| HOME | HELP | FEEDBACK | SUBSCRIPTIONS | ARCHIVE | SEARCH | TABLE OF CONTENTS |
Biophys J, November 1998, p. 2302-2312, Vol. 75, No. 5
Departments of *Biochemistry & Biophysics and #Physiology, University of North Carolina, Chapel Hill, North Carolina 27599-7260 USA
| |
ABSTRACT |
|---|
|
|
|---|
The cardiac muscle sarcoplasmic reticulum
Ca2+ release channel (ryanodine receptor) is a ligand-gated
channel that is activated by micromolar cytoplasmic Ca2+
concentrations and inactivated by millimolar cytoplasmic
Ca2+ concentrations. The effects of sarcoplasmic reticulum
lumenal Ca2+ on the purified release channel were examined
in single channel measurements using the planar lipid bilayer method.
In the presence of caffeine and nanomolar cytosolic Ca2+
concentrations, lumenal-to-cytosolic Ca2+ fluxes
0.25 pA
activated the channel. At the maximally activating cytosolic
Ca2+ concentration of 4 µM, lumenal Ca2+
fluxes of 8 pA and greater caused a decline in channel activity. Lumenal Ca2+ fluxes primarily increased channel activity by
increasing the duration of mean open times. Addition of the fast
Ca2+-complexing buffer
1,2-bis(2-aminophenoxy)ethanetetraacetic acid (BAPTA) to the cytosolic
side of the bilayer increased lumenal Ca2+-activated
channel activities, suggesting that it lowered Ca2+
concentrations at cytosolic Ca2+-inactivating sites.
Regulation of channel activities by lumenal Ca2+ could be
also observed in the absence of caffeine and in the presence of 5 mM
MgATP. These results suggest that lumenal Ca2+ can regulate
cardiac Ca2+ release channel activity by passing through
the open channel and binding to the channel's cytosolic
Ca2+ activation and inactivation sites.
| |
INTRODUCTION |
|---|
|
|
|---|
The release and sequestration of Ca2+
ions by an intracellular membrane compartment, the sarcoplasmic
reticulum (SR), is essential to the process of cardiac muscle
contraction and relaxation. In cardiac muscle, the influx of
Ca2+ via a voltage-sensitive dihydropyridine receptor
(DHPR)/Ca2+ channel (L-type) triggers the massive release
of Ca2+ by opening SR Ca2+ release channels
(CRCs) (for review see Wier, 1990
). The CRC binds the plant alkaloid
ryanodine with high affinity and specificity and hence is also known as
the ryanodine receptor (for reviews see Franzini-Armstrong and Protasi,
1997
; Sutko et al., 1997
; Meissner, 1994
). CRCs are ligand-gated
channels with Ca2+ as a major regulator. High-affinity
activating and low-affinity inactivating Ca2+ binding sites
have been identified (Liu et al., 1998
; Fruen et al., 1996
; Xu et al.,
1996
; Laver et al., 1995
; Chu et al., 1993
; Zimanyi and Pessah, 1991
;
Meissner and Henderson, 1987
). Rapid activation and inactivation by
cytosolic Ca2+ has suggested that these sites are located
on the large cytosolic foot region of the channels (Laver and Curtis,
1996
; Schiefer et al., 1995
; Sitsapesan et al., 1995
; Gyorke and Fill,
1993
). Various other endogenous effectors of CRCs have been identified including Mg2+, ATP, and calmodulin (Meissner, 1994
).
In addition to cytosolic Ca2+, SR lumenal Ca2+
may affect CRC activity. The most direct evidence for a regulation by
SR lumenal Ca2+ has been obtained in single channel
measurements using the planar lipid bilayer technique. SR lumenal
Ca2+ activated the skeletal muscle CRC in the presence of
cytosolic ATP (Sitsapesan and Williams, 1995
; Tripathy and Meissner,
1996
) but no or only a modest activation was observed in the absence of
ATP (Sitsapesan and Williams, 1995
; Tripathy and Meissner, 1996
;
Herrmann-Frank and Lehmann-Horn, 1996
). These results have raised
the interesting possibility that skeletal CRCs have SR intralumenal
Ca2+ binding sites that interact with cytosolic regulatory
sites (Sitsapesan and Williams, 1995
). An alternative suggestion has
been that SR lumenal Ca2+ flowing through the channel
regulates the skeletal muscle CRC by having access to cytosolic
activation and inactivation sites (Tripathy and Meissner, 1996
;
Herrmann-Frank and Lehmann-Horn, 1996
). In support of the latter
suggestion, high concentrations of the "fast" Ca2+
buffer 1,2-bis(2-aminophenoxy)ethanetetraacetic acid (BAPTA) increased
cytosolic ATP-activated, lumenal Ca2+-activated skeletal
muscle channel activities. This result suggested that lumenal
Ca2+ passing through the skeletal CRC regulates the channel
by having access to "BAPTA-inaccessible" Ca2+
activation and "BAPTA-accessible" Ca2+ inactivation
sites (Tripathy and Meissner, 1996
).
An increase in lumenal Ca2+ concentration also resulted in
an increase in cardiac CRC open probability. The presence of another cytosolic channel activator such as sulmazole (Sitsapesan and Williams,
1994a
) or ATP (Lukyanenko et al., 1996
) was required to observe
activation by lumenal Ca2+. These results were considered
to be inconsistent with the idea that lumenal Ca2+ ions
flowing through the channel have direct access to cytosolic Ca2+ activation sites.
The cardiac CRC represents a classical example of a
Ca2+-regulated Ca2+ release mechanism (Wier,
1990
). Its regulation by Ca2+ and other endogenous
effectors differs from that of the skeletal CRC (Franzini-Armstrong and
Protasi, 1997
; Sutko et al., 1997
; Meissner, 1994
). It is therefore
conceivable that the two channel isoforms are regulated differently by
lumenal Ca2+. To clarify the ways in which lumenal
Ca2+ ions regulate the cardiac CRC, we have investigated
their effects on single canine cardiac muscle CRCs, using the planar
lipid bilayer method. Our results indicate that lumenal
Ca2+ flowing through the channel regulates the cardiac
Ca2+ release channel via direct feedback by binding to
cytosolic Ca2+ activation and inactivation sites. An
activation of channel activity by lumenal Ca2+ was observed
at Mg2+ and ATP concentrations corresponding to those in
myocardium. These results suggest that activation of cardiac CRCs by
lumenal Ca2+ fluxes may be a physiologically relevant
mechanism. A preliminary report of this work has been presented in
abstract form (Xu and Meissner, 1997
).
| |
EXPERIMENTAL PROCEDURES |
|---|
|
|
|---|
Materials
Phospholipids were obtained from Avanti Polar Lipids (Birmingham, AL). All other chemicals were of analytical grade.
Preparation of sarcoplasmic reticulum vesicles and purification of Ca2+ release channels
Canine cardiac SR vesicle fractions enriched in
[3H]ryanodine binding and Ca2+ release
channel activities were prepared in the presence of protease inhibitors
as described (Xu et al., 1993
). The CHAPS
(3-[(3-cholamidopropyl)dimethyl-ammonio]-1-propanesulfonate)-solubilized canine heart 30S Ca2+ release channel complex was isolated
by rate density gradient centrifugation and reconstituted into
proteoliposomes by removal of CHAPS by dialysis (Lee et al., 1994
).
Single channel measurements
Single channel measurements were performed by fusing
proteoliposomes containing the purified cardiac muscle Ca2+
release channel with Mueller-Rudin-type bilayers containing
phosphatidylethanolamine, phosphatidylserine, and phosphatidylcholine
in the ratio 5:3:2 (25 mg total phospholipid/ml n-decane)
(Lee et al., 1994
). The side of the bilayer to which the
proteoliposomes were added was defined as the cis side. A
strong dependence of channel activity on micromolar cis
Ca2+ concentrations suggested that the cis side
corresponded to the SR cytosolic side in a majority (>98%) of our
recordings. The trans side of the bilayer was defined as
ground. Single channels were recorded in a symmetrical KCl buffer
solution (0.25 M KCl, 20 mM KHepes, pH 7.4) containing the additions
indicated in the text. Electrical signals were filtered at 2 kHz,
digitized at 10 kHz, and analyzed. Data acquisition and analysis were
performed with a commercially available software package (pClamp
6.0.3., Axon Instruments, Burlingame, CA) using an IBM-compatible
Pentium computer and 12-bit A/D-D/A converter (Digidata 1200, Axon
Instruments) (Xu et al., 1996
).
Determination of free Ca2+ concentrations
Free Ca2+ concentrations of >1 µM were determined
with a Ca2+-selective electrode (World Precision
Instruments, Inc., Sarasota, FL). Free Ca2+ concentrations
of <1 µM were obtained by including in the solutions the appropriate
amounts of Ca2+ and EGTA as determined using the stability
constants and computer program published by Schoenmakers et al. (1992)
.
Statistics
Results are given as means ± SE. Significance of differences of data was analyzed with Student's t-test. Differences were regarded to be statistically significant at P < 0.05.
| |
RESULTS |
|---|
|
|
|---|
Purified cardiac Ca2+ release channels reconstituted
into proteoliposomes were incorporated into planar lipid bilayers and
recorded in symmetrical 0.25 M KCl buffer. The use of K+
rather than Ca2+ as a current carrier avoided the buildup
of a large Ca2+ gradient near the mouth of the channel,
thus simplifying analysis of regulation of the cardiac CRC by
Ca2+. Single channel conductance with 0.25 M K+
as current carrier was 770 pS (Xu et al., 1993
). The effects of
cytosolic and lumenal Ca2+ on channel activity were
examined in the presence and absence of 10 mM cytosolic caffeine.
Caffeine increases the apparent Ca2+ affinity of the
Ca2+ activation sites (Liu et al., 1998
; Zucchi and
Ronca-Testoni, 1997
), which allows the use of low cytosolic
Ca2+ concentrations in testing the effects of lumenal
Ca2+. Channels were also recorded in the presence of 5 mM
cytosolic MgATP (0.7 mM free Mg2+) to better simulate the
intracellular conditions in myocardium.
Regulation of cardiac Ca2+ release channels by cytosolic and lumenal Ca2+ in the presence of 10 mM caffeine
In Fig. 1 A, a single
cardiac CRC was recorded in the presence of 10 mM cytosolic
(cis) caffeine at three different cytosolic Ca2+
concentrations and holding potentials of
35 and +35 mV. Short, often
not fully resolved channel events were observed with 0.1 µM free
Ca2+ in the cytosolic bilayer chamber (Fig. 1 A, top
traces). Elevation of cytosolic Ca2+ concentration to
1 µM increased channel open probability (Po) (middle traces) at both holding potentials. In the presence
of 10 µM cytosolic Ca2+, long open events interrupted by
brief closings were observed at both holding potentials, resulting in a
nearly fully activated channel (bottom traces).
|
Fig. 1 B shows that channels in the presence of 10 mM
cytosolic caffeine were half-maximally activated at ~1 µM cytosolic Ca2+, and half-maximally inhibited at
10 mM cytosolic
Ca2+. In agreement with previous studies (Liu et al., 1998
;
Fruen et al., 1996
; Xu et al., 1996
; Laver et al., 1995
; Zimanyi and Pessah, 1991
; Meissner and Henderson, 1987
), data of Fig. 1
B suggest that the cardiac CRC has both high-affinity
Ca2+ activation and low-affinity Ca2+
inactivation sites. Furthermore, Fig. 1 shows that the cardiac CRC
exhibits no significant voltage dependence when activated and
inactivated by cytosolic Ca2+ in the presence of caffeine.
The CRC showed a strong voltage dependence when the lumenal instead of
cytosolic Ca2+ concentration was elevated. In Fig.
2 A
(top traces), a single cardiac CRC was initially recorded
under conditions similar to those in Fig. 1 A (top
traces), i.e., at a low cytosolic [Ca2+] (<0.01
µM) in the presence of 10 mM cytosolic caffeine. The lumenal
Ca2+ concentration was <2 µM and the holding potentials
were
50 mV and +50 mV. As in Fig. 1, brief, often not fully resolved
channel events were observed at both holding potentials. An increase of lumenal Ca2+ concentration from <2 µM to 1 mM increased
Po >100-fold at
50 mV, but was essentially without
an effect at +50 mV (middle traces).
|
Fig. 2 B describes the dependence of mean Po of
minimally (<0.01 µM cytosolic Ca2+) and close to
maximally (4 µM cytosolic Ca2+) activated CRCs on lumenal
Ca2+ concentrations of 2 µM to 10 mM. For the minimally
activated channels, a significant increase in channel open probability
was observed at a lumenal Ca2+ concentration of 100 µM
and holding potential of
50 mV. To obtain a similar increase in
Po at +50 mV, a lumenal Ca2+ concentration of 5 mM and greater was required. A different response was observed for
channels that were close to maximally activated by 4 µM cytosolic
Ca2+. In this case, an increase in lumenal Ca2+
concentration lowered Po at
50 mV. No significant changes
in Po were observed at +50 mV. Data of Fig. 2 B
suggest that three parameters must be taken into account to understand
the way in which lumenal Ca2+ activates and inactivates the
cardiac CRC. These are the extents to which channels are activated by
cytosolic effectors such as Ca2+, the lumenal
Ca2+ concentration, and the holding potential.
A negative holding potential favors, whereas a positive holding
potential disfavors, the movement of cations from the SR lumenal (trans) side to the cytosolic (cis) side of the
bilayer. The different Ca2+ activation/inactivation curves
of Fig. 2 B suggest, therefore, that lumenal
Ca2+ flowing through the open channel affects channel
activity by having access to cytosolic Ca2+ regulatory
sites. Lumenal Ca2+ fluxes could not be directly measured
(except at 0 mV, see below) because of the presence of K+
as the major current carrier in our recording solutions.
Lumenal-to-cytosolic Ca2+ fluxes were therefore calculated
according to a barrier model that describes the ionic conduction of the
sheep cardiac CRC (Tinker et al., 1992
). Fig. 2 C shows the
dependence of mean Po of minimally (<0.01 µM cytosolic
Ca2+) and close to maximally (4 µM cytosolic
Ca2+) activated CRCs on the calculated lumenal
Ca2+ fluxes. Lumenal Ca2+ fluxes were
calculated at six holding potentials ranging from
65 mV to +65 mV and
four lumenal Ca2+ concentrations ranging from <2 µM to
10 mM. Fig. 2 C shows that at 0.01 µM cytosolic
Ca2+ channels were maximally activated at a
lumenal-to-cytosolic Ca2+ flux of ~1 pA.
Ca2+ fluxes of >10 pA appeared to be slightly inhibitory.
The SR membrane is highly permeable to K+ and
Cl
and the membrane potential across the SR membrane is
therefore generally believed to be close to 0 mV (Meissner, 1983
). The
effects of lumenal Ca2+ on Po were therefore
also determined at a holding potential of 0 mV in a symmetric 0.25 M
KCl buffer containing 3 mM lumenal free Ca2+ and a low
cytosolic Ca2+ concentration (<0.01 µM free
Ca2+ plus 10 mM caffeine). Under these conditions, the
Ca2+ current could be measured directly. The measured
Ca2+ current of 1.9 ± 0.1 pA (n = 5)
was close to a calculated value of 2.1 pA. The averaged Po
of 0.53 ± 0.21 (n = 5) was close to values that
yielded lumenal-to-cytosolic Ca2+ fluxes of ~2 pA at
negative and positive holding potentials (2.1 and 1.3 pA at
20 and
+20 mV and lumenal [Ca2+] of 1 and 5 mM, respectively).
Channels recorded at a close to maximally activating cytosolic Ca2+ concentration of 4 µM were not further activated by lumenal Ca2+ (Fig. 2 C). However, these channels were significantly inactivated at lumenal Ca2+ fluxes of 8 pA and greater.
An intriguing finding was that at a low cytosolic Ca2+
concentration lumenal Ca2+ fluxes were less effective than
cytosolic [Ca2+] in activating the CRC
(Po,max = ~0.8 in Fig. 1 B vs.
Po,max of ~0.5 in Fig. 2 C). This result can
be rationalized if lumenal Ca2+ inactivates before fully
activating the release channel. We tested this idea using the
"fast" complexing Ca2+ buffer BAPTA. Modeling studies
have indicated that the free Ca2+ concentration near the
release sites may reach values in excess of 10 mM (see Fig. 8). Because
of its high association rate, BAPTA is more effective than the
"slow" complexing Ca2+ buffer EGTA in suppressing such
a rise in Ca2+ concentration (Stern, 1992
). In the middle
traces of Fig. 2 A, a single lumenal
Ca2+-activated channel was recorded under standard
conditions; that is, in the presence of <0.01 µM cytosolic
Ca2+ and 10 mM cytosolic caffeine. Lumenal Ca2+
was 1 mM. Bottom traces of Fig. 2 A show that the addition
of 20 mM cytosolic BAPTA increased Po at
50 mV, but not
at +50 mV. Fig. 3 B (top
panel) summarizes the effects of 20 mM BAPTA on several lumenal
Ca2+-activated single channels. At lumenal Ca2+
fluxes of 0.25-4 pA, 20 mM cytosolic BAPTA increased Po.
At a flux of 3 pA, a Po value close to those observed in
the presence of 0.01-1 mM cytosolic Ca2+ was obtained
(Fig. 3 A, top panel). This result suggested that BAPTA was
apparently able to prevent lumenal Ca2+-mediated channel
inactivation by minimizing the buildup of a high inactivating
Ca2+ concentration near the cytosolic Ca2+
inactivation sites. However, BAPTA did not prevent channel activation, which suggested that at a concentration of 20 mM BAPTA did not lower
the Ca2+ concentration below a maximally activating
Ca2+ concentration of ~5 µM (Fig. 1 B) at
the cytosolic Ca2+ activation sites. A direct
pharmacological activation of CRCs by BAPTA appeared to be unlikely
because none was observed when lumenal Ca2+ fluxes were
0.1 pA (Fig. 3 B, top panel).
|
In the case of cytosolic Ca2+-activated CRCs, both the
Ca2+-activating and -inactivating sites see the same
[Ca2+]. In contrast, lumenal Ca2+ has access
only to cytosolic regulatory sites when the channel is open. In
addition, the Ca2+ activation and inactivation sites may
see different [Ca2+], depending on their relative
location with respect to the release site. It was therefore of interest
to compare the kinetic parameters of cytosolic
Ca2+-activated and lumenal Ca2+-activated
channels (Fig. 3, A and B). An increase in
cytosolic Ca2+ concentration from <0.01 µM to 100 µM
increased Po from close to zero to 0.8 by increasing the
number of channel events by more than 10-fold, and the duration of mean
open events by ~100-fold (Fig. 3 A). The duration of mean
closed events was maximally decreased by ~10,000-fold. A further
increase of cytosolic Ca2+ to 10 mM decreased
Po by shortening the duration of mean open events and
increasing the duration of mean closed events, without having an
appreciable effect on the number of channel events. In Fig. 3
B, channel parameters are plotted against the lumenal Ca2+ fluxes. Channels were recorded at eight holding
potentials ranging from
65 to +65 mV and 1 mM lumenal
Ca2+ and cytosolic Ca2+ concentration of <0.01
µM in the presence and absence of 20 mM cytosolic BAPTA. In the
absence of BAPTA, lumenal Ca2+ fluxes were less effective
than cytosolic Ca2+ in activating cardiac CRCs (top
panels of Fig. 3, A and B). Lumenal Ca2+ opened and closed channels less frequently than
cytosolic Ca2+ (second panels). In both cases,
mean open times were increased as channels were maximally activated by
raising cytosolic [Ca2+] from ~0.003 µM to 10 µM,
and lumenal Ca2+ fluxes from 0.04 to 3 pA (third
panels). However, they showed major differences in the durations
of mean closed times. An increase in cytosolic Ca2+ from
~0.003 to 10 µM decreased the mean closed times from 10,000 ms to
close to 1 ms (Fig. 3 A, bottom panel). By comparison, an increase in lumenal Ca2+ fluxes from 0.04 to 3 pA decreased
the mean closed times by <100-fold (Fig. 3 B, bottom
panel).
Cytosolic BAPTA significantly increased Po at elevated lumenal Ca2+ fluxes. This increase could be accounted for mostly by an increase in mean open times (Fig. 3 B, third panel). Some changes in the number of events and mean closed times were observed as well; however, none of these was significant.
Regulation of cardiac Ca2+ release channel by lumenal Ca2+ and Mg2+ in the absence of caffeine
The effects of lumenal Ca2+ on CRCs were also
investigated in the absence of caffeine. In Fig.
4 A a single channel was
recorded with 10 µM and 1 mM lumenal Ca2+. Cytosolic
Ca2+ was 1 µM, which was higher than in the recordings of
Fig. 2 because preliminary experiments indicated that lumenal
Ca2+ concentrations as high as 10 mM were ineffective in
activating the CRC at cytosolic Ca2+ concentrations of
<0.1 µM (not shown). At such low Ca2+ concentrations,
channels rarely opened in the absence of caffeine. To observe
appreciable channel activity in the absence of caffeine, a cytosolic
Ca2+ concentration of
1 µM was required.
|
Fig. 4 A shows that an increase in lumenal Ca2+
concentration from 10 µM to 1 mM caused an ~5-fold increase in
Po at
35 mV. By comparison, an only minimal increase in
channel activity was evident at +35 mV. Fig. 4 B compares
the dependence of CRC activity on lumenal Ca2+
concentrations at cytosolic Ca2+ concentrations that
resulted in either a minimum (1 µM Ca2+) or close to
maximum (10 µM Ca2+) channel activity in the absence of
caffeine. In the presence of 1 µM cytosolic Ca2+, lower
lumenal [Ca2+] was required at negative than positive
holding potentials to observe a significant increase in Po
(
0.2 mM at
35 mV vs.
5 mM at +35 mV; corresponding lumenal
Ca2+ fluxes were
0.8 pA and
0.7 pA). In the presence of
10 µM cytosolic Ca2+, Po decreased at the
negative holding potential at [Ca2+]
1 mM, whereas only
a small (not significant) increase was obtained at +35 mV at lumenal
[Ca2+] as high as 10 mM (corresponding Ca2+
fluxes were
3 pA and 0.9 pA, respectively). These results suggest that Ca2+-activated CRCs can be activated or inactivated in
a voltage-dependent manner by lumenal Ca2+ in the
absence of caffeine.
The inhibitory effects of lumenal Ca2+ on Po of maximally activated channels were also determined at a holding potential of 0 mV in a symmetric 0.25 M KCl buffer containing 20 mM lumenal Ca2+ and 10 µM cytosolic Ca2+. The measured Ca2+ current of 2.7 ± 0.4 pA (n = 4) was close to a calculated value of 3.1 pA. Po was significantly decreased by 32 ± 7% (n = 4) compared to control values obtained at ±5 mV at lumenal Ca2+ concentration of <2 µM (not shown). We conclude that the maximally Ca2+-activated CRCs can be inactivated at 0 mV by a directly measured Ca2+ flux in the absence of caffeine.
CRC conducts Mg2+ (Meissner, 1994
) and cytosolic
Mg2+ inactivates the cardiac CRC by binding to
Ca2+ activation and inactivation sites with micromolar and
millimolar affinity, respectively (Liu et al., 1998
; Laver et al.,
1997
). We rationalized that a voltage-independent inhibition of lumenal Mg2+ would suggest the existence of Mg2+
inhibitory sites that reside on the SR lumenal site, whereas a
voltage-dependent inhibition would favor the idea of an access of
lumenal Mg2+ to the cytosolic Ca2+ regulatory
sites. The effects of lumenal Mg2+ (0-50 mM) on single
cytosolic Ca2+-activated channels were tested at holding
potentials of ±5, ±35, and ±50 mV. In the presence of ~4 µM
Ca2+ in both bilayer chambers, a strong inhibition of
channel activity was observed at negative holding potentials that
favored the movement of lumenal Mg2+ to the cytosolic side
of CRC, and yielded lumenal-to-cytosolic Mg2+ fluxes of
2.0 pA. No appreciable inhibition was noted at positive holding
potentials that disfavored the movement of lumenal Mg2+ to
the cytosolic side of the bilayer and yielded Mg2+ fluxes
of <1 pA (not shown). We also measured the Mg2+ current at
0 mV in a symmetric 0.25 M KCl solution containing 10 mM lumenal
Mg2+. Addition of 10 mM lumenal Mg2+ decreased
Po to 22 ± 10% of the control at ±5 mV in the
absence of Mg2+ (n = 5). The directly
measured Mg2+ current of 2.1 ± 0.1 pA
(n = 5) agreed well with calculated value of 2.2 pA. We
conclude from these observations that lumenal Mg2+ fluxes
affected cardiac CRC activity by having access to the channel's
cytosolic Ca2+ regulatory sites. In frog skeletal muscle,
the Mg2+ levels in the SR lumen near the Ca2+
release sites increase rather than decrease during tetanus (Somlyo et
al., 1985
). An in vivo regulation by lumenal-to-cytosolic
Mg2+ fluxes appears, therefore, to be unlikely.
Regulation of cardiac Ca2+ release channel by cytosolic and lumenal Ca2+ in the presence of 5 mM MgATP
The total ATP and free Mg2+ concentrations in
myocardium have been estimated to range from 5 to 10 mM (Koretsune et
al., 1991
; Hohl et al., 1992
) and 0.7-1.0 mM (Murphy et al., 1989
),
respectively. Figs. 5 and
6 compare the voltage-dependence of
cytosolic and lumenal Ca2+-activated channel activities
recorded in the presence of 5 mM cytosolic MgATP (~0.7 mM free
Mg2+), but in the absence of caffeine. An ~10× higher
cytosolic Ca2+ concentration was required to half-maximally
activate the cardiac CRC (KHa = 14.4 µM vs. 1 µM, Figs. 5 B and 1 B, respectively). As observed in the presence of caffeine (Fig. 1), no significant voltage-dependence in channel activity was noted for cardiac release channels activated by cytosolic Ca2+ in the presence of 5 mM cytosolic MgATP (Fig. 5, A and B).
|
|
In contrast to cytosolic Ca2+-activated channels, CRC
activities indicate a voltage-dependence when recorded at elevated
lumenal Ca2+ concentrations. In Fig. 6 A, a
single cardiac CRC was recorded in the presence of 10 µM cytosolic
Ca2+ and 5 mM cytosolic MgATP at lumenal Ca2+
concentrations of 4 µM and 200 µM. Elevation of lumenal
Ca2+ resulted in increased channel activity at
50 mV but
not +50 mV. Fig. 6 B shows that at
50 mV channels were
significantly activated at lumenal [Ca2+] of ~200-1000
µM. Higher lumenal Ca2+ concentrations resulted in (not
significant) inactivation of channel activities. At +50 mV, higher
lumenal Ca2+ concentrations were required to observe an
increase in channel activity; however, these were not significant.
Fig. 7, A and B compares the kinetic parameters of cytosolic and lumenal Ca2+-activated channel activities recorded in the presence of 5 mM cytosolic MgATP. An increase in cytosolic Ca2+ concentration from ~0.1 to 100 µM increased Po from nearly zero to ~1.0. This increase could be largely accounted for by an ~100-fold increase in the number of channel events and ~1000-fold increase in mean open times (Fig. 7 A). Mean closed events were decreased by ~100-fold. A further increase of cytosolic Ca2+ to 10 mM decreased Po by decreasing mean open times and by slightly increasing the duration of mean closed events, without having an appreciable effect on the number of events. In Fig. 7 B, mean Po, number of channel events, and mean open and closed times are plotted against the lumenal Ca2+ fluxes. The latter were less effective in activating cardiac CRCs than cytosolic Ca2+ (Po,max = ~1 at cytosolic Ca2+ of ~100 µM vs. ~0.15 at lumenal Ca2+ flux of ~3 pA). Small increases in Po could be largely accounted for by small (significant) increases in duration of mean open times. Few, if any, changes were observed in the number of channel events and duration of mean closed events, as lumenal Ca2+ fluxes increased from 0.003 to 10 pA. Taken together, the data of Fig. 7, A and B suggest that lumenal-to-cytosolic Ca2+ fluxes can regulate the cardiac CRC in the presence of physiologically relevant concentrations of Mg2+ and ATP.
|
| |
DISCUSSION |
|---|
|
|
|---|
The results of this study suggest that lumenal Ca2+ flowing through the open cardiac Ca2+ release channel can regulate the channel by having access to cytosolic activation and inactivation sites. Activation in the presence of Mg2+ and ATP suggests that regulation of CRC by lumenal Ca2+ fluxes may be physiologically relevant.
Regulation of cardiac CRC activity by cytosolic and lumenal Ca2+
To distinguish between the effects of SR cytosolic and lumenal
Ca2+ on channel activity, single purified channels were
recorded in symmetric KCl media at different holding potentials and
with varying Ca2+ concentrations in the trans
(SR lumenal) and cis (cytosolic) chambers of the bilayer
apparatus. As previously observed for the skeletal muscle CRC (Tripathy
and Meissner, 1996
), a strong voltage-dependence of channel activities
was observed in the presence of elevated levels of lumenal, but not
cytosolic, Ca2+. A voltage-dependent activation by lumenal
Ca2+ was observed in the absence of caffeine provided
sufficiently high cytosolic [Ca2+] was used to partially
open the channel, which suggested that other channel activators such as
sulmazole (Sitsapesan and Williams, 1994a
) or ATP (Lukyanenko et al.,
1996
) were not required for cardiac channel activation by lumenal
Ca2+. In the absence of caffeine and with cytosolic
[Ca2+] of <0.1 µM in the presence (Fig. 7) and absence
(Fig. 4) of 5 mM MgATP, the cardiac CRC rarely opened. Under these
recording conditions, lumenal [Ca2+] as high as 10 mM was
not able to significantly activate the channel. In agreement with this
finding, cellular SR lumenal [Ca2+], which is thought to
be close to 1 mM, does not activate the "closed" CRC. As in cells,
where Ca2+ ions entering the cells activates the cardiac
CRC, the presence of a cytosolic activator such as Ca2+ or
caffeine was required before an activation and inactivation of the CRC
by lumenal Ca2+ could be observed. Lack of an activation of
the "closed" CRC by lumenal Ca2+ argues against a
low-affinity Ca2+ regulatory site that resides on the
lumenal site of the channel.
The lumenal-to-cytosolic Ca2+ fluxes were calculated using
a four-barrier model that describes the ionic conduction of the sheep cardiac CRC (Tinker et al., 1992
). In general, barrier models are
inadequate to explain ion fluxes through channels over a large range of
membrane potential (Chen et al., 1997
). This limitation was also
pointed out by Tinker et al. (1992)
who could not fit their data by a
four-barrier model at potentials >±80 mV. Recently, the flow of
K+ through cardiac CRC has been modeled by diffusion theory
using a combination of the Nernst-Plank and Poisson (PNP) equations (Chen et al., 1997
). The model predicts a high K+
concentration (~4 M) in the selectivity filter at bath concentrations as low as 25 mM, thus providing an explanation for the high
conductances of the CRCs. However, in contrast to the Tinker model, the
PNP model has not yet been extended to mixed solutions containing Ca2+. Tinker et al. (1992)
measured and modeled ion
conductances in bionic and mixed solutions, including Ca2+,
Mg2+, and K+. We directly measured
Ca2+ and Mg2+ currents and their effects at 0 mV in symmetric KCl solutions. Good agreement with the calculated
values suggests that at the membrane potentials used in our study, the
Tinker model serves as a useful "curve-fitting" tool to predict ion
fluxes in mixed solutions.
Parameters determining the extent of CRC activation and inactivation by lumenal Ca2+
The extent of CRC activation by lumenal Ca2+ was
dependent on the presence of Ca2+, MgATP, and caffeine in
the cytosolic (cis) chamber of the bilayer apparatus. In
agreement with observations of an increased Ca2+ affinity
of Ca2+ activation sites by caffeine (Zucchi and
Ronca-Testoni, 1997
; Liu et al., 1998
), channels could be more
effectively activated at lower lumenal Ca2+ fluxes in the
presence of caffeine (100 µM lumenal Ca2+ at
50 mV
corresponds to lumenal Ca2+ flux of 0.6 pA, Fig. 2
B) than in the absence of caffeine (200 µM lumenal
Ca2+ at
35 mV corresponds to lumenal Ca2+
flux of 0.8 pA, Fig. 4 B). Addition of 5 mM cytosolic MgATP
increases the Hill constant of Ca2+ activation by cytosolic
Ca2+ by 3-4-fold (Xu et al., 1996
; Fig. 6). In reasonable
agreement with this result, CRCs were activated by lower lumenal
Ca2+ fluxes in the absence of MgATP (0.8 pA in Fig. 4
B; in Fig. 6, 200 µM lumenal Ca2+ at
50 mV
corresponds to lumenal Ca2+ flux of 1.0 pA).
Lumenal Ca2+ fluxes lead to the buildup of a high cytosolic
Ca2+ concentration near the release sites (Stern, 1992
;
Fig. 8), which raised the possibility
that lumenal Ca2+ fluxes inactivated the channels before
they could be fully activated. We tested this idea using the "fast"
Ca2+-complexing buffer BAPTA. Because of its high
association rate BAPTA can suppress the rise in Ca2+
concentration at locations several nanometers away from the release site (Stern, 1992
; Fig. 8). Fig. 3 B (top panel)
shows that 20 mM cytosolic BAPTA increased channel activities close to
those observed in the presence of micromolar-to-millimolar cytosolic [Ca2+] (Fig. 3 A, top panel), thus supporting
the idea that lumenal Ca2+ fluxes cannot only activate but
also inactivate the cardiac CRC. Channel activation by cytosolic
effectors was required to observe the effects of lumenal
Ca2+. This finding limited the conditions that could be
used to test the effects of BAPTA. Specifically, BAPTA could not be
used to test the effects of lumenal Ca2+ fluxes in the
presence of 5 mM MgATP because, in agreement with the in vivo function
of the CRC, only few, if any, channel openings could be observed at
cytosolic Ca2+ concentrations of
0.1 µM.
|
Kinetics of CRC activation and inactivation by cytosolic and lumenal Ca2+
Kinetics of cytosolic Ca2+-mediated channel activation
and inactivation are, at least in principle, more straightforward than those by lumenal Ca2+ and will therefore be discussed
first. At low cytosolic Ca2+ concentrations, channels
opened infrequently and long-closed/short-open channel events
predominated, resulting in a low channel open probability (Figs. 1
A and 5 A). An increase in the number of channel
events and a decrease in closed mean times with increasing
Ca2+ concentration indicated that cytosolic
Ca2+ increased Po by increasing the transition
rates from the closed to open state(s). A second effect of increasing
cytosolic [Ca2+] was to increase the mean open times.
Ca2+ activated CRCs by a cooperative mechanism in the
presence of caffeine and MgATP, and the increase in mean open time may
have been therefore due to the cooperative binding of Ca2+
to the tetrameric channel complex. An increase in open times by
cytosolic Ca2+ was also observed for the sheep cardiac CRC
(Sitsapesan and Williams, 1994b
). This increase was explained by
assuming a Ca2+-dependent pathway between two open states.
High Ca2+ concentrations inactivate the channel by binding
to low-affinity sites (Liu et al., 1998
; Laver et al., 1995
). In our
single channel recordings, 10 mM cytosolic Ca2+ decreased
Po by decreasing the mean open times and increasing the
mean closed times, without appreciably affecting the number of single
channel events. These changes suggest that Ca2+ binding to
the Ca2+-inactivation sites affects both the transition
rates from the open-to-closed and from the closed-to-open states,
increasing the former and decreasing the latter.
According to our model, lumenal Ca2+ is only available to
cytosolic Ca2+ regulatory sites when a channel opens.
Ca2+ gradients formed by Ca2+ fluxes build up
and dissipate in ~50 µs as channels open and close (Simon and
Llinas, 1985
). Accordingly, cytosolic Ca2+ gradients formed
by lumenal Ca2+ fluxes likely had a lifetime that was less
than that of the shortest channel events seen in the bilayers (~0.2
ms). One would then expect that the frequency of channel openings is
being set mainly by the cytosolic Ca2+, caffeine, and MgATP
concentrations, while lumenal Ca2+ does not noticeably
affect the number of events and duration of mean closed events. In
agreement with this prediction, lumenal Ca2+ did not
significantly affect the number of channel events and duration of mean
closed events. Much of the increase in Po observed for
lumenal Ca2+-activated channels could be accounted for by
an increase in mean open times. This increase was likely due to the
rapid buildup of a cytosolic Ca2+ gradient because a
similar prolongation in mean open times was observed with increasing
cytosolic [Ca2+] (Figs. 3 A and 7
A, third panels). We conclude that lumenal Ca2+ ions flowing through open channels may increase the
duration of channel open events by elevating cytosolic
[Ca2+] at Ca2+ activation sites. The
frequency of these regulatory events is mainly set by cytosolic factors
that determine the frequency of channel openings such as cytosolic
Ca2+ or MgATP.
Location of activation and inactivation sites
Cryoelectron microscopy and image analysis have indicated that the
skeletal muscle CRC consists of a large 29 × 29 × 12 nm cytosolic "foot" region and a smaller transmembrane region that extends ~7 nm toward the SR lumen and likely contains a centrally located Ca2+ channel pore (Radermacher et al., 1994
;
Serysheva et al., 1995
). A very similar architecture has been deduced
for the cardiac CRC (Sharma et al., 1997
). The cardiac CRC is thought
to have at least two classes of Ca2+ binding sites, a
high-affinity activation and a low-affinity inactivation site. The
location of these sites, however, has not been established. Although
our single channel measurements cannot pinpoint the location of the
Ca2+ regulatory sites on the large cardiac CRC complex, our
data can provide tentative information with respect to their distance
from the cytosolic Ca2+ release site. Fig. 3 B
shows that lumenal Ca2+ fluxes of 0.1 pA did not
significantly activate the cardiac CRC in the presence of 10 mM
caffeine. By comparison, Ca2+ fluxes of 1 pA and greater
caused a nearly maximum activation of channels that were recorded in
the presence of 10 mM caffeine and 20 mM BAPTA. The cytosolic
Ca2+ concentration profiles that were obtained at lumenal
Ca2+ fluxes of 0.1 pA and 3 pA are included in Fig. 8. Also
indicated in Fig. 8 is the cytosolic Ca2+ concentration (1 µM, dotted line) that resulted in half-maximum activation
of CRCs in the presence of 10 mM caffeine (Fig. 1 B). Together these data show that lumenal Ca2+ fluxes as low as
0.1 pA should have been sufficient to maximally activate the CRC, even
if the activation sites would have been located 30 nm away from the
release site, which is more than the dimensions of the cardiac CRC.
Another argument against a distance
20 nm between the
Ca2+ activation and release sites is that 20 mM BAPTA at
lumenal flux of 3 pA would have been expected to lower channel
activity, which clearly was not the case. A similar paradoxical
situation between the measured cytosolic Ca2+-activating
concentrations and calculated effects of lumenal Ca2+
fluxes was obtained for the skeletal muscle CRC (Tripathy and Meissner,
1996
). To explain the paradox, skeletal muscle cytosolic Ca2+ activation sites were placed within the foot region at
BAPTA "inaccessible" sites. It was further suggested that these
sites see a minor portion, whereas Ca2+ inactivation sites
see a major portion of lumenal Ca2+. We propose a similar
model for the cardiac CRC. The model suggests that lumenal
Ca2+ fluxes increase Ca2+ concentrations to a
lesser extent at the Ca2+ activation than Ca2+
inactivation sites, thus explaining that, as observed in the present
study, Ca2+ inactivation sets in before the cardiac CRC can
be fully activated by lumenal Ca2+.
The distance between the Ca2+ release and Ca2+
inactivation sites of the cardiac CRC was estimated as follows. Fig. 2
C shows that channels activated by 4 µM cytosolic
Ca2+ in the presence of 10 mM caffeine were half-maximally
inactivated at a lumenal Ca2+ flux of ~10 pA. This flux
resulted in a half-maximally inactivating cytosolic Ca2+
concentration of 10 mM (Fig. 1 B) at a distance of ~3 nm
from the release site (Fig. 8). Single channel measurements with the fast Ca2+-complexing buffer BAPTA suggest that a distance
of 3 nm between the release and Ca2+ inactivation sites may
be an upper limit. BAPTA increased channel activities at a lumenal
Ca2+ flux of 3 pA to close a maximum value (Fig. 3
B). At a distance of 3 nm, a cytosolic [Ca2+]
of ~3 mM is calculated (Fig. 8), which appears to be too low to cause
substantial Ca2+ inactivation (Fig. 1 B). Higher
cytosolic [Ca2+] exists closer to the release site (Fig.
8). However, placement of Ca2+ inactivation sites too close
to the release site is problematic because it renders BAPTA ineffective
in lowering [Ca2+]. According to Fig. 8, a compromise is
reached at a distance of 1 nm from the release site. At this distance
and at a lumenal Ca2+ flux of 3 pA, a cytosolic
[Ca2+] of ~9 mM is calculated, which is lowered by 20 mM BAPTA to ~6 mM (Fig. 8). Such a decrease can account, at least in
principle, for the activating effects of BAPTA (Fig. 3 B).
Taken together, these results suggest that the Ca2+
inactivation site(s) lie(s) at a distance of
3 nm from the release site. This distance is reasonably close to the distances of 3-6 nm
estimated between the two sites of the skeletal muscle CRC (Tripathy
and Meissner, 1996
).
Physiological implications
In mammalian ventricular muscle, clusters of Ca2+
release channels are located near the surface membrane and tubular
infoldings (T-tubule) of the surface membrane (Franzini-Armstrong and
Protasi, 1997
). Immunolocalization studies suggest a co-distribution of CRCs with surface dihydropyridine receptors (Ca2+ channels,
L-type), which provides a morphological basis for the Ca2+-induced Ca2+ release (CICR) mechanism
(Carl et al., 1995
). Recent studies suggest that the opening of a
single L-type Ca2+ channel may be sufficient to evoke a
localized Ca2+ release event ("Ca2+ spark")
by activating one or more CRCs (Santana et al., 1996
). During L-type
Ca2+ channel opening the Ca2+ concentration can
reach millimolar values (Langer and Peskoff, 1996
), which are more than
enough to activate closely apposed Ca2+ release channels.
The present study shows that SR lumenal Ca2+ can contribute
to the regulation of cardiac SR Ca2+ release via direct
feedback by binding to channels that release Ca2+. In
myocardium these events may involve more than one channel because, in
addition to its own channel, lumenal Ca2+ fluxes may
activate and inactivate closely located Ca2+ release
channels.
| |
ACKNOWLEDGMENTS |
|---|
The authors thank Daniel A. Pasek for purifying the cardiac CRC,
Dr. Alan J. Williams for the computer program in calculating the
lumenal-to-cytosolic Ca2+ fluxes, and Dr. Judy Heiny for
the computer program in estimating the Ca2+ gradient near
the Ca2+ release sites. The latter program is based on Eq.
13 of the paper by Stern (1992)
.
This work was supported in part by National Institutes of Health Grants HL27430 and AR18687.
| |
FOOTNOTES |
|---|
Received for publication 30 December 1997 and in final form 11 August 1998.
Address reprint requests to Dr. Gerhard Meissner, Department of Biochemistry and Biophysics, University of North Carolina, Chapel Hill, NC 27599-7260. Tel.: 919-966-5021; Fax: 919-966-2852; E-mail: meissner{at}med.unc.edu.
| |
REFERENCES |
|---|
|
|
|---|
Biophys J, November 1998, p. 2302-2312, Vol. 75, No. 5
© 1998 by the Biophysical Society 0006-3495/98/11/2302/11 $2.00
This article has been cited by other articles:
![]() |
A. V. Zima, E. Picht, D. M. Bers, and L. A. Blatter Termination of Cardiac Ca2+ Sparks: Role of Intra-SR [Ca2+], Release Flux, and Intra-SR Ca2+ Diffusion Circ. Res., October 10, 2008; 103(8): e105 - e115. [Abstract] [Full Text] [PDF] |
||||
![]() |
D. R. Laver and B. N. Honen Luminal Mg2+, A Key Factor Controlling RYR2-mediated Ca2+ Release: Cytoplasmic and Lumi |