| HOME | HELP | FEEDBACK | SUBSCRIPTIONS | ARCHIVE | SEARCH | TABLE OF CONTENTS |
Biophys J, March 1999, p. 1659-1667, Vol. 76, No. 3
*Institut für Angewandte Physik, Ludwig-Maximilians Universität, Munich, Germany; #Department of Cell Biology, University of Nijmegen, Nijmegen, The Netherlands; §Physik Department E22, Technische Universität, Munich, Germany; and ¶Physiologisches Institut, Ludwig-Maximilians Universität, Munich, Germany
| |
ABSTRACT |
|---|
|
|
|---|
In testing various designs of cell-semiconductor hybrids, the choice of a suitable type of electrically excitable cell is crucial. Here normal rat kidney (NRK) fibroblasts are presented as a cell line, easily maintained in culture, that may substitute for heart or nerve cells in many experiments. Like heart muscle cells, NRK fibroblasts form electrically coupled confluent cell layers, in which propagating action potentials are spontaneously generated. These, however, are not associated with mechanical disturbances. Here we compare heart muscle cells and NRK fibroblasts with respect to action potential waveform, morphology, and substrate adhesion profile, using the whole-cell variant of the patch-clamp technique, atomic force microscopy (AFM), and reflection interference contrast microscopy (RICM), respectively. Our results clearly demonstrate that NRK fibroblasts should provide a highly suitable test system for investigating the signal transfer between electrically excitable cells and extracellular detectors, available at a minimum cost and effort for the experimenters.
| |
INTRODUCTION |
|---|
|
|
|---|
Cell semiconductor hybrids are of great interest
for a large variety of applications, such as monitoring electrical
communication within neuronal networks or other electrically active
cellular aggregates or the development of new neuronal prostheses. In
principle, they provide for noninvasive, simultaneous, and spatially
resolved recordings with long-term stability of bioelectrical activity from multiple single cells (Denyer et al., manuscript submitted for
publication; Gross et al., 1997
). These requirements are obviously not
met by classical microelectrode or patch-clamp recording
techniques. Optical recording using voltage-sensitive dyes, while
enabling simultaneous recording from different locations, cannot be
considered noninvasive, because it will eventually result in
photodynamic damage of cells (Schaffer et al., 1994
).
At present, two extracellular recording techniques are available that
are based on cells adherent to semiconductor-detectors or planar metal
electrodes. When electrically excitable cells are close to the gate
electrode of a field effect transistor (FET), their action potentials
can steer the source drain current (Bergveld et al., 1976
; Fromherz et
al., 1991
). Another possibility is to adhere cells close to planar,
extracellular microelectrodes, such as thin wires made of
indium-tin-oxide (ITO) or platinized gold (Gross et al., 1985
, 1995
;
Jimbo et al., 1993
; Regehr et al., 1989
) and measure their electrical
activity either as ohmic or transient currents. With both techniques,
signal transduction between single neurons of invertebrates (e.g.,
leeches (Fromherz et al., 1991
; Wilson et al., 1994
) or snails (Gross
et al., 1977
; Novak, 1986
; Regehr et al., 1989
)) and the extracellular
detector is possible. The signal-to-noise ratio is typically better
than 1000.
Gross et al. were able to monitor action potentials from mammalian
neuronal tissue adhered to extracellular microelectrodes (Gross et al.,
1995
, 1997
). Furthermore, the groups of Fromherz and Offenhäusser
could record electrical activity from single mammalian neurons
maintained 3-5 days in vitro (DIV) with FETs, which were stimulated
with artificial test pulses by patch clamp (Offenhäusser et al.,
1997
; Vassanelli and Fromherz, 1997
; Vassanelli and Fromherz, 1998
). At
present an important aim is still to improve recordings of defined
action potentials from single mammalian neurons under natural
conditions. New semiconductor designs with enhanced sensitivity will be
needed to reach this goal.
In addition to neurons, action potentials from layers of heart muscle
cells have been detected with FETs (Sprössler et al., manuscript
submitted for publication) and extracellular microelectrodes (Connolly
et al., 1990
; Denyer et al., manuscript submitted for publication;
Israel et al., 1984
, 1990
; Thomas et al., 1972
), respectively. Heart
muscle cells have been proved to be very stable systems for
extracellular potential recordings and can be used for drug screening
assays, correlating changes in beating intervals with the amount of
added pharmaceutical agents (Denyer et al., manuscript submitted for
publication). With cardiomyocytes, electrical activity is necessarily
associated with mechanical movement. Depending on the principle of
measurement used, electromechanical coupling may thus introduce
artificial signals.
Unfortunately, all of the cell systems described above are primary cultures and thus have to be freshly prepared for each experiment. Clearly, an electrically excitable cell system that could be kept in culture and could be easily grown on extracellular recording devices would be a very convenient means of testing new generations of cell-semiconductor hybrids.
Recently it was found that normal rat kidney (NRK) fibroblasts can
behave like an excitable tissue (deRoos et al., 1997a
,b
, 1998
). These
fibroblasts can easily be kept in culture and grow under standard cell
culture conditions. In these monolayers, Ca2+ action
potentials can be generated by depolarization with either bradykinin or
an elevation of the extracellular K+ concentration. When
only a part of the monolayer is depolarized by a localized addition of
high K+, a propagating action potential is generated that
travels at a speed of ~6 mm/s through the monolayer (deRoos et al.,
1998
). These action potentials are characterized by an upstroke to
positive membrane potentials and are carried by Ca2+, but
can also be carried by Sr2+ ions through Ca2+
channels. After a plateau phase (or shoulder) due to the opening of
Ca2+ activated Cl
channels, cells finally
return by repolarization to resting levels. Besides stimulated action
potentials, NRK fibroblasts can exhibit spontaneous Ca2+
action potentials, leading to synchronized Ca2+ spiking
(deRoos et al., 1997a
). Unlike heart muscle cells and neuronal cells,
these action potentials appear to have no Na+ component,
and the duration of the action potential is much longer in NRK fibroblasts.
Two sets of properties are central to the potential usefulness of a
cell type in testing cell-semiconductor hybrids: 1) its electrical
excitability and 2) its adhesion to the detector surface. Here we used
the whole-cell configuration of the patch-clamp technique to assess the
amplitude and time course of action potentials. Atomic force
microscopy (AFM) (Henderson et al., 1992
; Radmacher et al., 1992
) is an
established technique that enables the micromorphological study of
living cells. We make use of this technique in this study to determine
the shape, height profile, and adherence of cells growing on
semiconductor wafers. The immediate zone of adhesion, in turn, can be
imaged by reflection interference contrast microscopy (RICM) (Izzard
and Lochner, 1976
; Schindl et al., 1995
; Simson et al., 1998
), where,
in close analogy to the formation of Newton's rings (Hecht, 1987
),
optical interference is measured between cell and substrate.
| |
MATERIALS AND METHODS |
|---|
|
|
|---|
Cell culture
As substrates silicon chips (Cytosensor Microphysiometer chips; Molecular Devices Corporation, Sunnyvale, CA) covered with SiO2/Si3N4 and glass microscope cover slides (Assistent, Munich, Germany) were used. They were cleaned by sonification successively in ethanol, Millipore water (Milli-Q plus 185; Millipore, Eschborn, Germany), detergent (2% Hellmanex II, no. 320.001; Hellma GmbH, Müllheim, Germany), and KOH dissolved in ethanol solution and two times in Millipore water. All substrates used for heart cell cultures were coated with fibronectin to improve cellular adhesion. Because the aim of this paper is to compare the properties of NRK fibroblasts with heart muscle cells as a reference system, we adopted the fibronectin coating protocol from reports, in which recordings of extracellular potentials were reported (Denyer et al., manuscript submitted for publication; Sprössler et al., manuscript submitted for publication).
NRK fibroblasts (clone 49F) were seeded at a density of 10+4 cells/cm2 on uncoated glass or silicon substrates, respectively, and grown to confluence in bicarbonate-buffered Dulbecco's modified Eagle's medium (DMEM, Gibco no. 31966) supplemented with 10% newborn calf serum (no. N-4637; Sigma, Deisenhofen, Germany) and 1% penicillin-streptomycin (Sigma no. P-7539). Confluent cultures were made quiescent by incubating them in serum-free DF medium (DMEM/Ham's F12, 1:1, Gibco no. 11321; Life Technologies GmbH, Eggenstein, Germany) supplemented with 30 nM Na2SeO3 (Gibco no. 13012), 10 µg/ml human transferrin (Gibco no. 13008), and 1% penicillin-streptomycin.
Heart muscle cells were prepared according to the protocols of Riehle
et al. and Denyer et al. (Denyer et al., manuscript submitted for
publication; Riehle and Bereiter-Hahn, 1994
). Briefly, hearts were
extracted from 7-9-day-old chicken embryos and enzymatically dissolved. The cell suspension was then transferred in a tissue culture
flask and incubated for 1 h. This incubation allowed the majority
of fibroblasts to adhere to the flask, leaving an increased proportion
of ~80% myocytes in suspension (Blondel et al., 1971
). Finally,
heart cells were plated on substrates at densities of 25-30 × 10+4 cells/cm2 and incubated for 24 h.
Every 2 days, medium was exchanged with new M199 medium (Gibco no.
21183), supplemented with 2% of 1 M HEPES, 0.5% of
7.5%-NaHCO3, 0.5% ITS (Gibco no. 41400), 1.5% of 200 mM
L-glutamine, 1% penicillin-streptomycin solution, 0.13% amphotericin B solution, and 3% fetal calf serum (pH 7.5). After 1-2
days in vitro (DIV), large areas of the confluent cell layers started
beating. All measurements were made after 1-4 DIV.
Patch clamp
Current clamp was applied with an EPC7 patch-clamp amplifier
(List, Darmstadt, Germany), using the whole-cell configuration (Hamill
et al., 1981
) (see Fig. 1). All
measurements were made on confluent cells grown on silicon wafers at
room temperature without CO2 control.
|
NRK fibroblasts
Cells were incubated in a nominally Ca2+-free DF medium supplemented with 3 mM Sr2+ as previously described (deRoos et al., 1998Heart muscle cells
Spontaneous action potentials were recorded at parts of the cell layer where no contraction was visible. Pipettes were filled with a high-K+ solution (Risso and DeFelice, 1993Atomic force microscopy
AFM was performed with a commercial instrument (Bioscope;
Digital Instruments, Santa Barbara, CA) (see Fig. 1). All experiments were made on cells grown on silicon wafers. Wafers were glued in 35-mm
culture dishes, which were then filled with culture medium. Silicon
nitride cantilevers (Microlevers; Park Scientific, Santa Clara, CA)
were used as AFM tips. These had a force constant of 8 mN/m, calibrated
by the thermal noise method (Butt and Jaschke, 1995
). For obtaining
elastic properties and the real topography of the investigated sample,
the force mapping mode (Cleveland et al., 1995
) was employed: force
curves were taken while the tip was raster-scanned laterally over the
sample. As described in great detail previously (Domke and Radmacher,
1998
), fitting the force curves with the Hertz model yields a
quantitative value of the elastic (Young's) modulus and the real
height of the sample. Because this evaluation needs force curves
recorded on cells and on the uncovered substrate, subconfluent cells
were used.
Reflection interference contrast microscopy
The principle of image formation (Gingell and Todd, 1979
;
Rädler and Sackmann, 1993
; Wiegand et al., manuscript submitted for publication) is illustrated in Fig. 1. To discriminate between light reflected from the contact zone between cell and substrate and
from the organelles and the backside of the cells, one can change the
illuminating numerical aperture (INA) (Verschueren, 1985
). At high INA
values, reflections in the close proximity of the substrate surface
dominate the measured intensity I(x, y) (Gingell and Todd, 1979
; Wiegand et al., manuscript
submitted for publication). Multireflections were neglected because of
the low reflectivity of the particular interfaces. If one would assume in first order that only light I2 from the
medium/cell-membrane interface interferes with the reference intensity
I1 (neglecting I3,
I4, ...) and that the interface is parallel
to the substrate surface, then I(x, y)
would be a cosine transformation of the local distance
d1(x, y) between cell and
substrate. As a consequence of the higher refractive index of the cell
membrane (n2) than the index of the surrounding
medium (n1), light reflected from the
buffer/cell interface experiences a phase shift of
=
. Therefore, the areas of close contact of an adhering cell appear dark
in RICM.
All experiments were made with subconfluent cells grown on glass cover
slides. The microscope setup used for the present experiments was a
modified (Pluta, 1988
) Zeiss Axiomat microscope (Oberkochen, Ger-many). Monochromatic epi illumination was provided by a 100-W high-pressure mercury lamp and a bandpass filter (d
= 5 nm,
85% peak transmission) selecting the green 546.1-nm line. Field and aperture stops were adjusted to an INA of 0.75. The microscope was
equipped with a Zeiss Neofluar 63/1.25 Antiflex objective and two
polarizers. The antiflex technique (Schindl et al., 1995
) was used to
eliminate stray light in the microscope, which could obscure the low
intensity (1%) of the reflected light. RICM images were recorded with
a CCD camera (HR480, Aqua TV; Germany), preprocessed with a
Datacube image-processing system (Datacube Peabody, Boston, MA), and
stored with a S-VHS video recorder (AG7350; Panasonic). A video board
(Perceptics, Knoxville, TN) was used to digitize the images into 256 gray levels, and image processing was carried out with the software NIH
Image (Wayne Rasband, National Institutes of Health, Bethesda, MD). For
static image analysis the data were averaged over four to eight frames
to reduce camera noise.
| |
RESULTS |
|---|
|
|
|---|
Typical action potentials recorded with patch pipettes in the
current clamp mode are shown in Fig. 2.
NRK cells showed an action potential rising from a resting membrane
potential of
64 ± 7 mV (n = 11; all values are
given including their standard deviation) to a peak of 35 ± 5 mV. This yields a maximum change in membrane potential of 99 ± 9 mV. The rapid phase of the action potential was followed by a
plateau phase lasting 39 ± 11 s. During the upstroke of the
action potential, the rate of depolarization was 1.2 ± 0.3 V/s.
These results show that action potentials can be generated when the
cells were grown on wafers, and they had characteristics similar to
those already described.
|
Cardiac pacemaker cells had a maximum diastolic potential of
59 ± 7 mV (n = 7). Spontaneous action potentials occurred
at intervals of between 500 ms and several seconds and reached +8 ± 6 mV, corresponding to an amplitude of 67 ± 9 mV. The maximum rate of rise was 1.6 ± 0.7 V/s.
Because nontransparent silicon wafers were used, AFM had to be performed without the help of an optical microscope, and thus cells could not be visually selected. Furthermore, in cultures of cardiomyocytes, a comparatively large number of dead or loosely adherent cells were present. Consequently, the AFM tips had to be changed often because of contamination.
Typical AFM images of living NRK fibroblasts and heart cells are shown in Fig. 3. They were recorded in constant deflection mode with a loading force of ~1-2 nN. Simultaneously recorded height (Fig. 3, A, C) and deflection data (Fig. 3, B, D) are presented. The height signal is derived from the piezo's feedback loop that is used to keep the loading force of the AFM tip constant and corresponds to the rough topography of the sample. Because the feedback loop has a finite time constant, small deviations in the surface topography show up as deflections of the cantilever and form the deflection signal.
|
Cell length (l) and breadth (b), as well as substrate area covered (A) are given directly by the images. Values obtained for heart cells (n = 11) were l = 72 ± 22 µm, b = 34 ± 13 µm, A = 1300 ± 500 µm2. For fibroblasts (n = 7) we found l = 64 ± 19 µm, b = 37 ± 15 µm, A = 1700 ± 400 µm2. In contrast, the height values were reduced by a factor of ~25% because of compression by the cantilever tip. By fitting the force curves with the Hertz model (see Materials and Methods), the real height (h) of cells was obtained: h = 2.9 ± 0.7 µm for heart cells and h = 3.6 ± 0.6 µm for fibroblasts.
To further characterize the morphology of these cells, we introduced
two shape parameters: one to measure the tendency of cells to be oblong
(s1 = l/b), so that for a
disk-shaped ellipsoid (l = b)
s1 = 1, and for a cigar-shaped ellipsoid
(l
b) s1
.
Another parameter was used to describe flatness
(s2 = (
/8)1/2h/A1/2), where
for a sphere-like ellipsoid (l = b = h, A
l × b)
s2 = 1, and for a disk-like ellipsoid
(h
l, b) s2 = 0. The results obtained from AFM measurements were
s1 = 2.1 ± 1.1, s2 = 0.050 ± 0.015 for heart cells and s1 = 1.7 ± 1.3, s2 = 0.055 ± 0.011 for fibroblasts.
RICM measurements were carried out on ~100 cells from seven different
preparations (selected pictures are shown in Fig.
4). Single NRK fibroblasts could be
easily identified, and dark areas, which correspond to the regions of
closest contact (focal contacts; Izzard and Lochner, 1976
) could be
localized in nearly every cell. In RICM images with NRK fibroblasts,
focal contacts were found to be distributed throughout the whole
underside of cells, comprising 16 ± 5% (n = 10)
of the total area of the membrane facing the substrate.
|
To obtain a quantitative estimate of cell-substrate separation, we used
a model containing the following four refractive layers (Schindl et
al., 1995
), with their respective refractive indices chosen to best
approximate the experimental data: glass substrate (n0 = 1.53), liquid medium
(n1 = 1.33), cell membrane
(n2 = 1.45), and cytoplasm
(n3 = 1.35). The optical thickness of the
membrane (d2) was assumed to be 10 nm. Such a
model allows the calculation of reflected light intensity
(I) as a function of cell-substrate distance
(d1) (Rädler and Sackmann, 1992
, 1993
).
Because the function relating these parameters is periodic with the
wavelength of the light source, a given intensity cannot be
unequivocally identified with a distance. For the purpose of this work,
we assumed that d1 in the focal contacts was
below the first intensity maximum. This assumption seems reasonable, as
otherwise distances of >200 nm would have been required to explain the
measured low intensities of reflected light. Our standard model gave a
mean cell-surface distance inside the focal contacts of 30 nm. This
value showed variations between different focal contacts of the same
cell of ±15 nm (n = 10 focal contacts). Between means
of different cells variation was ±20 nm (n = 10 cells). To estimate errors associated with this approach, the optical
parameters were systematically varied: changes of ~1% in one of the
parameters, of which the most influential was
n3, yielded changes of up to ± 25 nm in
d1.
The shape of heart cells was less regular than that of NRK fibroblasts, and borders between different cells were often blurred. Generally, RICM pictures recorded with heart cells showed less contrast, and fewer focal contacts could be clearly identified. The relative membrane area taken up by focal contacts in cardiomyocytes was 6 ± 3% (n = 10). This value is significantly smaller than that obtained for fibroblasts. To improve adhesion, heart cells were grown on fibronectin-coated substrates (Denyer et al., manuscript submitted for publication; Sprössler et al., manuscript submitted for publication). A quantitative evaluation of the RICM data obtained for heart muscle cells therefore would have required the introduction of two additional parameters (n, d) in the optical model. However, in view of the error bars, no absolute values for the cell substrate distance are declared for cardiomyocytes.
Some RICM images recorded with cardiomyocytes showed large interference
fringes, which are thought to represent light reflected at the upper
cell membrane (Ver-schueren, 1985
). They could be clearly
differentiated from reflections at the lower membrane and did not
affect the identification of focal contacts. In particular, during
rhythmic contractions, those membrane areas that were identified as
focal contacts did not change their interference pattern, whereas interference fringes widened, consistent with their origin at the upper membrane.
| |
DISCUSSION |
|---|
|
|
|---|
Action potentials in NRK fibroblasts have been described only
recently (deRoos et al., 1998
). It has also been demonstrated that
opening of voltage-dependent L-type Ca2+ channels underlies
the early fast phase of the action potential, whereas the plateau phase
that lasts tens of seconds is likely to be mediated by Cl
flux through Ca2+-dependent Cl
channels.
In the present study, cardiomyocytes derived from embryonic chick
hearts showed action potentials with rise rates only slightly higher
than that of fibroblasts. It is therefore likely that the cardiomyocytes studied here were pacemaker cells lacking fast voltage-dependent Na channels. For these, maximum slopes of action potentials well below 10 V/s have been described earlier at
physiological temperatures (Jacobson and Piper, 1986
; Kodama and
Boyett, 1985
; Nathan, 1986
). The mean value of 1.6 V/s we obtained at
room temperature, therefore, seems to be in good agreement with
previous data. The kinetic similarity of the rising phases of
fibroblast and cardiomyocyte action potentials is furthermore
plausible, because in both cell types it is mediated by L-type
Ca2+ channels.
Because the maximum height range of the piezo used for the AFM measurements was less than 6 µm, a preselection of cells concerning their heights was made. In addition to the applied loading force, the AFM tip also exerts lateral shear stress on the cells. For both reasons, it is therefore likely that we preferentially selected cells that were well adhered to the substrate.
Because of the applied loading force the surface of the cells was compressed. Thus cytoskeletal structures from beneath the cell membrane became visible. Especially in the case of the NRK fibroblasts, stress fibers, i.e., bundles of actin filaments, could be clearly resolved (see Fig. 3 B), illustrating the need to use force maps to correctly estimate the true sample height. Analyzing force maps makes it possible to calculate the point where the AFM tip first touches the sample and thus to reconstruct the real topography of the cells. Comparison of heights obtained from force curve analysis with the raw height images consequently showed marked discrepancies. For instance, the height calculated from the force map of the fibroblasts of Fig. 3 was ~4.2 µm, but the same cell appeared to be 2.6 µm high in contact mode.
Summarizing the results of the morphological analysis using the AFM, it is clear that fibroblasts have a larger surface area and are less oblong and less flattened than cardiomyocytes.
Measuring the cell-substrate distance with RICM yielded clear differences between NRK fibroblasts and heart muscle cells in that focal contacts were more abundant and widespread in NRK fibroblasts than in cardiomyocytes.
Focal contacts have been described in a variety of cells as their
closest contacts to substrate (Alberts et al., 1994
, p. 841), where
distances are reduced to a few tens of nanometers. Our result (30 ± 25 nm) is in reasonable agreement with the values most often cited
in the literature (10-15 nm; (Izzard and Lochner, 1976
).
It should be noted in this respect that absolute values are highly
influenced by the optical model selected for the analysis of RICM data.
For instance, highly divergent refractive indices, especially for the
cytoplasm, can be found in the literature (Izzard and Lochner, 1980
;
Schindl et al., 1995
; Verschueren, 1985
). Furthermore, it has been
argued that the refractive index of cellular compartments may be
inhomogeneous. For instance, it may be higher than average at focal
contacts, because of an enrichment in actin filaments (Bereiter-Hahn et
al., 1979
).
In addition, the multiple layers used in the model are defined as
optical entities, not as pure cell biological compartments. Thus
the value of 10 nm assumed for the membrane thickness would comprise
both the intracellular actin network and the extracellular glycocalyx
and is therefore larger than estimates of the thickness of a pure lipid
bilayer (Johnson et al., 1991
; Rädler and Sackmann, 1993
), which
yield ~3-5 nm.
An additional result of the RICM observations is that interference
fringes attributed to reflection at the upper membrane were more
frequently observed with cardiomyocytes but hardly ever with NRK
fibroblasts. Reflections from the upper face of the membrane are to be
expected only from very flat cells (Verschueren, 1985
). This finding
thus correlates well with our AFM data, which also indicate that heart
cells were much flatter.
In conclusion, RICM has shown that NRK fibroblasts form a denser array of focal contacts with the substrate than heart muscle cells, and that the latter appear to be significantly less extended into the third dimension.
An advantage of the RICM technique lies in the fact that it provides a
direct image of the cell's adhesion profile. Alternative techniques
for quantitative determination of cell-substrate distances include
total internal reflection fluorescence (TIRF) (Axelrod, 1981
; Axelrod
et al., 1984
; Gingell et al., 1985
; Hornung and Fuhr, 1996
; Hornung et
al., 1996
) and fluorescence interference-contrast microscopy (FLIC)
(Braun and Fromherz, 1997
; Lambacher and Fromherz, 1996
). Like RICM,
TIRF can only be used with glass supports; FLIC, however, is usable
with illumination from above and can therefore be applied to objects on
opaque material like silicon. To date, FLIC has only been used with
cells of a simple geometry.
The adhesion to substrate is one of the key components of success of any model for a cell-semiconductor hybrid. In this respect, the relevance of the RICM data obtained with glass substrates to the question of cell adhesion to silicon substrates merits discussion. As will be shown below, available data suggest that the two materials are equivalent regarding 1) chemical composition, 2) roughness, and 3) surface charge density.
Highly inert borosilicate coverslips were used as the glass substrate
(Schott D263M glass: 64.1% SiO2, 8.4%
B2O3, 4.2% Al2O3, 6.4% Na2O, 6.9% K2O, 5.9% ZnO, 4.0%
TiO2, 0.1% Sb2O3). In contact with
electrolytic solution, the surface of SiO2 is formed by
silanol sites. The manufacturing process for the silicon chips with a SiO2/Si3N4 surface, as used here,
has been described by Bousse et al. (1990)
. Because the authors claim
that Si3N4 surfaces in contact with
electrolytic solution comprise less than 2% amine sites and more than
98% silanol sites (Bousse and Mostarshed, 1991
), SiO2 and
Si3N4 surfaces seem to have very similar
reactive sites. To our knowledge, no specific chemical reactions of
cellular components with the surface sites of borosilicate glass or
silicon wafers with nitride surface have been reported. Therefore it
seems reasonable to assume that glass substrates used with RICM
experiments had surface sites similar to those of the silicon
substrates used with the AFM and patch-clamp experiments.
The roughness of glass slides and silicon wafers was determined on the
nanometer scale with the AFM by recording height profiles H(x, y) across the substrate surface.
Because substrates could have a slightly inclined orientation toward
the x-y plane, only height deviations
H(x, y) referred to the principal
plane of the substrate were used for further calculations. We defined
the roughness
H
of the substrate as the normalized
integral over the absolute height deviation
H, as already
implemented in the commercial AFM software:
|
x =
y= 10 µm
we obtained a mean roughness of
H
= 0.37 ± 0.07 nm (n = 9) for the silicon chips and of 0.39 ± 0.05 nm (n = 8) for the glass slides, which were used as substrates for the cells. The two roughnesses are equal within their
error bars.
Charge densities of a surface in electrolytic solution are often
expressed in terms of the pH at the point of zero charge (pHpzc). For pH > pHpzc and pH < pHpzc, the surfaces are negatively and positively charged,
respectively. In contact with electrolyte, the surface of silicon
nitride is composed of both silanol sites (Si-OH) and primary amine
sites (Si-NH2) (Harame et al., 1987
), whereas the surface
of silicon oxide consists only of silanol sites. Because the
pHpzc found for silicon nitride surfaces (2-4) is not very
different from silicon oxide surfaces, Bousse et al. conclude that
"the surface of silicon nitride is practically the same as that of
silicon oxide, and that virtually no ionizable amine groups remain at
the surface" (Bousse and Mostarshed, 1991
). Furthermore, Bousse et
al. claim that "for properties such as biocompatibility or protein
adsorption, ... Si3N4 is expected to be very
similar to SiO2" (Bousse and Mostarshed, 1991
). Therefore we conclude that there should be no significant difference in the
surface charge density between silicon chips and glass slides.
As mentioned above, the cell-substrate distance of cells
adherent to silicon wafers can be directly measured by the
FLIC technique, which was recently introduced by Fromherz and
co-workers (Braun and Fromherz, 1997
). To our knowledge, to date only
FLIC data obtained with erythrocytes have been published. It is useful
to compare the distance between erythrocytes adherent to silicon substrates measured with the FLIC technique (Braun and Fromherz, 1997
)
with the distance between erythrocytes adherent to glass substrates,
measured with the RICM technique (Donath and Gingell, 1983
; Gingell and
Todd, 1980
; Gingell and Vince, 1979
; Wolf and Gingell, 1983
). Braun et
al. obtained d1 = 12.4 ± 0.7 nm with erythrocytes adherent to polylysine-coated silicon chips with SiO2 surface (Braun and Fromherz, 1997
). Using the RICM
technique, Gingel et al. estimated d1 to be
~10 nm with erythrocytes adherent to polylysine-coated RBC-glass at
physiological salt concentrations (Gingell and Vince, 1979
; Wolf and
Gingell, 1983
). As determined by the two techniques, these results
indicate that at least for erythrocytes, the cleft between cells and
substrate is on the same order of magnitude.
We have also shown in an additional patch-clamp control
experiment that action potentials of heart muscle cells and
NRK fibroblasts adherent to glass coverslips had the same
characteristics as action potentials recorded with cells adherent to
silicon wafers. Likewise, no differences were found
within error
bars
between additional AFM data obtained with heart muscle cells and
NRK fibroblasts adherent to glass substrates and the AFM data obtained
with cells adherent to silicon wafers (data not shown).
Therefore, our RICM data, although obtained with cells on glass coverslips, are most likely relevant to the problem of cell adhesion on silicon wafers.
Cell-substrate adhesion is of crucial importance for signal transduction between cell and detector. We have therefore attempted in this study to quantitatively describe this parameter by two different approaches. It appears plausible that cellular adhesion depends on the distribution and density of focal contacts. One would equally expect flatness and oblong shape to be indicators of adhesion quality, as strong attraction between cell and substrate is required to overcome the cell's inherent tendency to adopt a rounded shape.
The conclusions to be drawn from this study regarding the quality of adhesion of NRK fibroblasts versus cardiomyocytes appear to depend on the point of reference: seen from below (RICM), NRK fibroblasts have a larger number and density of focal contacts. On the other hand, probing cells from above (AFM) yields data compatible with stronger substrate attraction acting on cardiomyocytes than on fibroblasts.
However, there is evidence that substrate adhesion is less stable in
time for cardiomyocytes. We observed in several cases that, after 4 days in culture, an entire cell layer detached from the substrate and
formed a ball-like agglomerate. A tendency to gradually lose adhesion
so as to form a more rounded shape has been described earlier in
cultured cardiomyocytes (Jacobson and Piper, 1986
).
Our electrophysiological data indicate a close similarity between the action potentials of cardiac pacemaker cells and NRK fibroblasts. Because of their slow rise rate, only weak capacitative coupling to a detector is to be expected. The long duration of current flow and the large contact area, however, facilitate resistive coupling.
In conclusion, NRK fibroblasts offer many of the excitability properties of cardiomyocytes and show an adhesion profile that appears at least as strong and is likely to be more stable than that of heart muscle cells. In addition, the absence of contractions eliminates a possible source of artificial signals. As cell lines, NRK cells are easily obtained and cultured and provide standardized conditions that are difficult to realize with primary cell cultures. Thus excitable fibroblasts promise to be a useful alternative to cells that have been used previously in the study of cell-semiconductor coupling.
| |
ACKNOWLEDGMENTS |
|---|
The authors are grateful to Dr. M. Denyer and Dr. M. Riehle for heart cell preparation protocols. The authors are grateful to Dr. R. Simson and D. Braun for helpful discussions and comments about the RICM and FLIC method and to S. Dannöhl for the AFM roughness measurements. We particularly thank Prof. G. ten Bruggencate for support and equipment.
This work was supported by BMBF Germany (grant 0310845A to WJP, MG, and HEG) and the Deutsche Forschungsgemeinschaft (JD, MR).
| |
FOOTNOTES |
|---|
Received for publication 27 April 1998 and in final form 28 October 1998.
Address reprint requests to Dr. Hermann E. Gaub, Institut für Angewandte Physik, Ludwig-Maximilians Universität, München, Germany. Tel.: 49-89-2180-3173; Fax: 49-89-2180-2050; E-mail: gaub{at}physik.uni-muenchen.de.
| |
REFERENCES |
|---|
|
|
|---|
a quantitative theory for image interpretation and its application to cell-substratum separation measurement.
Biophys. J.
26:507-526[Abstract].
Biophys J, March 1999, p. 1659-1667, Vol. 76, No. 3
© 1999 by the Biophysical Society 0006-3495/99/03/1659/09 $2.00
| ||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
| HOME | HELP | FEEDBACK | SUBSCRIPTIONS | ARCHIVE | SEARCH | TABLE OF CONTENTS |