) and convolved with a Gaussian
distribution fitted to the closed state of the channel (Fig.
3, A and B). The
block and unblock rates obtained are shown in Figs. 3, C and
D, respectively. Whereas the blocking rate,
, increased
with higher concentrations of the blocker, the unblocking rate,
,
did not change significantly with increasing amounts of 1,12-DD,
indicating an open channel block (Neher and Steinbach, 1978
).

View larger version (33K):
[in this window]
[in a new window]
|
FIGURE 1
Recording of maxi calcium-activated potassium (BK)
channel during control; after application of 0.3, 1, and 3 mM
1,12-diaminododecane (1, 12-DD); and after washout of the drug.  ,
Closed states; ·····, first, second, and third open levels.
Pipette calcium concentration 1 µM. Holding potential +40 mV.
|
|

View larger version (15K):
[in this window]
[in a new window]
|
FIGURE 2
Dose-response curve of the effect of
1,12-diaminododecane on BK single-channel current amplitudes. Holding
potential 0 mV, n = 4.
|
|

View larger version (10K):
[in this window]
[in a new window]
|
FIGURE 3
(A) Current amplitude distribution
fitted to two Gaussians under control conditions; holding potential +40
mV. The first peak represents the closed level, and the second peak
represents the open state. (B) Amplitude histogram of a
patch held at +40 mV in the presence of 1 mM 1,12-diaminododecane. The
closed level was fitted to a Gaussian curve, the broadened and skewed
open level peak was fitted with a -distribution as described in the text. (C) Block rate at
different concentrations of 1,12-diamonododecane obtained from
-distributions at a holding potential of +40 mV, fitted to a linear
regression. Each point represents the mean of two or three individual
patches. (D) Unblock rate at different concentrations of
1,12-diamonododecane obtained from -distributions at a holding
potential of +40 mV, fitted to a linear regression. There was no
signifcant deviation from zero (p = 0.21). Each
point represents the mean of two or three individual patches.
|
|
The amount of amplitude reduction was voltage dependent and was found
to be higher at low command voltages, as shown by plotting the data
according to the model of Woodhull (1973)
(Fig.
4). This model
describes the relative channel conductance as
|
(4)
|
where
o is the conductance under control
conditions;
b is the conductance in the presence of
1,12-DD; Kd(0) is the dissociation constant at
zero voltage; z
is the effective valence at the blocking site, where z is the valence of 1,12-DD and
is a measure
of the voltage dependence or electrical distance of the block;
V is the membrane voltage; and F, R,
and T have their usual meanings. In its more convenient
linear form, this equation is
|
(5)
|
where z
can be determined from the slope of the
graph times RT/F (0.025 V) and
Kd(0) from the zero voltage intercept of the
plot:
|
(6)
|
From the plot in Fig. 4, the value for the effective valence was
calculated to be 0.72 (z is assumed to be 1; see also
Discussion) and Kd(0) = 4.2 mM. It is evident
that the blocking effect increases as the membrane voltage is made more
negative. This is expected if a cationic blocker enters the channel
from the outside of the membrane, because the voltage convention
defines the outside as zero voltage.

View larger version (14K):
[in this window]
[in a new window]
|
FIGURE 4
Voltage dependence of 1,12-diaminododecane (1 mM)
channel block. The y axis represents the relation of
single-channel conductance under control ( 0) versus
blocked conditions ( b). The solid line was fitted by
regression to the linear form of the Woodhull equation as given in the
text (n = 6).
|
|
Assuming a 1:1 reaction between the molecule and the channel pore, as
the Hill coefficient from the dose-response relationship suggests, it
is possible to calculate the number of sites in the channel that are
not occupied by 1,12-DD:
|
(7)
|
with a binding constant
|
(8)
|
where D is 1,12-DD and [Rb] is
the concentration of the sites that can be occupied.
The total number of sites in the channel [Rt]
that are either occupied [RbD] or
unoccupied [Rb] (but, in principle, can be occupied) or can never be occupied [Ru] by 1,12-DD is
defined by
|
(9)
|
Because the concentration of free sites [R] is
|
(10)
|
|
(11)
|
and
|
(12)
|
Normalized channel current amplitude data obtained at +40 mV were
fitted to the above equation with a K of 185/M (Fig.
5). The fraction of sites that cannot be
occupied by 1,12-DD
([Ru]/[Rt]) was 0.05, indicating that 95% of the binding sites were occupied by the
molecule.

View larger version (15K):
[in this window]
[in a new window]
|
FIGURE 5
Reduction of single-channel current amplitude by
1,12-diaminododecane at various concentrations. The solid line was
fitted to Eq. 12 as given in the text. Holding potential +40 mV
(n = 4).
|
|
To investigate whether the observed reduction of current amplitude was
artificially due to an altered gating of channels, open time
distributions were analyzed. Open time distributions were fitted to a
second-order exponential with two time constants (
1,
2). At control,
1 was 0.73 ± 0.18 ms, and
2 was 5.5 ± 1.2 ms (n = 3 ± SEM, holding potential +40 mV). At a concentration of 0.3 mM
1,12-DD, which reduces open probablity to 74% ± 23% (n = 3 ± SEM, holding potential +40 mV) of
control, but affects single-channel current amplitude only sligthly,
1 was 0.82 ± 0.21 ms and
2 was
4.0 ± 0.82 ms (n = 3 ± SEM, holding
potential +40 mV). There was no statistic significant difference
between control and experimental conditions.
Molecular modeling
Molecular dimensions were calculated for 1,12-DD and
tetraethylammonium (TEA). TEA had a cross-sectional diameter of 9 Å as calculated by Sybyl, whereas 1,12-DD was found to have a maximum cross-sectional diameter of 4-5 Å (Fig.
6). For comparison, potassium ions have a
diameter of 2.8 Å (Marcus, 1988
) (Fig. 6).

View larger version (72K):
[in this window]
[in a new window]
|
FIGURE 6
Molecular dimensions of (top) potassium
(diameter 2.8 Å); (middle) tetraethylammonium (TEA)
(diameter 9 Å); and (bottom) 1,12-diaminododecane drawn
in its maximum bend-over formation with an N-N distance of 9.9 Å (cross-sectional diameter of a single amino group of
1,12-diaminododecane, 4-5 Å). Note that 1,12-diamodocecane in this
configuration occupies 4.8 Å more space (maximum diameter 13.8 Å)
than TEA does.
|
|
Fig. 7 shows a plot of N-N distances of
1,12-DD versus time. The molecule exhibits large oscillations in N-N
distances during the first 20 ps of thermal activation at 2000 K to
start the simulation process and then settles between 9.9 Å and 13.8 Å at room temperature (300 K), from which data were taken. Estimation
of the flexibilities of different molecules revealed that spermine is
the most flexible of the molecules tested (Fig.
8). Relative distances of
N1-N4 were in a range from 6 Å to 13.8 Å. All
other poly- and diamines had lower flexibilities, except 1,12-DD, which
had a flexibility of 9.9-13.75 Å (Fig. 8). The flexibility of 1,12-DD
was little changed if only one amino group was protonated (12.9-15.4
Å). To compare our calculated values with those in the literature, we
also estimated flexibilities of some bis-quaternary ammonium ions, such
as hexamethyldecanamine and hexamethyldodecandiamine (Fig. 8). From
these results it appears that the flexibility of a molecule might play
a role in easing its access to the channel pore and its binding
site(s).

View larger version (31K):
[in this window]
[in a new window]
|
FIGURE 7
Molecular modeling: simulation of N-N distances of
1,12-diaminododecane. Note thermal activation during the first 20 ps at
2000 K (large amplitudes). The following 100 ps were simulated at room
temperature (300 K). The x axis time is in ps (=
10 12 s); the y axis N-N distance is in
Å.
|
|

View larger version (11K):
[in this window]
[in a new window]
|
FIGURE 8
N-N distances (Å) for various molecules at 300 K
(with both amino groups being protonated). Cn, diamines
with n C-chain length; PUT, putrescine; CAD,
cadaverine; SPD, spermidine; SP, spermine; bis-Q10,
hexamethyldecanamine; bis-Q12, hexamethyl-dodecandiamine. Note that
C12M is 1,12-diaminododecane, with only one amino group protonated.
|
|
However, spermine, a molecule that has a flexibility similar to that of
1,12-DD, is almost ineffective in altering channel conductance or
kinetics. Therefore, further differences between the molecules with
respect to their blocking efficacy were expected. It is well known that
the hydration of a molecule is important for its ability to enter or
pass through a channel. The question concerning the hydration of
polyamines and amines tested was therefore addressed by using the GRID
water probe approach. As expected, the results showed that all
molecules in their fully protonated state have shells of water around
their positively charged amino groups (Fig.
9). Diamines with a carbohydrate chain
length up to 8, including putrescine, were found to be completely
surrounded by a water shell, as were spermidine and spermine, because
of their additional amino groups within the molecule. Beginning with a
carbohydrate chain length of 10, water shells appeared to be divided
into two distinct baskets at both ends of diamine molecules according
to the presence of amino groups with a hydrophobic segment in between.
1,12-DD was found to have a hydrophobic intersegment of 4.0-5.0 Å (Fig. 9). It appears possible, therefore, that differences in hydration
are also involved in determining whether the molecule is able to reach
a binding site within the channel pore.

View larger version (102K):
[in this window]
[in a new window]
|
FIGURE 9
Hydrophilicity maps as calculated by the GRID
waterprobe. From top to bottom: putrescine, spermine,
1,12-diaminododecane. The basket structures around the molecules
indicate the hydration shells. Note the marked hydrophobic region
between the terminal water baskets of 1,12-diaminododecane.
|
|
We further calculated log D values, which provide
information about the hydrophobicity of a molecule; for all naturally
occurring polyamines, for 1,10-diaminodecane as well as for 1,12-DD
(Table 1, negative values indicate
hydrophilicity and positive values indicate lipophilicity. The results
obtained at pH 7.2 and experimental concentrations of K+,
Na+, and Cl
confirmed the simulations
obtained with the GRID water probe. Hydrophilicity decreased in the
order spermine > spermidine > putrescine > 1,10-diaminodecane > 1,12-DD. Hence 1,12-DD was the molecule with
the least hydrophilicity at physiological pH and was found to become
hydrophobic at more basic pH values, in contrast to polyamines (data
not shown).
View this table:
[in this window]
[in a new window]
|
TABLE 1
Log D values at pH 7.2 and [K+] + [Na+] = 150 mM, [Cl ] = 152 mM
corresponding to the bathing solutions used in electrophysiological
experiments
|
|
 |
DISCUSSION |
1,12-DD, when applied from the extracellular side, was found to be
an effective blocker of BK channels in GH3 cells, whereas diamines
shorter than 1,12-DD as well as naturally occurring polyamines were
unable to affect channel kinetics with respect to channel open
probability or mean open time. These results are in agreement with
earlier data showing that spermine was only effective if applied to the
inside of the cell membrane but not when applied to the outside (Weiger
and Hermann, 1994
).
It appears possible that the action of 1,12-DD is the result of surface
charge effects due to its two positive charges. In fact, there are
contradictory reports about the influence of positive net charges on
channel activity. Copello et al. (1991)
reported that an increase in
external positive charges caused by lowering pH results in a reduced
activity of BK channels from gall bladder epithelial cells. On the
other hand, Cornejo et al. (1989)
reported that changing external pH
had no effect on BK channels. In any case, it is expected that
molecules with more positive charges have a greater impact on negative
surface charges. Our data imply that the reduction of channel activity
by 1,12-DD is unlikely to be caused by compensation of negative surface
charges, because spermine, with four positive charges at physiological
pH, was almost ineffective. Furthermore, 1,12-DD and all other diamines with two positive charges would have been expected to be about equally
effective, which is not the case.
The view of a 1:1 reaction of 1,12-DD with its target inside the
channel is supported by a Hill coefficient of 0.8 for the reduction of
single-channel current amplitude. We further estimated that 1,12-DD
occupies 95% of available binding sites. An additional, so far unknown
second site of action is expected for the reduction of channel open
probability. Reduction of channel open probability appears to be caused
by a slow blocking mechanism. The reduction of single-channel current
amplitude by 1,12-DD can be explained by a fast block, where unblock
and block rates cannot be resolved by the recording system. This is in
accordance with the analysis of
-distributions fitted to all-point
amplitude histograms confirming a filtered two-state process of a fast
flickery block. Blocking and unblocking rates are in a similar range,
as previously reported by Yellen (1984)
for cesium and sodium ions in
this channel. Furthermore, with increasing concentrations of 1,12-DD,
blocking rates were augmented, whereas the unblocking rate was not
affected, as expected from an open channel block model (Neher and
Steinbach, 1978
). A similar combination of a fast and slow blocking
mechanism has been described previously by Bokvist et al. (1990)
for
the action of external tetraethylammonium on calcium-activated
potassium channels from mouse pancreas.
BK channels have been shown to be permeable to ammonium
(NH4+) ions (Blatz and Magleby, 1984
). From dimensional
considerations, this implies that the heads of diamines, which are of a
size similar to that of NH4+, should be able to enter
the channel. Our data, however, imply that the diameter is not the only
parameter that indicates whether a diamine will act as a blocker,
because variation in chain length caused considerable differences in
efficacy. In the following we will discuss aspects that may help to
explain the different actions of various amines in channel activity.
The finding that 1,12-DD has an effective valence, z
, of
0.72 can be interpreted in two ways. According to a model presented by
Miller (1982)
, bis-quaternary ammonium ions, which differ from 1,12-DD
only in the residue at each end of the methylene chain, bind to their
target sites within the channel pore in a bend-over conformation. Here
both amino groups of these molecules are able to interact with binding
sites at the same electrical distance, giving effective valences of
half the values calculated. Supposing a bend-over situation in the
channel, it may be expected that 1) the molecule slips in its extended
form into the channel, binds to one target site, and 2) bends over and
attaches with its tail to a second site within the channel at the same
electrical distance, i.e., close to the first amino residue. This
implicates a channel dimension that gives the molecule enough space to
bend over. Simulating the above situation for 1,12-DD at its closest
N-N distance (9.9 Å), it is still larger in its maximum diameter (13.8 Å) than TEA (9 Å). This suggests that 1,12-DD is not able to pass the
TEA binding site (at z
= 0.2) in its maximum bend-over
form, because in this conformation the molecule has a diameter that is
4.8 Å larger than TEA. It is more likely, therefore, that 1,12-DD
enters the channel in its extended form and then binds to a site within the channel. Once in the narrow channel pore, it appears even less
likely that the second amino group of the 1,12-DD molecule is able to
bend over and attach to a binding site.
It should be noted that there is a sudden increase in flexibility with
1,12-DD compared to smaller diamines. These calculations of flexibility
are generally in accordance with the observations of Dufourcq et al.
(1972)
, who investigated the conformation of dimethonium ions of
various lengths by NMR. They showed methylene groups to rotate freely,
but unfortunately they do not report N-N distances for longer diamines.
Only spermine has a length similar to that of 1,12-DD (N-N interatomic
distance of 16.024 Å versus 16.582 Å, respectively, in a fully
extended, linear conformation) and therefore the capacity to almost
bend over. The high flexibility of spermine is probably caused by the
two N atoms in the middle of the molecule. If a bent-over conformation
is involved in the blockade of channels, spermine is expected to be a
prime candidate. However, spermine, irrespective of its high
flexibility, is not an effective channel blocker if applied to the
external side. This further supports our view that it is unlikely that
1,12-DD blocks in a bent-over confirmation. Moreover, our calculations of flexibilities for bis-quaternary ammonium ions (alkane chain n = 10 and 12) suggest that they are probably also too
rigid to bind in a bent-over form within the narrow part of the
channel. However, it is difficult to compare bis-quaternary amonium
ions directly to 1,12-DD, because despite the fact that both molecules have approximately the same length, the residues are quite different in
their three-dimensional size, which may lead to different binding sites
of the molecules within the channel.
From our data it appears that 1,12-DD either senses only one binding
site within the channel at an electrical distance of 0.72, or both
positive charges bind to different sites that add up to 0.72. The
latter situation predicts that shorter diamines should also be able to
interact with a site located close to the channel entrance, for
instance, like the extracellular TEA binding site, which has an
effective valence of 0.13-0.20 (reviewed in Lattore, 1994
). Our
results do not support this notion, because all shorter poly- and
diamines were ineffective, indicating 1,12-DD to have only one binding
site within the channel, which is different from the TEA binding site.
Ruppersberg et al. (1994)
suggest that the effective volume including
bound water molecules of a large organic blocker like
argiotoxin636 (ATX) causes an overestimation of the
effective valence. This appears not to apply to our case, because 1)
1,12-DD is much smaller compared to ATX, and 2) BK channels have been
shown to exhibit four binding sites for K+, one of them
with an electrical distance of 0.7 (Neyton and Miller, 1988
), which is
in excellent accordance with our findings of 1,12-DD. Furthermore, this
site is also close to a z
of 0.65 for bis-quaternary ammonium ion (bis-Q5 to bis-Q8) blockers as reported by Miller (1982)
for sarcoplasmatic reticulum potassium channels. In theory, one could
expect diamines of the right length as well as naturally occurring
polyamines to interact with all four K+-binding sites
within the channel. However, because of the different dehydration
energies of these molecules needed to enter the channel (see below),
they appear to be excluded from interaction with these sites.
A further major difference of 1,12-DD compared to the other amines
tested is its hydrophobic intersegment between hydrophilic terminal
groups. It is feasible, therefore, that an interaction of the
hydrophobic intersegment of 1,12-DD with a hydrophobic patch or pocket
within the channel occurs. In this way the blocking action is supposed
to be stabilized, as suggested by Miller (1982)
for bis-quaternary
ammonium blockers with an increasing CH2 chain length. With
respect to the amines investigated, only 1,12-DD is long and flexible
enough to reach its binding site within the channel. We therefore
further propose that one amino group remains hydrated within the
channel vestibule outside the electrical field, which minimizes its
energy needs when entering the channel's tunnel, because only one of
the hydration shells on each end of the molecule has to be removed.
This view is confirmed by log D values as well as GRID water
probe simulations, indicating that 1,12-DD is the least hydrated
molecule tested and therefore has the lowest energy barrier when
entering the channel.
It has been suggested by several authors that K+ channels
are not symmetrical with respect to their inner and outer vestibules and TEA blocking sites (Hermann and Gorman, 1981
; Gray et al., 1988
;
Villarroel et al., 1988
; Lang and Ritchie, 1990
; Nomura et al., 1990
).
The cytoplasmic side of the channel appears to be much wider than the
extracellular side, which, in contrast, is more sensitive to a block by
TEA and cannot be accessed by bulky ions, like the muscle relaxant
gallamine (Nomura et al., 1990
). The TEA binding site in BK channels of
GH3 cells is at an electrical distance of <0.2 and has a binding
constant of 260 µM when applied to the outside (Lang and Ritchie,
1990
). 1,12-DD, containing an amino residue at each end of the alkyl
chain, is smaller in diameter than TEA and is therefore able to slip
deeper into the channel. Our finding that polyamines were ineffective up to a concentration of 10 mM when applied to the outside, as well as
our previous data (Weiger and Hermann, 1994
) showing polyamines to
affect the channel from the cytoplasmatic side, supports the notion
that this channel is not symmetrical.
External TEA is the most efficient blocker of calcium-activated
K+ channels in Aplysia neurons, whereas
increasing the hydrocarbon chain length of one of the side chains
decreases the binding ability of the compound (Hermann and Gorman,
1981
). Villarroel et al. (1988)
found externally applied bis-quaternary
compounds to block BK channels with an increasing
Kd(0) as the methylene chain length was
increased (up to five CH2-groups), which was accompanied by a decrease in the effective valence z
. They interpreted
these results by proposing a hydrophilic segment at the entrance of the
channel, which constitutes a barrier for hydrophobic molecules. Our
results show that polyamines as well as short diamines are not able to
interact with the channel, even if they are more hydrophilic compared
to bis-quaternary compounds. In contrast, 1,12-DD, which has a large
hydrophobic intersegment, was an effective blocker. This might be due
to the smaller size of the terminal amino groups compared to
bis-quaternary ammonium molecules, allowing the molecule to interact
with additional sites within the channel. It is also feasible that
variations in the structure of BK channels from different cells, such
as a hydrophobic pouch in channels (Miller, 1982
), play a role.
In conclusion, our results indicate that BK channels of GH3 cells have
a blocking site for 1,12-DD at 72% of the voltage drop across the
membrane when applied from the outside. All other diamines, as well as
naturally occurring polyamines, are excluded from the channel, which
can be explained by the distance of their charges, by their low
flexibility, or most likely by the amount of hydration and hence their
higher energy barrier upon entering the channel.
We thank Verena Kainz for technical help, Prof. P. Goodford for
providing the GRIN/GRID software, and the EDV-Zentrum der Universität Innsbruck for the computational facilities.
This work was supported by Österreichische Nationalbank, grant
5389, and the Medical Research Coordination Center, University of
Salzburg.
Address reprint requests to Dr. Thomas M. Weiger, Department of Animal
Physiology, Institute of Zoology, University of Salzburg,
Hellbrunnerstrasse 34, A-5020 Salzburg, Austria. Tel.:
43-662-8044-5679; Fax: 43-662-8044-5698; E-mail:
thomas.weiger{at}sbg.ac.at.