| HOME | HELP | FEEDBACK | SUBSCRIPTIONS | ARCHIVE | SEARCH | TABLE OF CONTENTS |
Biophys J, September 2001, p. 1710-1734, Vol. 81, No. 3
Institute of Theoretical and Experimental Biophysics, Russia Academy of Sciences, Pushchino, Moscow Region, Russia 142290
| |
ABSTRACT |
|---|
|
|
|---|
The physical causes for wide variation of Stokes shift values in emission spectra of tryptophan fluorophores in proteins have been proposed in the model of discrete states (Burstein, E. A., N. S. Vedenkina, and M. N. Ivkova. 1973. Photochem. Photobiol. 18:263-279; Burstein, E. A. 1977a. Intrinsic Protein Luminescence (The Nature and Application). In Advances in Science and Technology (Itogi Nauki i Tekhniki), Biophysics Vol. 7. VINITI, Moscow [In Russian]; Burstein, E. A. 1983. Molecular Biology (Moscow) 17:455-467 [In Russian; English translation]). It was assumed that the existence of the five most probable spectral classes of emitting tryptophan residues and differences among the classes were analyzed in terms of various combinations of specific and universal interactions of excited fluorophores with their environment. The development of stable algorithms of decomposition of tryptophan fluorescence spectra into log-normal components gave us an opportunity to apply two mathematically different algorithms, SImple fitting with Mean-Square criterion (SIMS) and PHase-plot-based REsolving with Quenchers (PHREQ) for the decomposition of a representative set of emission spectra of proteins. Here we present the results of decomposition of tryptophan emission spectra of >100 different proteins, some in various structural states (native and denatured, in complexes with ions or organic ligands, in various pH-induced conformations, etc.). Analysis of the histograms of occurrence of >300 spectral log-normal components with various maximum positions confirmed the statistical discreteness of several states of emitting tryptophan fluorophores in proteins.
| |
INTRODUCTION |
|---|
|
|
|---|
Tryptophan fluorescence is widely used to study
the location, physical and dynamic properties of microenvironment of
indole fluorophores, and the structural features and behavior of the protein molecule as a whole (Burstein, 1976
, 1977a
, 1983
; Lakowicz, 1983
; Demchenko, 1986
). Depending on the environment of tryptophan residues in proteins, the maximum position (
m)
and quantum yield (q) of tryptophan fluorescence could vary
widely, from 308 to 353 nm and from 0.4 to immeasurably low, respectively.
In 1967 Konev put forward the hypothesis of the existence of two main
classes of tryptophan residues in proteins, which possess discrete
values of fluorescent parameters
m and
q (Konev, 1967
; Volotovski and Konev, 1967
). One of the
classes included tryptophan fluorophores inside the protein in a
low-polar hydrophobic environment with a shorter-wavelength position of
fluorescent maximum (
m of ~330 nm) and
rather low quantum yield (0.04 to 0.07). The second class consisted of
exposed tryptophan residues in a high-polar aqueous environment with
long-wavelength position of spectra (
m of
~350 nm) and quantum yield equal or higher than that of free aqueous
tryptophan (~0.13-0.17). This hypothesis had been based on the
observation that protein spectrum shifts toward 350-353 nm upon
denaturation by urea, and toward 330-332 nm upon addition of anionic
detergents in acidic solutions. However, this model could not explain
the existence of proteins with a high quantum yield (for example,
0.20-0.27 for serum albumins (Longworth, 1971
)) and intermediate
spectral maximum positions (341.5 nm) for some single-tryptophan-containing proteins, such as human serum albumin (Ivkova et al., 1971
).
In 1973 one of us, with co-workers, revised and extended Konev's
hypothesis of discrete classes of tryptophan residues in proteins and
suggested a new model using some additional spectral parameters and
approaches (Burstein et al., 1973
). The spectral bandwidth at the
half-maximal amplitude 
was taken as an additional parameter. The
linear relationship was found between values of 
and maximum
position
m for tryptophan and other
C-3-substituted indole derivatives in solvents of various polarities.
These spectra could be regarded as a series of "elementary"
components representing the emission bands of individual tryptophan
residues in proteins. Existence of a spectral shift accompanying the
quenching of protein fluorescence by ionic solutes
(NO3
,
I
, Cs+) indicated the
multicomponent character of a protein emission spectrum. It was
demonstrated that the spectra of proteins, which are shifted upon
quenching, possess 
values exceeding those of "elementary"
components. The analysis of the differences between initial spectra of
such proteins and those after 20% quenching revealed that the
best-quenched components have the longest-wavelength position at ~340
nm in native proteins, which is ~10 nm shorter than that postulated
in the two-state model. However, the tryptophans in proteins denatured
by urea or guanidinium chloride have a spectrum with
m of ~350 nm. These results allowed us to
develop an extended model of discrete states (classes) of tryptophan
residues in proteins, which assumed the existence of five statistically
most probable classes (Burstein et al., 1973
; Burstein, 1977a
, 1983
).
According to the model, the following discrete classes of tryptophan
residues were predicted to be most probable in proteins (Burstein,
1977b
, 1983
):
| 1. | Class A ( m = 308 nm, structured spectra); the fluorophores, which do not form hydrogen-bound complexes in the excited state (exciplexes) (Hershberger et al., 1981 |
| 2. | Class S ( m = 316 nm, structured spectra) includes the buried tryptophan residues that can form the exciplexes with 1:1 stoichiometry;
|
| 3. | Class I ( m = 330-332 nm, ![]() = 48-50 nm) represents the buried fluorophores that can form the exciplexes with 2:1 stoichiometry;
|
| 4. | Class II ( m = 340-342 nm, ![]() = 53-55 nm) represents the fluorophores exposed to the bound water possessing very long dipole relaxation time, which precludes completing the relaxation-induced spectral shift during the excited-state lifetime;
|
| 5. | Class III ( m = 350-353 nm, ![]() = 59-61 nm) contains rather fully exposed fluorophores surrounded by highly mobile water completely relaxing during the excitation lifetime, which makes their spectra almost coinciding with those of free aqueous tryptophan.
|
At that time, there was constructed and used the calibrated
diagram 
versus
m for estimating the
contributions of three most frequent model classes (I, II, and III) of
tryptophan residues in the fluorescence spectrum of a protein (Burstein
et al., 1973
). The application of this hypothesis was rather effective
in the interpretation of protein tryptophan fluorescence data in
various biophysical and molecular-biology studies. However, the idea of the existing of discrete classes of tryptophans in proteins was based
on the analysis of very limited numbers of proteins. Now it seems
reasonable to reappraise the hypothesis of discrete states applying
more recent analytic and computing methods to the wide statistical
database of protein spectra.
Such a reappraisal is possible now due to progress in protein
preparation techniques and methods of component analysis of protein
emission spectra. It was shown that the fluorescence spectra of
tryptophan and its derivatives may be accurately described analytically
by a log-normal function (Burstein, 1976
), proposed initially for the
absorption spectra by Siano and Metzler (1969)
. Thereupon, it was found
that the shape of the emission spectra of tryptophan both in solutions
and in a protein depends only on the spectral maximum position
m in a known manner (Burstein and Emelyanenko,
1996
). This fact allowed us to develop effective algorithms of reliable
decomposition of tryptophan fluorescence spectra of proteins into
individual "elementary" log-normal components (Abornev and
Burstein, 1992
; Burstein et al., 2001
).
Here we present the results of such decomposition of tryptophan emission spectra of >100 different proteins, some in various structural states (native and denatured, in complexes with ions or organic ligands, in various pH-induced conformations, etc.). The database of obtained log-normal components allowed us to check the hypothesis of the discrete classes of tryptophan residues on the basis of a representative set of proteins. Analysis of the histograms of occurrence of spectral components with various maximum positions confirmed the statistical discreteness of several states of emitting tryptophan fluorophores in proteins. The discrete classes observed here are similar to those proposed in the model of discrete states in 1973-1977.
| |
MATERIALS AND METHODS |
|---|
|
|
|---|
Fluorescence spectra
The large majority of protein fluorescence spectra used in this
work and listed in Table 1 were taken
from the archive of experimental data of the Laboratory of Functional
Biophysics of Proteins (Institute of Theoretical and Experimental
Biophysics of the Russia Academy of Sciences). The spectra have been
published and/or analyzed in various special publications cited in the
column "References." These publications also contain the data about
protein preparations and techniques of fluorescence measurements. If
the spectra were measured elsewhere and given to us, they were
recorrected for instrument spectral sensitivity curves using the
emission spectra of aqueous tryptophan solution as a standard. Such a
recorrection was necessary because the component analysis algorithms
were developed based on the model spectra measured with our lab-made
instrument (Burstein et al., 1973
; Bukolova-Orlova et al., 1974
) with a
carefully estimated spectral sensitivity curve (Burstein and
Emelyanenko, 1996
).
The preparations of wheat germ agglutinin, inorganic pyrophosphatase
(pyrophosphate phosphohydrolase) from baker's yeast, monellin from
Dioscoreophyllum cummensii fruits, Escherichia
coli alkaline phosphatase, and subtilisin BPN' produced by
Sigma (St. Louis, MO) were kindly given to us by Dr. J. Borejdo
(University of North Texas Health Science Center, Fort Worth, TX).
Human and bovine carbonic anhydrases II, staphylococcal serine
protease, and subtilisin Carlsberg (Sigma) were a kind gift from Dr.
S. S. Lehrer (Boston Biomedical Research Institute, Boston, MA). The preparation of bovine carboxypeptidase A was from Reanal (Hungary). The yeast 3-phosphoglycerate kinase was from Sigma. Porcine pancreatic lipase was from Serva. Hen egg white ovalbumin was from Reakhim (Olaine, Latvia). Actin from dog heart was prepared by one of us (Ya.
K. R.) according to Pardee and Spudich (1982)
.
Fluorescence measurements
Fluorescence spectra of the several proteins marked in Table 1 (in the "References" column) as "Present work" were measured by us during the last six years. Acrylamide, KCl, KI, CsCl, Tris, and ATP preparations used in these experiments were ultra-pure grade of Russian or Soviet production or Sigma.
Steady-state emission spectra were recorded on the lab-made
spectrofluorimeter (Burstein et al., 1973
; Bukolova-Orlova et al.,
1974
) with collection of emitted light from the cell front face, that
allowed application of the strict correction function for screening and
reabsorption inner filter effects (Burstein, 1968
). The fluorescence
was excited with the mercury
|
Analysis and representation of spectral data
The decomposition of tryptophan fluorescence spectra of proteins
into log-normal components was performed for sets of spectra measured
at varying concentrations of quenchers using two algorithms: SIMS
(SImple fitting with Mean-Square
criterion) (Abornev and Burstein, 1992
; Burstein et al., 2001
) and
PHREQ (PHase-plot-based REsolving with
Quenchers, for two-component decomposition) (Burstein et
al., 2001
). For the decomposition of a single spectrum (without
quenchers) the modified SIMS algorithm was applied (Burstein et al.,
2001
). Using SIMS, the spectra were independently fitted by one, two,
or three components. The criterion of attaining the solution (a minimal sufficient number of components describing the spectra) was the minimal
root-mean-square differences (residuals) between theoretical and
experimental spectra multiplied by the number of parameters under
fitting. For several proteins two solutions with different numbers of
components, which had the similar values of this criterion, were
selected as the best ones.
The fact that the components of composite tryptophan emission spectra
of proteins are wide (~30-60 nm at half-maximal level) compared with
the differences between the values of their maximum positions (from 5 to ~50 nm), might considerably reduce the reliability of
decomposition. Therefore, we present in Table
2 the averaged results (values of the
maximum position,
m(i) and the
contribution into the area under spectrum, S(i)
and the standard deviations of averaging) obtained separately with the
mathematically different algorithms: PHREQ and SIMS. The good agreement
between the parameters that were obtained with these two methods
demonstrate the reliability of a result. We can note that for the
absolute majority of proteins the results obtained with these two
methods differ less than by errors of means. It allowed us to present
unified results of the component analysis for individual proteins
independent of the decomposition method.
Moreover, the majority of protein spectra were measured in the presence of various quenchers, in most cases more than once, using preparations from different sources or varying solvent conditions. To extract unified values of the parameters for any given protein or its conformer, two averaging schemes were applied to the sets of decomposition results: "Averaging" and "Mean Best Fit" (Table 2). According to the first scheme, the parameters of components were calculated as averages of all solutions obtained for all individual experiments, independent of the quality of the decomposition. Within the second scheme, only the data obtained with minimal values of the decomposition functional for each experiment were averaged.
| |
RESULTS |
|---|
|
|
|---|
In Table 2 we present the results of decomposition of tryptophan
fluorescence spectra of >100 different proteins, some in various
structural states (native and denatured, in complexes with ions or
organic ligands, and in various pH-induced states), obtained by the
above-mentioned algorithms, SIMS and PHREQ, and different averaging
schemes of the obtained solutions, averaging and mean best fit. The
SIMS algorithm was used to the log-normal decomposition of 163 sets of
tryptophan emission spectra. The PHREQ algorithm was applied to the 105 sets of fluorescence spectra because the other 58 spectra of proteins
were measured without quenchers, and only the modified SIMS algorithm
could be applied to decompose them. The results obtained with both SIMS
and PHREQ methods for absolute majority of proteins differ less than
errors of means presented in the
m(i) and S(i)
columns. It allows presenting the unified results of the component
analysis independent of the decomposition method. Besides the results
of log-normal component analysis, Table 2 contains the maximum position
values of whole, non-decomposed fluorescence spectra of proteins
("
m total," the third column). The
denatured proteins are italicized in the tables.
The database of log-normal components of protein tryptophan
fluorescence spectra shown in Table 2 may be regarded as a generalized representative database of fluorescence spectra of individual tryptophan residues in proteins. It allowed us to perform statistical testing of the hypothesis of discrete states, i.e., the existence of
the set of several classes of tryptophan residues in proteins discretely differing in their fluorescence spectral maximum positions, which was put forward as early as 1973-1977 (Burstein et al., 1973
;
Burstein, 1977a
, b
, 1983
). Such a test is performed here by
constructing and analyzing the histograms of occurrence of log-normal
components presented in the database of Table 2.
Before examining histograms of occurrence of individual log-normal
components, it seems reasonable to consider how randomly are
distributed spectral maximum positions of whole, non-decomposed emission spectra of proteins of our database. The histograms of occurrence of
m values of whole spectra are
shown in Fig. 1, A and
B for native and denatured proteins, respectively,
constructed using the "
m total" values
from Table 2. It is seen that the histogram of
m for native proteins is rather well fitted by
normal distribution with the peak at 336.7 ± 0.4 nm and
= 6.0 ± 0.9 nm, which is a good confirmation of random character
of the excerpt of native proteins. A worse fitting by the normal
distribution was obtained for the maximum positions of fluorescence
spectra of denatured proteins (the peak at 346.5 ± 0.6 nm;
= 4.1 ± 1.3 nm); however, it is expected due to the
small number of proteins and, mainly, due to essentially different
structural features of protein states formed under various denaturing
effectors used (urea, dioxane, extreme pH, etc.).
|
The canonical histograms of occurrence of maximum position values of
log-normal components (with the 2-nm steps) of emission spectra of
native proteins are presented in Fig. 2.
Panels A and B represent the distributions
m(i)
obtained with two decomposition algorithms, SIMS (375 components)
and PHREQ (249 components), respectively. Panels C and
D reflect the results obtained using two schemes of
averaging ("Average" and "Mean Best Fit" in Table 2),
respectively. All four histograms have the well-expressed deep minimum
at 335-337 nm as a common feature. This feature seems to clearly
demonstrate the existence of a statistical discreteness of at least two
large spectral classes of tryptophan residues in native proteins.
Moreover, panels A-D demonstrate reproducible dips at
329 ± 1 and 347 ± 1 nm, which may also mark the frontiers between overlapping discrete classes of tryptophans in
proteins.
|
|
However, the canonical form of histogram, constructed from columns,
cannot reflect the accuracy of calculated maximum position values and
of relative contributions of components in the whole emission spectrum.
Therefore, we constructed a new kind of histogram accounting for these
factors (Figs. 3-5). In such histograms,
each element (the individual ith spectral component) is
represented by the little Gauss distribution
y(
m(i)) with maximum at
m(i),
(i) equal to
the standard (root-mean-square one) error of the mean
m(i) value (see Table 2), and the
maximal amplitude of Gauss curves proportional to the relative
contribution S(i) of the ith component
to the total protein emission. Such a histogram is a sum of these
elements:
|
(i) is a multiplier equal to 1 if only one
decomposition result is selected for a protein spectrum, or to 0.5 in
the cases when two solutions with similar functional values are taken.
|
In such a representation, the histograms of Fig. 2 acquire the view
seen in Fig. 3 (curves N). In this case, the S(i)
values are taken to be 1, and
= 1.0 for every spectral
component. One can see that the main features of the canonical
histograms are retained in the new, Gauss-curve-based representation.
Besides the histograms for components of spectra of native proteins,
Fig. 3 also contains the curves obtained for proteins denatured under various influences (see Table 2). The shorter-wavelength "continua" reflect the fact that denaturation is not completed in some cases and
the emission spectra possess components belonging to the retained populations of native and/or partly unfolded molecules. However, the
highest peak at ~350 nm and peaks or shoulders at 340-347 nm are due
to the components belonging to tryptophans in proteins denatured by
urea or guanidinium chloride and by dioxane, pH and other less
unfolding denaturing factors. It is interesting that the histograms for
denatured proteins also have the minima at 335-340 nm, which position
coincides with the deep minima of histograms for native proteins.
We constructed two more Gauss-curve-based histograms with values
of
(i) and S(i) varying according
to the calculation data for native (N) and denatured (D) proteins. The
histograms accounting only for the differences in contributions of
individual components in whole spectra are presented in Fig.
4 (
(i) = 1.0 nm;
S(i) = var). The resulting reduction
in contributions of "small" components (S(i) < 0.01) in the histogram essentially
improved the resolution of individual peaks in it. The "small"
components may not only have worse determined
m values, but also may be erroneous in principle in the cases of bad quality of a spectrum under
decomposition. The fact that the improved resolution of peaks in such
histograms at ~326, 331, 345, and 350 nm allowed us to assume that
they reflect the existence of discrete classes of tryptophan emitters
in native proteins. The reduction of contributions of minor components
essentially decreased the relative amplitude of a shorter-wavelength
wing in the denatured-proteins' histogram. The remaining
shorter-wavelength peaks (instead of a "continuum") roughly
correspond to the peaks in the native-proteins' histogram. However,
the 350-nm peak and the shoulder at 340-347 nm became much
better-expressed.
|
To demonstrate that the resolution of peaks obtained in previous
histograms (and, thus, the observed spectral discrete classes) are
beyond the error of the estimation of the maximum position of spectral
components, we constructed the histograms (Fig.
5) accounting for the precision of
m(i) estimation (
(i)
= var) and the relative contributions of components
(S(i) = var). These histograms
demonstrate the presence of discreteness of emission of tryptophan
residues in proteins in the same manner as Figs. 3 and 4. There are
seen the global minimum at ~337 nm and four maxima at ~326, 333, 344, and 350 nm for native proteins. The PHREQ algorithm well-resolves
only two classes, because it was applied only to the limited number of
protein spectra, possessing one or two components. For denatured
proteins, accounting for
(i) made peaks even more
expressive. The main maxima for denatured proteins are at ~346 and
350 nm; however, the peak at ~334 nm also exists.
|
| |
DISCUSSION |
|---|
|
|
|---|
In 1973-1977 Burstein and co-workers postulated the
hypothesis of the existence of discrete classes of tryptophan residues in proteins (Burstein et al., 1973
; Burstein, 1977a
, 1983
). Later, algorithms of stable and reliable decomposition of composite tryptophan fluorescence spectra into log-normal components were developed (Abornev
and Burstein, 1992
; Burstein and Emelyanenko, 1996
; Burstein et al.,
2001
) that allowed us to verify and revise the hypothesis. Here, we
used mathematically different algorithms of decomposition of emission
spectra to examine the stability of solutions. The fitting algorithm
(SIMS) and the analytical ones (PHREQ) gave, in general, very similar
results: obtained maximum positions
m(i) differed within an error of
±2.8 nm, and contributions S(i) of components
differed within the range of ±8.6%.
First of all, we showed that the distribution of maximum positions of
total, nondecomposed spectra ("
m total" in
Table 2) for native proteins is rather well-fitted by a Gauss equation with the maximum at ~337 nm and dispersion of ~12 nm (Fig. 1
A), which demonstrated the randomness and, thus,
representativeness of the set of the proteins under study. Then, we
analyzed the distributions of the maximum position of log-normal
components taking into consideration the experimental deviations of
maximum position and the contributions of components to spectra of
native and denatured proteins (Figs. 2-5). All obtained data confirmed the existence of several statistically discrete classes of emitting tryptophan fluorophores in proteins. The discrete classes observed here
are in approximate agreement with those proposed in 1973-1977 in the
model of discrete states. A very important point is that there was no a
priori assumption about the discreteness in any algorithm used
for component analysis of fluorescence spectra (Burstein et al., 2001
).
It is evident that to find the causes for so widely differing and
discrete Stokes shifts in the emission spectra of tryptophan fluorophores in proteins one has to look in a variety of combinations of interactions of individual fluorophores with their environment, occurring mainly during the lifetime of the fluorescent excited state. The physical causes for the differences among the
spectroscopic classes can be analyzed in terms of various combinations
of Bakhsiev's theory of specific and universal interactions of the
excited fluorophores with their environment (Bakhshiev, 1972
). Both
kinds of interactions are induced by essential redistribution of
electronic density on the atoms and chemical bonds of fluorophore after
its electronic excitation. The specific interactions include changes in
the nearest range interactions with neighboring groups and/or solvent
molecules, i.e., resolvation, hydrogen bond formation, or other
noncovalent complexing (Bakhshiev, 1972
; Mataga et al., 1955
). The
universal interactions occur due to the dipole relaxation of
surrounding dielectric continuum in response to the changes in
direction and magnitude of fluorophore dipole moment at the excitation
(Bakhshiev, 1972
; Bilot and Kawski, 1962
; Lippert, 1957
; Liptay, 1965
;.
Mataga et al., 1956
).
The formation of stoichiometric complexes (most probably
hydrogen-bonded ones) of excited indole fluorophore with alcohols was
demonstrated experimentally (Walker et al., 1967
; Lumry and Hershberger, 1978
; Hershberger et al., 1981
). Such complexes with alcohols in apolar cycloheptane had discrete positions of fluorescence spectral maxima dependent on the stoichiometric ratios of
alcohol/fluorophore: the maximum was at 316 nm for the 1:1 ratio and at
~330 nm at the 2:1 ratio compared with the central peak at 307 nm in
the structured spectrum obtained in the absence of any polar
co-solvents. The authors interpreted these excited-state complexes
(exciplexes) as a result of H-
-bonding of alcohol hydroxyls with
indolic N- and C
-atoms as those possessing maximal electronic
density in the excited state. Such a location of H-bonds may be revised
in the light of recent quantum-mechanical calculations of electronic density distribution in the excited indole and tryptophan fluorophores, which revealed that maximal densities are located at the C
3, C
2,
and C
2 atoms in the main fluorescent
1La state of the indolic
ring (Callis, 1997
).
In proteins, the structured fluorescence bands coinciding with those of
nonexciplexed indole fluorophores occur in azurin (Burstein et al.,
1977
) and in bacteriorhodopsin purple membranes suspended in 2 M CsCl
(Permyakov and Shnyrov, 1983
). Such tryptophan residues were attributed
to class A in the hypothesis of discrete states. The structured
spectra similar to those of the exciplexes 1:1 occurring in several
single-tryptophan-containing proteins were assigned to class S
(Burstein, 1977a
, b
, 1983
). Emission spectra of classes A and S do not
undergo any spectral shift under freezing the protein solutions down to
196°C, i.e., the dipole moments of these fluorophores practically
do not change at the excitation. In the histograms obtained in this
work, classes A and S are reflected by peaks and/or shoulders at
305-308 and 316-318 nm, respectively (see Figs. 3-5).
In the model experiments (Walker et al., 1967
; Lumry and Hershberger,
1978
; Hershberger et al., 1981
), the maximum position of the exciplex
2:1 spectrum was not constant under increasing alcohol concentration,
which reflected the rise of Stokes shift induced by the solvent dipole
relaxation in response to the change of fluorophore dipole moment in
the excited state of the exciplex. Therefore, the florescence of
protein tryptophan residues possessing the spectra with maxima at
~330 nm and longer were assigned to the emission of exciplexes with
stoichiometry not <2:1 in the model of discrete classes (Burstein,
1977a
, b
, 1983
). The model provided three discrete classes (I-III) for
such exciplexes with stoichiometry
2:1, differed in their
accessibility to extrinsic quenchers (vanishing accessibility for class
I,
m at ~330 nm, and the accessibility of
>30% of that of free tryptophan for classes II and III). The
difference between two accessible classes was assumedly interpreted as
a result of different dipole relaxation rates in their environments.
The histograms (Figs. 3-5) contain peaks reflecting all three discrete
classes. However, the class I band in the histograms splits up into two
peaks, at ~325 and 332 nm. Almost all histograms contain the global
minimum at 336-337 nm and two evident maxima at 344-345 and 349-351
nm, which correspond to the emission of exposed tryptophan residues of
classes II and III, respectively. In the model of discrete classes, it
was suggested that exposed tryptophan residues in native proteins
should emit at 340-342 nm, and emission at 350-353 nm is due to
tryptophan residues of denatured proteins (Burstein et al., 1973
).
However, the extended set of proteins investigated here indicates that
tryptophans in native proteins also can have spectra with maxima at
~350 nm.
Tryptophan residues of denatured proteins (italicized in Tables 1 and
2) have the main peak positions at 340-345 and 351 nm. The
longest-wavelength peak corresponds to the completely unfolded proteins
in urea or guanidinium chloride solutions. However, the peak at
340-345 nm belongs mainly to the fluorophores in proteins denatured by
extreme pH values (e.g., pepsin at pH 6-9; see Table 2) or high
dioxane concentrations (chymotrypsin, chymotrypsinogen, and trypsin;
see Table 2). It is possible that such maximum positions of
fluorescence spectra are characteristic of tryptophan residues in such
intermediate unfolding states of proteins as molten globule (Ptitsyn,
1995
). The shorter-wavelength peaks (
m < 337 nm) in histograms for denatured proteins belong, most probably, to the fluorophores in molecules retained native or partly unfolded in denaturing conditions.
The model of discrete states reflects the existence in proteins of the five most manifested classes of tryptophan residues. The discreteness of fluorescence parameters has to have a probabilistic nature. The histograms obtained in this work reflected all these classes and can be regarded as a statistical confirmation of the hypothesis of discrete classes of tryptophan residues in proteins. It could be assumed that such a situation might be realized because tryptophan residues are located in a few kinds of physically preferred environments in protein structures that provide realization of different combinations of specific and universal interactions of excited fluorophore with its environment.
There were a lot of papers published during the last several last years
where it was demonstrated that tryptophan residues could have various
fluorescence parameters depending on their environment in proteins
(Callis, 1997
; Callis and Burgess, 1997
; Reshetnyak and Burstein,
1997a
, b
; Chen and Barkley, 1998
; Kuznetsova and Turoverov, 1998
;
Meagher et al., 1998
). Because highly resolved x-ray and NMR structures
of many proteins are now available, we developed a system of describing
physical and structural characteristics of the microenvironment of
tryptophan residues and examined the existence of discreteness of
structural parameters of the microenvironment of tryptophan residues in
proteins. Moreover, that work allowed us to elucidate the main physical
and structural factors determining the class of an individual
tryptophan residue. The next paper of this series contains the results
of that study.
| |
ACKNOWLEDGMENTS |
|---|
The authors are thankful to all colleagues from the Laboratory of Protein Functional Biophysics of the Institute of Theoretical and Experimental Biophysics (Pushchino) for everyday help and discussions. We thank Drs. K. K. Turoverov and R. V. Polozov for fruitful discussions. We are especially grateful to Drs. V. M. Grishchenko, L. P. Kalinichenko, and T. G. Orlova for the help in experimental work and to Drs. D. B. Veprintsev and D. S. Rykunov for valuable consultations and maintaining the function of the computers and nets. We are much obliged to all colleagues who placed protein preparations and/or fluorescence spectra at our disposal.
This work was supported in part by Grants 95-04-12935, 97-04-49449, and 00-04-48127 from the Russia Foundation of Basic Research.
| |
FOOTNOTES |
|---|
Received for publication 12 January 2001 and in final form 7 June 2001.
Address reprint requests to (present address) Dr. Yana K. Reshetnyak, Department of Molecular Biology and Immunology, Institute for Cancer Research, University of North Texas Health Science Center, 3500 Camp Bowie Blvd., Fort Worth, TX 76107. Tel.: 817-735-5417; Fax: 817-735-2133; E-mail: yreshetn{at}hsc.unt.edu.
| |
REFERENCES |
|---|
|
|
|---|
-lactalbumin AB under various physico-chemical conditions. I. Influences of pH and binding of sodium dodecyl sulfate.
Molecular Biology (Moscow).
7:753-759
-lactalbumin AB under various physico-chemical conditions. II. Denaturation by urea and various organic solvents.
Molecular Biology (Moscow).
9:795-804
G-globulin under dissociation on peptides.
Molecular Biology (Moscow).
2:587-593
Biophys J, September 2001, p. 1710-1734, Vol. 81, No. 3
© 2001 by the Biophysical Society 0006-3495/01/09/1710/25 $2.00
This article has been cited by other articles:
![]() |
G. Maglia, A. Jonckheer, M. De Maeyer, J.-M. Frere, and Y. Engelborghs An unusual red-edge excitation and time-dependent Stokes shift in the single tryptophan mutant protein DD-carboxypeptidase from Streptomyces: The role of dynamics and tryptophan rotamers Protein Sci., February 1, 2008; 17(2): 352 - 361. [Abstract] [Full Text] [PDF] |
||||
![]() |
M. Milescu, J. Vobecky, S. H. Roh, S. H. Kim, H. J. Jung, J. I. Kim, and K. J. Swartz Tarantula Toxins Interact with Voltage Sensors within Lipid Membranes J. Gen. Physiol., October 29, 2007; 130(5): 497 - 511. [Abstract] [Full Text] [PDF] |
||||
![]() |
Y. K. Reshetnyak, M. Segala, O. A. Andreev, and D. M. Engelman A Monomeric Membrane Peptide that Lives in Three Worlds: In Solution, Attached to, and Inserted across Lipid Bilayers Biophys. J., October 1, 2007; 93(7): 2363 - 2372. [Abstract] [Full Text] [PDF] |
||||
![]() |
J.-T. Su, S.-H. Kim, and Y.-B. Yan Dissecting the Pretransitional Conformational Changes in Aminoacylase I Thermal Denaturation Biophys. J., January 15, 2007; 92(2): 578 - 587. [Abstract] [Full Text] [PDF] |
||||
![]() |
C. Duy and J. Fitter How Aggregation and Conformational Scrambling of Unfolded States Govern Fluorescence Emission Spectra Biophys. J., May 15, 2006; 90(10): 3704 - 3711. [Abstract] [Full Text] [PDF] |
||||
![]() |
H.-W. He, J. Zhang, H.-M. Zhou, and Y.-B. Yan Conformational Change in the C-Terminal Domain Is Responsible for the Initiation of Creatine Kinase Thermal Aggregation Biophys. J., October 1, 2005; 89(4): 2650 - 2658. [Abstract] [Full Text] [PDF] |
||||
![]() |
D. Linke, J. Frank, M. S. Pope, J. Soll, I. Ilkavets, P. Fromme, E. A. Burstein, Y. K. Reshetnyak, and V. I. Emelyanenko Folding Kinetics and Structure of OEP16 Biophys. J., March 1, 2004; 86(3): 1479 - 1487. [Abstract] [Full Text] [PDF] |
||||
![]() |
S. L. Grage, J. Wang, T. A. Cross, and A. S. Ulrich Solid-State 19F-NMR Analysis of 19F-Labeled Tryptophan in Gramicidin A in Oriented Membranes Biophys. J., December 1, 2002; 83(6): 3336 - 3350. [Abstract] [Full Text] [PDF] |
||||
| ||||||