| HOME | HELP | FEEDBACK | SUBSCRIPTIONS | ARCHIVE | SEARCH | TABLE OF CONTENTS |
Biophys J, February 2002, p. 813-822, Vol. 82, No. 2

and
*Section de Biophysique des Protéines et des Membranes,
Département de Biologie Cellulaire et Moléculaire URA CNRS
2096,
Service de Chimie Moléculaire,
Département de Recherche sur l'État Condensé, les
Atomes et les Molécules and CEA Saclay, 91191 Gif sur Yvette
cedex, France
| |
ABSTRACT |
|---|
|
|
|---|
Cholesteryl cyclodextrins, obtained by grafting a
cholesterol moiety on the oligosaccharide core, combine the size
selectivity of the cyclodextrin cavity with the carrier properties of
model membrane systems such as micelles or liposomes. The cholesteryl cyclodextrins were incorporated as guests in chain perdeuterated dimyristoyl phosphatidylcholine (DMPC-d54) membranes. The deuterium nuclear magnetic resonance (NMR) spectra obtained with the A form of
cholesteryl-
-cyclodextrin (
CCA), with a succinyl
spacer inserted between the cholesterol moiety and the cyclodextrin
headgroup, indicated that this compound induces a lateral phase
separation of DMPC-d54, into a pure lipid phase and a cholesteryl
cyclodextrin-rich phase. The lipid exchange rate between the two phases
was slow on the NMR timescale (>10
5 s), and two
well-resolved spectral components could be detected. The laterally
segregated mixed phase was observed at various membrane concentrations
of cholesteryl cyclodextrin, even with dispersions containing only 5%
of the derivative. The dePaked spectra allowed the determination of the
relative amount of DMPC-d54 molecules contained in each phase, giving
~1 to 1.5 DMPC molecules per unit of
CCA. This ratio
was found to be independent of the total membrane concentration of
CCA. The cholesteryl cylodextrin-rich phase was detected
on a large range of temperature from
12°C to 25°C and exhibits a
smooth transition from a fluid environment to a more ordered state,
occurring ~0°C. A boundary phase between the pure lipid and
cyclodextrin-rich phase was detected at 19°C just below the
fluid-to-gel transition. The average orientational order was reduced in
the cholesteryl cyclodextrin-rich phase, and quasi-independent of
temperature, as opposed to the order parameters measured for the NMR
signals of the pure lipid phase. However, the NMR data obtained with
CCA deuterated on the cyclodextrin headgroup indicated that the latter was quasistatic, with very large order parameters (~120 kHz) at all temperatures, suggesting strong interactions between neighboring cyclodextrin headgroups. The interactions of
DMPC-d54 membranes with the B form of cholesteryl-
-cyclodextrin, lacking the succinyl spacer, was also investigated in a parallel study.
No lateral phase separation was found with this compound, indicating
that the spatial location and a precise positioning (allowed by the
spacer) of the cyclodextrin headgroup at the membrane interface was
crucial for the stability of the cholesteryl cyclodextrin lamellar phase.
| |
INTRODUCTION |
|---|
|
|
|---|
Cyclodextrins (CD) are water-soluble natural
cyclic oligosaccharides composed of 6, 7, or 8 glucose units (
,
,
and
cyclodextrins, respectively). Owing to their torus-shaped
structure, they delimit an internal rather hydrophobic cavity although
the external part of the molecule is hydrophilic. They are therefore
able to include hydrophobic compounds leading to water-soluble
inclusion complexes. This property has been used extensively in a wide
number of applications in fields such as pharmaceutical, cosmetics, or
food industries (Duchêne, 1990
). Chemical modifications of the
natural oligosaccharidic core allow orientation and modulation of the
properties of these cage-molecules toward specific applications. A
promising field concerns the addition of one or several highly
hydrophobic moieties on the hydrophilic carbohydrate, giving
amphiphilic compounds prone to self-organization in aqueous media or to
insertion in supramolecular assemblies such as liposomes or micelles.
It was observed that the grafting of one cholesteryl unit on natural CD
(the coupling can be direct or through a spacer) leads to amphiphilic molecules that can be efficiently inserted as guests in phospholipid liposomes. Using small-angle x-ray scattering, we have shown that the
insertion of cholesteryl-
-cyclodextrin in multibilayers of dimyristoyl phosphatidylcholine (DMPC) results in the formation of two
different lamellar phases, one is made of pure DMPC, the other one
being strongly loaded by the cholesteryl cyclodextrin guest
(Auzély-Velty et al., 1999
). This would indicate that the polar
CD moieties experience strong lateral interactions, sequestrating lipid
molecules in a two-dimensional network. Thus, it appears that besides
its biological interest, the cholesteryl cyclodextrin/DMPC system
offers also an interesting approach of the molecular-induced lateral
segregation of phospholipids within bilayers membranes.
To gain detailed molecular information on the cyclodextrin-induced
lateral segregation process, we have carried out a comprehensive deuterium magnetic nuclear resonance (2H NMR)
study with DMPC membranes containing derivatives of
cholesteryl-
-cyclodextrin, differentiated by the presence (A) or the
absence (B) of a succinyl spacer linking the cholesteryl moiety and the
cyclodextrin headgroup. Chain-deuterated DMPC probing the cholesteryl
cyclodextrin-induced perturbations, allowed the various phases to be
monitored separately on a large range of temperatures
(
12°C-37°C) and at various cholesteryl cyclodextrin
concentrations, providing detailed information on their nature and the
order of the lipids.
| |
MATERIALS AND METHODS |
|---|
|
|
|---|
Synthesis of cyclodextrin derivatives
6I-(cholest-5-en-3
-ylamido)succinyl-amido-6I-deoxy-cyclomaltoheptaose
(
CCA) and
6I-(cholest-5-en-3
-yloxycarbonyl)amino-6I-deoxy-cyclomaltoheptaose
(
CCB) (Scheme
1) were synthesized as described
previously (Auzély-Velty et al., 1999
). The deuterated analogues
of
-cyclodextrin and of
CCA,
regio-specifically labeled on the C-2 carbon of all glucose units, were
obtained according to a published procedure (Djedaïni et al.,
1990
). All compounds were fully characterized by high field proton NMR
and high resolution mass spectrometry.
|
Sample preparations
DMPC and chain deuterated DMPC-d54 were purchased from Avanti
Polar Lipids (Alabaster, AL) and the cholesterol from Sigma (St. Louis,
MO). Multilayered liposomes were prepared by mixing chloroform lipid
solutions and methanol solutions of the appropriate cyclodextrin
derivative. The solvent was then removed by evaporation under
N2. The solid residues were dried under vacuum
(10
2 mm Hg) for 12 h and dispersed by
continuous vortexing at 20°C in 100 to 300 µl of deuterium depleted
water (Eurisotop, France) equilibrated at pH 8.0 giving ~200 mM lipid dispersions.
2H NMR experiments
2H NMR spectra were recorded at 46 MHz on
a Bruker DMX 300 spectrometer equipped with a probe specifically
designed for solid state deuterium NMR experiments (Morris Instruments
Inc., Gloucester, ON, Canada). Spectra were acquired from
12°C to
37°C with a dwell time of 2 µs, 4-K data points, and a recycling
time of 200 ms. A quadrupolar echo pulse sequence (Davis et al., 1976
)
was used with pulse length of 3 µs and pulse separation,
, of 40 µs. The phase was adjusted to obtain no signal in the imaginary
channel, which was then discarded before the Fourier transform of the
echo. When necessary, the free induction decay was shifted by a
fraction of the dwell time using an orthogonal polynomial interpolation routine so that the Fourier transform could start at the top of the
echo (Davis, 1983
). Oriented 2H NMR spectra
(0°) were obtained by the numerical dePake-ing procedure described by
Sternin et al. (1983)
. The method of moments (Davis, 1979
; Davis et
al., 1979
) was also applied to the chain deuteron spectra. The narrow
(<3 Hz) dePaked methyl resonances found in the
10 to 10 kHz range
were simulated with a Gaussian line shape after baseline correction of
the data. Each resonance was fitted with three independent parameters
namely the frequency, the line width, and the intensity.
| |
RESULTS |
|---|
|
|
|---|
2H NMR of deuterated phospholipids provides
a suitable tool for studying the lipid membrane organization through
the direct measurement of the local orientational order parameters of
the C---D bonds of the lipid acyl chains and polar headgroups (Davis, 1983
). In particular gel-to-liquid crystalline phase transitions of
phospholipid membranes can be precisely monitored by following the line
shape changes of 2H NMR spectra of the
chain-deuterated lipid derivatives (Davis, 1979
; 1983
). In Fig.
1 A, the line shapes of
2H NMR spectra of saturated DMPC-d54 change
dramatically between 20°C and 19°C from a well-resolved, axially
symmetric distribution of quadrupolar splittings typical of the fluid
L
phase above 20°C, to a much broader
distribution of lipid molecules in the gel P
'
phase below 20°C. At higher temperatures, the quadrupolar splitting
distribution is typical of phospholipid bilayers in the fluid state
with a large quadrupolar splitting, or plateau, containing the
methylene groups near the membrane interface, smaller resolved
quadrupolar splittings for the methylene closer to the bilayer center,
and a narrow doublet due to the methyl group at the end of the chain.
The gel-to-liquid crystalline transition of perdeuterated DMPC occurs
at lower temperature (20°C) than the value of ~23°C, measured by
various techniques with pure unlabeled DMPC membranes (Marsh, 1990
;
Koynova and Caffrey, 1998
). This effect is due to the chain-chain
deuteron interactions that lower the phase transition temperatures of
deuterated phospholipids (Peterson et al., 1975
).
|
DMPC-d54 bilayers with cholesteryl-
-cyclodextrin A
The 2H NMR spectra recorded in the presence
of 20% molar
CCA (Fig. 1 B)
significantly differ from those obtained with pure DMPC. Above 20°C,
the lipids are all in the fluid state as probed by the liquid
crystalline line shape of the 2H NMR powder
patterns, and apparently there is only one component at 37°C. A
shoulder is detected at 25°C, on each side of the large quadrupolar
splitting of the plateau methylene groups, suggesting that at least two
components coexist. This shoulder appears more clearly when the
temperature is decreased. At 20°C, the resonances of the methyl
terminal deuterons are also split in two signals (±1.5 and ± 2.0 kHz), indicating the coexistence of two distinct types of DMPC
molecules in the fluid state, in slow exchange on the
2H NMR timescale. At 19°C, a gel phase
component is detected with signal intensity out to
±63 kHz,
and also
±6 kHz, where the signal of methyl groups in the gel
phase appears on pure DMPC-d54 spectra at the same temperature. Now we
can detect three components at 19°C, the DMPC molecules in the gel
phase coexisting with at least two species of DMPC in the fluid-like
state monitored by the outer and inner splittings, which will be
referred as component (I) and (II) in the following, of the methylene
deuterons of the plateau region and of the terminal methyl groups. On
cooling the sample further, the amount of the gel phase spectrum
increases while the maxima of the fluid component (I) detected on both
methyl and plateau resonances collapse. In contrast, the intensities of
the other fluid component (II) remain constant, although a progressive
broadening of the NMR lines occurs below 10°C.
The effect induced by
CCA on the DMPC-d54 acyl
chains can be analyzed in more detail after dePake-ing of the
2H NMR data (Fig.
2, bottom spectra). As shown on the
spectrum recorded with pure DMPC (Fig. 2, trace a), this
procedure allows clear monitoring of the individual quadrupolar
splittings of the myristoyl acyl chains, i.e., the terminal methyl
groups (1), the methylene groups localized at the end of the acyl
chains and those contributing to the plateau region (2). The two
components (I) and (II) observed in the presence of
CCA appear clearly on the dePaked spectrum
recorded with 20% (Fig. 2 b) or 30% (Fig. 2 c) of the cyclodextrin derivative. An estimation of the relative intensity
of the methyl resonances of component (I) and (II) gives ~30% and
50% of (II) at, respectively, 20% or 30% molar
CCA. The ratio of the two methyl components
was found to be independent of the pulse separation used in the
quadrupolar echo sequence (for values of
between 40 and 200 µs;
see Materials and Methods). This indicates that the measurement is not
distorted by differences in echo decay times for the methyl groups in
the two lipid phases.
|
Thus, the signal ratio of the two components is not equal to 1 and
changes with the guest/lipid ratio. This indicates that the two lipid
forms characterized by the splitting of the methyl resonances do not
result from the magnetic inequivalence of the sn-1 and
sn-2 chains, as observed in the presence of cholesterol (Sankaram and Thomson, 1990
). When 40% of the guest is added to the
bilayers (Fig. 2 d), we observe that component (I) has
almost disappeared, so that most of the signal of DMPC deuterons are now under component (II). The dePaked deuterium NMR spectra displayed in Fig. 2 show that for all membranes containing
CCA, the quadrupolar splittings of the methyl
and plateau methylene groups of component (II) do not depend on the
CCA-to-DMPC molar ratio, i.e., the order
parameters of the DMPC acyl chains in the new phase are approximately
invariant whatever the guest concentration in the membrane.
DMPC-d54 with cholesteryl-
-cyclodextrin B
In the B form of cholesteryl-
-cyclodextrin
(
CCB) the cholesteryl moiety is directly
linked to the amino group of cyclodextrin without the succinyl spacer
found in the A form. As seen in Fig. 2 (e-g),
the dePaked 2H NMR spectra of DMPC membranes
obtained at 20°C with the two derivatives are quite different.
Apparently, there is only one fluid component with
CCB, when the membrane is in the liquid crystalline state. The quadrupolar splittings of the plateau and methyl
deuterons have approximately the same values than those measured with
pure DMPC-d54, and are not decreased as observed with
CCA.
The dePaked lines are broadened in the presence of
CCB, while they are still narrow and resolved
with
CCA (Fig. 2, b-d). This line broadening is quite pronounced when the membrane
CCB concentration reaches 40% (Fig. 2
g).
Temperature dependence of DMPC-d54 bilayers with cholesteryl cyclodextrins
The temperature dependence of the DMPC/cholesteryl cyclodextrin
interaction was probed on large range of temperature from 37°C to
12°C. The dePaked spectra obtained with 20%
CCA or
CCB are
respectively shown in the stacked plots of Fig.
3, A and B. The
line widths and quadrupolar splittings measured for the methyl deuterons from these spectra are plotted in Fig.
4.
|
|
Temperature above 0o C
The first occurrence of the component (II) induced by the membrane incorporation of
CCA, is detected ~25°C at
the level of the plateau methylene signals, followed by a splitting of
the methyl resonances at 23°C.
It appears clearly that one component (I) is temperature
dependent, whereas the other (II) is barely affected. As shown in Fig.
4, there is a clear line broadening (Fig. 4 B) and a sharp increase of the quadrupolar splitting (from 5-13 kHz, Fig. 4
A) of component (I) below 20°C, at the
L
P
' transition temperature of pure DMPC-d54. In fact, it can be shown that the temperature dependence of the plateau and the methyl quadrupolar splittings measured with the signals of component (I) are similar to
that obtained with pure DMPC-d54. In contrast, the quadrupolar splittings of component (II) of both methylene and methyl deuterons remain quasiconstant below 20°C, without significant line broadening. As seen on the dePaked spectra displayed in Fig. 3 A, the
signal intensity of the plateau methylene deuterons starts to decrease below 15°C, and becomes barely detectable at 5°C. However, there is
no loss of intensity of the methyl signal, and no important quadrupolar
splitting changes or line broadening occur until the temperature
reaches 5°C, well below the fluid-to-gel phase transition. Cooling
the sample below 5°C leads to further broadening of the methyl
resonances of component (II), with a simultaneous increase of the
quadrupolar splitting, suggesting the formation at these temperatures
of a more ordered phase (Fig. 4, A and B).
As mentioned above, there is only one component on the
2H NMR spectra of
DMPC-d54/
CCB membranes, although the dePaked
resonances of the fluid methyl group measured above Tc are slightly
broadened (Fig. 3 B). The chain quadrupolar splittings are
temperature dependent in the presence of the B form of
cholesteryl-
-cyclodextrin, as observed with pure DMPC, and no
temperature-invariant component can be detected on the whole
temperature range (Fig. 3 B and Fig. 4, C and
D), as opposed to the results obtained with
CCA-containing membranes. Intensities of gel
phase lipids at ±63 kHz are detected at 19°C on the powder spectra,
indicating that a fluid to gel phase transition occurs (spectra not
shown). The chain methyl quadrupolar splitting is still detected below
this temperature and continues to increase regularly with a marked
inhomogeneous line broadening of the dePaked NMR lines ~15°C (Fig.
3 B). The distribution of the methyl deuteron intensities is
asymmetric, retaining a Gaussian line shape on the inner half width,
i.e., on the side of the center frequency of the spectrum, similar to that measured in the fluid phase above 19°C, and a broader shoulder on the outer width of the signal, which spreads over the frequency range of the methyl signal of the pure lipid in the gel phase. The
intensity of the outer shoulder increases when the temperature decreases, and at 0°C the methyl NMR lines are almost superimposable with the corresponding resonances of the pure lipid spectrum at the
same temperature.
The gel-to-fluid transition appears clearly from the temperature
dependence shown in Fig. 4 of the methyl line widths (Fig. 4
D) and quadrupolar splittings (Fig. 4 C),
although it is significantly smoothed, ranging between 20°C and
15°C. For the A form of cholesteryl-
-cyclodextrin, the
transition probed by the signal of component (I) is steeper and is
already achieved at 18°C (Fig. 4, A and
B).
The chain methyl line widths and quadrupolar splittings were also
measured at high concentrations (40%) of cholesteryl-
-cyclodextrin. The temperature dependence obtained for these two parameters with the
component (II) of DMPC membranes containing either 20% or 40% of
CCA are similar, with the same slope increase
below 5°C. Likewise, the related data obtained with the B form of
cholesteryl-
-cyclodextrin show that the temperature-induced
variations of the methyl line widths and quadrupolar splittings
measured at 20% and 40% of
CCB are similar.
The lipid phase changes were also monitored by the first moment
M1 analysis of the powder pattern spectra shown
in Fig. 1, and is displayed in Fig. 5 for
various concentrations (0, 5%, 20%, 30%, and 40%) of the A and B
form of cholesteryl-
-cyclodextrin. For all samples, the first moment
M1 is increased when the temperature is decreased
due to the thermally induced increase of the average orientational
order of the lipid acyl chains. In the case of pure DMPC, there is a
sharp change ~20°C associated with the gel-to-liquid crystalline
transition, as discussed above. The incorporation of either A or B form
of cholesteryl-
-cyclodextrin leads to a decrease of
M1 values, indicating a decrease of the average
orientational order of the hydrophobic chains in the presence of the
cyclodextrin derivatives. There is a large decrease of
M1 value between 10°C and 20°C in the
presence of the
CCA, leading to a progressive broadening of the fluid-to-gel transition, due to the growing fraction
of the fluid lipids found under component (II) on the deuterium
spectra. At 40%
CCA the first moment
variations are almost linear without sigmoid transition but with a
sixfold increase of the slope occurring ~18°C. The decrease of
M1 values measured below the transition for a
given amount of cholesteryl-
-cyclodextrin is less important with the
B form than with the A form, and the fluid-to-gel transition is less
affected with the former derivative. In particular, there is still a
sigmoid transition in the presence of 40% of
CCB, although shifted at lower temperature by
~3°C.
|
Temperatures below 0oC
As observed for the L
P
' transition at 19°C, there is another
sudden increase (20-32 kHz) of the methyl quadrupolar splitting of the
component (I) observed with the A form of cholesteryl-
-cyclodextrin
at approximately
8°C (Fig. 3 A). This transition is also
detected with the corresponding pure DMPC-d54 sample (Roux et al.,
unpublished results). A similar transition, occurring at approximately
4°C, has been observed previously by 2H NMR
with DMPC specifically deuterated on the methyl group of the
sn-2 chain (Westerman et al., 1982
'
L
' transition of the phospholipid, from the
gel (P
') phase to a pure lamellar gel
(L
') phase (Trahms et al., 1983
CCA displayed in Fig. 3
A shows that the methyl quadrupolar splitting of component
(II) (±10 kHz) is still detected at these temperatures even at
9°C
below the second transition observed with the pure lipid component (I).
When the temperature reaches
10°C, the dePaked methyl resonances
found at ±10 kHz disappear and are replaced by another signal
appearing approximately ±20 kHz, not detected at this temperature on
the corresponding 2H NMR of pure DMPC-d54. This
new quadrupolar splitting appears to be similar to that measured at
7°C for the pure laterally segregated lipids (I) in the gel state,
i.e., before the putative P
'
L
transition. Interestingly, this latter perturbation is correlated with the freezing of the bulk water, as
probed on the corresponding deuterium powder spectrum by the complete
and sudden loss of the narrow isotropic signal attributed to residual
deuterated water.
As opposed to
CCA membrane data, there is no
NMR evidence of a sharp transition below 0°C with
CCB, although the NMR lines show a marked
asymmetry below
8°C with intensities spreading over ±30 kHz.
DMPC-d54 bilayers with low concentrations of
cholesteryl-
-cyclodextrins
To test further the ability of
CCA to
induce the formation of a second lipid environment (II), we have also
obtained data at low concentration (5%) of
CCA. It appears that, despite this membrane
dilution, a second component is still detected, as shown in Fig.
6. Due to the low amount of
CCA, this component is not resolved on the
DMPC-d54 spectra recorded in the fluid phase (data not shown), but it
appears clearly on the 2H NMR spectrum recorded
at 19°C, just below the fluid-to-gel phase transition (Fig. 6
a). The analysis of the methyl region indicates very clearly
the coexistence of two fluid lipid environments with gel phase lipids,
as observed on the corresponding NMR spectra recorded with 20% of
CCA. To isolate these fluid components, we
have removed the gel signal by subtracting a fraction (~ 62%) of the
pure DMPC-d54 gel phase spectrum recorded at the same temperature. We
were able to obtain a difference spectrum (Fig. 6 b) with no signal left beyond ±40 kHz, containing only the signals of the fluid
lipids. The same procedure was applied to the NMR data recorded at
lower temperature, i.e., the same fraction (62%) of the pure lipid gel
phase spectrum at the corresponding temperature was subtracted. The
difference spectrum derived from the data measured after lowering the
temperature of one degree from 19°C to 18°C indicates clearly that
the fraction of the pure lipid remaining in the fluid state has now
moved into the gel state (Fig. 6 c). After dePake-ing of the
obtained difference spectra (Fig. 6 h), it can be shown that
the temperature dependencies of the line widths and quadrupolar
splittings of the methyl signal follow closely those obtained at 20%
and 40%
CCA. Similar difference spectra were
obtained at 10% of
CCA (data not shown), and
lead to the same conclusions.
|
2H NMR spectra were also obtained with 5% (Fig.
6, d-g) and 10% (data not shown) of the B form
of cholesteryl-
-cyclodextrin. The analysis of the difference spectra
obtained with the same procedure, as described above, confirms the
results obtained at higher concentrations, showing that there is no
additional component in the presence of this
cholesteryl-
-cyclodextrin derivative.
Deuterated
CCA in DMPC bilayers
The interaction of cholesterol cyclodextrin with zwitterionic DMPC
bilayers was probed with
CCA-d7 deuterated on
the oligosaccharide headgroup, at the level of the
C2 carbon of the seven glucose units. The
2H NMR spectra obtained with this derivative,
shown in Fig. 7, contain a very large
quadrupolar splitting (~120 kHz) with a broad featureless signal
spread over the whole frequency range. The larger splitting has no
thermal dependence, retaining the same value at all temperatures. On
the other hand, the intensity of the central signals decreases
progressively when the temperature is lowered, revealing a well-defined
quadrupolar splitting at 0°C. The broad signal distribution observed
at high temperatures could either reflect differences in the order
parameters of the glucose units or different environments of the
CCA molecules. We have also recorded
2H NMR spectra with native deuterated
-cyclodextrin-d7 (without the cholesteryl moiety) and obtained a
single narrow isotropic resonance, which indeed confirms that the
hydrophilic guest does not interact spontaneously with
phosphatidylcholine liposomes in the absence of a hydrophobic anchor
(data not shown). There is a 200-Hz difference between the chemical
shifts of the isotropic signal of free
-cyclodextrin-d7 and the
central narrow resonance found on the spectra of membrane-bound
CCA shown in Fig. 7. In the latter case the
isotropic signal is due to the deuterons of residual heavy water.
|
| |
DISCUSSION |
|---|
|
|
|---|
Our study shows that the A form of cholesteryl-
-cyclodextrin,
which contains a spacer between the sterol and the cyclodextrin moiety,
induces a lateral separation of lipid molecules in two distinct phases
containing pure DMPC and DMPC sequestrated between
CCA molecules. We report two components of the
DMPC-d54 spectra, with exchange rates that are slow on the
2H NMR timescale (>10
5
s
1), probing the occurrence of two different
lipid environments. Component (I) has the same thermal behavior as pure
DMPC membranes, namely 1) a line broadening at the gel-to-fluid
transition temperature of pure DMPC-d54 with the appearance of spectral
intensities characteristic of lipids in the gel state and 2) the same
quadrupolar splitting temperature dependence. Thus, this component is
associated with a pure DMPC phase, co-existing with a cyclodextrin-rich
phase appearing as component (II) on the NMR traces. These
2H NMR results are in good agreement with our
previous data obtained for the DMPC/
CCA system
using small angle x-ray scattering and differential scanning
calorimetry, which indicate also the coexistence of two lamellar phases
at 30°C (Auzély-Velty et al., 1999
). In the present study, we
have obtained NMR data providing detailed molecular information on the
DMPC/cholesteryl-
-cyclodextrin system on a large range of
concentrations and temperatures. A phase separation was found to occur
with only 5% of
CCA. The overall perturbation of the bilayer is weak at such concentration (almost probe level) so
the membrane order is close to that of pure DMPC, as shown in the
corresponding moment M1 curve (Fig. 5). Under these conditions, we can
partially dissociate discrete effects from global membrane perturbations induced by larger concentrations of the guest. We have
found that there are at least three lipid environments at 19°C just
below the fluid-to-gel transition of DMPC-d54. A first one, with the
smaller splitting, is associated with lipids interacting with
CCA, in a cholesteryl cyclodextrin-rich phase,
which we will refer to as the LCD phase in the
following, and appearing as component (II) on the
2H NMR spectra. A second one is associated to the
fluid signal with the larger quadrupolar splitting and should
correspond to lipids located at the boundary of the
LCD phase, remaining in the fluid state at 19°C
and a third one is that of pure lipids in the gel phase, not
interacting with the LCD phase. These three lipid
environments are clearly distinguished on the difference spectrum
obtained with 5%
CCA at 19°C (Fig. 6). A
quantitative analysis of the dePaked NMR spectra has been attempted by
simulating the fluid dePaked methyl resonances of component (I) and
(II) with Gaussian line shapes, and the results are shown in
Table 1. For the sample containing 5% of
CCA at 19°C, we have estimated that for 10 molecules of
CCA, the amount of DMPC in the
LCD phase, at the boundary of the
LCD phase and in the gel state are (within the
experimental error, respectively), 16, 57, and 118. As shown in Table
1, the number of lipids in the gel phase is quickly reduced when the
concentration of
CCA is increased, and for
30%
CCA there is no more lipids in the gel
phase. Indeed, the total number of fluid lipid per molecule of
CCA is also reduced, but it is mostly at the
expense of the fluid boundary lipids, whereas the number of lipid
molecules found in the LCD phase remains
approximately constant in the range of 1 to 1.5 DMPC per
CCA molecule. A similar ratio is also found at
temperatures above the fluid-to-gel transition at either 20% or 30%
of
CCA. At 40%
CCA,
which corresponds already to a global ratio of 1.5 molecules of DMPC
per cholesteryl-
-cyclodextrin, almost all the lipids should be in
the LCD phase. The calculated line width values
are indeed consistent with the data plotted in Fig. 4, showing that the
pure lipid resonances start to broaden at 19°C at the onset of the
fluid-to-gel transition, whereas those of the lipids in the
LCD phase are not affected by this transition. Thus, the DMPC-to-
CCA ratio in the
LCD phase appears to be remarkably invariant,
i.e., independent on both the temperature variations and the total
amount of cholesteryl-
-cyclodextrin. This strongly suggests that the
two phases are fully separated with DMPC either pure or mixed with
CCA. A possible explanation could be that these two phases are in fact macroscopically distinct. In such case,
the two 2H NMR components would just reflect the
heterogeneity of the sample with membrane aggregates enriched in
cholesteryl-
-cyclodextrin and pure lipid particles. This assumption
can be ruled out by the observation that, at all
CCA concentrations, the pure lipid phase does
interact with the LCD phase through the boundary
fluid lipids detected at the onset of the fluid-to-gel transition.
|
It appears that the lateral separation of the LCD
phase, detected at membrane concentrations as low as 5% of
CCA, has to be associated with strong
interactions between the cyclodextrin headgroups. The
form of
cyclodextrin alone, without cholesterol, is actually well known to form
aggregates in water and is 10-fold less soluble than the
and
derivatives. Interestingly, the chemical modifications of the
cyclodextrin hydroxyls, for instance by methylation, disrupt these
interactions and lead to completely different behaviors
(Auzély-Velty et al., 2000
). In our case, the
CCA cyclodextrin headgroups incorporated in
DMPC bilayers appear to be very rigid, because the deuterons of the
cyclodextrin headgroup exhibit a very large quadrupolar splitting,
independent of the temperature variations, giving a high order
parameter, corresponding to an almost complete absence of motion.
Thus, the emerging picture is that the stability of the
LCD phase should be governed primarily by the
hydrophilic interaction between cyclodextrin headgroups. In this case
hydrophobic interaction between the sterol and the phospholipid acyl
chains could be of secondary importance in maintaining the cohesion of
the LCD phase. The LCD
phase seems to contain a maximum of 1.5 DMPC per
CCA. Considering the ratio of the specific
area of the cyclodextrin headgroup and of the cholesteryl hydrophobic
anchor, it can be roughly estimated that, in the case of a packed
network of cyclodextrin headgroups, the volume left in between two
adjacent cholesteryl cyclodextrin molecules should effectively
accommodate for no more than two to three phospholipid molecules. The
acyl chains of these sequestrated lipids are more disordered than in
the pure lipid phase. This is shown by the decrease of the first moment
M1 and the reduction of the quadrupolar
splittings of the methyl and plateau deuterons observed in the presence
of
CCA. This effect is thus completely opposed
to the ordering of the phosphatidylcholine fluid phase, or
"condensing" effect, induced by cholesterol alone, which leads in
similar experimental conditions, and with the same cholesterol to
phospholipid ratio, to an average ~70% increase of the DMPC-d54
quadrupolar splittings (data not shown; Vist and Davis, 1990
). The acyl
chains quadrupolar splittings are also remarkably insensitive to
temperature variations in the LCD phase, as
opposed to what is observed in the pure lipid phase, and remain fluid
well below Tc. The above remarks support the model in which the packing
order of the LCD phase is not primarily
determined by chain-chain or cholesterol-chain interactions, as it
occurs in DMPC bilayers, but is rather dominated by the interactions between the large cyclodextrin moities. However, the chain deuterons become temperature sensitive between 5°C and
5°C, showing that the DMPC molecules do undergo a phase transition from a fluid phase to
more a ordered environment, as shown in Fig. 3 A and Fig. 4.
Yet, the methyl quadrupolar splittings are still smaller than those
measured in DMPC gel phase, indicating that the orientational order of
this new LCD state is smaller than in the
P
' gel phase of the pure lipid. This ordered
LCD phase seems to be quite stable and appears to
be preserved at low temperatures, even at
9°C when the pure lipids
appear to be in the rigid L
' lamellar gel
phase. However, it apparently breaks down at
10°C, where the lipids
associated to component (II) seem to undergo another transition. The
lipids should have evolved into a gel-like state, considering that the
quadrupolar splittings of their acyl chain methyl groups are now
comparable with those measured for the component (I) of the pure lipid
in the gel phase (Fig. 3 A). This transition could be due to
the freezing of the bulk water molecules observed simultaneously at
10°C, which probably lead to disorganization or even a disruption
of the cholesteryl-
-cyclodextrin headgroup network and a
rearrangement or a suppression of the LCD phase.
The role of the spacer introduced between the sterol and the
cyclodextrin is certainly decisive by increasing the conformational space offered to the
CCA headgroups anchored
at the membrane interface. Such a conformational flexibility is
probably required to achieve head to head interactions efficient enough
to induce the clustering effect leading to the sequestration of the
DMPC molecules in the LCD phase. The results
obtained with the B form of cholesteryl
-cyclodextrin, lacking the
succinyl spacer, support this model. In the presence of this
derivative, only one phase is detected with spectrum line shapes
indicating that the bilayers are still stable. In the fluid phase,
there is a decrease of the average orientational order as probed by the
first moment M1 values, which are approximately similar to those
obtained with bilayers containing
CCA. In
fact, the global disordering effects induced by these two cyclodextrin
derivatives on the DMPC acyl chains in the fluid phase are
quantitatively similar, although the molecular mechanisms involved in
the interaction of
CCA and
CCB with the lipid membrane appear to be
qualitatively different. In the absence of succinyl spacer, the B form
of cholesteryl-
-cyclodextrin must be distributed in the whole
bilayers, perturbing almost each phospholipid molecule, whereas with
the A form, two laterally segregated distinct phases are observed. This
appears quite clearly on the 2H NMR dePaked
spectra obtained with 20% of the cholesteryl-
-cyclodextrin derivatives displayed in Fig. 3. With
CCB
there is a smoothed gel-to-fluid phase transition involving the
ensemble of the lipids, whereas sharp phase transitions concerning only
a fraction of lipids separating from the
CCA-induced LCD phase
are observed at 19°C and also at
8°C. At high concentrations of
CCA, there is formation of an almost pure
LCD phase without cooperative fluid-to-gel transition, whereas a sigmoid transition is still detected with
CCB, indicating that the DMPC molecules are
still able to undergo a cooperative, although smoothed, transition to
the gel state (Fig. 5).
The ensemble of our NMR data provide conclusive evidences that there is
globally one lipid phase with
CCB, whereas a
pure lipid phase and a laterally segregated cholesteryl
cyclodextrin-rich phase are detected with
CCA.
Without the succinyl link to the cholesterol moiety, the cyclodextrin
headgroup of
CCB must be constrained at the
membrane surface with a reduced conformational space, hindering
probably the adequate positioning of adjacent headgroups and the
formation of the LCD phase observed with the
CCA. Thus, the cholesteryl cyclodextrin/DMPC
system gives a straightforward example on how an amphiphilic molecule
can affect lipid membranes with the local formation of a
two-dimensional molecular network within the bilayer, through
finely-tuned intermolecular headgroup interactions at the membrane interface.
The ability of bilayer membranes to incorporate the
cholesteryl-
-cyclodextrin derivatives should permit the liposome
transportation of hydrophobic cyclodextrin-bound drugs, standing out at
the bilayer surface toward the external medium, facilitating their
interaction with circulating molecules or macromolecular assemblies.
Indeed, the primary pharmacological interest of the
cholesteryl-
-cyclodextrin lies in the inclusion property of the
cyclodextrin cavity. Further efforts will thus be dedicated to
investigate the effect of the inclusion of a guest compound on the
cholesteryl-
-cyclodextrin liposome insertion and on the formation of
the LCD phase. Special attention will be given to
pharmacologically active compounds to design new formulations for the
administration of drugs combining the size-specificity of the
cyclodextrin moiety and the carrier properties of phospholipid
liposomes. It will be in particular interesting to evaluate the
relative potencies, if any, of the
CCA and
CCB derivatives and determine whether the
formation of the laterally segregated LCD phase
is pharmacologically relevant.
| |
ACKNOWLEDGMENTS |
|---|
We gratefully acknowledge J. P. Dalbiez for the purification of the cyclodextrin derivatives. We also thank E. Sternin and E. J. DuFourc for his advice concerning the DePake-ing method and M. Garrigos and J. M. Neumann for helpful discussions.
| |
FOOTNOTES |
|---|
Address reprint requests to Dr. Michel Roux, Département de Biologie Cellulaire et Moléculaire, Section de Biophysique des Protéines et des Membranes and URA CNRS 2096, CEA Saclay, 91191 Gif sur Yvette cedex, France. Tel.: 33-1-69-08-9678; Fax: 33-1-69-08-8139; E-mail: roux{at}dsvidf.cea.fr.
Submitted October 10, 2000, and accepted for publication November 16, 2001.
R. Auzely-Velty's present address: Centre de Recherches sur les Macromolécules Végétales, BP 53, 38041 Grenoble cedex 9, France.
F. Djedaini-Pilard's present address: Laboratoire de Chimie Organique, Université de Picardie Jules Verne, 80039 Amiens cedex, France.
| |
REFERENCES |
|---|
|
|
|---|
-cyclodextrin.
J. Label. Compd Radiopharm.
28:785-791
Biophys J, February 2002, p. 813-822, Vol. 82, No. 2
© 2002 by the Biophysical Society 0006-3495/02/02/813/10 $2.00
This article has been cited by other articles:
![]() |
K. Nag, K. M. W. Keough, and M. R. Morrow Probing Perturbation of Bovine Lung Surfactant Extracts by Albumin using DSC and 2H-NMR Biophys. J., May 15, 2006; 90(10): 3632 - 3642. [Abstract] [Full Text] [PDF] |
||||
| ||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
| HOME | HELP | FEEDBACK | SUBSCRIPTIONS | ARCHIVE | SEARCH | TABLE OF CONTENTS |