| HOME | HELP | FEEDBACK | SUBSCRIPTIONS | ARCHIVE | SEARCH | TABLE OF CONTENTS |
Biophys J, October 2000, p. 1876-1882, Vol. 79, No. 4
Biophysics Section, Laboratory of Cellular Biology, National Institute on Deafness and Other Communication Disorders, National Institutes of Health, Bethesda, Maryland 20892-0922 USA
| |
ABSTRACT |
|---|
|
|
|---|
Functioning of the membrane motor of the outer hair cell is tightly associated with transfer of charge across the membrane. To obtain further insights into the motor mechanism, we examined kinetics of charge transfer across the membrane in two different modes. One is to monitor charge transfer induced by changes in the membrane potential as an excess membrane capacitance. The other is to measure spontaneous flip-flops of charges across the membrane under voltage-clamp conditions as current noise. The noise spectrum of current was inverse Lorentzian, and the capacitance was Lorentzian, as theoretically expected. The characteristic frequency of the capacitance was ~10 kHz, and that for current noise was ~30 kHz. The difference in the characteristic frequencies seems to reflect the difference in the modes of mechanical movement associated with the two physical quantities.
| |
INTRODUCTION |
|---|
|
|
|---|
The outer hair cell has a motile mechanism
(Brownell et al., 1985
) in its lateral membrane that is unique among
biological motors in that it is directly dependent on the membrane
potential (Ashmore, 1987
; Santos-Sacchi and Dilger, 1988
). Its motile
activity is coupled with transfer of charge across the membrane
(Ashmore, 1990
; Santos-Sacchi, 1991
; Iwasa, 1993
). With this mechanism, energy gained by charge transfer is used for mechanical work. Such
direct electromechanical coupling, which must be advantageous when operating at high frequencies, was demonstrated by the shift in voltage dependence caused by an increase in membrane tension (Iwasa,
1993
; Kakehata and Santos-Sacchi, 1995
; Gale and Ashmore, 1995
). It is
further confirmed by a recent observation that a constraint on the
membrane area prevents charge transfer across the membrane (Adachi and
Iwasa, 1999
). For a further characterization of the motor, we examine
here the kinetic properties of charge transfer by the motor.
The easiest method of measuring charge transfer across the membrane is
the whole-cell voltage clamp because all motor charges in the cell
contribute to the signal, making the signal large. However, this method
has a relatively low time resolution, intrinsic to the recording
configuration. A low-pass filter is formed by the combination of the
access resistance of the recording pipette with the considerable
membrane capacitance of the cell. For example, if the membrane
capacitance is 20 pF and the recording pipette has an access resistance
of 5 M
, the circuit has a roll-off frequency lower than 2 kHz for a
voltage-clamp experiment. This frequency is significantly lower than
the human auditory range, which reaches 20 kHz. The roll-off frequency
is lower for a current-clamp experiment because the membrane resistance
is usually larger than the access resistance.
The standard on-cell configuration of patch clamp does not have the
frequency dependence of the whole-cell mode, but the seal conductance
is relatively large for the membrane area recorded. The optimal mode of
the recording is expected to be a "giant patch" configuration
(Hilgemann, 1995
) because it allows recording from larger membrane
patches with a seal that is similar to that of the standard on-cell
patch technique.
For kinetic study of charge transfer, we measured the frequency
dependence of the membrane capacitance and the power spectrum of
current noise under voltage clamp, using the giant on-cell patch
recording technique. The experimental data are compared with
theoretical predictions based on a simple two-state model of the motor
(Iwasa, 1997
). Preliminary versions of this work have been presented in
abstract form (Ehrenstein and Iwasa, 1997
).
| |
A SIMPLE TWO-STATE MODEL |
|---|
|
|
|---|
Two-state models are successful in describing the motility of the
outer hair cell (Ashmore, 1987
; Santos-Sacchi and Dilger, 1988
;
Ashmore, 1990
; Santos-Sacchi, 1991
; Iwasa, 1993
). In these models, two
states of the motor differ in their mechanical properties, such as in
the membrane area and in the charge distribution across the membrane.
Conformational transitions thus involve changes in both charge and
mechanical properties of the membrane. Because mechanical changes in
the membrane may require mechanical movement, which must follow
equations of motion, mechanical constraints and resistance may
reciprocally affect transitions of the motor. For the simplest
description of motor charge transfer, however, we ignore the reciprocal
effect. The following is a brief description of such a theory (Iwasa,
1997
). We will be able to examine the possible effects of
electromechanical coupling by comparing the predictions with our
experimental data.
Let s and
be two states of a motor unit (with
s and
implying small and large membrane area,
respectively). The characteristic angular frequency
0 (= 2
f0)
of the system is determined by the sum of the transition rate
k+ from s to
and the
rate k
of the reverse transition.
The probability P
(t)
that the motor is in state
at time t is given by
|
(1) |
= 1/(k+ + k
), which corresponds to the
characteristic frequency
0 = 1/
.
The probability P
that the motor
unit is in state
is given by
k+/(k+ + k
). The excess membrane capacitance Cm(
) and the power spectrum of
current noise SI(
) due to the motor
are then given, respectively, by (Iwasa, 1997
),
|
(2) |
|
(3) |
|
(4) |
is the equilibrium
probability of the motor in the extended conformation, and it is
expressed by
|
(5) |
At the high frequency limit, Eq. 3 is reduced to
|
(6) |
| |
MATERIALS AND METHODS |
|---|
|
|
|---|
Cell preparation
Bullas were obtained from guinea pigs in accordance with the protocol 902-99 NINDS/NIDCD (National Institute of Neurological Disorders and Stroke/ National Institute on Deafness and Other Communication Disorders). The organ of Corti was dissociated from opened cochleas by teasing with a fine needle under a dissection microscope. The strips of organ of Corti thus obtained were triturated three times gently with a plastic pipette and placed in a chamber mounted on an inverted microscope. The lengths of the cells used for the experiment ranged between 40 µm and 75 µm. In some of experiments, dispase (Boehringer-Mannheim) treatment (0.5 units/ml for 20 min at 21°C) was used before mechanical isolation.
Recording setup
We followed the standard method (Hilgemann, 1995
) for
fabricating giant patch pipettes with a microforge, although the tip diameter was between 2 and 4 µm and was small for pipettes for the
giant patch. The pipette resistance was less than 1 M
. We found it
essential to coat the pipette tips with a mixture of light and heavy
mineral oil, following the standard method for the giant patch, to form
a tight seal with hair cells.
Giant on-cell patches were formed on the lateral wall of the outer hair
cell at locations between the nucleus and the apical end. A
channel-blocking medium was used for the bath and in the pipette. The
medium contained 100 mM NaCl, 20 mM CsCl, 1.5 mM MgCl2, 20 mM tetraethylammonium, 0.5 M HEPES-Cs,
and 2 mM CoCl2. The osmolarity was adjusted to
300 mOs/kg with glucose (~5 mM), and the pH was adjusted to 7.4. The
record was taken from cells with a seal resistance that exceeded 2 G
.
A stock solution (100 mg/ml) of nystatin (Sigma) was prepared in dimethylsulfoxide. Nystatin was added to the bathing medium and sonicated immediately before use. The final concentration was 0.1 mg/ml.
Data acquisition and analysis
Data acquisition was performed with an Axopatch 200B (Axon
Instruments, Foster City, CA) operated in feedback resistor mode in
connection with an ITC-16 (Instrutech, Great Neck, NY) driven by the
Igor program (WaveMetrics, Lake Oswego, OR), with interface modules
created by Bookman Lab at the University of Miami (available from
Instrutech at http://www.instrutech.com/archive.html). The voltage
dependence of the membrane capacitance was monitored with the
phase-tracking technique (Fidler and Fernandez, 1989
) at 1 kHz while
the DC level was changed stepwise. Circuit modification required for
phase tracking in the on-cell configuration was assisted by Axon
Instruments. The frequency profile of the capacitance was obtained with
fast Fourier transform (FFT) from the current response elicited by a
voltage waveform of digitally generated wide-band noise. The noise used
had a root mean square amplitude of 5 mV and was 0.325 s in duration.
Current noise was recorded in 0.5-s sections. Each data acquisition was
repeated at least 20 times. The current output of the patch amplifier
was digitized at 10-µs intervals after an 8-pole Bessel
filter (model 900; Frequency Devices, Haverhill, MA) operating at
50-kHz corner frequency. The spectra were corrected for the filter in
the frequency domain. To improve the signal-to-noise ratio, capacitance
compensation was used at the shortest available time constant (10 µs). FFT was performed using 2048 points. The reference records for
the pipette capacitance were obtained with the same recording pipette by forming a tight seal on a piece of sylgard located in the same chamber after recording in the cell. As is the case for most on-cell patch experiments, the conductance and the capacitance of the rest of
the cell can be ignored in analyzing the record because both are large
compared with those of the sealed membrane patch, because of the large
difference in the membrane area. The setup was calibrated with a
circuit model for on-cell patches before experiments.
| |
RESULTS |
|---|
|
|
|---|
Records were taken from giant patches that were formed at the
lateral membrane of the outer hair cell. The experiment was performed
in the following sequence. First, the voltage profile of the
capacitance was obtained. That was followed by the frequency profile of
the membrane capacitance from FFT. Then the current noise spectrum was
measured. At the end of the experiment, the pipette used for the
experiment was pushed against a piece of sylgard placed on the bottom
of the chamber to form a high-resistance seal (~5 G
). The
frequency profile of the capacitance and the noise spectrum of the
sylgard-sealed pipette were used as the baselines.
Voltage dependence of the membrane capacitance
The membrane capacitance consisted of two components. One was the
regular membrane capacitance, which was independent of the membrane
potential, and the other was nonlinear capacitance, which had a
bell-shaped voltage dependence (Fig. 1).
The pipette potential of the peak was (55 ± 21) mV (mean ± SD, N = 46) and was consistent with the peak membrane
potential of ~
60 mV (Kakehata and Santos-Sacchi, 1995
) in the
whole-cell recording using channel-blocking media similar to ours. The
peak height of the nonlinear capacitance ranged from 30 fF to 300 fF
and was typically between 80 fF and 150 fF. The nonlinear component of
the capacitance was fitted with Eqs. 3 and 4 to obtain the unit
charge q, which determines the steepness, and the number
N of such units.
|
To examine the unit charge obtained with this method, we plotted it against the magnitude of the voltage-dependent component of the membrane capacitance, which may be used as a convenient indicator of the size of the membrane patch (Fig. 2). The plot showed a correlation that larger patches tend to show smaller values for the unit charge q.
|
|
During experiments, we usually kept the pipette open to the ambient pressure. In one series of experiments, we attempted to determine whether the unit charge q is dependent on pipette pressure. We found that the peak potential was affected by pressure applied to the pipette, but the value for the unit charge q was unaffected by it.
Frequency dependence of the membrane capacitance
The capacitance values near 1 kHz obtained with the FFT method (Fig. 3) were generally consistent with those obtained with phase tracking method. It had a roll-off at around (10.7 ± 4.4) kHz (mean ± SD, N = 50).
Hensen's cells were used as a control. Membrane patches formed on those cells had no noticeable voltage dependence of the membrane capacitance. The frequency dependence obtained was also flat (Fig. 4).
|
In a series of experiments, nystatin (0.1 mg/ml) was added to the bathing medium to determine whether the membrane permeability in the rest of the cell affected our result. Application of nystatin brought about neither a noticeable change in the voltage dependence of the capacitance nor a change in the frequency dependence of the capacitance above 1 kHz.
Power spectrum of current noise
The power spectrum (Fig. 5) of current noise at a given voltage was obtained by subtracting the spectrum of a sylgard patch, which was not voltage dependent, from the giant patch spectrum. The spectrum was high-pass type as expected, with the characteristic frequency usually higher than 30 kHz, exceeding the cutoff frequency of the capacitance spectra (Fig. 5 A). The amplitude of noise at a given voltage was well correlated with the capacitance at ~1 kHz. This correlation indicates that the spectrum obtained has a significant contribution from motor charges.
|
The spectra could be affected by components other than the one due to the motor charge. If the spectra are dominated by fluctuation of the motor charges, subtraction of two spectra obtained at different pipette potentials should have a similar relaxation time.
If these spectra contain a significant contribution from other components, which are not dependent on the membrane potential, the characteristic frequency of the subtraction spectrum may be significantly different from the two individual spectra.
The difference spectra (Fig. 5 B) of current noise had a cutoff frequency of about (33.6 ± 9.7) kHz (mean ± SD, N = 4). In some membrane patches the frequencies of subtracted spectra were lower than either of the two individual spectra. In those cases the voltage-independent components were larger and had high-pass frequencies higher than 50 kHz. Those observations were consistent with the observation that membrane patches on the Hensen's cells after sylgard subtraction showed a high-pass current noise spectrum with a characteristic frequency that exceeded 100 kHz.
Because obtaining a seal good enough for the difference noise spectra was extremely difficult, the patches with such records were a small subset of the patches, from which the capacitance was recorded. For those patches with good noise records, the characteristic frequency of the capacitance was (14.3 ± 3.9) kHz (mean ± SD, N = 4).
For the power spectrum of noise, the sylgard patch may not always serve
as a good control because the effect of the regular (voltage-independent) membrane capacitance remains uncompensated, giving rise to high-pass noise (Benndorf, 1995
).
| |
DISCUSSION |
|---|
|
|
|---|
Our results have features that are largely consistent with the theoretical predictions based on a simple two-state model, but they do show disagreements in some details. For example, the excess capacitance of tightly sealed giant membrane patches has a bell-shaped peak when plotted against the membrane potential, as predicted by the theory. Nonetheless, the width of the peak shows unpredicted dependence on the size of the membrane patch. The frequency dependence of the membrane capacitance is Lorentzian and the power spectrum of membrane current noise is inverse Lorentzian, as predicted. Nonetheless, the characteristic frequency of the capacitance is usually lower than the characteristic frequency of current noise. We will address these discrepancies below.
Motor charge
It has been pointed out previously that the frequency dependence
and power spectrum of current noise are not likely to provide additional data for distinguishing a two-state model from a three-state model, beyond what is obtained from the voltage dependence of the
membrane capacitance (Iwasa, 1997
). We thus discuss motor charge based
on a two-state model.
The mean value for the apparent motor charge qapp estimated from the voltage dependence of the membrane capacitance in the giant on-cell patches is often ~0.6e and is smaller than the value obtained with the whole-cell configuration. The estimate for the motor charge is inversely correlated with the estimated peak height of the nonlinear capacitance, which may be an indicator of the size of the sealed membrane patches (Fig. 2). What is the reason for such a correlation?
The curvature of the membrane patches can be a possible reason. Consider two sealed membrane patches, large and small, which are initially flat. A same hyperpolarizing voltage pulse would makes these membrane patches concave. Membrane tensions Tm in these two patches are equal, and the radius of the curvature r of the larger patch is larger in proportion to the patch diameter. If we assume Laplace's law, Tm = 1/2Pr, the pressure difference across the membrane is smaller for the smaller patch. Thus movement of the larger patch can be more effectively reduced by other factors in the experimental setup, such as surface tension at the air-water interface in the patch pipette.
An alternative explanation involves interactions between membrane patches and the surface of the glass pipette. It would be plausible that the area of the membrane with such interactions is softer and more flexible than the rest of the membrane, and such an area may extend a fixed distance along the membrane from the seal. Such nonuniformity of the membrane may facilitate area changes when the membrane potential is changed. Because the edge effect is greater in the smaller patch, the motor in the smaller patch is less constrained.
We have attempted to address this issue by applying pressure to the patch pipette because pressure applied to the pipette should affect the curvature of the membrane patch. Pressure application did not have an effect on the apparent value for the motor charge, although it shifted the potential that maximizes the capacitance. This observation favors the explanation by the edge effect.
In either case, the intrinsic motor charge q would then be
obtained by extrapolating to the small patch. The extrapolation leads
to a value (0.78 ± 0.03)e, which is similar to
those obtained in the whole-cell configuration (Ashmore, 1990
;
Santos-Sacchi, 1991
; Iwasa, 1993
; Kakehata and Santos-Sacchi, 1995
).
The characteristic frequency
Our results show that the frequency dependence of the membrane capacitance is low-pass and that the current noise spectrum is high-pass, as theoretically predicted (Eqs. 2 and 3). In addition, the magnitude of noise is larger at the pipette potential, at which the capacitance is larger. However, the characteristic frequencies of the capacitance and that of current noise differ considerably. The expected relationship (Eq. 6) between the capacitance and noise spectrum does not hold because the two characteristic frequencies are not equal.
A basic assumption in the theory that led to the relationship in Eq. 6 is that the charge transfer across the membrane can take place without being affected by any mechanical factor. Can it be a valid assumption in describing a system of motors? In the following we examine this problem.
Effect of viscous resistance
If charge transfer is indeed coupled with motor activity, it would be reciprocally affected by mechanical factors such as resistance and inertia. Transfer of charge across the membrane will not take place until associated mechanical movements occur, which are similar to static constraints (Adachi and Iwasa, 1999
|
(7) |
represents the effect of
friction. Then the relaxation time
is turned into (1 +
)/
(k+ + k
), leading to the characteristic
frequency
0 = (k+ + k
)/(1 +
).
The viscous drag
could be dependent on the mode of motion. Let
c represent the drag for collective motion,
and let
s represent the drag for independent
motion of a single motor unit. We may then have the characteristic
frequency
c0 for collective motion and the
frequency
s0 for independent motion,
determined by
|
(8) |
|
(9) |
|
(10) |
Interpretation of the data
To examine the validity of Eq. 10, we use voltage-dependent differences in the capacitance and current noise. We find that our data approximately satisfy the expected relationship in Eq. 10 (Fig. 6). However, as we have discussed earlier, our capacitance experiment may have underestimated the motor charge due to static constraints. If spontaneous fluctuation of the motor charge is not subjected to such constraints, the observed capacitance values give underestimates of the quantity represented (q2N) in Eq. 4 of ~10%. This factor actually improves the agreement, although the effect is minor. This agreement suggests that the two modes of our experiments are indeed subjected to different levels of viscous drag. It also provides further evidence for tight electromechanical coupling in the lateral membrane of the outer hair cell.
|
| |
CONCLUSIONS |
|---|
|
|
|---|
In conclusion, we detected current noise due to flipping of the charge associated with the membrane motor. The observed power spectrum of current noise is high-pass (inverse Lorentzian), and the observed frequency dependence of the capacitance is low-pass (Lorentzian), as expected from a simplified theory in which mechanoelectrical coupling is disregarded. The high-frequency asymptotes of the power spectrum of current noise are well correlated with the low-frequency asymptotes of the capacitance as expected. We found, however, that the characteristic frequency of the current noise spectrum is significantly higher than that of the capacitance, differing from the simplified theory. Such a difference in their characteristic frequencies appears to be the consequence of mechanoelectric coupling, in which the modes of mechanical motion can determine the speed of charge movement.
| |
FOOTNOTES |
|---|
Received for publication 10 March 2000 and in final form 14 June 2000.
Address reprint requests to Dr. Kuin H. Iwasa, Biophysics Section, Laboratory of Cellular Biology, National Institute on Deafness and Other Communication Disorders, National Institutes of Health, Building 9, Room 1E120, 9 Center Drive, MSC 0922, Bethesda, MD 20892-0922. Tel.: 301-496-3987; Fax: 301-480-0827; E-mail: kiwasa{at}helix.nih.gov.
| |
REFERENCES |
|---|
|
|
|---|
Biophys J, October 2000, p. 1876-1882, Vol. 79, No. 4
© 2000 by the Biophysical Society 0006-3495/00/10/1876/07 $2.00
This article has been cited by other articles:
![]() |
J. Ashmore Cochlear Outer Hair Cell Motility Physiol Rev, January 1, 2008; 88(1): 173 - 210. [Abstract] [Full Text] [PDF] |
||||
![]() |
R. D. Rabbitt, H. E. Ayliffe, D. Christensen, K. Pamarthy, C. Durney, S. Clifford, and W. E. Brownell Evidence of Piezoelectric Resonance in Isolated Outer Hair Cells Biophys. J., March 1, 2005; 88(3): 2257 - 2265. [Abstract] [Full Text] [PDF] |
||||
| ||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
| HOME | HELP | FEEDBACK | SUBSCRIPTIONS | ARCHIVE | SEARCH | TABLE OF CONTENTS |