| HOME | HELP | FEEDBACK | SUBSCRIPTIONS | ARCHIVE | SEARCH | TABLE OF CONTENTS |
Biophys J, October 1998, p. 2038-2049, Vol. 75, No. 4
*Physik Department E22 (Biophysics Group), Technische Universität München, D-85748 Garching, Germany, and #Department of Cell Biology and Anatomy, University of North Carolina, Chapel Hill, North Carolina 27599-7090 USA
| |
ABSTRACT |
|---|
|
|
|---|
A magnetic bead microrheometer has been designed which
allows the generation of forces up to 104 pN on 4.5 µm
paramagnetic beads. It is applied to measure local viscoelastic
properties of the surface of adhering fibroblasts. Creep response and
relaxation curves evoked by tangential force pulses of 500-2500 pN (and
~1 s duration) on the magnetic beads fixed to the integrin receptors
of the cell membrane are recorded by particle tracking. Linear
three-phasic creep responses consisting of an elastic deflection, a
stress relaxation, and a viscous flow are established. The viscoelastic
response curves are analyzed in terms of a series arrangement of a
dashpot and a Voigt body, which allows characterization of the
viscoelastic behavior of the adhering cell surface in terms of three
parameters: an effective elastic constant, a viscosity, and a
relaxation time. The displacement field generated by the local
tangential forces on the cell surface is visualized by observing the
induced motion of assemblies of nonmagnetic colloidal probes fixed to
the membrane. It is found that the displacement field decays rapidly
with the distance from the magnetic bead. A cutoff radius of
Rc ~ 7 µm of the screened elastic field
is established. Partial penetration of the shear field into the
cytoplasm is established by observing the induced deflection of
intracellular compartments. The cell membrane was modeled as a thin
elastic plate of shear modulus µ* coupled to a viscoelastic layer,
which is fixed to a solid support on the opposite side; the former
accounts for the membrane/actin cortex, and the latter for the
contribution of the cytoskeleton to the deformation of the cell
envelope. It is characterized by the coupling constant
characterizing the elasticity of the cytoskeleton. The coupling
constant
and the surface shear modulus µ* are obtained from the
measured displacements of the magnetic and nonmagnetic beads. By
analyzing the experimental data in terms of this model a surface shear
modulus of µ*
2 · 10
3 Pa m to 4 · 10
3 Pa m is found. By assuming an approximate plate
thickness of 0.1 µm one estimates an average bulk shear modulus of µ
(2
4) · 10
4 Pa, which is in
reasonable agreement with data obtained by atomic force microscopy. The
viscosity of the dashpot is related to the apparent viscosity of the
cytoplasm, which is obtained by assuming that the top membrane is
coupled to the bottom (fixed) membrane by a viscous medium. By
application of the theory of diffusion of membrane proteins in
supported membranes we find a coefficient of friction of
bc
2 · 109 Pa s/m
corresponding to a cytoplasmic viscosity of 2 · 103
Pa s.
| |
INTRODUCTION |
|---|
|
|
|---|
Viscoelasticity plays an important role in the
behavior of cells. It is a key factor in the regulation of the cell
shape of resting and moving cells, and it has even been conjectured
that the viscoelastic coupling between the plasma membrane and the cell
nucleus plays a role in the control of genetic expression (Ingber,
1997
; Forgacs, 1996
). The cell viscoelasticity is determined in a
complex way by the composite shell envelope composed of the lipid-protein bilayer with the associated actin cortex and by the
internal cytoskeleton composed of actin microfilaments, microtubules, intermediate filaments, and their associated proteins. High-precision measurements of viscoelastic parameters of cells are thus expected to
give insight into the structure of the cortical and internal cytoskeleton. Moreover, such measurements are of great practical value
in order to quantify the effect of drugs, mutations, or diseases on
the cell structure. Viscoelastic measuring techniques must fulfill
three conditions. First, they must allow local measurements on
micrometer-to-nanometer scales to account for the inherent heterogeneous architecture of cell envelopes. Since cellular
deformations may be followed by biochemically induced changes of the
local viscoelastic parameters, the techniques must secondly allow
repeated measurements. To compare the data, the third requirement is
that the data analysis is independent of a specific cell model. These requirements are fulfilled by microrheological techniques based on
optical tweezers (Choquet et al., 1997
), atomic force microscopy (Radmacher et al., 1996
), magnetic bead rheometry (Ziemann et al.,
1994
), and cell poking elastometer (Pasternak et al., 1995
). An
intriguing magnetic particle technique used to assay the cytoplasmic viscosity and intracellular mobilities has been developed by Valberg et
al. (cf. Valberg and Feldman, 1987
). It is based on the analysis of the
decay of remnant magnetic fields after twisting the magnetic particles.
It corresponds to our relaxation response analysis. The major
differences of this technique as compared to the others is that many
particles distributed within the cell are monitored. Moreover, the
method yields average values of the cytoplasmic viscosities.
Another strategy used to measure local elastic properties was
established recently. It is based on the analysis of the surface profile of adhering cells near the contact area and its alteration by
viscous shear forces in terms of the elastic boundary (Simson et al.,
1998
).
Many cell types such as Dictyostelium cells, white blood
cells, fibroblasts, or endothelial cells exhibit elastic moduli of the
order of 103 to 104 Pa and forces in the
nanonewton regime are required for the deformation of these cells (cf.
Evans, 1995
; Radmacher et al., 1996
). For this purpose, we developed a
magnetic bead microrheometer ("magnetic tweezers") allowing
application of local forces of up to 10 nN on paramagnetic beads of 4.5 µm diameter. This technique is applied to measure viscoelastic
parameters of the cell envelope of fibroblasts adhering to solid
substrates.
Magnetic beads (of 4.5 µm diameter) coated with fibronectin are fixed
to integrin receptors of the cell surface. Creep response and
relaxation curves evoked by tangential force pulses of 500-2500 pN (and
~1 s duration) are determined by the particle tracking technique. A
linear viscoelastic response is found for forces up to 2 nN in contrast
to the increase of local stiffness with stress amplitude reported by
Ingber (1997)
.
Three-phasic creep response curves exhibiting an elastic domain, a
relaxation regime, and viscous flow behavior are found. This
three-phasic response is formally accounted for by a mechanical equivalent circuit consisting of a Voigt body and a dashpot in series
where the Voigt element (composed of a Maxwell body and a spring in
parallel arrangement) accounts for the solidlike and the dashpot for
the fluidlike behavior. Based on the above analysis the viscoelastic
behavior of the cell is characterized by three parameters: an elastic
constant (k), a relaxation time (
), and a viscosity
(
0).
To relate these parameters to viscoelastic moduli of the cell envelope
and the cytoplasm, the adhering cell lobe is modeled by a thin elastic
plate which is coupled to a viscoelastic layer fixed on the side
opposite to the substrate. The elasticity of the top plate
(representing the plasma membrane) is characterized by a surface shear
modulus µ*. It is related to the shear modulus µ of the material as
µ* = µh, where h is the thickness of the shell composed of the membrane and actin cortex. The elastic effect of
the intermediate layer is characterized by a phenomenological coupling
constant
, referred to as the cytoskeleton coupling constant.
According to a theory of A. Boulbitch (1998, submitted for publication;
cf. Appendix for summary) the displacement field generated by a
local tangential force on the top membrane exhibits a logarithmic behavior in the plane of the membrane at distances r much
smaller than a screening length Rc while it
decays exponentially at r
Rc. The screening
length Rc is related to the shear modulus µ*
and the coupling constant
by Rc = 
1 = (µ*/
)1/2.
Experimental evidence for such a screened elastic deformation of the
cell surface is provided by accompanying displacement field mapping
experiments (Schmidt et al., 1996
). The local displacement of the
membrane surface evoked by the local tangential force is directly
visualized by observing the induced motion of colloidal probe beads
attached to the cell membrane in the neighborhood of the magnetic bead.
It is demonstrated that the displacement field decays rapidly with a
cutoff radius of Rc
7 µm. By analyzing the
observed decay of the displacement field with the distance from the
magnetic bead in terms of the theoretical model, one obtains values of
and µ*. It is thus possible to relate the elastic constant
(k) obtained from the equivalent circuit analysis to an
absolute shear modulus of the cell envelope.
For the evaluation of the viscous flow regime it is assumed that the
top membrane of the adhering cell lobe is coupled to the bottom (fixed)
membrane by a viscous fluid. The apparent viscosity of this fluid is
obtained from the velocity of the magnetic bead by application of a
theory previously elaborated to describe the diffusion of proteins
embedded in a bilayer membrane coupled to a solid surface through a
thin lubricating film (Evans and Sackmann, 1988
). This theory predicts
that the viscous flow field in the membrane is again screened by this
frictional coupling (Evans and Sackmann, 1988
). Thus the viscosity of
the cytoplasm can also be related to the value of the viscosity of the
dashpot
0. The screened penetration of the shear field
into the cytoplasm was observed by the induced deflection of
intracellular compartments.
| |
MATERIALS AND METHODS |
|---|
|
|
|---|
The high force magnetic bead rheometer
The microrheometer resembles the experimental set-up described
previously (Ziemann et al., 1994
; Schmidt et al., 1996
). It consists of
a central measuring unit comprised of a sample holder and a magnetic
coil with 1200 turns of 0.7 mm copper wire. The sample holder with
dimension 50 × 55 × 50 mm3 is mounted on an
AXIOVERT 10 microscope (Zeiss, Oberkochen, Germany). The coil current
is produced by a voltage-controlled current supply built in the
authors' laboratory that transforms the voltage signal of a function
generator FG 9000 (ELV, Leer, Germany) in a current signal with
amplitudes of up to 4 A. The microscope image is recorded by a CCD
camera (C3077, Hamamatsu Photonics, Hamamatsu City, Japan) connected to
a VCR (WJ-MX30, Matsushita Electric Industrial Co., Osaka, Japan). The
recorded sequences are digitized using an Apple Power Macintosh 9500 (Apple Computer, Cupertino, CA) equipped with a LG3 frame grabber card
(Scion Corp., Frederick, MD). The position of the particles is
determined with an accuracy of ~10 nm using a self-written single
particle tracking algorithm implemented in the public domain image
processing software National Institutes of Health Image (National
Institutes of Health, Bethesda, MD).
The important modification of the present apparatus, compared to the
previous one, is that only one magnetic coil is used in which the edge
of the pole piece can be positioned as close as 10 µm from the
magnetic particle (see Fig. 1). Because
of the very high field gradient in the close vicinity of the pole
piece, forces could be increased by a factor of ~103
compared to the earlier design (Ziemann et al., 1994
). Thus, forces of
up to 10 nN on a 4.5-µm paramagnetic bead were achieved (cf. Fig.
2). By using ferromagnetic beads such
forces could be achieved with bead diameters of 0.5 µm. A second
magnet cannot be used in the present device because of the strong
magnetic induction generated between the pole pieces at such small
distances.
|
|
Force calibration of the set-up
To calibrate the distance dependence of the force acting on the magnetic bead in the high force set-up, the bead velocity was determined near the pole piece in liquids of known viscosity at different coil currents ranging from 250 to 2500 mA. The bead velocity was computed from the measured displacement-time-graphs by numerical differentiation. Fig. 2 shows the results of a typical calibration of the force on a 4.5-µm paramagnetic bead (DYNABEADS M-450, Dynal, Oslo, Norway). We used dimethyl-polysiloxane with a kinematic viscosity of 12,500 cSt (DMPS-12M, Sigma Chemical Company, St. Louis, MO) as a calibrating liquid.
The velocity curves were converted into force curves using Stokes law and plotted versus the distance to the pole piece (see Fig. 2 a). For the highest coil currents, forces of up to 10,000 pN on a 4.5-µm paramagnetic bead were reached. The curves shown in Fig. 2 a were all obtained by using the same bead. For each measurement the bead was aspirated by a micropipette and pulled back to its starting position (at a distance of 110 µm to the pole piece). Thus, the errors resulting from different bead sizes and iron contents (~15-20%) could be avoided.
In Fig. 2 b the magnetic force is plotted versus the coil current for different distances from the pole piece. This graph shows a linear dependence between force and current indicating that the paramagnetic bead is fully magnetized and therefore does not exhibit a field-dependent magnetic moment, which would be the case for paramagnetic particles in low magnetic fields.
The overall error of the method for measuring absolute forces is determined by the standard deviations of the bead size and the iron content and was estimated to 15-20%. For relative measurements (performed with the same bead), the overall error depends only on the accuracy of the determination of the bead velocity and of the coil current. This leads to a small total error for relative measurements of forces and viscoelastic constants of 1-2%.
Sample preparation
The rheological measurements presented here were performed on National Institutes of Health 3T3 murine fibroblasts employing paramagnetic microbeads of 4.5 µm diameter bound to the cell membrane. National Institutes of Health 3T3 cells were provided by the Max-Planck-Institut für Zellbiologie (Martinsried, Germany). The cells were cultured in an incubator at 37°C and 5% CO2. The cell culture medium consisted of DMEM with 10% v/v fetal calf serum (both from Life Technologies, Frederick, MD).
As shown in Fig. 3, the microbeads were
coated with fibronectin, which provides indirect coupling to the actin
cortex via integrins located in the cell membrane (Miyamoto et al.,
1995
; Wang et al., 1993
). Fibronectin was covalently conjugated to
4.5-µm diameter paramagnetic polystyrene beads coated with reactive
tosyl groups (DYNABEADS M-450 tosylactivated, Dynal) according
to the procedure provided by the supplier. Carboxylated latex beads
with a diameter of 1 µm (POLYBEADS, Polysciences, Warrington, PA)
were used as nonmagnetic colloidal probes for the visualization of the
displacement field on the cell membrane (cf. Fig. 8). These beads were
also coated with fibronectin to ensure the coupling to the integrins.
|
Immediately before sample preparation the functionalized magnetic beads were washed once in PBS (phosphate buffered saline, Sigma Chemical Co.) using a magnetic separation device (MPC-1, Dynal) and the bead concentration was adjusted to ~105 beads/ml. Cells were then detached from the substratum using a trypsin-EDTA solution (Life Technologies) and transferred onto suitable coverglasses. After an incubation time of 1-2 h to allow complete adhesion of the cells, 1.5 ml bead solution per coverglass was added. Beads were incubated with cells for 15 min and washed gently before mounting the coverglass on the sample holder of the magnetic bead rheometer.
Evaluation of creep experiments by mechanical equivalent circuit
Creep experiments are performed by recording the deflection and
relaxation of the magnetic beads (or nonmagnetic probe beads) following
rectangular force pulses. The trajectories of the beads are determined
by the single particle tracking technique with an accuracy of ±10 nm.
Fig. 4 shows a typical sequence of
responses of a magnetic bead to a sequence of rectangular force pulses
of duration
t = 2.5 s. The responses exhibit
three regimes: a fast elastic response (I), a relaxation regime (II),
and a flow regime (III).
|
The time-dependent deflection x(t) of the body of
Fig. 5 a evoked by a stepwise
force F(t) can be easily expressed as
superposition of the deflection of the Voigt body and of the dashpot
according to Fung (1993)
. Therefore, the deflection of the bead
(normalized by the applied force amplitude F) is given
by
|
(1a) |
is given
by
|
(1b) |
|
|
The four parameters characterizing the equivalent circuit can be
reduced to three observables with the following physical meaning:
because the amplitude of the elastic displacement (regime I) is
determined by x = F/(k0 + k1) the sum k = k0 + k1 is a measure of the effective spring constant
of the system. As defined in Eq. 1b,
is the relaxation time
required for the transition from the elastic to the viscous regime and
0 is a measure for the effective viscous friction
coefficient of the bead in the viscous flow regime.
The analysis of the viscoelastic response curves evoked by the tangential force pulses in terms of the three observables defined above is a first and straightforward step of data analysis. It is sufficient to observe local variations of the viscoelastic properties on the cell surface or to study differences between different cells (cf. Fig. 7). However, it is a much more difficult task to relate these parameters to viscoelastic moduli of the cell surface or the cytoplasm. This will be attempted below by introduction of a simplified model of the adhering cell lobes.
|
| |
RESULTS AND DISCUSSION |
|---|
|
|
|---|
Evaluation of response curve in terms of equivalent circuit
We studied the creep response curves of 10 cells while analyzing
several magnetic beads on each cell. Moreover, measurements were
performed for three to five different traction forces for each magnetic
bead. The three viscoelastic parameters k,
, and
0 defined above (cf. Eqs. 1) were determined by analysis
of the creep-response curves as described in Fig. 5. The data are
summarized in Fig. 7. To distinguish the results obtained for different
cells or on different sites on the adhering lobe of one cell the
individual measurements are plotted separately. Values for different
cells are distinguished by different symbols. Open and closed symbols of the same shape characterize measurements of the same cell but at
different sites. Measurements performed with the same particle but with
different force amplitudes are marked with equal symbols. A closer
inspection of the data shows that all viscoelastic parameters may
differ by up to an order of magnitude from cell to cell, but that the
values obtained for each individual cell differ by much less.
To check the linearity of the viscoelastic response, the creep response curves were recorded as a function of the applied forces ranging from 500 to 2000 pN. In Fig. 8 the time-dependence of the displacements (normalized by the applied force) obtained for different applied forces is plotted. In this example the curves coincide within experimental error with the exception of the curve for F = 2213 pN. This implies that the viscoelastic behavior of the system is linear for at least forces of up to ~2000 pN. The measurements of the viscoelastic moduli presented in Fig. 7 were performed in the linear regime using forces up to 2000 pN.
|
Strain field mapping experiment
A typical experiment is shown in Fig.
9. A number of nonmagnetic colloidal
latex beads (numbered 1 to 9) are deposited on the cell surface
together with one magnetic bead (marked as M). Beads are bound to
integrins via the fibronectin coating. The creep response and
relaxation curves generated by rectangular force pulses of 3700 pN were
recorded by using the particle tracking technique. The amplitudes of
deflection generated by pulses of 1 s duration normalized with
respect to the polar angle cos
(cf. Eq. 2 below) were measured and
plotted in Fig. 9 c. Although the relaxation time
is of
the order of 0.1 s we use the amplitudes at t = 1 s as a measure for the elastic displacement. Because all creep
response curves exhibit essentially the same shape, this approximation
procedure is justified. These measurements were also performed at a
force larger than 2000 pN to facilitate the observation of the particle
deflections. However, several displacement field mapping experiments
performed with lower forces yielded the same distance-dependence of the
normalized deflections.
|
The three nonnumbered beads in Fig. 9 were also deflected, but the deflection amplitude could not be measured accurately enough since the images overlap, thus preventing the application of the particle tracking procedure. Another intriguing way to determine the displacement field is the use of intracellular particles as markers instead of latex particles. In Fig. 10 an experiment is presented demonstrating that cell vacuoles exhibit detectable induced deflection amplitudes (see bottom row in Fig. 10 b). The experiment shows that the shear displacement field penetrates partially into the cell cytoplasm; thus intracellular particles may potentially be used as probes to estimate the local penetration depth of the displacement field.
|
Evaluation of the displacement field data by a simple cell model
To determine real elastic moduli (and shear viscosities) of the cell envelope from the viscoelastic parameters obtained by analyzing the creep response curves in terms of the equivalent circuit, one requires a theory of the elastic displacement of the adhering cell lobe generated by local tangential forces acting on the cell surface. Such models yield the geometric prefactor relating the elastic modulus of the cell surface to the spring constant of the equivalent circuit.
Because the microscopic structure of the cell lobe is not known, one has to introduce suitable models. One obvious possibility would be to consider the cell lobe as a thin homogeneous elastic slab, one side of which is fixed to a solid surface. However, this model would not account for the fact that the cell lobe is composed of two juxtaposed membranes and that these are interconnected by an intracellular cytoskeleton, as follows from the distribution of intracellular compartments in the cell lobe.
In view of these considerations, we assume that the cell lobe can be
considered as a partially collapsed shell composed of a lipid-protein
bilayer with associated actin cortex (called the composite plasma
membrane), and which is filled by a viscoelastic gel coupled to the
actin cortex. Therefore the adhering cell lobe is mimicked as two
juxtaposed elastic sheets of shear modulus µ* (representing the
composite membrane), which are attached to an elastic medium
(accounting for the cytoskeleton). The coupling between the actin
cortex and the cytoskeleton is characterized by a phenomenological
coupling constant
, which is a measure for the cytoskeleton membrane
coupling strength per unit area (see the Appendix for details). It is
further assumed that the bottom shell is fixed to the surface and it is
not deformed during our measurements. This assumption is justified by
the fact that the displacement field decays rapidly within the
cytoplasm (cf. Fig. 9).
The problem of the elastic deformation of such a body by a tangential
point force acting on the surface has been solved by A. Boulbitch
(1998, submitted for publication). The essential results are summarized
in the Appendix where the general expression for the displacement field
is given. The main result is that the displacement field
u(r,
) caused by the local force is screened.
It depends logarithmically on the radial distance from the point where
the force is applied if r
Rc while
u(r,
) decays exponentially if r is
large compared to the screening length Rc.
To test the validity of such a screened displacement field we analyzed
the distance-dependence of the displacement field by the
displacement-field mapping technique (cf. Fig. 9). The displacement vector u(r,
) can be written in cylindrical
coordinates (cf. Eq. A7). The radial component is given by
|
(2) |
is the angle between the force direction and
r. In Fig. 9 c the reduced radial displacement
component ur/cos
is plotted as a function of
r.
By fitting the theoretical displacement field to the observed data one
can estimate
and thus Rc. This has been done
in four cases yielding cutoff radii in the range of a few micrometers. The fit shown in Fig. 9 c yields a value
0.15 µm
1 corresponding to a cutoff radius
Rc
7 µm and a surface shear modulus µ*
of 4 · 10
3 Pa m. As
2 =
/µ*
the coupling constant is
= 107 Pa m
1.
The surface shear modulus µ* is also obtained by considering the
absolute deflection of the magnetic bead in the direction of the
magnetic field as a function of the force. The relationship between the
deflection and the force is obtained by averaging the displacement
u(R,
) at the boundary of the bead adhesion disk over all angles
. At the present stage of analysis the radius is assumed to be about equal to the radius of the bead. Equation A2
yields
|
(3) |
|
|
(4) |
0.5) and that the screening length of the advancing lobes is about the same for all cells. With the value of
obtained from the displacement field mapping experiments, the
transformation factor {K0(
R) + (1
)K0(
1R)}/4
in
Eq. 4 becomes 0.17 for a magnetic bead of the radius R = 2.25 µm. The average spring constant k
0.01 Pa m (cf. Fig. 7) thus yields an average surface shear modulus µ*
2 · 10
3 Pa m. Considering the large
variability of the viscoelastic moduli of individual cells, this value
agrees reasonably well with µ*
4 · 10
3 Pa m
obtained from the above analysis of the displacement field experiment.
The three-dimensional (3D) shear modulus of the cell envelope is
related to µ by µ = µ*/h. The thickness h
of the composite membrane is certainly smaller than the cell lobe,
which is 1-2 µm. By assuming a value of h
0.1 µm [as it was measured for neutrophils by Zhelev et al. (1994)
] one
obtains a 3D shear modulus of µ
2 · 104 to
4 · 104 Pa.
It is important to experimentally estimate the values of the strain tensor to find out whether the linear approximation used for the calculations is valid. This can be done by calculating the measured relative displacements of the latex beads. This yields strains in the range of 2-5%, indicating that the measurements take place in the linear regime.
Evaluation of the viscous flow in terms of effective cytoplasmic viscosity
To relate the two-dimensional (2D) viscosity
0 of
the equivalent circuit to the viscosity of the adhering cell lobe we
assume that the magnetic bead is moving in a fluid membrane coupled to a solid surface through a viscous medium of thickness
dc. The situation is very similar to that of
protein diffusion in fluid-supported membranes, which are separated
from the solid surface by a lubricating film of viscosity
c. This problem has been treated previously both
theoretically and experimentally (Evans and Sackmann, 1988
; Merkel et
al., 1989
). The viscous drag force on a disk embedded in the membrane
and moving with velocity v is
|
(5) |
) and
K1(
) are modified Bessel functions. The
dimensionless parameter
is defined by
= R(bs/
m)1/2.
Here
m is the 2D viscosity of the bilayer membrane,
R is the radius of the disk which in our case is equal to
the contact area between the magnetic bead and the membrane, and
bs is the friction coefficient of the coupling
medium, which is related to the viscosity of the viscoelastic layer of
thickness dc by bs =
c/dc. For large values of
(in
practice, for
> 1), the second term on the right side of Eq. 5 can
be neglected. The drag force in this limit does not depend on the
membrane viscosity and is Fd =
R2dc
1
cv.
The 2D viscosity of membranes is of the order of
m = 10
9 N s/m (Merkel et al., 1989
c is
typically of the order of 200 Pa s (Bausch et al., 1998, submitted for
publication). Therefore,
102 and the above
approximation is well fulfilled in our case. Consequently, the
effective viscosity
0 of the equivalent circuit is
related to the friction coefficient of the coupling medium (the
cytoplasm) by the obvious relation: bs =
0/
R2.
The viscosity
0 obtained from the slope of the viscous
flow regime of the creep response curve is
0 = 0.03 Pa s m. By assuming that the radius of the contact area of the bead
on the membrane is about equal to the bead radius (R = 2.25 µm) one obtains for the friction coefficient of the cytoplasm a
value of bs
2 · 109
Pa s/m. By assuming dc
2 µm our
estimation yields
c
4 · 103
Pa s.
| |
DISCUSSION |
|---|
|
|
|---|
The magnetic bead rheometer designed in the present work allows generation of forces in the nanonewton range, which are strong enough to enable local measurements of viscoelastic parameters of cell envelopes (comprising the lipid/protein bilayer and the associated actin cortex). By application of the high-resolution particle tracking technique bead deflections may be measured with at least 10 nm lateral resolution and a time resolution of 0.04 s. The viscoelastic response is linear at least up to forces of 2000 pN, corresponding to maximum displacement amplitudes of 1 µm. Most measurements, with the exception of some of the displacement field experiments, were performed at 500-1000 pN, corresponding to displacements of 250-500 nm.
The creep response curves of the cells are analyzed in terms of the equivalent circuit because this model can be most easily adapted to the observed creep response curves in a model-free manner. The relationships between the viscoelastic parameters of the equivalent circuit and the viscoelastic moduli of the cell surface are, however, model-dependent and it is therefore most convenient to analyze measurements first in terms of the equivalent circuit.
Our displacement field mapping experiments show that the elastic displacement of the cell surface generated by local tangential forces is screened at lateral distances of a few micrometers from the point of attack. Strong screening of the elastic deformation has also been established recently in the cytoplasm by similar displacement field mapping experiments (Bausch et al., 1998, submitted for publication; unpublished data of this laboratory). This screening of the elastic deformation of the membrane and the cytoskeleton is an important condition for the local measurement of viscoelastic parameters on cell surfaces. However, local measurements are important for at least two reasons. First, they allow the study of viscoelastic properties of closed shells by restricting to the analysis of local deformations. Second, cell envelopes generally exhibit heterogeneous lateral organizations, and the elastic deformation may also be anisotropic due to coupling of various cytoskeletal elements including stress fibers to the actin cortex.
The absolute values for the shear modulus and the viscosity obtained by
modeling the cell lobe as two elastic sheets coupled by a viscoelastic
gel are certainly rough estimates. However, the values agree rather
well with data obtained by other techniques. In our study an average 3D
shear modulus of µ
2 · 104 to 4 · 104 Pa is obtained. This value is in acceptable agreement
with the AFM measurements. Thus, AFM measurements performed on human
platelets by Radmacher et al. (1996)
yield bulk moduli of 1-50 kPa,
while in chicken cardiocytes the elastic moduli range from 10 to 200 kPa. The latter value is measured on top of stress fibers (Hofmann et
al., 1997
).
Our results are in contrast to findings of Wang et al. (1993)
, who used
a twisting rheometer to measure the viscoelastic properties of bovine
capillary endothelial cells. Apparent Young's moduli of ~8 Pa and
viscosities of 5-10 Pas were obtained, about four orders of magnitude
smaller than our values. The discrepancy may be due to the way the
deformation is applied: we apply a real shear force, whereas in the
experiments of Wang et al. (1993)
a twisting force is applied. This
also makes it difficult to compare the absolute values of the applied
stresses. Assuming an approximate radius of the adhesion area of the
bead of 1-2.25 µm, we estimate applied stresses of ~300-60
Nm
2, while in the measurements of Wang et al. the
stresses are only 3 Nm
2. In separate experiments we found
that application of such small forces leads to detectable deflections
only if the beads are attached to the extracellular matrix.
Furthermore, the strain hardening reported by these authors could not
be reproduced in our studies. As can be seen in Fig. 10, saturation
effects were observed only for forces exceeding 2000 pN.
Our analysis yields an average value for the cytoplasmic viscosity of
2 · 103 Pa s. Sato et al. (1984)
found for the
cytoplasmic viscosity of the axoplasm of squid axon a value of
104-105 Pa s, while Valberg and Butler (1987)
and Valberg and Feldman (1987)
using twisting rheometry have found
values ranging from 250 to 2800 Pa s inside macrophages, in good
agreement with our results.
The viscosity obtained by our method should be compared with the value
measured by the micropipette aspiration technique developed by Evans
(1995)
which was applied by Tsai et al. to human neutrophils (1994)
. In
this case the viscosity is obtained from the speed of penetration of
the cell into the pipette at a constant suction pressure. Typical
values found are of the order of 100 Pa s, which are an order of
magnitude smaller than our value. This may be due to the fact that our
measurements are done on the rather flat advancing lobe of the
fibroblast, which may exhibit a much higher viscosity than the whole
cell body of blood cells.
It should be also noted that the origin of the viscous flow regime is not understood yet. In the framework of the present model it would be determined by the rate of decoupling (fracture) of the connections between the membrane-associated actin cortex and the intracellular cytoskeleton. It could, however, be determined equally well by the fracture of lateral cross-links within the actin cortex. A decision between these two possibilities cannot be made on the basis of the present experiments.
An intriguing finding of the current analysis is that the displacement field seems to be anisotropic, as is demonstrated by the large deviations of the direction of deflection of the colloidal probes from the direction of an isotropic displacement field. This may be a consequence of the coupling of the actin cortex to local stress fibers. By improving the technique of selective coupling of smaller probe beads to membrane receptors, the displacement field mapping technique could probe local elastic anisotropies of the plasma membrane and the underlying cytoskeleton.
The magnetic bead technique provides a versatile tool for cell
rheometry. By deposition of several beads it allows simultaneous measurements at different sites on the cell surface (cf. Fig. 3
a). The technique can be simultaneously applied to the cell surface and the cytoplasm. As it is essentially a nonperturbing technique creep, response curves can be recorded repeatedly. This allows detection of temporal changes of the local viscoelasticity. It
may thus also be applied to evaluate local changes of the cytoskeletal structure (e.g., the formation of stress fibers) caused by local mechanical agitations or by the binding of integrins. Such local modifications of the cytoskeleton were recently reported for
endothelial cells by Chicurel et al. (1998)
. Evidence was provided that
coupling of colloidal beads to integrins leads to a local
reorganization of the actin cortex, resulting in an increase of the
messenger RNA concentration near the focal adhesion site 20 min after
integrin binding.
The above considerations suggest that magnetic bead rheometry is a promising new technique to gain insight into such biochemically induced changes of the local constitution of the cell cytoskeleton.
| |
APPENDIX |
|---|
|
|
|---|
Elastic deformations of juxtaposed coupled membranes by local tangential force
The cell membrane, consisting of the lipid bilayer attached to
the actin cortex, is represented by a thin elastic plate supported by a
viscoelastic substrate. The lobe shape makes it possible to assume that
its top membrane is flat. The bottom membrane is considered as rigid
and fixed to the solid substrate. A basic assumption of the present
model is that the actin cortex is coupled to the bulk cytoskeleton
consisting of microtubules, intermediate, and actin filaments. To
consider the effect of this gel on the membrane deformation we adopt
the simplified mechanical model of the cell lobe displayed in Fig.
11. The bulk cytoskeleton is assumed to
consist of pre-stressed and unstressed compartments. The former consist
of the stress fibers, which either penetrate the whole thickness of the
lobe connecting the top and the bottom membranes (cf. Fig. 11,
b and c; filaments numbered 1), or connect the
top membrane to a stressed region of the network, which is attached to
the bottom membrane by another stress fiber (cf. Fig. 11, b
and c; fibers marked by number 2). Assume that the lobe
possesses nst such stress fibers per unit area
and that they exhibit an average tension T. Besides the
pre-stressed fibers, the bulk cytoskeleton may contain unstressed parts
of the network coupled to the actin cortex (cf. Fig. 11, b
and c; fibers number 3). An in-plane displacement of the
cortex u = (ux,
uy) is followed by tilting of the stress fibers in the
pre-stressed parts of the cytoskeleton. It causes bending of the stiff
microtubules and intermediate filaments and stretching of wrinkles and
meshes of the unstressed parts of the cytoskeleton. Therefore, the
unstressed parts of the cytoskeleton can be characterized by the number
density nun of attachments of these components
to the actin cortex and by an average spring constant
kun. Under a lateral membrane displacement
u both mechanisms give rise to a restoring force
|Frest| = S(Tnst tan
+ kunnun|u|),
where S is the membrane area. The first term describes the
contribution of the pre-stressed and the second of the unstressed
cytoskeletal components. Making use of the relation tan
u/H one finds
|
(A1) |
as
Frest =
S
u where
|
(A2) |
as a
phenomenological parameter that has the dimension of a spring constant
per unit membrane area.
|
The displacement field generated by a local tangential force on the top membrane has been calculated by Boulbitch (1998, submitted for publication) and the theory is summarized below.
The equation of the mechanical equilibrium of a 3D body is well-known
(Landau and Lifshitz, 1959
). To transform it to the case of a thin
plate, an averaging procedure (over the direction perpendicular to the
plane) has to be performed (Muschelishvili, 1963
). This allows
expression of the equation of equilibrium in terms of a membrane shear
modulus µ* obtained by integrating the shear modulus over the
membrane thickness h: µ* = µh. Taking
into account the restoring force mentioned above, one obtains the
following equation of the mechanical equilibrium of the composite
membrane:
|
(A3) |
2 =
/µ*. Here 
1 is a
length scale. As will become evident below, Rc = 
1 = (µ*/
)1/2 is a cutoff radius that
accounts for the screening of the displacement field by the
cytoskeleton. By considering Eq. A2 one obtains
|
(A4) |
T/kun) one finds Rc
(dcµ*/Tnst)1/2.
In the opposite case Rc
(µ*/kunnun)1/2.
If the cutoff radius is much larger than the radius of the magnetic
bead R (Rc
R) one can
assume that the force is point like F = F0
(r) where
F0 is the absolute value of the force acting on
the magnetic bead along the x axis. The displacement field
for the local tangential force is given by the following expressions:
|
(A5) |
|
|
(A6) |
|
1 = [(1
)/2]1/2
. Note that for the limiting case
R
the equations (A5-A6) describe the elastic
deformation of a single thin plate, the displacement field exhibiting
the well-known logarithmic behavior usual for the flat theory of
elasticity (Muschelishvili, 1963
|
The displacement components can be expressed in cylindrical
coordinates. Introducing the unit vector n = (cos
,
sin
) directed along the radius-vector r the radial
component of the displacement vector u:
ur = (u · n) is given by
|
(A7) |
| |
ACKNOWLEDGMENTS |
|---|
The authors thank G. Marriot (Max-Planck-Institut für Zellbiologie, Martinsried, Germany) for providing the National Institutes of Health 3T3 murine fibroblasts.
This work was supported by the Deutsche Forschungsgemeinschaft (Sa 246/22-3) and the Fonds der Chemischen Industrie.
| |
FOOTNOTES |
|---|
Received for publication 15 December 1997 and in final form 11 July 1998.
Address reprint requests to Prof. Dr. Erich Sackmann, Physikdepartment E22, Lehrstuhl für Biophysik, Technische Universität München, James-Franck-Strasse, D-85748 Garching, Germany. Tel.: +49 (089) 289-12471; Fax: +49 (089) 289-12469; E-mail: sackmann{at}physik.tu-muenchen.de.
This paper is dedicated to the memory of Fred Fay, an outstanding pioneer in new forms of light microscopy imaging for biology, and a good friend.
| |
REFERENCES |
|---|
|
|
|---|