| HOME | HELP | FEEDBACK | SUBSCRIPTIONS | ARCHIVE | SEARCH | TABLE OF CONTENTS |
Biophys J, October 1999, p. 1945-1959, Vol. 77, No. 4
*Department of Neurobiology and Behavior and #Howard Hughes Medical Institute, State University of New York at Stony Brook, Stony Brook, New York 11794 USA
| |
ABSTRACT |
|---|
|
|
|---|
Cut-open recordings from Xenopus oocytes
expressing either nerve (PN1) or skeletal muscle (SkM1) Na+
channel
subunits revealed slow inactivation onset and recovery kinetics of inward current. In contrast, recordings using the macropatch configuration resulted in an immediate negative shift in the
voltage-dependence of inactivation and activation, as well as
time-dependent shifts in kinetics when compared to cut-open recordings.
Specifically, a slow transition from predominantly slow onset and
recovery to exclusively fast onset and fast recovery from inactivation
occurred. The shift to fast inactivation was accelerated by patch
excision and by agents that disrupted microtubule formation.
Application of positive pressure to cell-attached macropatch electrodes
prevented the shift in kinetics, while negative pressure led to an
abrupt shift to fast inactivation. Simultaneous electrophysiological recording and video imaging of the cell-attached patch membrane revealed that the pressure-induced shift to fast inactivation coincided
with rupture of sites of membrane attachment to cytoskeleton. These
findings raise the possibility that the negative shift in voltage-dependence and the fast kinetics observed normally for endogenous Na+ channels involve mechanical destabilization.
Our observation that the
1 subunit causes similar changes in
function of the Na+ channel
subunit suggests that
1
may act through interaction with cytoskeleton.
| |
INTRODUCTION |
|---|
|
|
|---|
Voltage-gated Na+ channels are
heteromeric complexes consisting of a large pore-forming
subunit
and one or more small auxiliary
subunits (Hartshorne and Catterall,
1984
). Mammalian brain Na+ channels are complexes of
(260 kD) and two distinct auxiliary subunits designated
1 (23 kD)
and
2 (21 kD). Skeletal muscle Na+ channels are
heterodimers composed of an
subunit and a single
subunit (38 kD), which is homologous to the brain
1 subunit (Isom et al., 1994
).
Expression of rat brain or rat skeletal muscle Na+ channel
subunits alone in Xenopus oocytes yields Na+
currents that activate and inactivate in response to depolarization and
are inhibited by TTX (Goldin et al., 1986
; Trimmer et al., 1989
; Joho
et al., 1990
). However, as first reported by Auld et al. (1988)
,
Na+ currents resulting from injection of
subunit RNA
inactivate more slowly than channels present in endogenous tissue.
Rapid inactivation of Na+ current is restored when
subunits are coexpressed with low molecular weight rat brain mRNA,
suggesting a possible requirement for auxiliary subunits for normal
functional expression (Auld et al., 1988
; Krafte et al., 1990
). Indeed,
coexpression of rat brain
1 subunit RNA with type IIA
RNA
results in accelerated inactivation of Na+ current,
increased peak current amplitude, and shifts in the voltage-dependence
of inactivation to more negative membrane potentials. These changes all
mimic the effects of low molecular weight brain mRNA on Na+
channel expression and function (Isom et al., 1992
).
The existence of factors other than auxiliary
subunits that can
alter inactivation kinetics has been suggested by studies in which
Na+ channel
subunits are expressed in cells lacking
endogenous Na+ channel
and
1 subunits. Expression of
rat cardiac (rH1) and rat brain type IIA in mammalian cell lines
results in Na+ channels with rapid activation and
inactivation characteristic of native neuronal Na+ channels
(Scheuer et al., 1990
; West et al., 1992
; Qu et al., 1994
). Similar
results have been obtained after transient expression of the rat and
human skeletal muscle SkM1 Na+ channels in human embryonic
kidney (HEK 293) cells (Ukomadu et al., 1992
; Chahine et al., 1994
).
The mechanisms governing fast and slow inactivation of Na+
channels are poorly understood. A growing body of evidence supports the
hypothesis that fast and slow inactivation are structurally distinct
processes that are not tightly coupled and are not mutually exclusive
(Rudy, 1978
; Featherstone et al., 1996
; Townsend and Horn, 1997
;
Vedantham and Cannon, 1998
). Single-channel analysis of rat brain
(Moorman et al., 1990
) and skeletal muscle (Zhou et al., 1991
)
Na+ channel
subunits, expressed in Xenopus
oocytes, show interconversion between two inactivation modes. Thus, the
subunit does not have an absolute requirement for the auxiliary
subunits in order to exhibit normal gating behavior. Consistent with
this idea, several studies have identified conditions under which
exogenously expressed
subunits can be converted from slow to fast
inactivation without the aid of a
1 subunit (Krafte et al., 1990
;
Zhou et al., 1991
; Fahlke and Rudel, 1992
; Fleig et al., 1994
; Chen and
Cannon, 1995
). The results presented in this paper extend these
observations by showing conversion of
subunit from slow to
exclusively fast inactivation through cytoskeletal disruption. The
functional characteristics of the converted
subunit are
quantitatively similar to the actions of the
1 subunit, suggesting a
common mechanism.
| |
METHODS |
|---|
|
|
|---|
Sections of ovary were surgically isolated from anesthetized
Xenopus frogs (Nasco, Fort Atkinson, WI) and were
enzymatically treated with 10 mg/ml collagenase (Gibco BRL, Grand
Island, NY) for 20 min. After extensive washing the follicle cell layer
was mechanically removed from stage V-VI oocytes and cells were allowed to recover in a nutrient OR-3 medium overnight. The OR-3 medium contained 50% L-15 medium, 100 µg/ml gentamycin, 4 mM glutamine, and
30 mM Na-HEPES (all Gibco BRL, Grand Island, NY), pH-adjusted to 7.6 with NaOH. The next day, oocytes were individually injected with
100-140 ng of RNA coding for either SkM1 (Trimmer et al., 1989
) or
human PN1 (Klugbauer et al., 1995
, kindly provided by F. Hoffman)
subunit. In cases where human
1 (Makita et al., 1994
, kindly
provided by A. George) was tested, the oocytes were injected with a
mixture of 75 ng
RNA and 25 ng
1 RNA, and maintained at 18°C
in OR-3 medium. The methods used to synthesize the RNA were identical
to those previously published (Murray et al., 1995
).
Na+ current was measured using either standard cut-open
oocyte voltage clamp (Taglialatela et al., 1992
) or macropatch
techniques (Leonard et al., 1986
) within 2-5 days after the RNA
injection. In both cases the current was generally recorded from the
animal side of the oocyte at 21-22°C. For micropatch and macropatch
recordings, the oocytes' vitelline membrane was removed manually and
the oocyte was repeatedly penetrated with a blunt electrode. This
action, combined with the high-potassium bath solution, nulled the
membrane potential. The bath solution contained (in mM): 120 KCH3SO3, 2 MgCl2, 1 K-EGTA, and 10 K-HEPES at pH 7.2. Micropatch electrodes were pulled to a final outer
diameter (O.D.) of ~2-5 µm using a Flaming/Brown micropipette
puller (Model P97, Sutter Instrument Co., Novato, CA) and lightly
fire-polished. Macropatch pipettes (borosilicate glass, WPI, Sarasota,
FL) were pulled to an O.D. of ~20 µm, coated with a 1:3 mixture of
Parafilm/mineral oil, and fire-polished to a final tip diameter of
~10-15 µm. Pipettes were filled with a solution containing (in
mM): 120 NaCH3SO3, 2 CaCl2, and 10 Na-HEPES at pH 7.2. Both cell-attached and excised patches formed seals
in excess of 2 G
upon application of steady, gentle, negative
pressure. Na+ currents were recorded by means of an
Axopatch 200A amplifier (Axon Instruments, Inc., Burlingame, CA) and
processed using HEKA Pulse software (Instrutech, Great Neck, NY). The
currents were sampled at 50 kHz and filtered at 10 kHz before analysis.
Capacitive transients were compensated using a combination of manual
compensation on the amplifier and further processing using either a P/4
or P/10 leak subtraction protocol.
For cut-open oocyte voltage clamp recordings the three-compartment
chamber provided with the CA-1 voltage clamp (Dagan Corporation, Minneapolis, MN) was used. Both top and guard chamber solution contained (in mM): 110 NaCH3SO3,
2Ca(CH3SO3)2, and 10 Na-HEPES at pH
7.2. The bottom chamber contiguous with the cell interior contained a
solution composed of (in mM): 120 KCH3SO3, 1 K-EGTA, and 10 K-HEPES at pH 7.2. Agar bridges filled with 120 mM
NaCH3SO3 and containing a black platinized
platinum wire were used to pass current and control the chamber
potentials. An intracellular micropipette filled with 3 M KCl (~100
k
) measured the membrane potential. Currents were acquired using a
CA-1 oocyte clamp amplifier (Dagan). Oocytes that showed an obvious
lack of proper voltage control were discarded.
Data analysis was performed using HEKA PulseFit software (Instrutech,
Great Neck, NY) and IGOR Pro (WaveMetrics, Lake Oswego, OR). The
current-voltage relationships for Na+ currents were fitted
by the Goldman-Hodgkin-Katz equations and the half-activation potential
was determined on the basis of the fit. Steady-state inactivation data
were fitted with a Boltzmann equation I(V) = amplitude/(1 + exp (
(V
Vhalf)/slope))
and midpoint of inactivation determined from this relationship. The decay of Na+ currents and time course of recovery from
inactivation were fitted by either single or summed exponential
functions. Cumulative data are presented as the means and standard
deviations (means ± SD).
Video imaging of the macropatch was performed on a Zeiss Axioscope FS-2
using a 63× water-immersion Zeiss physiology objective (n.a. 0.9) with
further magnification provided by a 2× optovar. Differential
interference contrast provided a sharp image of the plasma membrane of
the oocyte and the pigmented cytoplasmic inclusions located at the
animal pole. Video of the entire experimental sequence was performed
using a Sony RGB color video camera (model DXC-960MD). The video images
were acquired at rates of either 0.2 Hz or 0.5 Hz with a Scion
Instruments LG-3 frame-grabber by means of a Power Macintosh G3
computer. The stored video images were processed off-line using
National Institutes of Health image software. Electrophysiological recording of the macropatch Na+ current in response to a 10 ms depolarization to
10 mV was synchronized to video acquisition.
Accordingly, the corresponding video frame and Na+ current
could be matched for analysis. Intrapipette pressure was controlled
using a pneumatic transducer tester DPM-IB (Bio-Tek Instruments,
Winooski, VT).
| |
RESULTS |
|---|
|
|
|---|
Coexpression of the
1 subunit alters Na+ channel
subunit function
Cut-open oocyte voltage clamp recordings were used to compare the
functional properties Na+ channel
subunits to
+
1
channels. The Na+ current resulting from expression of
either PN1 (Fig. 1 A) or SkM1
(Fig. 2 A)
subunits alone
exhibited a slow decay of inward current, reflecting slow channel
inactivation. The majority of SkM1 and PN1
subunit patches
exhibited a pure monoexponential decay of inward current. For SkM1
channels, inactivation occurred with an average time constant of
14 ± 4 ms (n = 10) at a membrane potential of
5
mV. Slightly faster rates of inactivation were observed for PN1
subunits, which averaged 9 ± 3 ms (n = 9) at 5 mV. Coinjection of the
1 subunit RNA with either PN1 (Fig. 1
B) or SkM1 (Fig. 2 B)
subunit RNA in
Xenopus oocytes resulted in fast inactivation of
Na+ current. The time course of current decay was
monoexponential with a fitted time constant corresponding to 1.3 ± 0.2 ms (n = 6) at
5 mV for PN1 and 0.9 ± 0.1 ms (n = 11) at
10 mV for SkM1 Na+
channels.
|
|
The effects of
1 subunits on the voltage-dependence of activation
and inactivation were determined for both PN1 and SkM1 Na+
channel types. Comparisons of the current-voltage relations indicated that
1 left-shifted the midpoint of activation by an average of
6
mV for PN1 (Fig. 1 C) and
5 mV for SkM1 (Fig. 2
C). Steady-state inactivation was determined by use of
either a 300-ms (for PN1) or 800-ms (for SkM1) conditioning pulse to
produce inactivation followed by a 10-ms test pulse to a voltage
corresponding to peak inward current. These parameters were selected
because they consistently produced a steady-state level of inactivation
for each channel isoform. Boltzmann fits to the steady-state
inactivation relations obtained from PN1 Na+ channels
indicated no difference in the midpoint for
and
+
1 channels
(Fig. 1 D). Fitting of the SkM1 relations indicated a
6 mV
shift in steady-state inactivation for
+
1 channels (Fig. 2
D).
Fast inactivation of inward current could also be experimentally
induced by "super-injection" of RNA. Pure slow inactivation of both
PN1 and SkM1 Na+ channel
subunits was faithfully
observed under conditions wherein ~100 ng of
subunit RNA was
injected into the oocyte. By contrast, injection of ~1.5 µg of
subunit RNA encoding either channel type resulted in currents that
decayed with a biphasic time course. In the case of SkM1
subunits
the fast component of inactivation accounted for over half of the total
inward current (data not shown) and had an average time constant of
0.5 ± 0.2 ms (n = 5) at
10 mV. The residual
slowly inactivating inward current decayed with the typical slow time
constants observed for pure slow currents. Neither the
voltage-dependence of inactivation nor activation was shifted as a
result of the fast inactivation, indicating that the fast and slow
components of inactivation had similar voltage-dependence. The
possibility that the fast inactivation represented a loss of voltage
control due to the large size of the current (20-50 µA) was ruled
out by reducing external sodium concentration. Reduction of
Na+ current did not affect the biexponential decay of
inward current.
Macropatch recording alters voltage-dependence and kinetics of
subunit function
In the cut-open mode of voltage clamp the Na+ current
associated with the
subunit was stable over time (>30 min) without any noticeable change in amplitude or kinetics (n = 30)
(Fig. 3 A). However, formation
of large cell-attached patches using the macropatch configuration
(pipette tip O.D. ~15 µm) consistently resulted in a gradual and
permanent transition to fast inactivation over the course of minutes
(n = 40). Immediately after formation of the macropatch
(Figs. 1 E and 3 B) the time course of
inactivation of Na+ current was indistinguishable from that
obtained using the cut-open recordings from the same oocyte (Figs. 1
A and 3 A). However, over time, a fast component
of inactivation appeared that resulted in an overall decay that was
described by a biexponential function (Figs. 1 F and 3
C). This transition was not accompanied by any substantial
change in peak inward current (Fig. 3, B and C).
Furthermore, measurement of the amplitudes of fast and slow
inactivating components indicated a slow transition to pure fast
inactivation with no change in overall current amplitude (Fig. 3
F). In a few experiments the macropatch was intentionally
excised from the oocyte by drawing the patch pipette far away from the
cell. In all of these cases the transition to fast inactivation was
accelerated.
|
The macropatch recordings also revealed differences in
voltage-dependence compared to recordings obtained using the cut-open voltage clamp technique. Large negative shifts in the current-voltage relations (Fig. 3 D) and steady-state inactivation (Fig. 3
E) were observed immediately after seal formation. A smaller
left shift in voltage-dependence of both activation and inactivation occured during the subsequent 15 min of recording. This difference in
voltage-dependence was not due to errors in estimating the actual
membrane potential for macropatch recording because the oocyte membrane
was pierced by a blunt electrode in the presence of 120 mM
KCH3SO3 to fully eliminate the resting
potential. The midpoint of activation for cut-open recordings averaged
21.4 ± 3.6 mV (n = 9) compared to
44.7 ± 3.3 mV (n = 9) for macropatch recordings (Fig. 3
D). This represented a 23 mV difference in the
voltage-dependence of activation. The midpoint of steady-state inactivation for cut-open recordings averaged
47.3 ± 2.1 mV
(n = 9) compared to
92.9 ± 7.3 mV
(n = 9) for macropatch recordings (Fig. 3
E). This represented a 46 mV difference in the
voltage-dependence of inactivation.
Comparison of
1 subunit effects on channel function to the
macropatch-induced changes in function
The effect of macropatch recording on Na+ channel
inactivation kinetics (Figs. 3, B and C; 4 C) appears to be qualitatively similar to the effects
mediated by
1 subunit coexpression (Fig. 4). Unlike the time-dependent transition
to fast inactivation kinetics by
subunits alone, macropatches from
oocytes expressing both
and
1 subunits exhibited fast
inactivation from the onset of seal formation. Quantitative differences
of these two mediators of fast inactivation were examined by measuring
the voltage-dependence of fast inactivation time constants for cut-open
+
1, macropatch
+
1, and macropatch
Na+
current after the time-dependent shift to fast inactivation. No
significant differences were measured for macropatch
+
1 versus macropatch
currents after transition to pure fast inactivation (Fig. 4 F). Thus,
1 subunits have no additive effect on
speeding inactivation beyond that observed for the
subunit alone.
Further comparisons to cut-open recordings were complicated by the
macropatch-induced change in the voltage-dependence. However, it
appears that differences in the time constants of fast inactivation
exist between cut-open
+
1 and macropatch
Na+
current (Fig. 4 F). In particular, the inactivation time
constants for cut-open
+
1 current are larger at all potentials
tested. Due to the differences in voltage-dependence it is not possible to precisely compare time constants at negative potentials: the range
over which inactivation kinetics are highly voltage-dependent. However,
comparisons at positive potentials reveal a small difference. An
explanation for these differences may reside in the effects of
macropatch formation on acceleration of activation kinetics, a point
which will be discussed in a later section.
|
Similar actions of
1 and macropatch formation on
subunit
function are reflected in the recovery rates for fast and slow inactivating components of inward current. Recovery rates from inactivation were determined using 800-ms inactivating prepulses to
10 mV, followed by a test pulse at prescribed recovery intervals (Fig. 5 A). Overall results
from five oocytes expressing SkM1
subunits indicated that
Na+ current recovery follows a biexponential time course at
140 mV. Moreover, the two time-dependent components of recovery
correspond to fast and slow inactivating components of inward current,
respectively. This is reflected in the measurements of the individual
contribution of fast and slowly decaying inward currents to the overall
inward current at each interval. For interpulse intervals <10 ms the inactivation of pulse 2 inward current was purely fast, with a time
constant corresponding to 0.7 ms (Fig. 5 A). This fast
inactivation contrasted with the observed decay of pulse 1 current
which, in all trials, exhibited >90% slow inactivation. At longer
interpulse intervals the recovered current exhibited mixed slow and
fast inactivation with progressively greater contribution by slow
inactivation with increased recovery interval. By the time that the
interval reached 0.5 s the current was predominantly slowly
inactivating, as demonstrated by the pulse 2 current trajectory (Fig. 5
A).
|
The time constants for recovery of fast inactivating components of the
SkM1
subunit measured by the cut-open recording technique (Fig. 5
B) were compared to those measured for fast inactivating currents seen in the presence of
1 subunit (Fig. 5 D) and
after macropatch conversion of
subunit (Fig. 5 C).
Comparisons of the recovery curves for cut-open recordings of SkM1
+
1 currents to those obtained after macropatch-induced conversion
of SkM1
subunit showed similar fast time constants for recovery.
These data support the idea that the
1 subunit acts to speed
inactivation in a manner similar to macropatch effects on the
subunit.
In contrast to the findings on inactivation kinetics, the effects of
macropatch formation on the voltage-dependence of activation and
steady-state inactivation were different from those mediated by the
1 subunit. Coexpression of the
1 subunit resulted in a small
negative shift in the voltage-dependence of activation and inactivation
measured using cut-open recordings (Figs. 1 and 2). The small shift by
the
1 subunit contrasts with the large negative shift that
accompanies the macropatch formation (Fig. 4). This large shift in
voltage-dependence of activation and steady-state inactivation was not
prevented by
1 coexpression (Fig. 4, D and E).
Comparisons of macropatch recordings of
+
1 current to
current
revealed no significant difference.
Mechanical destabilization mediates the time-dependent shift to fast inactivation
A role of cytosolic factors in promoting a conversion to fast
inactivation was indicated by our finding that the transition to fast
gating was accelerated after patch excision. The idea that cytoskeleton
might be involved was suggested by our finding that the conversion to
fast gating was dependent on the size of the electrode tip. Micropatch
recordings (electrode O.D. ~2-5 µm) showed little transition to
fast inactivation over the time period that macropatch recordings
exhibit conversion (Fig. 6, A
and B). These micropatch recordings also failed to exhibit
the negative shift in activation (Fig. 6 C) and steady-state
inactivation (Fig. 6 D) that accompanies the formation of
macropatches. The micropatch recordings were similar to those obtained
from cut-open oocyte recordings in terms of both kinetics and
voltage-dependence. Further similarities were also reflected in the
somewhat slower activation kinetic when compared to macropatch
recordings. Both micropatch (Fig. 6 B) and cut-open oocyte
(Fig. 2 B) recorded current activated slower than macropatch
inward current (Figs. 4 C and 6 A). It is not
likely that these differences reflect inadequate voltage control
because the differences can be observed for two different variations of
cell-attached recording methods. Therefore, the faster rise of inward
current observed with macropatch recording is likely to reflect
accelerated activation, similar to the effects on inactivation. This
macropatch-dependent speeding of activation kinetics may be, in part,
responsible for the somewhat slower apparent inactivation rate measured
for
+
1 channels (Fig. 4 F). Thus, the more
synchronized activation could provide for less overlap of activation
and inactivation.
|
To examine for morphological changes that might accompany macropatch-induced, time-dependent changes in kinetics we utilized high-power differential interference contrast microscopy to examine the membrane within the macropatch pipette (Fig. 7). Simultaneous electrophysiological recordings monitored the change in kinetics of Na+ current after formation of the seal. The video capture and test depolarizations to activate maximal Na+ current were synchronized at 5-s intervals. We found that the initial contact with the oocyte membrane dictated the amount of membrane that entered the electrode upon formation of a gigaohm seal. When the electrode was pressed firmly against the oocyte membrane, application of negative pressure resulted in the entry of a small dome of membrane. By contrast, when the macropatch electrode was allowed to lightly touch the oocyte membrane before application of negative pressure, a considerable amount of membrane entered the tip during application of negative pressure (Fig. 7). The latter method had the advantage that a large amount of pigmented cytoplasmic inclusions accompanied the membrane in the patch. As the membrane was slowly drawn in the electrode, these pigmented inclusions appeared to be drawn along by virtue of an apparent mechanical attachment to the membrane.
|
In a series of experiments (n = 5 cell attached patches) we controlled the pressure in the pipette interior to accelerate or prevent the growth of membrane area in the electrode (Fig. 8). Application of positive pressure (4-5 mmHg) prevented the increase in membrane area as well as conversion to fast inactivation. Alternatively, application of negative pressure facilitated the rate of conversion to fast inactivation. We took advantage of the observation that the rate of conversion could be accelerated by negative pressure to examine for morphological changes that might accompany conversion. The negative pressure was adjusted to speed conversion, and we observed a sudden change in morphology that accompanied the abrupt conversion to fast inactivation (Fig. 7). The pigmented inclusions, which were drawn toward the membrane as though attached, collapsed back into an amorphous ball at some critical degree of membrane stretch. The video frame showing this dissociation was precisely correlated with the abrupt change from slow to fast inactivation. Also, associated with the collapse in granule projections was a further increase in the swelling of the membrane in the pipette. Subsequent application of positive pressure to reduce the membrane area did not alter the inactivation or cause it to revert to slow inactivation. However, after the abrupt conversion to fast inactivation, a small non-inactivating component of inward current was observed. Release of negative pressure resulted in an immediate disappearance of this current (Fig. 7, bottom right) and reapplication of negative pressure resulted in reappearance. This inward current was likely due to the activation of stretch-activated ion channels that were associated with the expansion of the membrane. These findings were reliably reproduced on eight separate membrane patches, supporting the assertion that the detachment was causal to the change in inactivation kinetics.
|
Based on the observation that functional conversion was associated with
disruption of cytoskeletal links to the membrane, we tested for a role
of actin or microtubules in mediating the response. Inhibition of actin
polymerization by treatment with 10 µM cytochalasin D
(n = 3) (Cooper, 1987
) or intracellularly injected 25 µg/oocyte at 5 U/mg gelsolin (n = 3) (Kwiatkowski, 1999
) resulted in a flattening of the oocyte. However, recordings of
Na+ current revealed no associated effects on channel
kinetics or voltage-dependence. Intracellular injection of 10 µl 10 mM phalloidin (n = 3), an F-actin stabilizer (Cooper,
1987
) also showed no effect on Na+ channel function. In
contrast, treatment with 10 µM nocodazol (n = 3), an
inhibitor of microtubule polymerization (Hoebeke et al., 1976
),
affected the rate of conversion to fast inactivation. Instead of the
gradual slow transition to fast inactivation, nocodazol-treated oocytes
showed a complete and abrupt transition soon after formation of the
macropatch (Fig. 6, E and F). Nocodazol had no
effects on inactivation or voltage-dependence measured by cut-open
recordings (n = 6). Several other widely used agents
that interfere with microtubule formation, such as colcemide,
colchicine, vincristine, and vinblastine, were without effect.
| |
DISCUSSION |
|---|
|
|
|---|
Our findings point to a dependence of voltage-activated
Na+ channel function on the type of methodology used to
record Na+ current. Specifically, macropatch recording of
subunit Na+ current, in the absence of expressed
auxiliary subunits, reveals large shifts in voltage-dependence and
greatly accelerated inactivation (Fleig et al., 1994
; Chen and Cannon,
1995
) when compared to recordings made by either conventional
microelectrode or cut-open oocyte methods. As discussed below, the
regulation of function by recording configuration likely involves
intermolecular interactions between the
subunit and cytoskeletal
elements. The cytosolic regulation of
subunit function is
reminiscent of regulation by the
1 subunit, suggesting the use of a
common pathway.
The first functional consequence of the macropatch recording mode was a
large negative shift in voltage-dependence of activation and
inactivation of the
subunit Na+ current compared to
cut-open recordings. Both PN1 and SkM1
subunits showed a 23-mV
shift in the midpoint of peak activation and an even larger shift of 46 mV for steady-state inactivation, confirming previous macropatch
studies on expressed
subunit channels in Xenopus oocytes
(Fleig et al., 1994
). This shift was fully established at the earliest
measurable time following seal formation, thus setting it apart from
the time-dependent shift in kinetics. Similar effects of patch
formation on voltage-dependence of endogenous Na+ current
have been reported for chromaffin cells (Fenwick et al., 1982
) and
cardiac cells (Cachelin et al., 1983
; Kunze et al., 1985
; Kimitsuki et
al., 1990
). In an elegant study that combined two-microelectrode and
cell-attached patch recordings of the same cell, a left shift in
inactivation and activation was observed only for the patch current
(Fahlke and Rudel, 1992
). The lack of shift in microelectrode recorded
current demonstrated that the gigaseal formation results in a
local alteration in the functioning of the Na+ channel.
Interestingly, similar negative shifts have been associated commonly
with ruptured whole-cell patch clamp recordings from native sodium
currents (Fernandez et al., 1984
; Wendt et al., 1992
). Should such
negatively shifted voltage-dependence exist for endogenous
Na+ current in mature neurons, the channels would be
largely inactivated at resting membrane potential. This raises the
possibility that whole-cell patch clamp recording methods led to shifts
in voltage-dependence similar to those mediated by patch formation,
possibly through the same mechanism.
The second functional alteration that accompanied macropatch recordings
was a time-dependent acceleration in inactivation kinetics, also
confirming previous studies on expressed Na+ channels
(Fleig et al., 1994
; Chen and Cannon, 1995
). At the moment of seal
formation and soon thereafter, the Na+ current inactivated
over tens of milliseconds. Typically, over time, the kinetics changed
from slow inactivation, to mixed slow and fast inactivation, eventually
displaying pure fast inactivation. This time-dependent change was
observed for both neuronal (PN1) and skeletal muscle (SkM1)
Na+ channel isoforms (Figs. 1, E and
F; 3, B and C). As with the shift in
voltage-dependence, the effect of gigaseal formation on Na+
current kinetics was local, as shown for studies on both native (Kunze
et al., 1985
; Kimitsuki et al., 1990
) and expressed Na+
current (Fahlke and Rudel, 1992
; Chen and Cannon, 1995
). Single channel
studies of rapidly and slowly inactivating components underlying
macroscopic current have suggested that the SkM1
subunit has
intrinsic bimodal gating kinetics (Moorman et al., 1990
; Zhou et al.,
1991
). The conversion was proposed to result from a time-dependent
shift from a predominantly slow modal inactivation to a principally
fast modal inactivation (Zhou et al., 1991
). This idea is compatible
with our findings for both PN1 and SkM1 Na+ channels.
First, our results show that during the transition to fast inactivation
the decay of inward current was well-described by two individual
components bearing fixed fast and slow decay rates, consistent with two
modes. Second, we observed no change in peak current amplitude during
the transition to fast inactivation; only the ratio of the fast and
slow components changed. Finally, cut-open recordings indicated that
slowly inactivating Na+ current could be transiently and
reversibly converted to fast inactivating current during repetitive
depolarizations of the oocyte. This latter observation is best
explained by differences in the rates of recovery from inactivation for
fast and slow inactivating modes. It is unlikely that the shift in
voltage-dependence was causal to or required for the eventual changes
in inactivation kinetics. Cut-open recordings from oocytes injected
with large amounts of SkM1 or PN1 RNA show substantial amounts of fast
inactivation in the absence of a negative shift in voltage-dependence
of activation and inactivation. Additionally, as mentioned above, upon
repetitive stimulation, the slowly inactivating Na+ current
converted to purely fast inactivating Na+ current (Krafte
et al., 1990
; Zhou et al., 1991
; Fig. 5) without a negative shift
in voltage-dependence.
The changes in voltage-dependence and inactivation kinetics may be the
result of mechanical deformation associated with macropatch recording.
For example, if small-diameter patch electrodes, instead of macropatch
electrodes, were used to record Na+ current, the
time-dependent shift to fast inactivation was slowed and the negative
shift in voltage-dependence was prevented. This reflects differences in
the deformation of the membrane required to establish a gigaohm glass
tissue seal. Direct evidence for the idea that deformation of a
macropatch membrane leads to fast inactivation was provided by
simultaneous imaging of patch membrane and electrophysiological
recording of Na+ current. Upon application of negative
pressure to the patch membrane we observed an abrupt conversion from
slow to fast inactivation at the exact moment of disruption of some
type of attachment between the cell interior and the membrane. An
expansion of the patch membrane within the electrode followed the
rupturing of the attachments. While substantial alterations in membrane
morphology are known to occur during patch formation (Milton and
Caldwell, 1990
; Sokabe and Sachs, 1990
), our results provide the first
direct evidence showing that disruption of cytoskeletal/membrane
attachments mediates functional conversion of an ion channel. The
question arises as to whether the conversion to fast inactivation is
due to cytoskeletal disruption or to the resultant stretching of the
membrane. For example, changes in membrane tension (Opsahl and Webb,
1994
; Lundbak et al., 1996
) or membrane thickness (Haydon and Kimura,
1981
; Hendry et al., 1985
) have been shown to alter the
voltage-dependence and/or inactivation kinetics of Na+
channels. While it is clear that a critical level of stretch triggers
the conversion, two observations support the idea that membrane tension
per se is not the direct mediator of altered kinetics. First, after
conversion by stretch, further distortions of the membrane elicited
through application of negative or positive pressure had little or no
effect on kinetics. In fact, the membrane could be reduced to its
original area by means of positive pressure with no alteration in
inactivation kinetics, showing the stretch per se has no effect.
Second, reversible shifts to fast inactivation could be observed after
repetitive depolarization using cut-open recording techniques:
conditions that do not involve stretch.
It is also unlikely that the cytoplasmic attachments that were observed
to break upon negative pressure were the direct mediators of functional
conversion to fast inactivation, because patch excision did not lead to
an abrupt change in kinetics. Instead, we propose that the additional
membrane stretch, which occurred as a direct result of breaking these
connections, altered a physical relationship between the
subunit
and an associated structural protein(s). One site of interaction on the
subunit might govern the inactivation kinetics while a second,
weaker interaction might affect the voltage-dependence. A
"tethered" gating model (Hamill and McBride, 1997
) postulated elastic coupling between cytoskeleton and gating structures on the
channel, an idea that accounts for the key features associated with
macropatch conversion of the
subunit. Ordinarily, such elastic
interactions would provide for reversible transitions between slow and
fast inactivation, like those observed during recovery of sodium
current from the inactivated state. However, the dissolution of such
elements following extreme stretch, as shown for macropatches (this
article and Hamill and McBride, 1997
) could result in irreversible
conversion in both voltage-dependence and inactivation kinetics. The
model would also potentially explain the observation that injection of
large amounts of RNA encoding the
subunit led to significant
amounts of fast inactivation (data not shown; Krafte et al., 1990
; Zhou
et al., 1991
). In such oocytes the cytoskeletal proteins may be
limiting and too few in number to provide for association with all of
the
subunits.
Potential cytoskeletal candidates underlying the functional conversion
continue to emerge from molecular studies of the
subunit and
auxiliary proteins. Actin (Fukuda et al., 1981
), syntrophin (Gee et
al., 1998
), and ankyrin (Srinivasan et al., 1988
; Kordeli et al., 1990
)
have been shown to associate with the Na+ channel
subunit. In our studies, disruption of actin had no effect on SkM1
Na+ channel function. Functional studies have shown a
dependence of squid axon Na+ channel kinetics on
microtubules (Matsumoto et al., 1984a
, b
). We observed an effect of
nocodazol, an inhibitor of microtubule polymerization, on inactivation
kinetics. Moreover, patches from nocodazol-treated oocytes exhibited an
abrupt shift in inactivation kinetics rather than the slow transition
normally observed. We suspect that this reflects an indirect role of
microtubules, such as countering membrane stretch, because nocodazol
affected only the rate of macropatch-induced transition and exerted no
effect on cut-open recordings of Na+ current inactivation.
The macropatch-induced fast inactivation for the sodium
subunit
alone represents a marked departure from the characteristically slow
inactivation observed for cut-open recordings of
subunits. However,
a striking similarity exists between the fast inactivation observed for
these converted
subunits and for
+
1 channels recorded by the
cut-open technique. Both channel types recovered quickly from
inactivation and good agreement was found for the time constants of
recovery. Apparent small differences in kinetics were reflected in
somewhat slower activation and inactivation of
+
1 channels
compared to macropatch-converted
subunits. Rather than representing
actual differences in inactivation rates, it is likely that the faster
decay was a direct consequence of faster and more synchronous
activation for the macropatch-converted
subunit. Additional
evidence for similarities between macropatch and
1 effects on
subunits was reflected in the absence of additive effects on the
inactivation by the
1 subunit after macropatch conversion of the
subunit. The observed similarities between macropatch effects and
1
subunit-induced changes are important for two reasons. First, the
functional conversion of the
subunit seen in macropatch recordings
may help explain previously observed fast inactivation of
Na+ currents seen in the apparent absence of
1 subunits
(Scheuer et al., 1990
; Ukomadu et al., 1992
; West et al., 1992
; Chahine et al., 1994
; Makita et al., 1994
; Qu et al., 1994
). Second, and more
importantly, the similarities suggest a shared mechanism of action,
raising the new possibility that the
1 subunit acts via interactions
with the cytoskeleton. Accordingly, the
1 subunit might interfere
with cytoskeletal components that normally bind to the
subunits.
Such interference would cause mechanical destabilization, perhaps
leading to a favoring of the intrinsic fast modal gating of the
subunit. Tests of this await identification of the specific regulatory
molecules capable of binding to or modulating the
subunit.
| |
ACKNOWLEDGMENTS |
|---|
The authors thank Drs. Enrico Stefani and Ricardo Olcese for instruction in both macropatch and cut-open oocyte recording techniques. RNA for oocyte expression was synthesized by members of Dr. Mandel's lab, including Ed Han, David Kennedy, and Janet Allopena.
This work was supported by National Institutes of Health Grant NS-34375 (to P.B. and G.M.).
| |
FOOTNOTES |
|---|
Received for publication 14 April 1999 and in final form 6 July 1999.
Address reprint requests to Dr. Anatoly Shcherbatko, Department of Neurobiology and Behavior, SUNY at Stony Brook, Stony Brook, NY 11794. Tel.: 516-632-8982; Fax: 516-632-9714; E-mail: ashcherb{at}brain.neurobio.sunysb.edu.
| |
REFERENCES |
|---|
|
|
|---|
1 subunit: a deletion analysis.
Pflugers Arch.
431:186-195[Medline].
subunit of the rat brain Na channel is sufficient for expression of functional channels in Xenopus oocytes.
Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. USA.
83:7503-7507[Medline].
1 subunit of the rat brain sodium channel.
Science.
256:839-842[Medline].