| HOME | HELP | FEEDBACK | SUBSCRIPTIONS | ARCHIVE | SEARCH | TABLE OF CONTENTS |
Biophys J, May 2000, p. 2441-2451, Vol. 78, No. 5
Adolf-Butenandt-Institut, Lehrstuhl für Stoffwechselbiochemie der Universität München, 80336 München, Germany
| |
ABSTRACT |
|---|
|
|
|---|
The polar interface of membranes containing phosphatidylglycerol or cholesterol was studied by 2H nuclear magnetic resonance (NMR) as a function of membrane hydration. The membranes were macroscopically aligned and hydrated with deuterium oxide. Water uptake and membrane annealing was achieved under NMR control, using a novel hydration technique. Well-resolved 2H quadrupolar doublets were obtained from individual hydroxyl residues and from the interlamellar water. The response of the phosphatidylglycerol headgroup and of the cholesterol molecule to the spontaneous evaporation of interlamellar water could be thus monitored continuously. It is shown that the phosphatidylglycerol headgroup undergoes changes of conformation and average orientation with respect to the membrane surface and that the off-axis motion of the cholesterol molecule decreases. The deuteron exchange between hydroxyl residues and surface-associated D2O was determined by an inversion transfer technique. The exchange rates of the hydroxyl residues in the phosphatidylglycerol headgroup were different and depended strongly on the total hydration of the membrane. Significantly lower and almost hydration-independent rates were obtained for cholesterol. These results will be discussed with reference to earlier reports on the headgroup dynamics of phosphatidylglycerol and on the interaction of cholesterol with the membrane-water interface.
| |
INTRODUCTION |
|---|
|
|
|---|
Much research has been invested into an
understanding of the spontaneous water uptake by phospholipid membranes
(Cevc, 1993
), with particular emphasis on the molecular response of the
phospholipid headgroup (Bechinger and Seelig, 1991
; Lindblom et al.,
1991
; Ulrich and Watts, 1994b
; Volke et al., 1994b
; Zhou et al., 1999
) and on the development of interbilayer forces (Cevc et al., 1995
; Simon
et al., 1995
; Israelachvili and Wennerström, 1996
). Biomembrane hydration has been frequently studied by deuterium
(2H) nuclear magnetic resonance (NMR) with
ordinary water being replaced by deuterium oxide (Finer and Darke,
1974
; Cornell et al., 1974
; Ulmius et al., 1977
; Finer, 1979
; Borle and
Seelig, 1983a
; Bechinger and Seelig, 1991
; Klose et al., 1992
; Volke et al., 1994a
,b
; Ulrich and Watts, 1994b
; Hsieh and Wu, 1996
; Faure et
al., 1997
). This technique exploits the sensitivity of the 2H quadrupolar interaction with respect to
interfacial order and dynamics. Planar membrane alignment on a solid
support further enhances the intrinsic sensitivity of the
2H NMR experiment and circumvents problems
associated with the inhomogeneity of unoriented multibilayers (Koenig
et al., 1997
). The majority of these studies have dealt with
single-component model membranes using synthetic lipids with
zwitterionic headgroups. Less data are available, however, on the
hydration of complex lipid mixtures, including cholesterol and charged lipids.
The present study is focused on the interaction of surface-associated
water with lipid hydroxyl groups in the polar membrane interface. Two
different examples of such lipids were considered, i.e.,
phosphatidylglycerol and cholesterol. Exchange of hydroxyl hydrogens
for deuterium in the presence of surface-associated D2O and macroscopic membrane alignment yielded
well resolved 2H quadrupolar doublets for the
deuterated hydroxyl residues and for the interlamellar
D2O. Lipid mixtures containing
phosphatidylglycerol were chosen as a paradigm for energy-conserving
biomembranes. Proton diffusion within the polar membrane interface,
which is believed to be essential for energy coupling in mitochondria
and prokaryotes (Williams, 1988
; Teissié et al., 1993
; Lechner
and Dencher, 1994
; Teissié, 1996
), may involve the hydroxyl
groups of phoshoplipids such as cardiolipin or phosphatidyglycerol.
These lipids typically represent major components of energy-conserving membranes (Neidleman, 1993
). A sort of "proton wiring" (Pomès and Roux, 1998
) was envisaged, e.g., it has been argued that the negative net charge of the phosphodiester moiety and the unesterified glycerol hydroxyl residue in the cardiolipin headgroup represent a
charge-relay system capable of propagating protons at the membranes surface (Hübner et al., 1991
). Lipids with the potential for interfacial hydrogen bond formation may be also important for the
defense against environmental stress, e.g., dehydration of procaryotic
organisms (Dowhan, 1993
). Combining the alignment technique with
2H NMR, we obtained separate quadrupolar
splittings from the nonequivalent deuterated hydroxyl residues in the
phosphatidylglycerol headgroup, which made it possible to determine the
individual OD/D2O deuteron exchange rates.
The current knowledge of the interaction of cholesterol with
phospholipids and interfacial water is still incomplete, despite the
fact that the molecule is ubiquitous in eukaryotic membranes (for
recent review articles see McMullen and McElhaney, 1996
; Finegold,
1993
). It is customary to assume that the 3-
-OH group of the
molecule resides in the interfacial region of the bilayer where it may
form transient hydrogen bonds (McMullen and McElhaney, 1996
).
Interactions with the available OH-bond acceptors, i.e., fatty acids
carbonyls, unesterified oxygens of the headgroup phosphodiester moiety
and water, have been demonstrated by molecular modeling (Robinson et
al., 1995
; Tu et al., 1998
) and NMR spectroscopy (Le Guerneve and
Auger, 1995
). The functional significance of these interactions has not
been fully established, however. The deuterated OH group can be used as
a probe for H-bond formation and hydrogen exchange. It is shown here
that the OD/D2O exchange is approximately five
times slower for cholesterol than for phosphatidylglycerol at full
membrane hydration. This difference indicates that cholesterol preferentially forms hydrogen bonds with acceptors other than water. At
the same time, however, our data argue against a long-lived hydrogen
bond, e.g., with the fatty acid carbonyls of the surrounding phospholipids (Wong et al., 1989
).
The orientation of cholesterol in liquid crystalline phospholipid
membranes has been previously studied in great detail using 2H NMR of multiple deuterated cholesterol
analogs (Dufourc et al., 1984
). The rigidity of the sterol backbone, as
opposed to the flexible PG headgroup, facilitates a unique
interpretation of the residual quadrupolar splittings in terms of
molecular orientation and rotational symmetry. Therefore, a second
2H label was introduced here into C-3 of the
sterol skeleton to explore the molecular dynamics of the
membrane-water interface as a function of interfacial hydration.
| |
MATERIALS AND METHODS |
|---|
|
|
|---|
Chemicals
Phospholipids (POPC, POPG, sodium salt) were obtained from
Avanti Polar Lipids Inc. (Alabaster, AL). The sodium salt of EYPG was
from Sigma-Aldrich (Deisenhofen, Germany). Cholesterol,
cholest-5-en-3-on, LiAlD4 and deuterated
tert-butanol
((CH3)3COD) were also
purchased from Sigma-Aldrich. Deuterated cholesterol
(
-(3-2H)-cholesterol) was prepared from
cholest-5-en-3-on essentially according to a published procedure
(Wheeler and Mateos, 1958
). Briefly, 100 mg
LiAlD4 was dissolved in 8 ml carefully dried
tetrahydrofuran, and 0.5 ml
(CH3)3COD was slowly added
while stirring at 0°C. One hundred milligrams of cholest-5-en-3-on in
8 ml tetrahydrofuran was added, and the solution was incubated for
1 h at room temperature. The mixture was then poured into 8 ml
10% HCl while stirring and cooling on ice. The aqueous solution was
extracted three times with chloroform (50 ml, 25 ml, and 25 ml)
followed by washing of the combined chloroform phase with 25-ml
portions of 10% HCl, saturated NaHCO3, and
water, respectively. After drying over CaCl2, the
solvent was evaporated and the residue was recrystallized from hot
ethanol. The resulting
-(3-2H)-cholesterol was
checked for purity by TLC and 1H-NMR.
Sample preparation
A total of 30 mg of the lipids was dissolved in 5 ml of deuterated methanol (CH3OD). The solution was spread evenly on 50 ultrathin glass plates (8 × 18 × 0.08 mm; Marienfeld Lab. Glassware, Bad Mergentheim, Germany) and dried for 20 min under a flow of warm air and then at room temperature for at least 18 h in vacuo (20-30 Pa). The glass plates with the dried lipid deposits were stacked on top of each other with gentle pressure and inserted, along with a pair of glass cylinder segments, into an open glass tube of 9.8 mm i.d. as shown in Fig. 1. Two small paper strips were soaked in D2O and then dried carefully. Three µl D2O were spotted onto each of the dry strips and the strips were attached at the short sides of the stack (Fig. 1). The cylinder was rapidly stoppered by appropriately machined teflon plugs with silicon o-rings, and the membranes were annealed for 3 h at 40°C. Further hydration was achieved by repeating the process until the desired water/lipid ratio was achieved. The first three hydration steps yielded D2O/lipid ratios of 10-15 mol/mol. The total time required for sample annealing was 12-15 h, depending on the number of hydration steps. Slow evaporation of the interlamellar water (from maximum hydration to a D2O/lipid ratio of ~6 mol/mol; see Results) typically proceeded within two weeks. Stepwise hydration resulted in planar alignment of the membranes, whereas sudden addition of larger quantities of D2O sometimes led to the formation of vesicular structures as shown by 31P-NMR spectroscopy.
|
2H-NMR
2H-NMR spectra were recorded with a VARIAN
VXR-400S spectrometer (2H-frequency 61.4 MHz).
2H-spectra of the macroscopically aligned lipid
samples were acquired using a 10-mm i.d. flat wire solenoid coil. A
home-built goniometer, attached to a stepper motor under software
control, was used for accurate sample orientation with respect to the
magnetic field. The annealed specimen was mounted into the goniometer
and the orientation of the stack was varied systematically. The
quadrupolar splittings 
Q of the
2H signal from surface associated
D2O were fitted according to 
Q = 1/2(3 cos2
1)
Q0 where
denotes the angle
between the normal to the membrane stack with respect to the magnetic
field and 
Q0 the maximum splitting. This yielded
the required parallel orientation (
= 0°) within ±1°. The
progress of sample annealing could be also directly followed in the NMR
spectrometer by the sharpening of the D2O doublet
components and by the minimization of a central D2O signal (most probably arising from unoriented
water). The quadrupolar echo sequence (Davis et al., 1976
) was applied
for signal excitation using composite pulses with a 90° pulse width of 7 µs, a pulse spacing of 20 µs and recycling time of 0.7 s.
The rate constants, kOD, of the
2H transfer from deuterated hydroxyl, OD,
residues to D2O were measured using the inversion transfer technique (Led and Gesmar, 1982
). Selective inversion of the
D2O doublet was achieved by an appropriate
low-power radio frequency pulse (90° pulse width, 140 µs)
positioned at the center frequency in the spectrum. Excitation of lipid
bound deuterons was excluded due to the large frequency dispersion in
the macroscopically aligned membranes. The entire inversion transfer
sequence was (
)sel-
-(
/2)x-
-(
/2)y-
-acquisition,
where the frequency selective 180° pulse,
(
)sel, inverts the D2O
signal and the nonselective 90° pulses,
/2, correspond to the
usual quadrupolar echo sequence. The echo delay
was typically 20 µs. Increasing the delay time
resulted in the expected time
variation of the OD signals (cf. Fig. 6 B). Reference
spectra were recorded after each acquisition in the inversion transfer
series, and signal amplitudes were normalized with respect to the
average amplitudes in the reference spectra. The
D2O signal was suppressed after signal
acquisition by digital filtering (low-frequency signal suppression) to
minimize baseline distortions and integration artifacts at the OD
resonance positions. Thirty-five filter coefficients were used for a
sharp filter cutoff (VNMR software, version 5.1). Inversion recovery
experiments, i.e.,
(
)nonsel-
-(
/2)x-
-(
/2)y-
-acquisition,
were performed immediately after the inversion transfer series to
obtain the spin lattice relaxation time
T1z for the interbilayer
D2O, which was assumed to be independent of the
deuteron exchange rate. Nine
-increments and 64 transients per
increment were sufficient for a reliable
T1z determination.
The inversion transfer results were evaluated on the basis of the
coupled differential equations for a two-side exchange (Led and Gesmar,
1982
)
|
(1) |
|
(2) |
OD
and M
W denote the magnetizations and the
equilibrium magnetizations, respectively, of the OD deuterons and of
the partially ordered D2O. The normalized
experimental data were fitted to Eqs. 1 and 2 by manual parameter
variation (cf. Fig. 6) using Mathematica (Wolfram Research, Inc.,
Campaign, IL). The parameters R1OD and
R1w are the longitudinal relaxation rates of OD (obtained by the fitting procedure) and of
D2O (determined experimentally) and
kw and
kOD refer to the forward and backward deuterium exchange according to ROD + D*OD
ROD* + DOD, where the
asterisk denotes magnetic labeling by selective inversion. The
corresponding second-order rate constants, k
and k
, can be formally expressed in terms of
the deuteron exchange rates, i.e., kOD = k
[D2O] and
kw = k
[ROD]. A further condition is provided by the chemical equilibrium,
i.e.,
|
(3) |
| |
RESULTS |
|---|
|
|
|---|
Macroscopically aligned bilayers containing phosphatidylglycerol
An equimolar mixture of POPC and EYPG was macroscopically aligned and hydrated with deuterium oxide as described in Methods. The orientation of the glass plates was chosen to give the maximum D2O quadrupolar splitting, indicating that the normal to the glass plates was parallel to the direction of the magnetic field. The sealing of the glass tube (Fig. 1) was deliberately not completely tight, which led to a continuously decreasing water/lipid molar ratio in the sample. The evaporation rate was sufficiently slow (even at 37°C) so that the ratio was always nearly constant within the acquisition period of approximately 1 h. Thus, the spontaneous water evaporation permitted an investigation of interfacial membrane properties from full hydration to very low hydration under NMR control.
A series of 2H-NMR spectra recorded over a range
of hydration values is shown in Fig. 2.
The strong doublets in the center of the spectra are due to
interlamellar D2O (quadrupolar splitting
1
kHz), whereas the small signals with quadrupolar splittings of
28
kHz can be attributed to the headgroup hydroxyl moieties of the PG
component (with OD replacing OH). The deuterium oxide/phospholipid molar ratio, denoted by nw, was
calculated from the signal integrals, using sufficiently long
relaxation delays to warrant full recovery of the OD and
D2O signals.
|
The observation of separate signals indicates that the chemical
exchange among hydroxyl and water deuterons is slow on the NMR time
scale. With decreasing hydration (nw < 20) the hydroxyl doublet splits into two subspectra, which are
tentatively assigned in Fig. 2 to the individual hydroxyl residues (
and
, corresponding to the central and terminal segments of the
glycerol headgroup, respectively; cf. Scheme
1). It must be noted that this assignment is based on the assumption that the
-OD moiety has more motional freedom at low hydration values (cf. Fig.
3 A) than the
-OD, resulting in a smaller quadrupolar splitting. Selective labeling of the
PG headgroup would be necessary to confirm this assignment. The signal
amplitudes of the
and
-OD resonances are different as a result
of varying line broadening.
|
|
The quadrupolar splittings 
Q
and

Q
obtained over the entire experimentally
accessible hydration range are summarized in Fig. 3 A.
Three regions (designated as roman numerals in Fig. 3 A) can
be identified where the PG headgroup signals respond differently to
increasing hydration. Starting with nw
5, 
Q
increases with increasing hydration
and reaches a plateau value of 28 kHz at
nw
9, whereas

Q
increases monotonously until both resonances
merge at nw
20. There is only one
OD doublet when the interlamellar water level increases further. The
increasing OD quadrupolar splittings in region I suggest that the
development of a coherent layer of interfacial water results in a
continuous change of the average headgroup orientation with respect to
the membrane surface. Small changes of the dihedral angles within the
PG headgroup probably lead to the coalescence of the OD-resonances in
region II, whereas there may be hardly any change of the average
headgroup conformation in region III, although the membranes take up
another 20-30 mol of interlamellar water per lipid headgroup.
Hydration of the mixed POPG/EYPC membranes was feasible up to
nw
60 without loss of lamellar
order, as was confirmed independently by 31P NMR
(data not shown).
The coalescence of the OD resonances reflects the changing headgroup conformation rather than an increasing interresidue deuteron exchange rate. This has been verified by running 2H spectra of oriented PG/PC samples over a temperature range from 0°C to 50°C (experiments not shown). In samples with nw < 20, there was no signal coalescence, even at 50°C, whereas the signal splitting did not reappear in the low temperature range in samples with nw > 20. Moreover, the different line widths of the two signal pairs, as noted above (Fig. 2), suggest that exchange with the interlamellar D2O occurs at different rates.
A plot of the quadrupolar splitting of the interlamellar
D2O versus nw
may be also tentatively divided into different regions (Fig.
3 B), i.e., there is a sudden increase of the splitting at
low hydration (up to nw
6)
followed by a region where the splitting decreases monotonously (from
nw
6 to
nw
40). It can be recognized,
however, that this division differs from that in Fig. 3 A.
Bilayers containing cholesterol
A mixture of 30 mol% of double deuterated cholesterol (after
exchange labeling of the hydroxyl group of
-(3-2H)-cholesterol, the molecule will be
denoted by cholesterol-d2) with POPC was
macroscopically oriented and hydrated with D2O as described above. The covalent deuteration at C-3 and the exchange deuterated hydroxyl residue at the same carbon position yielded quadrupolar splittings of 87 kHz and 51 kHz, respectively, at 37°C
and nw = 48 (see top trace in Fig. 6
for a representative spectrum). These assignments were confirmed by
hydration with H2O instead of
D2O or by hydration of unlabeled cholesterol with D2O, where only the respective resonance pairs
remained. Likewise, addition of small quantities of deuterochloric acid
(DCl) led to drastic line broadening of the OD component only
(quadrupolar splitting ~51 kHz), indicating that acid catalysis
results in rapid deuteron exchange between the cholesterol OD and the
surrounding D2O.
The D2O quadrupolar splitting and the splittings
of the cholesterol CD and OD deuterons (
QD20,

QCD and 
QOD, respectively)
decreased monotonously with increasing
nw (Fig. 4). The ratio

QCD/
QOD was nearly constant
over the entire hydration range (10
nw < 60; see insert in Fig.
4 A). This is to be expected when the rate of deuteron
chemical exchange remains slow and the reorientation rate of the OD
about the CO bond is fast with respect to the quadrupolar splitting.
The deuteron exchange is indeed negligible with respect to the residual
quadrupolar splittings as shown below. Thus, both deuterons reflect the
increasing motional freedom of the sterol molecule when the membrane
interface becomes increasingly hydrated.
|
It has been shown previously by 2H NMR, that the
cholesterol molecule undergoes axially symmetric motion in membranes
with 30 mol% of cholesterol and well above the main phase transition of the host phospholipid (Dufourc et al., 1984
). Axial molecular motion
implies that the quadrupolar splitting of the 3-
-CD is associated
with an order parameter SCD, i.e.,

QCD = 3/4
(3 cos2
1)SCD, where
denotes
the quadrupolar coupling constant and
the orientation of the
membrane normal with respect to the magnetic field. A molecular order
parameter can be obtained providing that the principal axis of motion
of the cholesterol molecule as a whole is known, i.e.
Smol = SCD/S
, where
S
= 1/2(3 cos2
1) and
represents the rigid angle between the CD bond vector and the molecule
fixed principal axis (Seelig, 1977
; Dufourc et al., 1984
). Dufourc et
al. obtained
= 84 ± 2° in a mixture of 1,2-dimyristoyl-sn-glycero-3-phosphocholine (DMPC) with 30 mol% of multiply deuterium-labeled cholesterol. Using this result and taking account of the membrane orientation
= 0, the
quadrupolar splittings obtained at nw = 48 (
QCD = 87 kHz) and
nw = 10 (
QCD = 91.5 kHz) yielded Smol = 0.71 and
0.74, respectively (37°C). This is less than the value of 0.79 observed in a mixture of 30 mol% cholesterol in DMPC at the same
temperature (Dufourc et al., 1984
) which may be a consequence of the
disordering effect of the double bond in the sn-2 chain of the POPC molecule.
There was no reversal of 
QD20 on going to very
low hydration (nw < 5) as in the PG
system (Fig. 4 B; cf. Fig. 3 B). The splittings were also slightly larger in the cholesterol membranes, e.g.

QD20 was 3 kHz at
nw = 10 and 37°C, when
nw refers to the phospholipid only or
2.6 kHz when nw includes the
cholesterol component, as compared to 2.2 kHz in the POPC/EYPG mixture
at the same hydration and temperature (both phospholipid components
included in the calculation of nw).
Further insight into the dynamics of the membrane interface was
obtained from the spin lattice relaxation time
Tlz of the interlamellar
D2O and of the sterol deuterons (Fig.
5). The
T1z values of the
D2O component increased from 18 ms at
nw = 4 to ~90 ms at
nw = 20. The spin lattice relaxation
of the cholesterol OD resonance changed from 20 ms to an almost
constant level of 50 ms, whereas the corresponding CD relaxation was
less hydration dependent (~5 to 10 ms). The former observation
indicates that the OD bond vector attains free rotation when the
hydration ratio exceeds nw
8. The
spin lattice relaxation times tended to a common value when
nw
5, suggesting that partial
breakdown of a continuous layer of interlamellar water severely
restricts the free rotation of the interlamellar
D2O and of the entire cholesterol molecule.
|
Chemical exchange among hydroxyl and water deuterons
Inversion transfer experiments were performed at 30°C to determine the deuteron exchange rate according to Eqs. 1-3. The total time required for a set of inversion transfer and inversion recovery experiments was approximately 4.5 h. The water/lipid ratio decreased within this time range by a few percent, even when nw was > 25. This error was accounted for by interpolation between the first and last spectrum of the series.
Representative 2H-spectra of
cholesterol-d2 (30 mol% in POPC) and the
corresponding fit to the experimental signal amplitudes according to
Eqs. 1-3 are shown in Fig. 6,
A and B, respectively. Only the signal pair with
the smaller quadrupolar splitting (3-
-OD) is affected by the
inversion transfer sequence, in agreement with the above signal
assignment. The exchange rate constants were determined analogously for
pure POPG membranes (spectra not shown). The measurements were made
with pure POPG rather than with the PG/PC mixture to keep the total
time for the experiment as short as possible. The hydration dependence
was similar to that in the PC/PG mixture, except that the OD
quadrupolar splittings were larger by approximately 5%. As expected,
both 2H doublets were affected by the inversion
of the D2O signal.
|
The results obtained for POPG and for cholesterol are summarized in
Fig. 7. It can be recognized that the
kOD values for the POPG-headgroup
strongly depend on the hydration ratio
nw, i.e., kOD increases from 200 s
1 at nw
6 to >1000 s
1 at
nw
45 for both OD signals in POPG.
Specifically, kOD is slightly smaller
below nw
8 for the
- than for
the
-OD, whereas the opposite is true between
nw
10 and 20, which is in
qualitative agreement with the variable line broadenings of the
individual resonances (cf. Fig. 2).
|
The exchange rates for the cholesterol 3-
-OD deuteron are smaller,
with a flat maximum at nw
27, and
less dependent on the hydration ratio than those obtained for the PG
headgroup residues. At the highest hydration level studied
(nw
38) the
OD-D2O exchange rate was more than five times
larger for the POPG hydroxyls than for the 3-
-hydroxyl of
cholesterol-d2 (Fig. 7).
| |
DISCUSSION |
|---|
|
|
|---|
The technique of lipid hydration and membrane alignment described
in the present study differs from the conventional procedure where
hydration is achieved by incubation of predried lipid deposits in an
atmosphere of constant vapor pressure (Wieslander et al., 1978
; Klose
et al., 1992
; Ulrich and Watts, 1994a
; Volke and Pampel, 1995
). The
very slowly dehydrating lipid-D2O multibilayers
(cf. Fig. 1) are not strictly at thermodynamic equilibrium. This has been accounted for by keeping the change of the water/lipid molar ratio
nw during the total acquisition time
of the NMR experiments <5%, whereas experiments with a higher
evaporation rate were discarded. Advantages of this "close to
equilibrium" hydration include the possibility to monitor water
uptake and membrane annealing and to measure quadrupolar splittings,
relaxation parameters, and deuteron exchange rates continuously over a
broad range of water/lipid molar ratios in a single sample after the
annealing has been established.
The short average lifetime of labile deuterons in amino- or hydroxyl
residues makes it difficult to observe the corresponding 2H NMR signals in randomly oriented lipid
dispersions at physiological temperatures. It is shown here that
homogeneous alignment of membranes between glass slides yields
well-resolved 2H-signals from deuterium-exchanged
hydroxyl residues, even if the water/lipid molar ratio is close to the
maximum uptake capacity of the particular membrane. The exchangeability
of headgroup and water deuterons affords an accurate determination of
nw by signal integration. The parallel
orientation of the membrane normal with respect to the magnetic field
results in the maximum effective quadrupolar splitting
(
Q
3 cos2
1 with
= 0), which
meets the basic requirement kOD

Q for slow hydroxyl-water exchange on the
NMR time scale. Water that is not associated with the lipid interface
(isotropic water) can be easily excluded from signal integration, which
represents a further benefit of using oriented versus nonoriented membranes.
Exchange labeling of the hydroxyl groups may help to elucidate the
dynamics and the structural changes within the PG headgroup as a
function of membrane hydration. The headgroup dynamics of phosphatidylglycerols in excess water have been studied previously by
2H NMR after selective deuteration of the three
glycerol carbons (Wohlgemuth et al., 1980
; Borle and Seelig, 1983b
;
Marassi and Macdonald, 1991
). Spin lattice relaxation-time measurements
of labeled dipalmitoyl phosphatidylglycerol (Wohlgemuth et al., 1980
) or of E. coli PG (Borle and Seelig, 1983b
) led to the
conclusion that the segmental fluctuations of the headgroup are similar
to those of the zwitterionic lipids and even not much different from the mobility of neat gycerol (Borle and Seelig, 1983b
). At 40°C, the
quadrupolar splittings of the
,
, and
segments of E. coli PG were 10.2, 4.5, and 0.8 kHz, respectively. Using order
parameters rather than quadrupolar splittings makes a comparison with
our aligned and exchange deuterated membranes practicable (cf. Figs. 2
and 3). Order parameters for the C
-O and
C
-O bond vectors in the headgroup glycerol moiety can be
calculated from the observed OD quadrupolar splittings, taking account
of the macroscopic alignment at
= 0 (which yields twice the
quadrupolar splitting of an unoriented sample). An order parameter
|SOD| follows from

QOD = 
OD
|SOD|, where the bars denote
absolute values. The quadrupolar coupling constant
OD has a value of 220 kHz for a deuteron in an
OD bond (Soda and Chiba, 1969
). Transformation according to
|SCO| = (3 cos2
1)
1
|SOD| yields the desired order
parameter of the C-O bond vector (Seelig, 1977
). An average order
parameter |SCO| = 0.12 for the
and
segments can be obtained from the OD splitting of 27.7 kHz,
using a COD bond angle
= 108.5° (see top spectrum in Fig. 2). The respective order parameters
|SCD| in the selectively labeled E. coli PG at full hydration (Borle and Seelig, 1983b
) were
0.08, 0.04, and 0.006 for the
,
, and
segments. The larger
order parameter value obtained from the OD quadrupolar splitting is likely to be due to the membrane alignment on a solid support and to
the solidifying effect of intermolecular hydrogen bonding in the
absence of excess water.
An evaluation of the OD quadrupolar splittings in structural terms is
not straightforward. The orientation of the PG-headgroup with respect
to the membrane surface has been examined earlier by small-angle x-ray
(Watts et al., 1981
) and neutron scattering techniques (Mischel et al.,
1987
). These experiments were performed in the ordered phase of DPPG or
E. coli PG, respectively, at very low hydration
(nw
2.6). An approximate tilt of
30° was derived from this data for the PG headgroup, although an
alternative interdigitated structure could not be strictly excluded
(Mischel et al., 1987
). The scattering results and the NMR data may be
not directly comparable, however, considering the different
experimental conditions.
The counterdirectional change of the the
- and
-quadrupolar
splittings in region II of Fig. 3 A resembles the behavior
of the
- and
-methylene headgroup signals in selectively
2H labeled phosphatidylcholines where the
-splitting increases and the
-splitting decreases when the
interlamellar water content is reduced below
nw = 20 (Ulrich et al., 1992
;
Bechinger and Seelig, 1991
). The observation that a plot of

Q
versus 
Q
was almost
linear with a negative slope was taken as evidence that the quadrupolar
splittings reflect slight changes of the average orientation of the
phosphocholine dipole rather than variations of the fluctuational
amplitude of the headgroup (Bechinger and Seelig, 1991
). The changes of

Q
and 
Q
shown in Fig.
3 A are more complicated, however. A plot of

Q
vs. 
Q
is not linear
and its slope changes sign on going from region I to region II. A
straightforward interpretation in terms of a unique conformational
change in the PG headgroup is therefore not warranted here. The
parallel decrease of the splittings with decreasing hydration (region
I) is probably related to the breakdown of a continuous primary
hydration shell, accompanied by the formation of an interheadgroup
H-bonding network that replaces the headgroup-water interaction. The
concomitant steep decrease of 
QD20 at low
hydration values (Fig. 3 B) may be also a result of the reorganization of the membrane interface at
nw < 8. Borle and Seelig identified a
primary hydration shell (bound water) of 10-16 water molecules per mol
of PG by measuring relaxation times and D2O line
widths, whereas the D2O quadrupolar splittings
were not resolved in their nonoriented samples (Borle and Seelig,
1983b
). Thus, it seems reasonable to assume that the counterdirectional change of 
Q
and 
Q
in
region II (8 < nw < 20) is the
result of slight changes of the headgroup torsion angles, whereas the
decrease of 
Q
in region I
(nw < 8) is associated with a
restructuring of the interface and probably with the formation of a
more strongly hydrogen bonded state of the headgroup as noted above.
Another possibility that must be considered is the replacement of
D2O molecules in the hydration shell of the
sodium counterions with OD residues of the PG headgroup.
The majority of earlier studies on the modulation of the phospholipid
bilayer by cholesterol were performed in the presence of disaturated
phosphatidylcholines. The prime focus was on the alteration of
lipid-chain ordering and on the concomitant suppression of the phase
transition in these systems (Finegold, 1993
; McMullen and McElhaney,
1996
). Comprehensive ternary phase diagrams, including unsaturated
phospholipids and phospholipids other than phosphatidylcholine are
still scarce, however (Vist and Davis, 1990
; Thewalt and Bloom, 1992
;
McMullen and McElhaney, 1995
). Thus, lateral segregation of the
membrane into liquid-crystalline and liquid-ordered domains, which has
been observed in mixtures of cholesterol with DMPC and DPPC, must be
considered when dealing with hydration in mixed membranes. In a recent
monolayer study, it has been shown that POPC with 30 mol% cholesterol
remains in the fluid phase at applied lateral pressures of up to 40 mN/m, without phase separation (Worthman et al., 1997
). This is also in
line with an earlier study using small-angle x-ray scattering where
lateral phase separation of the components was not detected at 21°C
and 50 mol% cholesterol in egg PC (McIntosh et al., 1989
). Therefore,
it seems justified to assume that the POPC/30 mol% cholesterol
membrane studied here at 30 and 37°C represents a homogeneous mixture
even at low hydration values.
The quadrupolar splittings (Fig. 4) and the spin lattice relaxation
data (Fig. 5) suggest that the cholesterol molecule acquires increasing
motional freedom with increasing hydration of the membrane-water interface. At low hydration (nw
10), the deuteron signals from the doubly labeled sterol are rather
broad, which results in ill-defined quadrupolar splittings. The spin
lattice relaxation times, T1z, in this
region reflect the motional restriction of the cholesterol molecule and
of the residual D2O. Increasing hydration
(nw > 10) leads to a monotonous
decrease and, eventually, to almost invariable 
QCD and 
QOD values, the
ratio of which remains constant up to the maximum hydration attainable
in the oriented system. An analysis of these relations in terms of the
off-axis motion of the cholesterol molecule is beyond the scope of this
article and will be given elsewhere. It may be noted that the maximum
hydration value obtained in the present study
(nw
60 with respect to the
phospholipid component) is significantly higher than values reported
previously for lecithin membranes without cholesterol (Rand and
Parsegian, 1989
; Morrison, 1993
).
The dependence of 
QD20 on the degree of membrane
hydration has been described by some authors in terms of a simple
two-state model, assuming surface "bound" and interlamellar
"trapped" water. This model predicts a linear relation between

QD20 and 1/nw,
providing that both bound and trapped water are present in the system
(Finer and Darke, 1974
; Lindblom et al., 1991
; Faure et al., 1996
;
Wassall, 1996
). The earlier assumption of discrete hydration shells
with a unique 
QD20 in each individual hydration
layer (Finer and Darke, 1974
; Finer, 1979
) certainly represents an
oversimplification, however. Another model assumes exponentially
decreasing individual D2O splittings, leading to
an average splitting 

QD20
= A/nw (1
exp(
nw/C)) with
A and C being adjustable parameters (Volke et
al., 1994b
). This model is physically sound and gave acceptable results
in nonoriented POPC dispersions (Volke et al., 1994b
). A satisfactory
fit to the present data was not obtained, however, probably as a result
of the planar membrane alignment. Specifically, our values tend to a
level of ~1 kHz at the highest hydration values (both for the PC/PG
and for the PC/cholesterol membrane systems) rather than to zero
quadrupolar splitting as suggested by the above equation. A different
behavior was reported for a nonoriented dispersion of PG in
D2O where the quadrupolar splitting vanishes at
nw
40 (Lindblom et al., 1991
),
probably as a result of diffusion along the curved multibilayer
surfaces and exchange with water in packing defects.
Therefore, single exponentials were used here according to

QD20 = A + B
exp(
nw/C), without
alluding to a particular hydration model (cf. Figs. 3 B and
4 B). The decay constant C for the
POPC/cholesterol mixture (in mol D2O per mol
POPC, neglecting the cholesterol component of the mixture) from a fit
to the data in Fig. 4 B (37°C) was 13.3 mol/mol and the
limiting quadrupolar splitting A + B was 5.35 kHz
(a decay constant of 9 mol/mol is obtained when both components are
considered in the calculation). A similar decay constant (15.7 mol/mol)
was obtained when 
QCD versus
nw was fitted analogously (Fig.
4 A), i.e. both quadrupolar splittings reflect the
relaxation of the system into a fully hydrated equilibrium state. This
may be compared with the decay of 
QD20 in the
PC/PG mixture (Fig. 3 B) where the fit yielded
C = 10.0 mol/mol and A + B = 4.15 kHz, respectively. An analogous experiment performed at 37°C
with POPC alone (not shown) gave a decay constant of 6.9 mol/mol and a
limiting splitting of 5.9 kHz. A similar difference between egg
phosphatidylcholine and egg phosphatidylcholine/cholesterol mixtures
has been previously observed by small-angle x-ray scattering with
respect to the decay constants of the force-distance relation at
hydration values nw
10 (Jendrasiak
and Hasty, 1974
; Marsh, 1989
), whereas, to our knowledge, the PG/PC
system has not been studied so far.
Proton exchange via chains of hydrogen-bonded surface residues is
believed to be an essential step of the energy transduction in
mitochondrial, bacterial, and photosynthetic membranes (Williams, 1988
), although the extent to which this process involves the lipid
headgroups is still a matter of debate (Teissié et al., 1993
;
Teissié, 1996
). Hydrogen exchange between water and phospholipid ethanolamine headgroups has been studied previously in small sonicated vesicles, using the transverse relaxation of the water protons (Ralph
et al., 1985
). These authors presented a model where a rapid
intrasurface H+ exchange among the
NH2 groups is catalyzed by internal,
hydrogen-bonded water molecules. This assumption accounts for the fact
that the overall exchange rate was almost two orders of magnitude
larger than expected when only catalysis by OH
ions was considered (Ralph et al., 1985
). The overall exchange rates
obtained here in an unbuffered PG membrane are similar to those
reported for the vesicle system, e.g., at
nw = 40 the exchange rate
kOD
950 s
1
(30°C), which compares favorably with
1500
s
1 obtained by Ralph et al. at pH6 (25°C).
Thus, it may be assumed that the exchange is accelerated by a hydrogen
bond network that comprises both water molecules and headgroup
residues, including the negatively charged phosphodiester moiety. A
mechanism like this may be responsible for the steep decrease of
kOD in the aligned PG membrane when
water evaporation (nw
20) results
in the breakdown of a continuous hydrogen bond network (Fig. 7). It is
noteworthy that the decrease of the exchange rates roughly coincides
with the onset of the conformational change in the PG headgroup as indicated by the quadrupolar splittings (see regions I and II in Fig.
3 A). It may be also noted that, for an assessment of the
effective hydration in the PG interface, it would be necessary to
consider water binding by the sodium counterions, which reduces the
number of water molecules available for headgroup hydration and
intermolecular hydrogen bonding.
The exchange rate obtained in the POPC/cholesterol mixture is
approximately five times lower at nw
40 than the rate obtained in the POPG membranes. This may be
attributed to the embedment of the cholesterol molecule within the
membrane, rendering the hydroxyl group much less accessible to water.
It is also customary to assume strong hydrogen bonding with the
phospholipid carbonyl groups. Neither of these assumptions is
satisfactory, however. It has been demonstrated recently, using
quasielastic neutron scattering, that diffusive motion in the direction
of the membrane normal increases drastically when going from 20 to
36°C (Gliss et al., 1999
). This is in line with a molecular dynamics
study, where it was shown that the distribution profile of the hydroxyl oxygen along the bilayer normal has a width at half height of 7 Å and
that the hydroxyl group interacts exclusively with water about half of
the time (Tu et al., 1998
). Although, in these studies, the cholesterol
molecule was embedded in DPPC and the cholesterol concentration was
significantly different (40 and 12.5 mol%, respectively), it cannot be
maintained that cholesterol forms strong hydrogen bonds with the
phospholipid carbonyl oxygens. It must be therefore assumed that the
cholesterol exchange differs mechanistically from the deuteron exchange
observed in the PG membrane surface, where the exchange may be
catalyzed by the neighboring phosphodiester moiety.
| |
ACKNOWLEDGMENTS |
|---|
Supported by the Deutsche Forschungsgemeinschaft, Sonderforschungsbereich 266, Teilprojekt B 12.
| |
FOOTNOTES |
|---|
Received for publication 18 November 1999 and in final form 24 January 2000.
Address reprint requests to Klaus Beyer, Adolf-Butenandt-Institut, Universität München, Schillerstrasse 44, 80336 München, Germany. Tel.: +49-89-5996-470; Fax: +49-89-5996-415; E-mail: kbeyer{at}med.uni-muenchen.de.
| |
Abbreviations used |
|---|
Abbreviations used: POPC, 1-palmitoyl-2-oleyl phosphatidylcholine; POPG, 1-palmitoyl-2-oleyl phosphatidylglycerol; EYPG, phosphatidylglycerol obtained by headgroup exchange from egg yolk lecithin; PC, phosphatidylcholine; PG, phosphatidylglycerol.
| |
REFERENCES |
|---|
|
|
|---|
and L
' phases by 2H solid state NMR of D2O.
FEBS Lett.
405:263-266[Medline].