| HOME | HELP | FEEDBACK | SUBSCRIPTIONS | ARCHIVE | SEARCH | TABLE OF CONTENTS |
Biophys J, June 2002, p. 3022-3036, Vol. 82, No. 6
Hopkins Marine Station, Pacific Grove, California 93950 USA
| |
ABSTRACT |
|---|
|
|
|---|
Considerable published evidence suggests that
-subunits of the cloned channel sqKv1A compose the "delayed
rectifier" in the squid giant axon system, but discrepancies
regarding inactivation properties of cloned versus native channels
exist. In this paper we define the mechanism of inactivation for sqKv1A
channels in Xenopus oocytes to investigate these and
other discrepancies. Inactivation of sqKv1A in Xenopus
oocytes was found to be unaffected by genetic truncation of the
N-terminus, but highly sensitive to certain amino acid substitutions
around the external mouth of the pore. External TEA and K+
ions slowed inactivation of sqKv1A channels in oocytes, and chloramine T (Chl-T) accelerated inactivation. These features are all consistent with a C-type inactivation mechanism as defined for
Shaker B channels. Treatment of native channels in giant
fiber lobe neurons with TEA or high K+ does not slow
inactivation, nor does Chl-T accelerate it. Pharmacological differences
between the two channel types were also found for 4-aminopyridine
(4AP). SqKv1A's affinity for 4AP was poor at rest and increased after
activation, whereas 4AP block occurred much more readily at rest with
native channels than when they were activated. These results suggest
that important structural differences between sqKv1A homotetramers and
native squid channels are likely to exist around the external and
internal mouths of the pore.
| |
INTRODUCTION |
|---|
|
|
|---|
Studies of voltage-gated ion channels in the
squid giant axon have contributed to fundamental discoveries such as
the basis of action potential generation (Hodgkin and Huxley, 1952
),
the mechanism of open-channel block (Armstrong, 1969
), and the
existence of gating currents (Armstrong and Bezanilla, 1973
). Although
single channel studies have revealed three species of voltage-gated
K+ channels in the giant axon (Llano et al.,
1988
) and its cell bodies in the giant fiber lobe (GFL) of the stellate
ganglion (Nealey et al., 1993
), the vast majority of the classic,
"delayed-rectifier" K+ conductance
(gK) in this system has been
attributed to a 20 pS channel (Llano and Bookman, 1986
; Perozo et al.,
1991
; Nealey et al., 1993
).
Heterologous expression of a squid cDNA (sqKv1A) isolated from the
stellate-ganglion/GFL complex produces K+
channels in Xenopus oocytes with macroscopic and single
channel properties similar to those of the native 20 pS channel
(Rosenthal et al., 1996
). These biophysical data, along with
localization of sqKv1A transcripts and protein in the giant-axon/GFL
system, strongly support the hypothesis that channels formed by sqKv1A
-subunits underlie the native macroscopic
gK. This assignment is also supported
by the pH-dependence for block of both channel types by
tityustoxin-K
(Ellis et al., 2001
). This feature in sqKv1A is
accounted for by titration of a single histidine residue in the
external turret region.
Although such a stringent set of matches reasonably justifies
identification of sqKv1A as a component of the native channel, it does
not demonstrate that native channels are composed of sqKv1A homotetramers or address whether sqKv1A
-subunits experience different post-translational modifications in the two cases. Functional effects in these cases might be subtle, and the exceptional ability to
study native gK in squid axons and GFL
neurons permits a detailed examination of this fundamental issue.
In this paper we focus on three important functional discrepancies that
exist between sqKv1A channels expressed in Xenopus oocytes
and native gK in giant axons and GFL
neurons. First, external TEA and K+ ions slow
inactivation of sqKv1A channels in oocytes (see also Brock et al.,
2001
) in essentially the same way as that described for classic C-type
inactivation of Shaker B (Choi et al., 1991
; Lopez-Barneo et
al., 1993
; Baukrowitz and Yellen, 1995
) and other Kv1 channels (Yellen,
1998
). However, these agents do not slow inactivation of native
gK (Mathes et al., 1997
). Second, we
report here that chloramine T (Chl-T) accelerates inactivation of
sqKv1A channels and concomitantly leads to irreversible loss of channel activity. Both effects are seen for C-type inactivation with
Shaker B channels (Schlief et al., 1996
). We find that Chl-T
affects inactivation of the native channels differently. Third, we find that 4-aminopyridine (4AP) blocks activated sqKv1A channels far better
than resting channels, as it does with Shaker B channels (see also McCormack et al., 1994
). In contrast, 4AP preferentially blocks resting channels in GFL neurons just as it does in giant axons
(see also Kirsch et al., 1986
). These discrepancies suggest that
structural differences exist in the regions surrounding the external
and internal mouth of the pore in sqKv1A homotetramers versus native channels.
Use of the Xenopus system also facilitated a
mutagenesis-based approach to define inactivation of sqKv1A channels.
Our results provide no evidence for an N-type mechanism and indicate a
conventional C-type process. We also describe the powerful influence of
a particular amino acid of the external turret region on inactivation
kinetics. This residue (H351) is at the position equivalent to F425 in
Shaker B, but it's prominent role in C-type inactivation
has not been widely recognized (Perez-Cornejo, 1999
). Some of these
results have appeared in abstract form (Jerng and Gilly, 1999
).
| |
MATERIALS AND METHODS |
|---|
|
|
|---|
Molecular biology
The plasmid containing sqKv1A cDNA has been previously described
(Rosenthal et al., 1996
). All experiments described here utilized a
version of sqKv1A in which functional expression is enhanced through
two mutations in the amino-terminus that do not alter any known
functional properties (Liu et al., 2001
). Amino acid 5 (Val) was
deleted, and Gly-87 was replaced by Arg in the T1 domain. This
construct (sqKv1A
V5 G87R) is designated as "wild-type" sqKv1A
in the present paper. The N-terminal deletion mutant used (sqKv1A
1-34 G87R) has been previously described (Liu et al., 2001
).
Point mutations were introduced into the sqKv1A
V5 G87R construct
using the QuikChange site-directed mutagenesis method (Stratagene, La
Jolla, CA). Mutations at Ser-375 were confirmed by manual sequencing using a commercial kit based on the dideoxy chain-termination method
(Amersham Biotech Inc., Piscataway, NJ). Mutations at His-351 were
confirmed by automated sequencing (Applied Biosystems, Foster City,
CA). Capped cRNA transcripts were synthesized with the T7 mMessage
mMachine in vitro transcription system (Ambion, Austin, TX) after
linearizing with NotI (New England Biolabs, Beverly, MA).
Oocyte injection and electrophysiology
Stage V and VI oocytes from Xenopus laevis
(Nasco, Fort Atkinson, WI) were defolliculated by treatment with
collagenase (Type IA, Sigma, St. Louis, MO or Type A, Boehringer
Mannheim, Indianapolis, IN) according to described protocols (Iverson
and Rudy, 1990
). cRNA was injected (~0.5-2 ng/oocyte) with a
Nanoject microinjector (Drummond, Broomall, PA). Injected oocytes were
incubated at 16-18°C in standard ND96 (in mM: 96 NaCl, 2 KCl, 1.8 CaCl2, 1 MgCl2, and 5 HEPES, pH 7.5 with NaOH) supplemented with 5 mM sodium pyruvate and 5 µg/ml gentamycin. Whole-oocyte currents were recorded 1-2 days after
injection using a standard two-electrode voltage clamp technique
(GeneClamp 500B, Axon Instruments, Foster City, CA). Microelectrodes
were filled with 3 M KCl (tip resistances of <1.5-2 M
). Currents
were filtered at 2 kHz and sampled at
1 kHz, depending on the length
of depolarization.
The bath solution for two-electrode recordings was either ND96 or a low-chloride version that contained (in mM) 96 sodium gluconate, 2 potassium gluconate, 1.8 CaCl2, 1 MgSO4, and 5 HEPES (pH 7.5). The gluconate salts (and all other reagents) were purchased from Sigma or Aldrich (St. Louis, MO). Chloride replacement was found to greatly improve the stability of sqKv1A currents in two-electrode recordings without altering any properties discussed in this paper. TEA and 4AP replaced sodium on an equimolar basis when these agents were used. To prepare low-chloride TEA-containing solutions, TEA-OH was titrated with gluconic acid.
Cell-attached patch recordings were performed 2-3 days after cRNA
injection using a List LM-EPC7 patch clamp (Medical Systems, Greenvale,
NY) as previously described (Liu et al., 2001
). The bath solution
contained (in mM) 140 KCl, 2 MgCl2, 1 CaCl2, 10 HEPES, and 11 mM EGTA (pH 7.3, adjusted
with KOH). The pipette solution contained (in mM) 125 NaCl, 15 KCl, 6 MgCl2, 1 CaCl2, and 5 HEPES
(pH 7.3, adjusted with NaOH). Patch pipettes were made from Corning
glass 7052 (Garner Glass Company, Claremont, CA) and typically had a
tip resistance of 1-2 M
. Currents were filtered at 2 kHz with an
8-pole Bessel filter (Frequency Devices, Haverhill, MA) and digitized
at 1 kHz.
Linear ionic (leak) and capacity currents were subtracted on-line with
both recording methods using a conventional P/-4 procedure, except in
the case of prepulse protocols designed to assay steady-state inactivation. The latter measurements were carried out with the two-electrode method only when the leak current was <100-150 nA at
the holding potential of
60 or
70 mV. Temperature was 22-24°C for all experiments.
Electrophysiology with squid GFL neurons
Neurons were manually dissociated from the GFL portion of the
stellate ganglion of adult Loligo opalescens collected
locally and maintained as previously described (Gilly et al., 1990
)
with minor modifications. GFL neurons were plated onto 5-mm glass
coverslips (Bellco Glass, Inc., Vineland, NJ) that had been coated with
2% concanavilin A in a manner similar to that originally
described. In addition, 5 mM trehalose was added to the culture medium,
pH was increased to 8.0, and incubation temperature was lowered to 12-14°C. Neurons were normally used within 5-6 days of plating. Properties of K+ currents
(IK) described in this report do not
appear to change over this time, although density of
IK increases somewhat (unpublished data).
Whole-cell recordings were carried out as previously described (Mathes
et al., 1997
). The external solution contained (in mM) 470 NaCl, 10 KCl, 10 CaCl2, 20 MgCl2, 20 MgSO4, 0.2 tetrodotoxin, 10 HEPES (pH 7.8-8.0).
NaCl was replaced with KCl on an equimolar basis for those experiments
with high external K+. The internal solution
contained (in mM) 20 KCl, 50 KF, 80 potassium glutamate, 10 lysine
(titrated to pH 7 with HEPES), 1 EGTA, 1 EDTA, 381 glycine, 291 sucrose, 4 MgATP. Final pH was set to 7.8 with tetramethylammonium hydroxide.
Recordings were carried out at 20-24°C. Holding potential was
80
mV unless otherwise noted. P/-4 subtraction was carried out on-line as
described above. Signals were generally sampled at either 20 kHz (or 1 kHz) and filtered at 6 kHz (or at 2 kHz) with an 8-pole Bessel filter
(LPF-8, Warner Inst., Hamden, CT).
Data acquisition and analysis
Data acquisition and pulse generation used desktop personal computers and either a custom-built interface and software (D. R. Matteson, Dept. of Physiology, University of Maryland) or a commercial package (Digidata 1200A interface and pClamp 7.0; Axon Instruments). Additional data analysis used Sigmaplot (Jandel, San Rafael, CA) and Igor Pro (Wavemetrics, Eugene OR). Results are expressed as means ± SD.
| |
RESULTS |
|---|
|
|
|---|
Activation and inactivation of sqKv1A channels in oocytes
Outward K+ currents
(IK) recorded in a cell-attached patch
from an oocyte expressing sqKv1A channels activate rapidly and
inactivate incompletely to a steady-state level in ~500 ms at room
temperature (Fig. 1 A). The
time course of IK decay due to
inactivation is well described by a single exponential with a time
constant of ~120 ms at all voltages from +10 to +60 mV (fits not
illustrated). This value is about twice that observed at 18°C for
sqKv1A channels expressed in Sf9 cells (Brock et al., 2001
),
but the reasons for this difference are not clear. In neither case do
sqKv1A channels display a biphasic inactivation time course like that
shown by their proposed native counterparts in GFL neurons or giant
axons (Mathes et al., 1997
).
|
The relationship between voltage-dependent activation and steady-state
inactivation for sqKv1A channels in oocytes is illustrated in Fig. 1
B. Conductance (gK) at a
given voltage (V) was determined from the change in
IK amplitude
(
IK) following repolarization at
the time of peak IK to the holding
potential (VH) as
gK =
IK/(V
VH). Values of
gK(V) thus determined were
normalized by maximal gK
(gKmax), and the normalized
gK-V curve (
, Fig. 1
B) is well fit by a fourth-power Boltzmann function with a
voltage midpoint (Va) of
34 mV and a
steepness parameter (sa) of 9 mV/e-fold change. These fits are useful for comparing wild-type and
mutant channels and are not intended to support a specific model of
activation (see below and legend to Table
1).
|
Steady-state inactivation was determined by assaying the amplitude of
IK at +60 mV following a prepulse of
10 s duration to voltages between
80 mV and 0 mV and normalizing
to maximal IK, IKmax (
, Fig. 1 B). This
relationship is adequately described by a first-power Boltzmann
distribution with a midpoint voltage (Vi) of
35 mV and steepness
(si) of 4 mV/e-fold change. Similar results were obtained from two-electrode recordings (see Table 1).
SqKv1A channels do not inactivate by an N-type mechanism
To test the possibility that the N-terminus might contribute to
sqKv1A inactivation (Hoshi et al., 1990
), a genetic truncation mutant
was created (sqKv1A
1-34 G87R) starting at the naturally occurring
Met-35 residue of sqKv1A. This eliminates the N-terminus almost to the
beginning of the T1 domain. Inactivation of these mutant channels is
essentially unchanged (Fig. 1 C), suggesting that
inactivation does not involve a conventional N-terminal element.
This finding is also consistent with the fact that inactivation
properties of sqKv1A channels are virtually identical to those observed
for the naturally occurring splice variants sqKv1B and sqKv1D when
expressed in oocytes (Rosenthal et al., 1997
; Liu et al., 2001
). These
variants possess truncated N-termini with respect to sqKv1A (13 and 34 amino acids, respectively) and have several amino acid differences in
the T1 domain and C-terminus, but they show identical primary
structures from S1 through S6.
In addition, the effect of internal TEA on inactivation was tested for
sqKv1A channels. IK was recorded using
a two-electrode voltage clamp from several oocytes before and after
injecting TEA-Cl to achieve a final internal concentration of 5 mM
(calculated assuming an oocyte diameter of 1 mm). TEA injection reduced
IK by ~75% but did not alter time
course of inactivation (data not shown), as would be expected for a
conventional N-type mechanism (Choi et al., 1991
). This finding, along
with the genetic evidence discussed above, makes it unlikely that
inactivation of sqKv1A channels involves a conventional N-type mechanism.
Effects of external TEA and K+ ions on inactivation kinetics
TEA and K+ ions interact with the external
mouth of Kv1 channels by either blocking or permeating, respectively.
Transient block of the conducting pore by TEA prevents entry of the
channel into the C-inactivated state, and this competition between TEA and inactivation results in slowing of inactivation kinetics (Grissmer and Cahalan, 1989
; Choi et al., 1991
). K+ ions
similarly slow C-type inactivation by stabilizing the open state
(Yellen, 1998
).
External TEA and K+ ions were tested on sqKv1A
channels expressed in oocytes using the two-electrode voltage-clamp. In
agreement with data from Sf9 cells (Brock et al., 2001
), TEA
slowed the rate of inactivation by approximately the same degree as
that observed for IK amplitude
reduction (Fig. 2, A and
B). Elevated concentrations of external
K+ also dramatically slowed inactivation of
sqKv1A channels in oocytes (Fig. 2 C). Inactivation on a
longer time scale was monitored by periodically sampling
IK during 5-s pulses to +60 mV in the presence of external K+ concentrations of 2-98
mM. Data in Fig. 2 D reveal a slowing of 7.6-fold over this
range. In addition, the fraction of non-inactivating IK also increases with increasing
external K+. This latter effect is also seen for
native gK (Mathes et al., 1997
).
|
C-type inactivation of sqKv1A is supported by mutagenesis studies
A mutagenesis approach was also used to test whether a C-type
inactivation mechanism is a property of sqKv1A channels. Point mutations of the sqKv1A
-subunit were introduced at the residue (Ser-375) corresponding to Thr-449 in Shaker B, an amino
acid critical to C-type inactivation (Lopez-Barneo et al., 1993
).
Families of IK records from
cell-attached patches are illustrated in Fig. 3 for wild-type SqKv1A (Fig. 3
A) and for substitutions of Ser-375 by Thr (S375T, Fig. 3
B) and by Val (S375V, Fig. 3 C). Both
substitutions dramatically slow inactivation, and the time course of
IK at +60 mV is compared for
wild-type, S375T, and S375V channels in Fig. 3 D. Similar
results were obtained with two-electrode recordings. As indicated in
Table 1, these effects on inactivation kinetics are accompanied by only
small changes in activation and steady-state inactivation parameters
(see Table 1).
|
These results are similar to those reported for the same amino acids at
position 449 of Shaker B. C-type inactivation is very fast
with Ser at position 449 (Schlief et al., 1996
), Val-449 produces the
slowest inactivation (Lopez-Barneo et al., 1993
), and the
Shaker B wild-type Thr-449 is intermediate. Thus, in
agreement with the pharmacological findings discussed above, our
mutational analysis supports a C-type inactivation mechanism for sqKv1A
channels that is fundamentally similar to that in Shaker B.
Residue 351 of the sqKv1A
-subunit is also critical to C-type
inactivation
Titration of a histidine residue (His-351) underlies the
pH-sensitivity of block of sqKv1A channels by tityustoxin-K
(Ellis et al., 2001
). This residue corresponds to Phe-425 of Shaker
B, and substitution of His at this site (F425H) leads to pH-dependent charybdotoxin binding and increases the pH-sensitivity of C-type inactivation (Perez-Cornejo et al., 1998
; Perez-Cornejo, 1999
; Thompson
and Begenisich, 2000
). Because the turret and P-region of
Shaker B and sqKv1A are highly conserved, we created a
series of amino acid substitutions for His-351 to test the importance of this position to C-type inactivation.
Fig. 4 A presents results for the indicated mutants; in each case, IK at +60 mV is illustrated (two-electrode recordings). It is clear that the nature of the amino acid at position 351 has a profound influence on the rate of inactivation (see Table 1). Bulky, hydrophobic residues (H351W and H351F) lead to faster inactivation in comparison to the wild-type channels. Glycine (H351G), a small, polar residue, displays a rate similar to wild-type channels, but substitution by nonpolar alanine (H351A) leads to a marked slowing (Table 1). Charged residues, both acidic (H351D) and basic (H351K) also greatly slow inactivation. No functional expression was obtained with H351N and H351C (not illustrated). Data in Table 1 indicate that none of the H351 substitutions have large effects on activation, suggesting that the amino acid at this position is directly influencing the inactivation process.
|
Sensitivity of wild-type sqKv1A channels and of H351 mutants to oxidation by chloramine-T: a link to C-type inactivation
Studies of Shaker B channels lacking N-type
inactivation show that treatment by the oxidant chloramine T (Chl-T)
leads to a progressive and irreversible reduction of peak
IK ("rundown") with a time course
that is positively correlated to Chl-T concentration and to the rate of
C-type inactivation (Schlief et al., 1996
). Differential sensitivity to
Chl-T treatment of the H351 mutants was therefore tested as a
means of associating the functional changes observed for these
mutations with modification of a C-type inactivation mechanism.
IK from oocytes expressing wild-type
sqKv1A channels exhibits rundown following Chl-T application, as
monitored by delivering 700-ms pulses to +60 mV every 41 s, an
interval sufficiently long to allow complete recovery from inactivation
(Fig. 5 A). The time course
was analyzed by normalizing peak IK at
each time, IK(t), to the
last pulse before Chl-T application,
IK(0). Examples of data and
single-exponential fits for several Chl-T concentrations are shown in
Fig. 5 B. Time constants for 250 µM (
), 500 µM (
), and 1 mM Chl-T (
) were respectively 462 ± 109 s
(n = 3), 295 ± 57 s (n = 3),
and 192 ± 16 s (n = 3). At a concentration
of 50 µM (
) Chl-T decreased peak
IK only by ~10% after 13 min, and this concentration thus represents an approximate "threshold" for a
detectable effect.
|
This experiment was also carried out with the H351 mutants using 250 µM Chl-T (Fig. 4 B). For H351F, the slightly faster
inactivation (relative to wild-type) was associated with faster
IK rundown. Conversely, rundown was
much slower in those mutants with slowed inactivation (H351A, H351D,
and H351K). Glycine appears to be an exception, because rundown is
slower than that of wild-type, even though inactivation is fairly
normal. A similar correlation between the kinetics of Chl-T-induced
rundown and inactivation was described for C-type inactivation in
Shaker B (Schlief et al., 1996
). Our results thus support
the idea that the amino acid at position 351 plays an important role in
C-type inactivation of sqKv1A channels.
Differential effects of Chl-T treatment on inactivation of sqKv1A and native K+ channels
Studies on Shaker B channels have also indicated that
the rate of C-type inactivation is accelerated by application of Chl-T, and this effect is manifested by the appearance of a rapidly
inactivating component (
~ 25 ms; Schlief et al., 1996
).
Inactivation of sqKv1A channels was also accelerated following Chl-T
application, as indicated by comparison of
IK traces recorded before application and midway during the rundown period (Fig. 5 C,
inset; dotted trace has been scaled). Before application of
Chl-T, the time course of IK decay is
well fit by a single exponential with a time constant of ~150 ms, but
after treatment, a biexponential fit was necessary with half of the
fractional amplitude in a rapidly inactivating component. This
analysis, carried out on four separate experiments, yielded the
following parameters (means ± SD): fast component fractional
amplitude (AF) = 0.45 ± 0.02 and time constant (
F) = 38 ± 4 ms; slow component amplitude (AS) = 0.45 ± 0.02 and time constant (
S) = 150 ± 15 ms; non-inactivating fractional amplitude
(ANI) = 0.04 ± 0.02.
Development of the rapidly inactivating component during Chl-T treatment does not occur with the same time course as IK rundown (compare Fig. 5, B and C). The time course of the increase in AF in 250 µM Chl-T is well described with a single exponential with a time constant of ~146 s (Fig. 5 C, solid curve), whereas rundown at this concentration is about three times slower (see above). This suggests that the loss of IK and the appearance of the rapidly inactivating component are not due to a single Chl-T-induced modification.
Experiments similar to those described above were also carried out with
GFL neurons. Although Chl-T induces IK
rundown in a way similar to that described above for sqKv1A, the time
course of inactivation in GFL neurons is not accelerated. Fig.
6 A shows the effect of 125 µM Chl-T on peak IK amplitude (
;
500 ms pulses to +40 mV) normalized to the last measurement before
Chl-T application (time 0). The time course of
IK rundown can be described by a single exponential with a time constant of 490 s (open
symbols; fit not shown), a value comparable to that observed for
250 µM Chl-T acting on sqKv1A.
|
Data are also shown in Fig. 6 A for another experiment in which Chl-T was sequentially applied at increasing concentrations of 5, 10, and 50 µM; 50 µM Chl-T induces a detectable rundown of IK that progresses with an estimated time constant of ~1900 s (fit not illustrated), and this "threshold" concentration is thus similar to that observed for sqKv1A.
Despite this similarity in the effect of Chl-T on native and cloned
squid channels, Chl-T treatment altered the time course of inactivation
of native IK in a manner essentially
opposite to that described above for sqKv1A and Shaker B. Fig. 6 B shows IK obtained
before application of 125 µM Chl-T. Under the recording conditions
used here (+40 mV; 22°C) the majority of inactivation is fast (Mathes
et al., 1997
), and a double-exponential fit of the pre Chl-T trace is
illustrated (fast AF = 25.5 nA and
F = 43.3 ms; slow
AS = 12.1 nA and
S = 218 ms; non-inactivating
ANI = 15.1 nA). Following Chl-T
treatment, the illustrated fit corresponds to a reduction of
AF by a factor of 0.36 with much
smaller amplitude reductions for the slowly and non-inactivating
fractions (0.82 and 0.72, respectively). Neither fast nor slow time
constants were significantly changed, however (41.9 ms and 240 ms,
respectively). Similar results were obtained in several other
experiments, although in some cases all components were reduced more
equally. At any rate, the rapidly inactivating component of native
IK is clearly decreased by Chl-T,
unlike the results with sqKv1A channels. In both cases, sensitivity of
inactivation kinetics to external TEA or K+ is
not qualitatively altered by Chl-T treatment (data not illustrated).
Comparison of the actions of 4AP on native K+ channels and sqKv1A expressed in oocytes
Characterization of 4AP block of voltage-gated
K+ channels was originally carried out on squid
giant axons, where it was found that channels were blocked at typical
negative holding potentials and depolarizing voltage steps resulted in
a time- and voltage-dependent relief of block (Yeh et al., 1976
; Kirsch
et al., 1986
). Block could be restored by prolonged repolarization to
negative potentials. These authors concluded that 4AP binds to the
K+ channels in a resting, closed state that was
at an intermediate position in the activation pathway and thereby
hinders activation from progressing beyond this state toward channel opening.
These early studies were hampered by the inability to utilize long voltage-clamp steps with the axial-wire voltage-clamp method, and therefore many of the measurements were not straightforward. We have reexamined the actions of 4AP on the same native channels in GFL neurons using whole-cell voltage-clamp, and these results can thus be more directly compared with those on cloned channels expressed in oocytes.
Fig. 7 A confirms that a low
concentration of 4AP (0.1 mM) blocks most of the native GFL
K+ channels at
100 mV in the absence of any
activating pulses. The first trace in 4AP was recorded 7 min after
changing solutions with the cell continuously held at
100 mV (no
intervening pulses). Three additional traces taken at 1-min intervals
are also illustrated. The small additional decrease was typical, but
this effect was not explored in detail.
|
SqKv1A channels in oocytes display basically the opposite
state-dependency for 4AP-block. Thus, resting channels are insensitive and activation enhances block. Application of 0.1 mM 4AP to
non-inactivating S375V channels at
80 mV for 7 min with no
intervening pulses did not affect peak
IK at 0 mV (fraction blocked = 0.04 ± 0.07, n = 4). At much higher 4AP
concentrations (5-10 mM) block of resting sqKv1A channels did occur
(see also below).
Activation of sqKv1A channels markedly enhances the ability of 4AP to
block. Exposure of non-inactivating sqKv1A S375V channels to 0.5 mM 4AP
at
80 mV for >2 min produced no decrease in peak IK for the first test pulse to
20 mV
(Fig. 7 C; compare control and trace
1). IK appears to
inactivate, but this reflects time-dependent block of activated
channels by 4AP. After three more pulses at 2-min intervals, a steady
level of block is attained (fractional block of peak
IK = 0.59 ± 0.03, n = 3). Similar results were obtained with wild-type
sqKv1A channels.
Relief of 4AP block produced by activation
Voltage- and time-dependent relief from 4AP block is demonstrated in Fig. 8 for native GFL K+ channels. At 0 mV (Fig. 8 A) 0.05 mM 4AP blocks most IK, and there is little sign of relief during the pulse. However, at +70 mV (Fig. 8 B) there is a marked rise in IK from an initial level that reflects channels that were not blocked at the start of the pulse. This level is difficult to define unambiguously, because relief is so fast, but it lies somewhere below the left-pointing arrowhead. Channels that are relieved from block can apparently inactivate, and the overall IK time course is thus dictated by both the rates of relief of block and of inactivation. Relief of 4AP block with sqKv1A channels is much slower and less pronounced, only becoming apparent at very positive voltages, i.e., above >+80 mV (not illustrated). This phenomenon was not studied in detail.
|
Reestablishment of 4AP block of native channels following activation-dependent relief
Fig. 9 A shows the slow
activation due to relief of block by 0.01 mM 4AP and subsequent
inactivation of native IK in a GFL neuron at +40 mV as described in conjunction with Fig. 8. The first 30 ms of another pulse in 4AP is illustrated on an expanded time base in
Fig. 9 B (pulse 1), and steady-state
IK at 750 ms is indicated (
). After
repolarization to
80 mV for 2 s, a second pulse to +40 mV
resulted in a rapidly activating IK
(pulse 2, right half of Fig. 9 B) that is nearly
as large as the pre-4AP control (Fig. 9 A).
|
This phenomenon was seen in every GFL neuron thus studied and is
similar to the pattern reported for native channels underlying Ito in mammalian heart (Campbell et
al., 1993
). The "extra" peak IK in
pulse 2 appears to represent channels that have become unblocked during
pulse 1, which then inactivate. Following repolarization, these
channels become available to contribute to
IK as they recover from
inactivation
provided pulse 2 is delivered before recovered channels
can be blocked again by 4AP at the resting potential. Thus, by varying
the interval between pulses 1 and 2, an estimate of the time course of
resting-channel block can be obtained. Results using this approach from
two cells in 40 mm external K+ (
) and in 500 (
) mM K+ are illustrated in Fig. 9
C, and a time constant of ~4 s is evident. High external
K+ does not appreciably affect the rate of block
of resting native channels.
Only a few experiments of this type were carried out on oocytes
expressing wild-type sqKv1A channels, but there was no sign of
reestablishment of resting block at
70 mV in the presence of 4AP
concentrations as high as 1 mM for inter-pulse intervals of 200 s
(not illustrated). This is consistent with poor block of resting sqKv1A
channels as discussed above.
Comparison of 4AP-affinity for native and sqKv1A channels
To compare the affinities of sqKv1A and native channels for 4AP at
the holding potential we carried out dose-response analysis for both,
and results are illustrated in Fig. 10.
Measurements of peak IK for native
channels (Fig. 10 A) used brief pulses (5 ms) to 0 mV to
minimize relief of block after maximal block was established, as
described for Fig. 7 A. This gives an estimate of the
affinity for the resting channels. The 4AP-affinity of resting sqKv1A
channels was carried out using similar test pulses, but these were the
first pulses after applying a given concentration of 4AP and waiting
5-7 min (Fig. 10 B). To measure 4AP affinity of activated
sqKv1A channels, test pulses were preceded by four to five long pulses
(750 ms) to
10 mV to maximize the fraction of channels blocked at the
holding potential. Test pulses were delivered 10-20 s after the final
"conditioning" pulse (Fig. 10 C).
|
Hill-plot analysis (Fig. 10 D) yields Kd values of 5 µM for resting native channels, 3.2 mM for resting sqKv1A, and 75 µM for activated sqKv1A. Although waiting for a longer period before the first pulse would reduce the apparent Kd for resting sqKv1A channels, it is unlikely that the large difference for resting native versus sqKv1A channels would be drastically affected.
| |
DISCUSSION |
|---|
|
|
|---|
In this paper we positively identify the inactivation mechanism of
sqKv1A channels as being C-type with both mutagenesis and pharmacological tests using TEA, K+, and Chl-T.
All of these agents interact with C-type inactivation in
Shaker B channels in characteristic ways that are clearly
evident with sqKv1A channels. Results in this paper add to and greatly expand previous studies (Mathes et al., 1997
; Brock et al., 2001
) in
demonstrating significant disparities in the actions of each of these
pharmacological agents for heterologously expressed sqKv1A channels
versus the native "delayed-rectifier"
gK in squid GFL neurons and giant
axons. Furthermore, we find that 4AP displays greatly different
affinities for sqKv1A and native channels when they are in the resting
state. All of these functional discrepancies implicate structural
differences in the external and internal mouths of the pore. We are
unaware of examples of any post-translational modifications that
produce such effects, and consider such hypothetical modifications to
be unlikely.
Taken together, these findings do not support the idea that the native
channel in the giant-axon/GFL system is a homotetramer composed of
sqKv1A
-subunits. Although we cannot at present account for
the mechanistic origin of the observed differences, much has been
learned from the journey.
C-type inactivation of sqKv1A channels
Pharmacological results from Xenopus oocytes and
Sf9 cells suggest that sqKv1A channels inactivate by a
C-type mechanism like that found in Shaker B and other Kv1
channels. This assertion was substantiated by mutational analyses in
the present study. Deletion of the amino-terminus nearly to the start
of the T1 domain has no apparent affect on inactivation, making a
conventional N-type mechanism highly improbable. Molecular
rearrangements underlying C-type inactivation involve many residues of
the turret-pore region (Yellen, 1998
; Gandhi et al., 2000
; Larsson and
Elinder, 2000
), and several positions are particularly critical. One of
these, residue 449 of Shaker B, flanks the outer mouth of
the pore (Doyle et al., 1998
), and substitution of the wild-type
threonine (T449) with serine (T449S) or valine (T449V) substantially
accelerates or impedes inactivation, respectively (Schlief et al.,
1996
; Lopez-Barneo et al., 1993
). Inactivation of sqKv1A channels shows
the same pattern in comparing wild-type serine at the homologous
position (S375) with the mutations S375T and S375V.
We have identified another position that is equally critical to
inactivation of sqKv1A channels. Substitution of histidine 351 (H351)
with a variety of amino acids profoundly affects inactivation. Rates of
inactivation for these mutants show a positive correlation with the
rate of IK rundown induced by Chl-T,
similar to the pattern found with T449 mutations in Shaker B
(Schlief et al., 1996
). This implicates H351 with a C-type inactivation
mechanism in sqKv1A, and the analogous residue in Shaker B
(F425) is also probably important (Perez-Cornejo, 1999
).
Mutations at this turret position, at least in sqKv1A, can clearly dominate the influence of the critical residue Ser-375 (Thr-449 of Shaker B) on inactivation kinetics. This feature allows controlled manipulation of C-type inactivation kinetics without directly altering critical residues in the external mouth of the pore, and such an ability may be useful in future studies of the role of permeating and blocking ions in C-type inactivation.
Analysis of inactivation kinetics for the series of H351 mutants reveals a general trend in which charged and small, hydrophobic residues at this position disrupt inactivation, and large aromatic residues accelerate it (Fig. 4 A). Wild-type histidine presents an exception to this generalization, however, because inactivation is faster at low pH when H351 would be expected to be charged (unpublished data). Difficulty in drawing a definitive correlation between amino acid side chain structure and inactivation rate probably reflects the complex and relatively large-scale molecular motions involved in C-type inactivation.
Effects of external TEA and K+ ions on inactivation of sqKv1A versus native K+ channels
Properties of native channels in GFL neurons differ significantly
from those of sqKv1A in regard to the effects of external TEA and
K+ ions on inactivation. Neither external TEA nor
K+ slows inactivation of the native channel
(Mathes et al., 1997
; Brock et al., 2001
), whereas both agents do so in
the case of sqKv1A. This qualitative difference is not due to the
different ionic conditions (i.e., ionic strength; divalent cation or
potassium concentrations) in the experimental solutions used for GFL
neurons versus amphibian or insect heterologous expression systems
(Brock et al., 2001
and unpublished data).
The inability of TEA to slow inactivation does not preclude a C-type
mechanism in the native channels, however. External TEA does not slow
rapid C-type inactivation in Shaker B channels with certain
mutations in the outer mouth of the pore (e.g., T449K; Molina et al.,
1997
). Although such a situation might well occur in the native squid
channel, it is difficult to see how it would arise if the channels were
composed of sqKv1A homotetramers.
External K+ ions also slow C-type inactivation,
at least in Kv1 channels showing rapid inactivation in low
K+, and this effect appears to be universal in
cloned Kv1 channels (Yellen, 1998
). In Shaker B,
K+ ions appear to interact with the inactivation
mechanism through occupancy of a binding site located between positions
T441 and T449 in the primary sequence (Baukrowitz and Yellen, 1996
;
Harris et al., 1998
). Amino acids at these nine positions are
universally conserved in Kv1
-subunits, but how occupancy of this
K+-binding site is coupled to movements of
residues that influence C-type inactivation is not known.
High external K+ does alter inactivation of both
native and sqKv1A channels in one qualitatively similar way.
Inactivation is incomplete in both channel types, and the fraction of
non-inactivating IK increases in
elevated K+ concentrations (Fig. 2 D
of this paper and Fig. 11 A of Mathes et al., 1997
). Thus,
permeating K+ ions appear to stabilize the open
state in the native channel and in sqKv1A and other Kv1 members, but
the precise mechanisms coupling K+ occupancy to
inactivation kinetics must still differ in some way.
Differential effects of Chl-T on IK from native and sqKv1A channels
Chl-T oxidizes methionine and cysteine residues. In
Shaker B
6-46 acceleration of inactivation by Chl-T has
been attributed to oxidation of Met-448 in the outer mouth of the pore
(Schlief et al., 1996
), but other unidentified residues are also
involved in the rundown phenomenon. Our data for sqKv1A showing
different rates for the appearance of the rapidly inactivating
component of IK and for the loss of
IK are consistent with this position.
Treatment with Chl-T does not accelerate inactivation of the native channel in a comparable way, and actually reduces the amount of rapidly inactivating IK in relation to the non-inactivating component. This results in an overall slowing of inactivation in GFL cells after Chl-T treatment, and inactivation kinetics after treatment remain insensitive to external TEA and K+ ions (unpublished data). Thus, Chl-T treatment does not confer sqKv1A-like properties to native channels. Alternatively, it could be argued that oxidation of M374 of sqKv1A (equivalent to M448 in Shaker B) by Chl-T induces a biphasic inactivation process that is similar to that seen with native IK. This similarity is likely to be superficial, however, because kinetics of sqKv1A channels remain sensitive to external K+ after treatment with Chl-T (unpublished data).
At present, the significance of the contrasting effects of Chl-T on inactivation kinetics in native versus sqKv1A remains unclear. Presumably, Chl-T is able to oxidize the relevant methionine residue (universally conserved in Kv1 members) in both cases, but the molecular mechanisms that couple this event to other residues controlling C-type inactivation would appear to differ. The complex effects of Chl-T and multiple sites of action make speculation concerning such differences premature.
Differential state-dependencies of block by 4AP
In squid giant axons and GFL neurons, 4AP blocks resting channels
at very negative holding potentials, and block is rapidly relieved by
strong depolarization (Yeh et al., 1976
; Kirsch and Narahashi, 1983
;
Kirsch et al., 1986
; this study). 4AP is a poor blocker of resting
sqKv1A channels, and activation dramatically enhances block. In this
case, 4AP appears to remain "trapped" in its blocking position
following repolarization (Armstrong and Loboda, 2001
).
These observations suggest the observed state-dependencies of 4AP block
may be a product of differential accessibility of the 4AP binding site.
However, it is difficult to rule out a difference in spontaneous
openings at highly negative voltages in the two channel types as a
contributing factor. Although we do not have accurate measurements of
open probability for either channel type at
80 to
100 mV, the
similarity of the macroscopic
gK-V relations (Brock et
al., 2001
) suggest that it must be extremely low in both cases. It
seems unlikely that this factor alone could account for the potent
block of resting native channels at
80 mV by 0.1 mM 4AP (Fig. 9
B) and essentially no block under similar conditions with sqKv1A.
To our knowledge, all other Kv1 homotetramers show the sqKv1A-type of
pattern for 4AP block (McCormack et al., 1994
; Stephens et al., 1994
;
Russell et al., 1994
; Yao and Tseng, 1994
; Yamane et al., 1995
) as do
native channels in lymphocytes (Kv1.3; Choquet and Korn, 1992
). A
similar situation exists with Kv2.1 (Kirsch and Drewe, 1993
). However,
Kv3.1 (Kirsch and Drew; 1993
) and Kv4 members (Tseng et al., 1996
;
Jerng et al., 1999
) show "resting-channel" block, as does the
putative native Kv4 channel responsible for calcium-independent
transient outward K+ current
(Ito) in ventricular myocytes
(Campbell et al., 1993
).
It is presently unclear what gives rise to these differences.
Mutagenesis studies with Kv2.1 and Kv3.1 (Kirsch et al., 1993
) suggest
that 4AP interacts with residues localized to the cytoplasmic halves of
transmembrane segments S5 and S6. The relevant S6 residues correspond
to positions 469-476 of Shaker B, and this short stretch of
amino acids straddles a pair of prolines (P473 and P475 in Shaker B) near the intracellular end of the pore (Doyle et
al., 1998
) that may be intimately involved with activation gating (Liu et al., 1997
; Yellen, 1998
). Although it is likely that this region of
the inner pore is involved in state-dependent block by 4AP, mechanistic
details and the role of S5 residues are presently unknown.
Implications for the molecular identification of squid and other native K+ channels
Voltage-gated channels are multi-subunit, integral membrane
proteins and are thus exposed to a variety of extracellular and cytoplasmic factors and elements in the lipid bilayer. Biophysical and
pharmacological properties of these channels are defined largely, but
no means entirely, by the four
-subunits that form the channel proper. Heteromultimers may form by combination of different
-subunits belonging to the same subfamily, e.g., Kv1 (Covarrubias et
al., 1991
; Li et al., 1992
; Xu et al., 1995
), and specific functional properties of heteromultimers can be different than those in the corresponding homotetramers (Rupersberg et al., 1990
; Isacoff et
al., 1990
) and are usually intermediate in nature (MacKinnon, 1991
;
MacKinnon et al., 1993
).
Discrepancies between inactivation properties of native
K+ channels in GFL neurons and sqKv1A
homotetramers in oocytes as described in this paper consistently
implicate structural features in the outer mouth of the conducting
pore. Primary determinants of the relevant properties are thought to be
specific residues on the Kv1
-subunits themselves. We therefore
favor the idea that the native squid channel in question is formed by
sqKv1A
-subunits in combination with another squid Kv1 member that
confers a unique set of properties to the heteromultimers.
It is particularly surprising that the native channels do not show the
"standard" Kv1-type of 4AP sensitivity, i.e., poor block under
resting conditions. However, the cited studies were all carried out on
Kv1 homotetramers, and 4AP block of heteromultimers has not been
extensively studied. It is extremely unlikely that the native squid
channel is actually a Kv3 or Kv4 member that is sensitive to 4AP at
rest. The sensitivity of native channels to
S-nitrosodithiothreitol (a Kv1-specific blocker; Brock and Gilly, 2001
), the pH-dependence of block by tityustoxin-K
(Ellis et
al., 2001
), and substantial molecular and biochemical evidence (see
Introduction) provide compelling evidence that the native channel is a
Kv1 type. However, preliminary evidence has revealed another squid Kv1
-subunit expressed in the giant fiber lobe that is not sensitive to
tityustoxin or external TEA (Jerng et al., 2001
), potentially
consistent with the heteromultimer hypothesis. Present work is directed
at exploring this possibility. An alternative idea that the native
squid channel is a heteromultimer of sqKv1A and a squid Kv3 or Kv4
member has no foundation in the literature whatsoever.
In reality, actual structural differences present in a squid Kv1
heteromultimer need not be major to account for observed functional
discrepancies. For example, inactivation in the presence of TEA could
occur from a partially activated but closed state or from a blocked
state more readily in the native channels than in sqKv1A. Such behavior
would be consistent with the prominent flickering characteristic of
single channel activity of both channel types (Perozo et al., 1991
;
Nealey et al., 1993
; Rosenthal et al., 1996
). This might mask the
effect of TEA on inactivation kinetics in native channels (see also
Jerng and Covarrubias, 1997
; Jerng et al., 1999
), even though the
relevant structural difference might be subtle.
Equating a cloned channel with its supposed native counterpart
necessitates stringent comparisons of both functional and
pharmacological characteristics. The native channel can be indicated to
be a homotetramer composed of a specific
-subunit only when a suite
of these properties is closely matched. Exactly how close this match
needs to be to make a definitive conclusion is difficult to define.
Formation of heteromultimeric channels in native tissues greatly
complicates such identifications, however, and rigorous functional
comparison of channels in heterologous expression systems and in native
neurons remains challenging.
| |
ACKNOWLEDGMENTS |
|---|
We thank Dr. T. I. Liu for conducting some experiments and Jeni Boustani for generating several of the H351 mutants described in this paper. We are also grateful to Dr. Manuel Covarrubias for critical reading of this manuscript.
This work was supported by National Institutes of Health Grant NS-17510.
| |
FOOTNOTES |
|---|
.
Address reprint requests to W. F. Gilly, Hopkins Marine Station, Pacific Grove, CA 93950. Tel.: 831-655-6220; Fax: 831-655-6220; E-mail: lignje{at}stanford.edu.
Submitted November 6, 2001, and accepted for publication February 15, 2002.
| |
REFERENCES |
|---|
|
|
|---|
-subunits may contribute to properties of native channels in the squid giant axon system.
Biophys. J.
80:434a. (Abstr.).