| HOME | HELP | FEEDBACK | SUBSCRIPTIONS | ARCHIVE | SEARCH | TABLE OF CONTENTS |
Biophys J, February 2002, p. 762-771, Vol. 82, No. 2
and
*Shemyakin-Ovchinnikov Institute of Bioorganic Chemistry, Russian
Academy of Sciences, 117997 Moscow, Russia, and
Leiden Institute of Chemistry, Gorlaeus Laboratories,
Leiden University, 2300 RA, Leiden, The Netherlands
| |
ABSTRACT |
|---|
|
|
|---|
Zervamicin IIB is a 16-amino acid peptaibol that forms
voltage-dependent ion channels with multilevel conductance states in planar lipid bilayers and vesicular systems. The spatial structure of
zervamicin IIB bound to dodecylphosphocholine micelles was studied by
nuclear magnetic resonance spectroscopy. The set of 20 structures
obtained has a bent helical conformation with a mean backbone root mean
square deviation value of ~0.2 Å and resembles the structure in
isotropic solvents (Balashova et al., 2000
. NMR structure of the
channel-former zervamicin IIB in isotropic solvents. FEBS
Lett 466:333-336). The N-terminus represents an
-helix, whereas the C-terminal part has a mixed
310/
R hydrogen-bond pattern. In the
anisotropic micelle environment, the bending angle on Hyp10 (23°) is
smaller than that (47°) in isotropic solvents. In the NOESY
(Nuclear Overhauser Effect Spectroscopy) spectra, the characteristic attenuation of the peptide signals by 5- and 16-doxylstearate relaxation probes indicates a peripheral mode of the peptaibol binding
to the micelle with the N-terminus immersed slightly
deeper into micelle interior. Analysis of the surface hydrophobicity reveals that the zervamicin IIB helix is amphiphilic and well suited to
formation of a tetrameric transmembrane bundle, according to the
barrel-stave mechanism. The results are discussed in a context of
voltage-driven peptaibol insertion into membrane.
| |
INTRODUCTION |
|---|
|
|
|---|
Peptide antibiotics forming amphiphilic helices
in the presence of lipid bilayers play an important role in defense
systems of various organisms. There is a variety of subtypes of such
antibiotics produced by fungi, insects, amphibia, and mammalians. The
mechanism of action of these agents remains unclear, although studies
of their activity on model systems suggest that the peptides interact with the membrane of the target cell. The antibiotic property is
thought to be related to the increased ion permeability of the membrane
(Bechinger, 1999
; Epand and Vogel, 1999
). With the expansion of
pathogenic organisms resistant to conventional antibiotics, the
pharmacological application of antimicrobial peptides attracts steadily
increasing interest (Gabay, 1994
).
The object of our study zervamicin-IIB (Zrv-IIB) is a member of the
antibiotic peptaibol-family. Peptaibols are small (7-24 amino acids)
peptides of fungal origin, which contain a high proportion of
helix-promoting
,
-dialkylated amino acids (Aib,
-aminoisobutyric acid; Iva, D-isovaline), an acetylated
N-terminus and a C-terminal
-amino alcohol
(Sansom, 1991
). Zrv-IIB and several other highly homologous zervamicins
were isolated from cultures of Emericellopsis salmosynnemata
(Argoudelis et al., 1974
). Zervamicins consist of 16 amino acid
residues. The sequence of Zrv-IIB is:
AcTrp-Ile-Gln-Iva-Ile5-Thr-Aib-Leu-Aib-Hyp10-Gln-Aib-Hyp-Aib-Pro-Phl16 (Hyp, 4-hydroxyproline; Phl, L-phenylalaninol).
In zervamicins the characteristic
Gly11-x-x-Pro14 motif of
the alamethicin-peptaibol subfamily is replaced by
Aib7-x-x-Hyp10 (Sansom,
1991
).
Zrv-IIB is active against Gram-positive bacteria, less active against
Gram-negative bacteria, and nontoxic for eukaryotic cells (Argoudelis
et al., 1974
; Argoudelis and Johnson, 1975
). In planar lipid bilayers
(Balaram et al., 1992
) and vesicular systems (Kropacheva and Raap,
1999
), Zrv-IIB forms voltage-dependent ion channels with multilevel
conductance states. The current-voltage relationships for Zrv-IIB are
very asymmetric. The peptide forms channels in the presence of
cis-positive potentials only (cis denotes the
side of bilayer to which the peptide was added), although at high
peptide concentrations, it demonstrates potential-independent behavior
(Kropacheva and Raap, 1999
).
The conventional model for voltage-gated peptaibol action (the
so-called barrel-stave (BS) model) (Baumann and Mueller, 1974
; Sansom,
1991
) involves the formation of an electrolyte-filled pore by a bundle
of parallel helices. It is generally thought that different conductance
levels correspond to different helix bundles. The transitions between
levels occur only in a sequential manner by the release or uptake of
the monomers from the conducting aggregate. It is worth noting that the
BS model is generally accepted to describe naturally occurring ion
channels (Marsh, 1996
) and, hence, peptaibols can be considered more
realistic models of the voltage-gated channels than gramicidin and
other channel-forming peptides (Sansom, 1998
).
The BS model corresponds well to the experimental data on multistates'
conductance levels and voltage-current asymmetry, but the mechanism of
the peptaibol voltage-gating remains unclear. The models for
voltage-gated peptaibol channels, initially proposed for alamethicin,
involve either voltage-driven conformational changes in the
transmembrane bundle of the petaibol molecules (bending around
Pro14 (Fox and Richards, 1982
), or around the
residues Aib10, Gly11,
Leu12 (Franklin et al., 1994
; Yee et al., 1995
))
or voltage-driven insertion into the membrane of molecular helical dipoles.
The relatively small size of antimicrobial peptides make them ideal
objects for nuclear magnetic resonance (NMR) investigation (Bechinger,
1999
; Epand and Vogel, 1999
). In our previous work (Balashova et al.,
2000
) the spatial structure of Zrv-IIB was determined in isotropic
solvents. It was shown that in solvents of different polarity (ranging
from chloroform/methanol (9:1 v/v) to methanol/water (1:1 v/v)) the
peptide maintains a well defined spatial structure. These results
suggest that the voltage gating of Zrv-IIB is not conditioned by
substantial conformational changes.
The large size of the membrane-peptide system makes it difficult to
determine the spatial structure of a membrane-bound peptide in its
native environment. Therefore, membrane mimetics, such as detergent
micelles, are commonly used in NMR studies of membrane peptides and
proteins (Opella et al., 1994
; Henry and Sykes, 1994
; Pervushin and
Arseniev, 1995
). Although the micelles do not exactly reproduce the
membrane environment (they possess a highly curved surface in contrast
to flat bilayers), in some cases they are able to maintain the spatial
structure and functionality of transmembrane (TM) peptides and proteins
(Pervushin and Arseniev, 1995
; Vinogradova et al., 1998
).
Here we report the spatial structure of Zrv-IIB incorporated into dodecylphosphocholine (DPC) micelles. Using lipid-soluble paramagnetic spin labels, we show that the peptide is bound to the micelle surface and oriented approximately parallel to it. Comparison with the previous study shows that the spatial structure of Zrv-IIB changes only slightly upon transition from isotropic solvents of different polarity to the heterogeneous micellar environment. These results provide further evidence for the insertion model of voltage gating.
| |
MATERIALS AND METHODS |
|---|
|
|
|---|
Sample preparation
Zrv-IIB was isolated and purified according to the previously
described protocol (Balashova et al., 2000
). Nondeuterated DPC and its
perdeuterated analog (98% deuterium) were purchased from Avanti Polar
Lipids (Alabaster, AL). The 5- and 16-doxylstearates are products of
Sigma (St. Louis, MO). D2O (99.9% deuterium) was purchased from Isotope (Moscow, Russia).
The sample containing Zrv-IIB in micellar solution was prepared as follows. A mixture of dry DPC (16.6 mg) and dry Zrv-IIB (2 mg) was dissolved in 0.5 ml of a 1:1 mixture of 2,2,2-trifluoroethyl alcohol/chloroform. The obtained solution was evaporated in vacuum and dissolved in 0.5 ml D2O. After that, the sample was sonicated and lyophilized. The solid residual was again dissolved in 0.5 ml D2O and lyophilized. The last operation was repeated twice. Finally, the sample was dissolved in 0.6 ml H2O (10% D2O) and used in the NMR experiments. The resulting concentration of Zrv-IIB was 1.8 mM and the peptide/detergent ratio was 1:40. Unless otherwise stated, the pH of the sample was 6.8-7.0. The 5- and 16-doxylstearates were added as a solution in methanol-d4. The molar ratio of detergent to spin-label was 63:1. The maximal amount of deuterated methanol in the sample was 3 µl and the pH was controlled before and after addition of the spin probe. To measure the deuterium exchange rates of amide protons, the sample was lyophilized and dissolved in D2O, pH 4.8 (direct pH-meter readings). The sample for diffusion measurements of DPC micelles was prepared by dissolving 16.6 mg of nondeuterated DPC in 0.6 ml H2O (10% D2O).
NMR spectroscopy, data processing, and spectral assignment
All NMR experiments were performed on a Varian Unity-600
spectrometer (Varian, Palo Alto, CA). DQF-COSY (Rance et al., 1983
), TOCSY (Bax and Davis, 1985
) with mixing times
(
m) of 70 ms, and NOESY (Jeener et al., 1979
)
with
m values of 50, 100, and 200 ms were
recorded in the pure phase-absorption mode by collecting hypercomplex
data (States et al., 1982
). The Watergate (Piotto et al., 1992
) and
Flip-back (Lippens et al., 1995
) techniques were used to suppress
strong solvent resonance. A relaxation delay of 3.2 s was used.
Unless otherwise stated, all NMR experiments were performed at the
temperature of 30°C. Chemical shifts were measured relative to the
protons of H2O, the chemical shift of the signal
being arbitrarily chosen as 4.75 ppm. For the diffusion measurements, a
slightly modified version of the spin-echo experiment was used
(Dubovskii et al., 2001
). Before the diffusion experiments, the
temperature of the sample was allowed to equilibrate for at least
1 h. The calibration of the gradient unit was performed using the
same method and the set of solvents as in Orekhov et al. (1999)
. Thirty
one-dimensional (1-D) NMR spectra were recorded with the strength of
the encoding/decoding pulse field gradients varied in the range from 0 to ~30 Gs/cm. Delays for the diffusion of 150-350 ms were used. A
relaxation delay of 5 s was used before each scan. The signals of
the well resolved protons in the 1-D spectra were used to process the
diffusion data on Zrv-IIB/DPC complexes or nondeuterated DPC.
Self-diffusion rates and their uncertainties were obtained by the
two-parameter least-squares exponential fit to the signal decays versus
the square of the gradient strength.
To detect amide protons with slow hydrogen deuterium exchange rates, 1-D and 2-D NOESY spectra were recorded in a 4-h repetition cycle starting after dissolution of the Zrv-IIB/DPC sample in D2O, pH 4.8, 30°C. The rates of amide protons exchange on the solvent deuterons were determined by the exponential fitting of the measured peak intensities of the 1-D spectra or in the fingerprint region of the NOESY spectra. Temperature coefficients of the chemical shifts of the amide protons were measured by linear fitting of the chemical shift values determined from the 1-D and 2-D NOESY spectra recorded in the temperature range from 15 to 50°C.
All NMR spectra were processed and quantified using macros within the
VNMR software (Varian). For further analysis 2-D spectra were converted
into the format of the XEASY program (Bartels et al., 1995
). Proton
resonance assignments for L-amino acids were obtained by a
standard procedure (Wuthrich, 1986
); assignment of Aib and Iva residues
was performed simultaneously with the sequential assignment. Crosspeak
intensities were measured using an algorithm of a nonlinear
least-squares approximation for lineshapes of the crosspeak sections in
both directions of the 2-D spectra implemented in the XEASY program.
3JN
coupling constants
were determined with the program INFIT (Szyperski et al., 1992
) from
the NOESY crosspeaks.
3J
coupling constants
were evaluated by the analysis of patterns of
/
crosspeaks in the
DQF-COSY spectrum of the Zrv-IIB/DPC sample in
D2O.
Experimental constraints and spatial structure calculation
The spatial structure calculation was performed using the
simulated annealing/molecular dynamics protocol as implemented in the
DYANA program version 1.5 (Guntert et al., 1997
). Interproton distance
constraints were derived from the crosspeak intensities measured in the
NOESY spectra with
m = 100 ms, where
spin-diffusion effects might be ignored. Meaningful interproton
distance constraints (174) were derived from 536 unambiguously assigned
NOESY crosspeak volumes via a 1/r6 calibration
with the CALIBA function of DYANA.
Stereospecific assignments of
-methylene protons and torsion angle
constraints for
1 angles of amino acids were
obtained by analysis of the local structure in the HABAS function of
DYANA using the available
3J
spin-spin coupling
constants and NOE distance constraints derived from the NOESY spectrum
with
m = 50 ms. Pseudoatom constraints were
used in cases when the stereospecific assignment for prochiral centers
was unknown. The side chains of Zrv-IIB are often mobile, and the
crosspeaks arising from their protons correspond to a set of
conformations. To eliminate unrealistic conformations and to describe
the available conformational space, we did not constrain those protons
nor pseudocenters that were affected by the angles for which we could
not reject their mobility. Application of the procedure (Dementieva et
al., 1999
) gives torsion angle constraints and stereospecific
assignments. Stereospecific assignments of
,
,
-methylene
protons for imino acids (Pro/Hyp) were obtained based on NOESY
crosspeak volumes in spectrum with
m = 50 ms.
Stereospecific assignments of
-methyl groups for Aib residues and
helix handedness in the C-terminus were determined using iterative cycles of structure calculation. On each stage, assignment of
one Aib residue was changed. The analysis of corresponding changes in
the DYANA target function led to the assignment of all eight methyl
groups. The calculations revealed that only a right-handed conformation
is compatible with the experimental data. Based on this information,
eight torsion angle constraints for the
angles were derived from
3JN
spin-spin coupling
constants in HABAS function of the DYANA.
After generation of the set of 50 structures matching the interproton
upper distance and torsion angle constraints, 29 additional lower
distance constraints (3.0 Å), based on the expected crosspeaks (according to the structures obtained) but not present in the NOESY
spectra with
m = 200 ms, were introduced as
described in Jaravine et al. (1997)
.
Ten amide protons which have a half-exchange time to solvent deuterons
>1 h and temperature coefficients of the chemical shifts <6 ppb/°C
were supposed to be involved in hydrogen bonds. The acceptors of
hydrogen bonds were found by the analysis of preliminary structures
(the hydrogen bonds were observed in >30 of 50 calculated structures).
In accordance with geometric criteria for hydrogen bonds (Baker and
Hubbard, 1984
), six distance constraints were used in subsequent
calculation for each hydrogen bond: three upper (3.3, 2.3, 3.5 Å) and
three lower (2.5, 1.8, 2.6 Å) for i + 4
i
hydrogen bonds (
-helix), as well as three upper (3.4, 2.4, 3.5 Å)
and three lower (2.6, 1.9, 2.2 Å) for i + 3
i
hydrogen bonds (310-helix) for d(O,
N), d(O, HN), and d(C,
HN) distances, respectively.
The next generation of 100 structures was calculated with the addition
of hydrogen bonds and lower distance constraints, and the best 20 of
them were selected according to the following criteria: (1) each
structure differs from all others by a root mean square deviation
(rmsd) of the backbone atom coordinates
0.05 Å and (2) a low final
DYANA target function (
0.02 Å2). To prevent
bad sterical contacts, the best 20 DYANA structures were subjected to
the conjugate gradients energy minimization in the program Discover
(Insight II (2.1.0), Biosym Technologies, San Diego, CA) with the
CVFF (consistent valence force field) (Dauber-Osguthorpe et
al., 1988
) and the same distance and torsion angle restraints, as used
on the last stage of the DYANA's protocol. This resulted in a
remarkable decreasing of van der Waals forces and restraint terms in
the total energy, although the rmsd in the set of structures did not
change significantly.
Visual analysis of the structures and figure drawings were performed
using the MOLMOL program (Koradi et al., 1996
). The molecular hydrophobicity potential (MHP) created by peptide atoms in the surface
points of the lowest-energy helical structure of Zrv-IIB was calculated
as described in Efremov and Vergoten (1995)
. The resulting distribution
of the MHP was visualized by means of 2-D isopotential plots of the
and z coordinates, where
is the rotation angle around
the helix axis, and z is the rise distance along the helix axis.
Protein Data Bank and BioMagnetic Resonance Bank accession codes
The chemical shifts of Zrv-IIB in the presence of DPC micelles have been deposited into the BioMagnetic Resonance Bank (accession code 4993). NMR constraints and derived atomic coordinates (20 models) have been deposited into the Protein Data Bank (accession code 1IH9).
| |
RESULTS |
|---|
|
|
|---|
Stoichiometry of the Zrv-IIB/DPC micelle complex
Like many other peptaibols, Zrv-IIB itself is not water-soluble
and, according to our assumption, in the presence of DPC, all peptide
molecules are in the micelle-bound form. We monitored the complex
formation between DPC and Zrv-IIB via diffusion measurements at 30°C
of pure DPC micelles and mixed DPC/Zrv-IIB micelles. Measured diffusion
constants (1.20 ± 0.02 ×10
10
m2/s pure DPC; 1.06 ± 0.02 ×10
10 m2/s Zrv-IIB/DPC
complex) and corresponding hydrodynamic Stokes radii (23.1 ± 0.5 Å; 26.2 ± 0.5 Å) revealed that the size of micelles is slightly
altered by the Zrv-IIB binding. Ultracentrifugation, light scattering
(Lauterwein et al., 1979
), and electronic paramagnetic resonance
(EPR) (Brown et al., 1981
) studies have shown that DPC at
concentrations used in NMR experiments forms uniformly sized micelles
comprised of 50-60 detergent molecules. At the experimental conditions
(70 mM DPC; peptide:detergent ratio 1:40) used here, no evidence was
found for Zrv-IIB aggregation. We estimated the aggregation number for
Zrv-IIB/DPC complex, based on the assumptions that the peptide is
monomeric and evenly distributed between DPC micelles and that the
density of micelle is not changed upon Zrv-IIB binding. This
calculation shows that ~1.6 (± 0.3) peptaibol molecules are bound
per one micelle consisting of ~66 (± 12) molecules of detergent.
NMR assignments
Spin systems of all L-amino acids were identified in
the DQF-COSY and TOCSY spectra. The aromatic spin systems of
Trp1 and Phl16 were
assigned on the basis of the NOE connectivities between aliphatic and
aromatic protons. The assignment of Iva4
resonances was obtained by analysis of the characteristic TOCSY pattern
of the
C
H2-C
H3
fragment in addition to their intraresidue NOESY crosspeaks d
N(i, i).
Then the sequential assignment was carried out using
dNN(i, i + 1),
d
N(i, i + 1),
and d
N(i, i + 1) connectivities (Fig. 1). In most
previous NMR studies of peptaibols, it has proven difficult to obtain
complete assignments for the methyl groups of the Aib residues.
However, in our case this problem was significantly alleviated. Zrv-IIB
contains only four Aib residues with nondegenerated chemical shifts of
amide and methyl protons. Thus, assignment of all eight methyl group
was easily obtained using the NOE
d
N(i, i)
crosspeaks.
|
Qualitative characterization of the Zrv-IIB conformation
A summary of the NMR data obtained for Zrv-IIB in the DPC micelles
solution is shown in Fig. 1. The absence of long range (i-j > 4) contacts and NOE connectivities
d
N(i, i + 2)
and d
N(i, i + 3) distributed along the sequence, argues for a helical conformation of
the molecule. The 3JN
spin-spin coupling constants on the N-terminus are
consistent with this, having the values ~5Hz, which are typical for
right-handed helical conformation. Based on this data, it is difficult
to discriminate between 310- and
-helices on
the N-terminus. However, the
d
N(i, i + 4)
contacts which have never been observed in
310-helices count in favor of the
-helix
(Wuthrich, 1986
).
In addition to L-Leu, L-Gln, and Phl, the
C-terminus of Zrv-IIB contains four Aib and three Pro/Hyp
residues. The values of 3JN
spin-spin coupling
constants for Leu8, Gln11,
and Phl16 exceed 6 Hz, and this part of the
molecule apparently has the conformation of consecutive turns forming a
helix-like structure. The break of sequential connectivities observed
on Hyp10 (Fig. 1) is attributable to helix
bending on Hyp residue; nevertheless, some of the (i,
i + 2) and (i, i + 3) contacts pass
through this region. That led us to conclude that the helix is not
broken on Hyp10. It is well known that the Aib
residue is sterically restricted to adopt the helical conformation
(Karle and Balaram, 1990
), but in contrast to "usual"
L-amino acids, it does not possess chirality and
can be involved in both right- and left-handed structures. Hence,
before the structure calculation we did not exclude the possibility of
a left-handed structure in the C-terminal part of Zrv-IIB.
The single set of signals in the NMR spectra reveals the absence of
cis-trans X-Pro peptide bond isomers. The
trans orientation of the
Aib9-Hyp10,
Aib12-Hyp13, and
Aib14-Pro15 peptide bonds
was established based on the intensive sequential NOE crosspeaks
between C
-CH3 protons of
Aib and C
H2 protons of
the subsequent Pro or Hyp residues.
Slow hydrogen-deuterium exchange rates and small temperature
coefficients of the chemical shifts of the amide protons over the range
of residues from Iva4 to
Phl16 indicate reduced solvent accessibility and
possible participation in hydrogen bonds. Formation of such bonds along
the peptide sequence is consistent with the overall helical structure,
although the slow exchange rate of the amide proton of
Iva4 is quite surprising. There are two possible
explanations for this: (1) the helix begins from bifurcated hydrogen
bond among the NHs of Iva4,
Ile5, and the carbonyl group of
Trp1 or (2) the N-terminal part is
completely
-helical and the carbonyl of the acetic group acts as a
hydrogen-bond acceptor.
Stereospecific assignments of the Aib residues
One of the most difficult problems in the NMR determination of a
peptaibol spatial structure is the stereospecific assignment of the two
chemically equivalent but stereochemically different
-methyl groups
of Aib residues, which are involved in the majority of the structurally
important NOE contacts. The high abundance of Aib residues in peptaibol
sequences makes their assignment critical for structure calculation.
Two proposed methods for such assignment are based on the spatial
nonequivalence of the methyl groups in the right or left handed helical
conformation. The first method uses the values of intraresidual NOE
crosspeaks between the amide proton and the two methyl groups (Esposito
et al., 1987
); in the second method, the up- or low-field shifts of the
resonances of 13C
atoms
are used (Anders et al., 1998
). However, the results of such an
assignment depend completely on the helix handedness, and these methods
fail for Aib-rich segments. In this case, full stereospecific
assignment can be obtained only on preliminary stages of the structure
calculation by using all available data (Anders et al., 2000
).
Although the C-terminus of Zrv-IIB is clearly not "Aib-rich," (it contains only four nonsequential Aib residues), we attempted to assign Aib methyl groups without any assumption about the helix handedness. This was done by means of the iterative structure calculation (see Materials and Methods). It was found that the C-terminus represents a right-handed helix.
Spatial structure of micelle-bound Zrv-IIB
The structure of Zrv-IIB was calculated with the assumption that a
single backbone conformation is consistent with all available experimental data. The correctness of this assumption is confirmed by:
(1) a small number of constraint violations, (2) small rmsd values
(Table 1), and (3) a scatterplot of
and
torsion angles in the obtained set of structures (Fig.
2). The results of the spatial structure
calculation are collected in Table 1. The structure of Zrv-IIB (Fig.
3), represents an amphiphilic helix with
a total length of 26 Å. The helix is bent on
Hyp10, with a bending angle of
~23o. The N-terminal part of the
molecule forms an
-helix stabilized by five i + 4
i-type hydrogen bonds
(Ac:CO···HN:Iva4;
Trp1:CO···HN:Ile5;
Ile2:CO···HN:Thr6;
Gln3:CO···HN:Aib7;
Iva4:CO···HN:Leu8). The
C-terminal half accommodates two hydroxyprolines
(Hyp10 and Hyp13) and one
proline (Pro15) into a helical
-ribbon
stabilized by three hydrogen bonds of the i + 3
i-type
(Thr6:CO···HN:Aib9;
Leu8:CO···HN:Gln11;
Aib9:CO··· HN:Aib12; an
approximate 310-helix with missing hydrogen bonds
at Hyp10 and Hyp13) and two
hydrogen bonds of the i + 4
i-type
(Hyp10:CO···HN: Aib14;
Aib12: CO···HN: Phl16).
|
|
|
To assess in detail the polarity properties of Zrv-IIB, we calculated
the values of MHP on its surface. This potential characterizes the
relative hydrophobicity of different parts of the molecular surface.
The resulting 2-D isopotential contour map MHP (
, z) is
shown in Fig. 4 (top). The map
is a projection of the surface MHP values onto a cylinder with its
z axis corresponding to the helix axis. The rotation angle
is defined around the z axis. Only hydrophobic regions
(which have high MHP values) of the Zrv-IIB surface are displayed. It
is seen that the helix of Zrv-IIB has a pronounced amphiphilic
character. The polar side chains of Gln3,
Thr6, Hyp10, and
Hyp13, along with the small side chains of Aib
residues, form a hydrophilic convex side of the molecule. Additionally,
the polar face is enhanced by the presence of both the side chain of
Gln11 and the exposed carbonyl oxygen of
Aib7, which do not participate in intramolecular
hydrogen bonds. The ends of the helix are also polar because of the NH
and CO groups that are uncompensated by hydrogen bonds. In contrast,
the concave surface of the helix is formed by the presence of bulky
nonpolar side chains of Trp1,
Ile2, Ile5,
Leu8, and Phl16 residues.
They create a prominent hydrophobic pattern on the peptide surface. It
is reasonable to suppose that the polar side chains of the Zrv-IIB
molecule line the pore and possibly stabilize the channel bundle via
creation of intermolecular hydrogen bonds. Therefore, the side chain
mobility in Zrv-IIB bound to membrane-mimic media is of great interest.
As illustrated in a scatterplot of the
1
torsion angles (Fig. 2), the side chains of Trp1,
Ile2, Gln3, and
Ile5 are flexible, whereas
Thr6, Leu8,
Gln11, and Phl16 have only
one mostly populated
1 rotamer (
60 ± 30o).
|
Comparison of the backbone and side chain torsion angles of Zrv-IIB in
isotropic solvent of moderate polarity (Balashova et al., 2000
) and the
anisotropic micelle environment (Fig. 2) reveals that the spatial
structure of the peptide does not significantly change in these two
different media. This conclusion is also confirmed by low backbone rmsd
values (0.89 Å) between the two structures. However, the lowest rmsd
are observed on the regions 1-9 (0.28 Å) and 11-16 (0.29 Å). So the
most significant changes occur near the Hyp10,
the site of helix bending. Indeed, the bending angle in DPC (23°) is
significantly smaller than that in methanol (47°), thus leading to
the increased helix length (26.1 Å vs. 25.6 Å).
Effects of 5- and 16-doxylstearates on the 1H-NMR signals of micelle-bound Zrv-IIB
Relaxation probes are widely used to determine micelle-embedded
(Brown et al., 1981
; Dubovskii et al., 2001
) or water-exposed (Franklin
et al., 1994
) fragments of polypeptides. To elucidate the location of
Zrv-IIB in DPC micelles, the 5- and 16-doxylstearate relaxation probes
were incorporated into the DPC micelle with the nitroxide moiety being
preferentially located close to the surface and the center of the
micelle, respectively (Brown et al., 1981
). These probes, in
combination, induce broadening of the signals of a peptide immersed in
any region of the micelle (Papavoine et al., 1994
).
Specific broadening of the proton signals in the Zrv-IIB/DPC complex was monitored using NOESY spectra at the DPC/probe molar ratio of 63:1 (i.e., approximately one relaxation probe per micelle). To characterize the effect of the relaxation probes on the Zrv-IIB protons, we compared the amplitudes of selected intraresidual crosspeaks (Fig. 5) with and without probe. Attenuation of crosspeak intensities induced by 16-doxylstearate (Fig. 5) has a remarkable i, i + 4 and i, i + 3 periodicity. The signals of residues, which form the hydrophobic face of the molecule, were found the most attenuated. In contrast, the signals of the polar residues were almost insensitive to the probe. Addition of 5-doxylstearate decreases the intensities of the crosspeaks, but also with appreciable periodicity (data not shown).
|
Using the obtained spatial structure of Zrv-IIB, one can construct a model of the Zrv-IIB/DPC complex (Fig. 5, insert). The peptide is oriented approximately parallel to the micelle surface with the polar face directed outside. The strongest attenuation of the signals of Trp1 corresponds to a deeper immersion of the N-terminus, as compared with other parts of the molecule, into the micelle.
| |
DISCUSSION |
|---|
|
|
|---|
The spatial structure of Zrv-IIB as compared with other peptaibols
The spatial structure of Zrv-IIB (bent helix) is apparently
defined by some essential features in its sequence.
,
-Dialkylated amino acids (Aib, Iva) distributed along the sequence
stabilize the helical conformation (Karle and Balaram, 1990
), whereas
the bend is caused by Pro or Hyp residues. Nowadays, atomic coordinates are published for several peptaibols, such as crystal structures of
alamethicin (Alm, 20-residue peptaibol) (Fox and Richards, 1982
),
Leu1-zervamicin (Karle et al., 1994
), antiamoebin
I (16-residue peptaibol highly homologous to Zrv-IIB) (Snook et al.,
1998
), and NMR structure of chrysospermin C (19-residue peptaibol) in
DPC micelles (Anders et al., 2000
). All of these structures and Zrv-IIB
structures in methanol and DPC represent bent helices, the
N-termini of the molecules reveal very similar
-helical
conformations, whereas their C-termini have different
spatial structures, from
-helical in chrysospermin C to helical
-ribbon in antiamoebin I and Leu1-zervamicin.
Zrv-IIB has mixed 310/
R
helical conformation in C-terminal part. Peptaibol's
helices are always bent on a central Pro/Hyp residue
(Pro14 and Hyp10 in Alm and
Zrv-IIB, respectively), but the bending angle is different (from 20°
in chrysospermin C and Zrv-IIB in DPC environment to 90° in
trichorzianin A VII (Condamine et al., 1998
)) in various peptides and
even in various structures of the same compound. In addition, some of
the known structures of peptaibols have exposed carbonyl oxygen at
position i-3 (Gly11 and
Aib7 in case of Alm and Zrv-IIB, respectively),
where i denotes the bending Pro/Hyp residue. This is because
imino acids do not have NH group and, therefore, can not participate in
hydrogen bonding. Functional necessity of the
helix-bending/carbonyl-exposing
Gly11-x-x-Pro14 motif was
demonstrated on Alm analogs bearing "mutations" in the 11/14
position, which had dramatically decreased the number of conductance
levels and their lifetimes (Duclohier et al., 1992
; Kaduk et al., 1997
,
1998
). For zervamicins the significance of the carbonyl exposure in
Aib7 was demonstrated on the "completely
apolar" synthetic analog of zervamicin AI. Although exposed backbone
carbonyls are the only polar groups in this peptide (Karle et al.,
1987
), it demonstrates voltage-dependent conductance with two
conductance levels (Balaram et al., 1992
). Therefore, we can
characterize Zrv-IIB in DPC micelles being the norm for the peptaibolic
spatial structure.
Structure of Zrv-IIB in the context of the BS model
The BS model is generally used to describe ion channels formed by
peptaibols, as confirmed by a great number of experimental evidences.
The most convincing arguments include the formation of channels by
N- or C-terminal template-assembled alamethicins (You et al., 1996
; Duclohier et al., 1999
) and detection of peptaibol pores in membranes by neutron in-plane scattering (He et al., 1996
).
Recent analysis showed that the antibiotic action of peptaibols is
described precisely by the BS model (Beven et al., 1999
).
Zrv-IIB has a large content of the 310-helical
structure and the relatively small bending angle, which results in the
overall length of ~26 Å. This is significantly longer than a
16-residue
-helix (22.5 Å) and sufficient (taken into account the
effect of hydrophobic matching (Killian, 1998
)) to span the hydrocarbon region of the bilayer. For example, gramicidin A, another
channel-forming peptide, in its active form (helical dimer) has a
length ~25.5 Å (Arseniev et al., 1985
), easily traverses the
bilayer, and if necessary, is able to adjust its thickness (Harroun et
al., 1999
).
Aromatic residues were found in many TM segments of large, natural ion
channels and in gramicidin A (Killian and von Heijne, 2000
). In Zrv-IIB
such residues (Trp1 and
Phl16) are situated on the edges of the molecule.
In a possible TM active state they are capable to stabilize the
N- and C-termini on the interface between
hydrocarbon region and the polar headgroups of the lipid bilayer. The
exposed carbonyl oxygens in the central part of the molecule are
important for the functionality of peptaibols and are also found in
structures of nonpeptaibolical ion channels. In a recently determined
structure of the bacterial K+ channel, the
exposed carbonyls play a role of the selective filter (Doyle et al.,
1998
). In gramicidin A, the exposed carbonyls help to dehydrate
monovalent cations passing through the channel (Bechinger, 1999
) and
form the site of divalent cation binding (Pervushin and Arseniev,
1995
). We propose that the exposed carbonyl group in
Aib7 in Zrv-IIB also plays a role in ion conducting.
The strong amphiphilic character of Zrv-IIB helix is pictorially
illustrated by the 1-D MHP plot (Fig. 4, bottom): a
prominent maximum of the function MHP(
) at 210° <
< 330°
corresponds to its nonpolar side, whereas the minimum at 60° <
< 180° to the most hydrophilic one. The hydrophilic face of the
helix is represented by the strip of polar residues and ideally suited to the formation of the interior of the pore. On the contrary, the
hydrophobic surface pattern most probably corresponds to helix-helix interfaces in the bundle. Analysis of the distribution of hydrophobic and hydrophilic regions on the molecular surface allows speculations about stoichiometry of the Zrv-IIB helix bundle. The distinct minimum
and maximum on the 1-D MHP plot (Fig. 4, bottom) are
characteristic for tetrameric helix bundles. In contrast, pentameric
bundles reveal two minima and two maxima on the 1-D MHP plot (Efremov et al., 1999b
). These findings are in agreement with the assumption that the low conductance level channels of Zrv-IIB comprise four peptide molecules (Balaram et al., 1992
).
The consideration mentioned before makes us confident that Zrv-IIB has
sufficient length to span the hydrocarbon region of the membrane and it
is well adapted to form an oligomeric, TM ion pore. Earlier, the models
for Zrv-IIB bundles were developed based on the crystal structure of
Leu1-zervamicin. In these models, the helices
were associated in a parallel fashion, with the C-termini
situated in close proximity to one another and with the
N-termini arranged in the funnel shape (Sansom et al.,
1993
).
The mechanism of Zrv-IIB action
The DPC micelle has a diameter comparable with the membrane
thickness and a form of a prolate ellipsoid (Lauterwein et al., 1979
).
Numerous NMR studies of small helical peptides in micellar environment
argue for the retention of their mode of binding (TM or interfacial)
upon the transition from bilayer to micelle (Opella et al., 1994
;
Pervushin and Arseniev, 1995
). Thus, our data suggest that monomeric
Zrv-IIB binds on the bilayer/water interface in the helical
conformation. However, all available experimental data about the pore
state of Zrv-IIB are compatible with the BS model. Therefore, an
external force is needed to transfer the helix of Zrv-IIB from the
interfacial to the TM orientation, because the Zrv-IIB conductance is
strongly voltage dependent (Balaram et al., 1992
; Kropacheva and Raap,
1999
). Thus, Zrv-IIB activation is driven by the interaction of the
applied electric field with the helical dipole moment, i.e.,
reorientation of the amphiphilic helix from interfacial to TM state.
One of the key events in peptaibolic activation is the aggregation of
peptides (Woolley et al., 1994
). In our NMR study (peptide/detergent ratio 1:40) we have not found evidences for Zrv-IIB aggregation. The
electrophysiology investigations of peptaibols are usually conducted at
much lower peptide/lipid ratios and, most probably, Zrv-IIB monomeric
state remains on the membrane/water interface. Therefore, the
aggregation of Zrv-IIB takes place after its transition into the TM orientation.
Zrv-IIB forms channels in the presence of cis-positive
potentials (Balaram et al., 1992
; Kropacheva and Raap, 1999
) that, in
the context of the voltage-gated insertion model, corresponds to the
penetration of its N-terminus across the membrane. Such an
asymmetrical behavior denotes a higher ability of the
N-terminus to penetrate hydrocarbon region of the bilayer as
compared with the C-terminus. It was suggested that
insertion of the peptide from the C-terminus requires a more
extensive, energetically unfavorable dehydration of the polar groups
then insertion from the N-terminus (Ben-Tal et al., 1996
;
Chipot and Pohorille, 1998
). Estimations with our atomic solvation
model (Efremov et al., 1999a
) showed that the transfer from water to
membrane interior of nonhydrogen-bonded NH or CO group requires +0.8 or
+2.0 kcal/mol, respectively. The N-terminus of Zrv-IIB has
three HN groups, which are not involved in hydrogen bonding, whereas at
the proline-rich C-terminus there are four uncompensated CO
groups. Therefore, insertion from the N-terminus of Zrv-IIB
is ~5 kcal/mol less energetically costly than that from the
C-terminus. At the same time, orientation of the Zrv-IIB
helix dipole (~41 Debye calculated with CVFF charges) along
the external electric field (200 mV applied to a 30-Å thick bilayer)
is ~2.6 kcal/mol more favorable than the opposite one (this
orientation corresponds to N- or C-terminal
inserted states at a fixed voltage direction). According to these crude
estimations, the N-terminal insertion into membrane with
cis-positive potential is significantly more preferable. It
is interesting to note that N-terminus of Zrv-IIB is more
buried in the DPC micelle (Fig. 5) than other parts of the molecule. If
this preferential orientation retains on the bilayer membrane, it will
promote N-terminal penetration across the membrane as well.
And we can consider the proposed model of voltage gating as a
preorientation/insertion model (Fig. 6).
A similar voltage-gating model was proposed for Alm (Barranger-Mathys and Cafiso, 1996
).
|
| |
ACKNOWLEDGMENTS |
|---|
This work was supported in part by the Ministry of Science and Technology of Russian Federation, by the Russian Foundation of Basic Research (RFBR) Project 00-15-97877, and by the Netherlands Organization for Scientific Research (NWO) Project 047.006.009.
| |
FOOTNOTES |
|---|
Submitted May 21, 2001 and accepted for publication October 12, 2001.
Address reprint requests to: A. S. Arseniev, Shemyakin-Ovchinnikov Institute of Bioorganic Chemistry, Russian Academy of Sciences, ul. Miklukho-Maklaya, 16/10, 117997 Moscow, Russia. Tel.: 7-095-3305929; Fax: 7-095-3355033; E-mail: aars{at}nmr.ru.
| |
REFERENCES |
|---|
|
|
|---|
-helix insertion into lipid bilayers.
Biophys. J.
70:1803-1812
-helix formation.
Biophys. J.
76:2448-2459
-helical peptides as revealed by Monte Carlo simulations and molecular hydrophobicity potential analysis.
J. Phys. Chem.
99:10658-10666
-helical bundles in ion channels.
Theor. Chem. Acc.
101:73-76
-helical peptide molecules containing Aib residues.
Biochemistry.
29:6747-6756
-helix, and
a-bend ribbon.
Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. U.S.A.
84:5087-5091
Biophys J, February 2002, p. 762-771, Vol. 82, No. 2
© 2002 by the Biophysical Society 0006-3495/02/02/762/10 $2.00
This article has been cited by other articles:
![]() |
P. E. Kristiansen, G. Fimland, D. Mantzilas, and J. Nissen-Meyer Structure and Mode of Action of the Membrane-permeabilizing Antimicrobial Peptide Pheromone Plantaricin A J. Biol. Chem., June 17, 2005; 280(24): 22945 - 22950. [Abstract] [Full Text] [PDF] |
||||
![]() |
Z. O. Shenkarev, T. A. Balashova, Z. A. Yakimenko, T. V. Ovchinnikova, and A. S. Arseniev Peptaibol Zervamicin IIB Structure and Dynamics Refinement f |