| HOME | HELP | FEEDBACK | SUBSCRIPTIONS | ARCHIVE | SEARCH | TABLE OF CONTENTS |
Biophys J, November 2002, p. 2560-2574, Vol. 83, No. 5
*Department of Neurosciences, Ottawa Health Research Institute, and
Department of Medicine, University of Ottawa, Ottawa,
Ontario K1Y 4E9, Canada
| |
ABSTRACT |
|---|
|
|
|---|
Mechanosensitivity in voltage-gated calcium channels
could be an asset to calcium signaling in healthy cells or a liability during trauma. Recombinant N-type channels expressed in HEK cells revealed a spectrum of mechano-responses. When hydrostatic pressure inflated cells under whole-cell clamp, capacitance was unchanged, but
peak current reversibly increased ~1.5-fold, correlating with inflation, not applied pressure. Additionally, stretch transiently increased the open-state inactivation rate, irreversibly increased the
closed-state inactivation rate, and left-shifted inactivation without
affecting the activation curve or rate. Irreversible mechano-responses proved to be mechanically accelerated components of run-down; they were
not evident in cell-attached recordings where, however, reversible
stretch-induced increases in peak current persisted. T-type channels
(
1I subunit only) were mechano-insensitive when expressed alone or when coexpressed with N-type channels
(
1B and two auxiliary subunits) and costimulated with
stretch that augmented N-type current. Along with the cell-attached
results, this differential effect indicates that N-type
mechanosensitivity did not depend on the recording situation. The
insensitivity of T-type currents to stretch suggested that N-type
mechano-responses might arise from primary/auxiliary subunit
interactions. However, in single-channel recordings, N-type currents
exhibited reversible stretch-induced increases in
NPo whether the
1B subunit
was expressed alone or with auxiliary subunits. These findings set the
stage for the molecular dissection of calcium current mechanosensitivity.
| |
INTRODUCTION |
|---|
|
|
|---|
Calcium influx through voltage-gated calcium
channels is essential in many neuronal functions. The influx has
immediate effects such as neurotransmitter release and the shaping of
action potentials and firing patterns, plus long-term effects mediated
via calcium-sensitive enzymes that regulate gene transcription, axonal
outgrowth, neuronal migration, and more. Based on electrophysiological
and pharmacological properties, different types of calcium channels
(designated L-, N-, P-, Q-, R-, and T-type) have been distinguished
(Moreno Davila, 1999
; Catterall, 2000
). Consistent with their central
role in signal transduction, Ca2+ channels are
heavily modulated.
Diverse unidentified, identified, and cloned channels from organisms as
different as bacteria, plants, frogs, and rats exhibit mechanosensitive
responses (Hamill and Martinac, 2001
). The first evidence that calcium
channels feel and respond to membrane stretch came from whole-cell
voltage clamp of arterial myocytes (Langton, 1993
), and evidence has
subsequently accumulated that L-type currents in cardiac (Matsuda et
al., 1996
), gastric (Xu et al., 1996
), arterial (Ruiz-Velasco et al.,
1996
; Kimura et al., 2000
), and intestinal (Holm et al., 2000
) smooth
muscle and also pituitary cells (Matzner et al., 1996
) and osteoblastic
cells (Ryder and Duncan, 2001
), increase with stretch and/or shear.
However, the channels involved have been molecularly indeterminate, and
morphologically diverse native cells have been used in conjunction with
assorted mechanical stimuli (hydrostatic swelling, osmotic swelling,
and extracellular perfusion) whose effects on cell geometry were not cross-correlated against the ongoing electrophysiological
mechano-responses.
Here, we address calcium channel mechanosensitivity in a recombinant
system. Expression of specific proteins, human brain N-type and rat
brain T-type, in undifferentiated clonal cells (HEK cells) provided a
standard cell morphology. Studying recombinant N-type was preferable to
L-types because for N-type in HEK cells, inactivation is not mediated
by the divalent charge carrier (Patil et al., 1998
; Jones et al.,
1999
). During whole-cell recording, with inflation (positive pipette
pressure) as the mechanostimulus, cell shape and pressure were
continually monitored. Invariably, in cells that inflated, reversible
and irreversible mechanosensitive changes occurred for the N-type
currents. T-type currents made no response, a differential
responsiveness that was surprising but was confirmed in cell-attached experiments.
| |
MATERIALS AND METHODS |
|---|
|
|
|---|
Constructs
Human embryonic kidney T-antigen-transformed (HEK-tsA201) cells
were provided by G. Zamponi (University of Calgary, Calgary, AB). Human
embryonic kidney (HEK 293) cells stably expressing the rat T-type
Ca2+ channel (
1I) were
obtained from E. Perez-Reyes (University of Virginia, Charlottesville,
VA). This version of the rat
1I
Ca2+ channel (GenBank accession number AF086827)
used to generate this stable cell line is a C-terminally truncated
version of the predicted full-length rat
1I
Ca2+ channel and appears to be missing a short
section at the 3' end of the coding sequence. This C-terminal
truncation appears to have little functional effect on the
electrophysiological properties of
1I (Lee et
al., 1999
). Human brain cDNAs encoding
1B,
1b,
2-
subunits
(N-type calcium channel) were obtained from M. W. McEnery (Case
Western Reserve, Cleveland, OH). The cDNA for the enhanced green
fluorescent protein was provided by G. Zamponi.
Cell culture and transient transfection
Cell lines (<20 passages) were maintained in Dulbecco's
modified Eagle's medium (DMEM) with 10% fetal bovine serum and 1% penicillin/streptomycin at 37°C/5% CO2. To sustain
stable expression of rat
1I, 1 mg/ml active
geneticin (GIBCO-BRL, Burlington, Ontario, Canada) was added to the
medium. Cells were grown to 80% confluency, split with 0.5 ml of
trypsin-EDTA (1×) per 25-cm2 flask, and plated
at 10% confluency on 12-mm round glass coverslips. The next day, using
a standard calcium phosphate protocol, we transiently transfected cells
with cDNAs for human brain
1B,
1b, and
2-
subunits plus enhanced green fluorescent protein in a molar ratio of
3:3:3:2 (usually 6 µg/µl for each subunit, but for single-channel
recordings from cells expressing all subunits, only 1 µg/µl/subunit). After 8-12 h, cells were washed with Dulbecco's modified Eagle's medium, allowed to recover for 12 h, and then incubated at 28°C for 1-3 days before recording. Products for cell
line maintenance were obtained from GIBCO-BRL, and chemicals for
recording solutions were purchased from Sigma Chemical Co. (St. Louis, MO).
Electrophysiology
Whole-cell and cell-attached patch clamp (Hamill et al., 1981
)
currents were recorded 36 h after transfection from isolated enhanced green fluorescent protein-expressing cells that were round or
eye-shaped. Coverslips were attached to a chamber (Warner Instrument
Corp., Hamden, CT) bottom with silicone grease. Recordings were
obtained at room temperature (21-23°C) with an Axopatch-1D (Axon
Instruments, Foster City, CA). Patch pipettes, made of borosilicate (N51A Garner, Claremont, CA; 1.15-mm inner and 1.65-mm outer diameter) had resistances of 1-3 M
when fire-polished for the whole-cell configuration. Electrode capacitance was compensated before disrupting the patch, with the amplifier's fast transient cancellation circuits. Series resistance was compensated up to 70% in all experiments except
those designed for monitoring membrane area (see next section) and was
routinely checked during the course of experiments. Currents were
filtered at 1 kHz. Leak current was subtracted by a P/-4 protocol in
the data acquisition software (pClamp6, Axon Instruments). Pipettes for
cell-attached recording were coated with Sylgard (Sylgard 184, Dow
Corning, Wiesbaden, Germany) and fire polished to achieve 4-5 M
with 100 mM BaCl2 or higher in the case of
single-channel recordings. Patches with low apparent channel density
were chosen for experiments, but the brevity of unitary events
prevented us from ascertaining N, the number of functional
channels in any patch, with certainty. Pipette pressure was applied and
monitored with a transducer (DPM-1B, Bio-Tek, Winooski, VT). Unchanging baseline currents during mechanostimulation indicated the cells did not
exhibit endogenous mechanosensitive currents under our recording
conditions. The presynaptic action potential (AP) recorded by Borst et
al. (1995)
was scanned, digitized, and scaled for use as a waveform for
AP clamp recordings.
Membrane capacitance (Cm) and series resistance (Ra) measurements with and without cell inflation
To simultaneously monitor membrane area and ionic current,
Cm,
Ra, and
IBa were obtained applying a
double-voltage-step protocol (a 4-ms step from
90 to
70 mV, then a
240-ms step from
90 to +10 mV). We applied an off-line analysis
method using the following equations from Pappone and Lee (1996)
:
Ra =
/C and
Cm =
Q + Iss
/Vp.
Capacitative charge was measured from the integral of the current
transient (
Q). To correct for the exponential rise of the
voltage step, all current Iss was
integrated and summed with a component equal to
Iss
.
Vp is the amplitude of the applied voltage step (20 mV); Iss is the
current measured at steady state with respect to baseline before the
step; and
, the decay time constant of the capacitative transient,
is calculated according to I(t) = (Io
Iss)exp(
t/
) + Iss. We performed this analysis with a
routine using Labtalk from Origin 6.0 (Microcal Software, Northampton, MA).
Solutions
Whole-cell recordings
The external recording solution contained (in mM) 20 BaCl2, 1 MgCl2, 10 HEPES, 40 tetraethylammonium (TEA)-Cl, 10 glucose, and 65 CsCl (pH 7.2 with CsOH; 315 mOsm) or, for activation and inactivation curves, closed-state inactivation, and double-pulse experiments (see Figs. 6, A-D, 8, and 9), 2 BaCl2, 1 MgCl2, 10 HEPES, 40 TEA-Cl, 10 glucose, and 105 CsCl (pH 7.2 with CsOH). The pipette solution contained (in mM) 105 CsCl, 25 TEA-Cl, 11 EGTA, 1 CaCl2, and 10 HEPES (pH 7.2 with CsOH) unless otherwise noted. For low intracellular Cl
conditions, the pipette solution contained
(in mM) 120 N-methyl D-glucamine, 60 HEPES, 1 MgCl2, and 10 EGTA (pH 7.3 with
methanesulfonic acid), and an extracellular solution of 150 Tris, 1 MgCl2, 10 BaCl2 (pH 7.3 with methanesulfonic acid) was used. In some experiments ATP-Na2 was added to the pipette solution or EGTA
was replaced with BAPTA. Just before recording, coverslips were washed
in a Tyrode's solution to avoid precipitation of
BaSO4 from streptomycin-SO4 in the growth medium. Solution osmolarities were measured with a 3MO
micro-osmometer (Advanced Instruments, Needham Heights, MA).
Cell-attached recordings
The composition of the bath solution, designed to zero the resting membrane potential was (in mM) 120 K-aspartate, 1 MgCl2, 5 EGTA, 10 HEPES, and 20 KCl (pH 7.4 with KOH; 320 mOsm with sucrose). Patch pipettes were filled with a solution of the following composition (in mM): 100 BaCl2, 10 TEA-Cl, and 10 HEPES (pH 7.4 with TEA-OH).Single-channel recordings
High-resistance pipettes (10-16 M
with 100 mM
BaCl2) were used, and seals usually exceeded 30 G
. Leak and capacitive current subtraction was performed by
averaging segments of traces with no activity from the same voltage
protocol in the same experiment and subtracting this average from each
episode using pClamp 8.1 (Axon Instruments). Currents were recorded
with an Axopatch 200B, sampled every 100 µs, filtered online at 2 kHz, and then off-line Gaussian filtered at 1 kHz. Openings to main and
subconductance levels were observed in all patches (as is evident in
the all-points histograms in Figs. 11 and 12) but were not analyzed
separately. Single-channel activity (formally, the sum for each unitary
current level, i, of iNPo where
N is the number of functional channels and
Po the probability of being open) was
obtained from the all-points histograms by fitting with the pClamp 8.1 routine for weighted sum of Gaussians for open states.
Analysis of electrophysiological data
Graphs and curve fittings were done with Origin 6.0. The peak
I/V relationships were fitted to the following
transform of a Boltzmann function:
|
|
Cell volume measurements
Imaging of cells was via the inverted microscope's (Hoffman
modulation, ×40, NA 0.5 objective) CCD camera (Hitachi Denshi Canada,
Ltd., Nepeah, ON) whose video output was fed into a JVC time-lapse VCR for off-line analysis using a frame grabber DT3155 (Data
Translation, Marlboro, MA). Images were collected during electrophysiological recording and collated by synchronization of
pClamp and time-lapse VCR timers. The cross-sectional area (CSA) of
traced regions was determined with ImageJ 1.06 (NIH Image), and cell
borders were traced on the monitor by mouse and computer-generated cursor. Each image was traced twice, and the values were averaged. This
analysis process allowed detection of changes in cell CSA with an
accuracy of 2-3%. We calculated relative cell volume changes (Vol/Vol0) using the equation
Vol/Vol0 = ((test CSA)/(control CSA))3/2 (Churchwell et al., 1996
).
Statistics
Results are presented as means ± SE. Except where noted, comparison was by unpaired or paired t-test, used as appropriate. Significance level was p < 0.05.
| |
RESULTS |
|---|
|
|
|---|
Ba2+ current just after whole-cell access: run-up and run-down
Human neuronal
1B,
1b, and
2-
subunits were transiently expressed in HEK 293-tsA201 cells. To avoid
confounding stretch- and time-dependent effects in our experimental
conditions, currents were first characterized over time. After
obtaining the whole-cell configuration, cells were clamped to
90 mV
and Ba2+ current
(IBa) was elicited by a 240-ms step to
+10 mV (Fig. 1 A). During the
first 5-30 s after whole-cell access, a spontaneous increase in peak
IBa (i.e., run-up) was observed,
followed by a slower decline (i.e., run-down; Fig. 1,
A and B). During the post-access period, there
was an increase in the activation rate (Fig. 1 A,
inset). Run-down was significantly slower (e.g., Fig. 2 A) for an inter-episode
interval of 15 s than for 5 s (p < 0.001; n = 6), indicating that N-type
Ba2+ current run-down was caused, at least in
part, by cumulative inactivation.
|
|
Simultaneously we monitored, over time, the speed of inactivation (Fig. 1 B). Just after whole-cell access, inactivation was sufficiently slow that even with pulse durations of hundreds of milliseconds, fits to exponentials were unreliable; as an arbitrary index of inactivation speed, therefore, we calculated the extent of inactivation during a 240-ms pulse (e.g., Fig. 1 B, right-hand axis). As Fig. 1, A and B (right axis) indicates, inactivation speeded up until it reached a plateau (Fig. 2 B).
Unlike run-down, run-up of peak IBa coincided with a slowing of inactivation; i.e., during the run-up period, the inactivation index fell (Fig. 1 B). This suggested that current contained a slowly recovering component, a possibility tested by pulsing at several higher frequencies (0.2-, 0.3-, and 0.4-s inter-episode intervals). Because an initial run-up of peak IBa was absent at these higher frequencies (Fig. 2 C; the absolute value of I/Imax falls continuously), we suspect that frequent pulsing prevented slow-mode channels from recovering from inactivation. This would also be consistent with the finding (data not shown) that during frequent pulsing as in Fig. 2 C, inactivation speed was constant.
Use of more physiological pipette solutions (with ATP or low
Cl
) did not significantly alter the time course
of run-down (Figs. 1 B and 2 A) or run-up (Fig. 1
B). Despite significantly slower run-down with 15-s
inter-episode intervals, we mostly used the 5-s protocol; 15-s
intervals proved impractical for monitoring rapid responses to membrane
stretch (Fig. 3 A). For all
solutions, the tendency for inactivation to speed up over time was
evident, although for low Cl
(e.g., Fig. 1
B, right axis), this reached a plateau
at a significantly smaller value (p < 0.001, multiple
comparison Tukey test versus 5 s; Fig. 2 B).
|
If free Ba2+accumulated and caused run-down, then
the percent run-down should correlate strongly with the maximal run-up
IBa magnitude in any cell, an effect
that would intensify with longer barium influx. Instead, for
n = 12 cells (maximal
IBa range,
2 to
9.5 nA), when
percent run-down after 10 and then 20 depolarization episodes was
plotted (not shown) against maximal
IBa, the correlation was weak, with
regression coefficients of
0.4 and then
0.3 (+0.4 and +0.3 for
IBa taken as positive).
Effect of membrane stretch on the amplitude of peak IBa
Cell volume was manipulated via pressure in the recording pipette and was monitored by video-microscopy. Whenever positive pressure succeeded in producing a volume increase (e.g., Fig. 3 A), this was accompanied by a current increase. Although visible inflation often lagged behind the onset of pressure, they coincided in Fig. 3 B (CSA not shown). Enhancement of peak currents coinciding with inflation was also observed for experiments using BAPTA (not shown). If the mechanically induced increase in peak IBa were an artifact of increased divalent buffering during inflation (resulting from blowing in EGTA), then pipette solutions that either clamp buffer capacity or slightly increase cytoplasmic [Ba2+] during inflation should eliminate the stretch effect. In a series of tests, therefore, we added Ba2+ to the pipette so that solution blown into the cell would have a known low level of free Ba2+. Specifically, we inflated cells using a 0.3 mM free Ba2+ solution (calculated with MaxChelator freeware for the regular 11 mM EGTA pipette solution except with 10 mM Ba2+ used instead of 1 mM Ca2+). As seen in Fig. 3 C, inflating with this solution did not discernibly alter the outcome. The run-down time (70 ± 26 s; n = 4 cells) was not significantly different and, critically, the response to inflation was like that for the control pipette solution: peak IBa increased 1.5-fold ± 0.1(n = 4), and inactivation speeded up with stretch. These data strongly suggest that the inflation effect was not mediated chemically but was mediated mechanically by membrane stretch.
We, like Langton (1993)
, sometimes found that substantial pressures
(+30 and +50 mm Hg) would not yield a perceptible change in cell
volume. In those cases, there was no increase in
IBa. Partially blocked pipette tips
may have prevented such cells from experiencing the applied pressure
even though access for voltage clamp was adequate. Confirming that
inflation was the critical parameter, peak
IBa increase correlated strongly with
the cell volume change (Fig. 4,
left) but was uncorrelated with the magnitude of pressure
applied (Fig. 4, lower right). Another plot (Fig. 4, upper right) demonstrates that maximum
inflation was not a function of pressure.
|
To ascertain whether shifting I/V relations
explained the peak effect, we recorded
IBa with 20 mM
Ba2+in the bath before, during, and after
inflation (not shown). Although the fitted
Gmax increased significantly from
18 ± 2 nS to 26 ± 2 nS, equivalent to recruiting 800 units
of 10 pS via inflation (p < 0.005, paired
t-test; n = 6), peak
IBa scaled up to the same extent
across all voltages (e.g., at
10 mV and +30 mV,
Iduring/Ibefore was 1.5 ± 0.1 and 1.5 ± 0.2, respectively) and the reversal
potential (54 ± 1 mV before and 55 ± 2 mV during and after)
was unaffected. In other words, there was no evidence for an
inflation-induced shift in the I/V relations.
Ra and Cm during applied pressure
To determine whether inflation-induced increases of
IBa required an increased membrane
area, membrane capacitance (Cm),
IBa, and CSA were measured
simultaneously with and without pressure. To preserve the capacitative
transients needed for determining Cm
and Ra (see Materials and Methods),
leakage current was not subtracted on-line. A raw current trace
sequence in Fig. 5 (top) illustrates that stretch increased peak
IBa with no change in leakage current
(unchanged baseline). Note that although stretch increased both peak
IBa and CSA,
Cm decreased and did not change more
than 2%. For five stretch measurements with positive pressures (n = 4 cells) the average absolute percent change in
Cm ([maximal
Cm during stretch]/[mean
Cm prestretch] × 100) was 2.8 ± 0.6%, with increases in two of five and decreases in three of five
measurements. During the entire illustrated experiment, series (i.e.,
access) resistance (Ra) (Fig. 5,
center) varied <5% (the change for n = 5 was 4.6 ± 0.6%; 3 decreased, 1 increased, and 1 unchanged).
|
Effect of stretch on inactivation and activation curves
A double-pulse protocol was used to generate inactivation curves
for IBa (Fig.
6, A-C). Prepulse
potentials (
130 to +10 mV) were applied for 7 s, and then after
a 10-ms interval, at
100 mV, the membrane was stepped to +10 mV for
240 ms (i.e., test pulse). The recovery time allowed between 7-s
prepulses was 10 s. Test currents, normalized to those obtained
for the
130-mV prepulse, were plotted against prepulse potentials and
fitted by a Boltzmann equation (see Materials and Methods). Time
control recordings (over 4-16 min; n = 10) showed a
spontaneous 7-mV leftward shift (Fig. 6 A) with initial and
final half-inactivation voltages (V0.5) at
73 ± 0.9 mV and
80 ± 0.7 mV and no change in slope factor (k;
12 ± 0.8 mV versus 12 ± 0.7 mV). For cells maintained in an
inflated condition by positive pressure over a 4-19-min interval
(n = 12; Fig. 6 B), an 18-mV leftward shift
was obtained (V0.5 =
73 ± 0.9 mV without stretch and
91 ± 0.9 mV with stretch), with
k constant at 13 ± 0.8 mV before and during stretch.
The stretch-induced V0.5 shift, which
developed gradually and was irreversible (Fig. 6 C), was
significantly larger than the spontaneous shift (p < 0.0009, unpaired t-test).
|
Activation data in time control (not shown) and stretch experiments
(Fig. 6 D) were fitted with a Boltzmann equation (see Materials and Methods). The curves were obtained by stepping in 10-mV increments from Vh =
100 mV to
+70 mV, starting from
70 mV, for 20 ms before repolarizing to
50
mV. Activation V0.5 values and
k (in mV) showed no significant changes with time (from
V0.5 =
1.9 ± 0.6 and
k = 7.4 ± 0.5 to
V0.5 =
2.3 ± 0.6 and
k = 7.9 ± 0.5, 4-8 min later; n = 5) or with stretch (from V0.5 =
1.7 ± 0.7 and k = 8.5 ± 0.7 for the
control to V0.5 =
2 ± 0.5 and k = 8.7 ± 0.5 with stretch over 4-10 min;
n = 7).
Kinetic properties of IBa during stretch
The rate of activation of IBa
with and without stretch was compared for normalized current peaks
(e.g., Fig. 3 B, inset, and Fig.
7 B for steps from
90 mV to
+10 mV). In all cells tested, and over a wide range of voltages, no
effect of stretch on the activation rate was observed. Stretch did not,
therefore, increase peak IBa via this
mechanism.
|
The gradual speeding of open-state inactivation invariably seen in 5-s inter-episode recordings (e.g., Fig. 1 B) was immediately accelerated by stretch, as Fig. 7, A and B, illustrates. Stretch acceleration of open-state inactivation was transient rather than irreversible (e.g., Fig. 7 A, +4 mmHg). Additionally, although it was dramatic early in the recordings, stretch acceleration could not be elicited at all once inactivation speed reached a plateau (e.g., Fig. 7 A). This changing effectiveness of stretch is summarized quantitatively in Fig. 7 C.
N-type channels inactivate preferentially from intermediate closed
states (Patil et al., 1998
), so we tested whether stretch affected this
process using a protocol involving 20-pulse trains (10-ms pulses, from
90 to +10 mV, with a 50-ms inter-episode; Fig.
8 A). The extent of
closed-state inactivation over the course of these trains was
quantified as the proportion: 1
(last pulse current/first pulse
current). As illustrated in Fig. 8 C (left), membrane stretch (+7, +4, and +7 mmHg) dramatically enhanced the process of inactivation from intermediate closed states. On the right
side of Fig. 8 C, the graph for selected 20-pulse trains (a-e) from this cell illustrates in fuller
detail that stretch acted in a progressive and irreversible manner.
Fig. 8 B, which charts the process over time (100, 200, 300, and 400 s) in control cells versus cells subjected to stretch,
indicates that stretch augmented a background time-dependent increment
in the speed of inactivation from intermediate closed states. Not
surprisingly, 10-ms depolarizing steps separated by 980 ms
(corresponding to first and last pulses only in the 20-pulse trains)
elicited identical currents (Fig. 8 D, left), as
expected if, during the earliest 20-pulse trains, inactivation occurred
preferentially from intermediate closed states. That said, over time
(50-450 s was tested; Fig. 8 D, right), the
relative height of IBa at the end
pulse did diminish. This loss (i.e., during the uninterrupted 980-ms
interval at
90 mV) was significantly (p < 0.005, Wilcoxon signed rank test) enhanced by membrane stretch.
Simultaneously, a minor time-dependent increase (e.g., see
arrows in Fig. 8 D, left) in the
activation rate was measured (
= 2.2 ± 0.5 ms at
t = 0 s and 1.5 ± 0.4 ms at
t = 400 s; n = 6;
p < 0.006, paired t-test), but this was
unaffected by stretch. Yet again, therefore, we found that even as
stretch was enhancing a spontaneously occurring (i.e.,
time-in-whole-cell-configuration-dependent) process, it had no impact
on activation kinetics.
|
Differential stretch effects on T- and N-type IBa
Whole-cell recordings
In the next series of experiments we asked 1) whether low-voltage-activated calcium channel currents (T-type) were mechanosensitive like the high-voltage-activated N-type and L-type channel currents and 2) whether T- and N-channels in the same cellular setting responded in a channel-specific manner to stretch. Whole-cell recordings were made with a double-pulse protocol that activated both types of currents but also allowed them to be dissected. For the first question we used HEK cells stably transfected with the
1I (T-type calcium channel) subunit, and for
the second question we transiently transfected into this cell line the
human
1B (N-type calcium channel),
1b, and
2-
subunits. As demonstrated in Fig. 9
A, in cells stably expressing T-type channels only,
30 mV
and +10 mV elicited large and small inward currents, respectively. Stretch had no discernible impact on these T-type currents at either
voltage; increasing the inflationary pressure until rupture did not
change this (n = 3). By contrast, when only N-type
channels were expressed (Fig. 9 B),
30 mV elicited no
current and +10 mV elicited large inward currents, and as we have now
come to expect, stretch increased the current at +10 mV. Next the two channels were coexpressed so they could simultaneously be subjected to
precisely the same mechanical stimulus. As illustrated in Fig. 9
C, stretch did not affect the current elicited at
30 mV
(this is T-only current) yet increased that at +10 mV
(n = 5). Taken together with the control for T-type (as
in Fig. 9 A), we conclude that the entire effect at +10 mV
was caused by an N-type current response to stretch. This amounted to
1.4 ± 0.1-fold peak increase (n = 7). Notice that
the imposed cell inflation did not affect the baseline between steps or
during steps when no voltage-dependent current was elicited (e.g., Fig.
9 B,
30 mV).
|
Cell-attached recordings
Because the cell-attached patch recording preserves the content of the cytoplasm and provides a different way (pipette aspiration) to subject membrane to tension, we performed some experiments in this configuration. To obtain macroscopic N-type or T-type currents from the patches, pipettes of ~2-µm inside diameter (after polishing) were used. At the beginning of recordings of N-type current (one pulse every 5 s), run-up was evident (data not shown), but the currents stabilized by ~25 s, and thereafter there was no evidence of run-down. Every time suction in the range of
15 to
55 mmHg was
applied to patches to generate membrane stretch, a reversible
increase in the peak (and sustained) N-type current was observed (Fig.
10 A). The increase averaged
33 ± 6% (n = 9, from six patches) or 1.3-fold.
In five of six patches, inactivation was unaffected by stretch,
although in a sixth (Fig. 10 A, inset) it showed
a minor change. For patches from cells expressing T-type current (Fig.
10 B), no change was observed when pressure was applied (n = 6) and then, with successive pulses, increased
until rupture occurred. Likewise, stretch did not elicit currents in
nontransfected cells (n = 3; Fig. 10 C).
|
Single-channel recording
In our macroscopic recordings, stretch reversibly increased N-type
IBa without detectably accelerating
its onset. One possible explanation was that stretch increased unitary
current. To examine this, we made cell-attached single-channel
recordings of N-type IBa, both for
channels in cells expressing the
1B subunit
alone (see Meir and Dolphin, 1998
) and for cells coexpressing the
1B/
2-
/
1b combination (for the latter, the quantities of cDNAs were reduced). The
small membrane patches used in these experiments would necessarily have
encompassed less long-range structure than large patches used for
macroscopic recording. Consequently, the single-channel recordings
represent the simplest situation (mechanically speaking) in which we
tested effects of stretch on N-type channels. To collect enough events
for even the simplest analyses, stretch was applied continuously during
and between depolarizing steps, so even though the patches were
initially formed as gentle patches (as defined by Small and Morris,
1994
), the data were collected from nongentle patches.
Single-channel data with and without stretch are seen in Figs.
11 (
1B subunit
alone) and 12 (the
1B/
2-
/
1b
combination). Raw data from several patches are included, illustrating
the range of prestretch channel activity in our patches. For the entire collection of patches tested before, during, and after stretch (at one
or more suction levels), Fig. 12 B plots the single-channel activity (means and errors) obtained from analysis of the all-points histograms. Because the high-concentration divalent pipette solutions (100 mM Ba2+ was used) needed for single-channel
recording right-shift the I/V, 20 mV was used as
the test voltage. Within-patch comparisons of these data sets showed
that stretch significantly and reversibly increased channel activity
both for
1B alone (2.4-fold increase) and for
the
1B/
2-
/
1b
combination (1.7-fold increase; see Fig. 12 for statistical details).
The magnitude of these stretch-induced activity increases were
comparable to the ~1.5-fold stretch-induced peak
IBa increases measured in the
macroscopic current experiments. Inspection of both the overlapped
traces and the all-points histograms shows there are no grounds
for suggesting that stretch increased the amplitude of the fully open
state. Because subconductance events were characteristic of control
records for both
1B alone and for the
1B/
2-
/
1b
combination, a possible explanation for the stretch-induced increase of
N-type current was that stretch transformed subconductance events into
full-conductance events. Although the brevity and amplitude spread of
the subconductance levels prevented their precise quantitation, the
histograms argue against the possibility of stretch-induced conductance
level switch; the sub- and full-conductance contributions to histograms
increased about equally during stretch.
|
|
Thus, the single-channel data demonstrated the following: 1)
1B subunits alone can generate
mechanosensitive N-type channels, and 2) unitary current amplitude is
not mechanosensitive. By elimination, mechanosensitivity probably
resides with channel kinetics and/or the number of functional channels.
Given the presence of subconductances, the small amplitude and short
duration of the unitary current events, and the lack of a striking
qualitative stretch effect (e.g., a switch from sub- to
full-conductance), however, extensive data sets will be required to
uncover any stretch-sensitive effects on N or
Po. Additional investigations might
most profitably be done with channel variants that tend to make more
prolonged openings.
Action potential clamp recordings and stretch
Finally, we wished to gauge whether the mechano-responses of N-type currents would be perceptible during the sorts of brief repetitive voltage excursions experienced in neurons. We performed AP clamp recordings under whole-cell clamp (see Materials and Methods), applying a series of nine AP trains (frequency, one train per 20 s). Within each train, the peak AP amplitude fell with time, giving a ratio of the ninth to the first of 0.8 ± 0.04 (n = 4) that was insensitive to stretch (data not shown). In Fig. 13 A, the peak value of the first AP of each train is plotted as a function of time (i.e., at 20-s intervals). Every time positive pressure inflated the cell, increase peak IBa increased (by 26 ± 3%; n = 6, from 4 cells). This ~1.3-fold increase in the magnitude of N-type current during spike trains is consistent with what was observed for steps. Insofar as the inward currents attained their prestretch levels faster during the APs, a nontrivial consequence of stretch-augmented currents in vivo could be to accelerate as well as increase intracellular [Ca2+] changes during spikes. AP waveform trains applied to nontransfected cells (Fig. 13 B, left) elicited no inward current, and cell inflation had no effect on the recorded current in these cells (Fig. 13 B, right).
|
| |
DISCUSSION |
|---|
|
|
|---|
Overview
For recombinant N-type channels in a cell line, we observed a
phenomenon seen in many native preparations for L-type currents (references in Introduction): membrane stretch increases the peak current ~1.5-fold. Despite the potential physiological and/or pathological interest of mechanosensitive calcium currents, the reports
from smooth muscle cells have attracted little attention (e.g.,
Catterall, 2000
; Jaggar et al., 2000
). Perhaps there have been concerns
that the responses depend as much on the recording conditions as on the
channels themselves. We found, however, that a T-type channel construct
did not respond to stretch, even when coexpressed and costimulated with
N-type channels. This strongly suggests that either the channels
themselves or their subtype-specific arrangements in the plasma
membrane underlie the susceptibility of the N-type currents to membrane
stretch. Unpublished preliminary results for recombinant L-type
channels (B. Calabrese and C. E. Morris) in HEK cells confirmed
the stretch-induced increase reported from native cells.
Mechano-responses shared by native L-type and recombinant N-type (and
L-type) calcium channels are presumably not reliant on native cell
morphological and biochemical specializations. In addition to the
stretch-induced peak current increase, N-type channels showed several
other effects, some reversible (e.g., enhanced rate of inactivation
from open states) and some not (e.g., enhanced rate of inactivation
from closed states). The irreversible effects were like stretch
accelerations of spontaneous run-down processes and as such may have
links to what in intact cells would be classed as modulation (e.g.,
Kepplinger et al., 2000
).
Membrane tension and voltage-gated channels
Stretch effects on N-type channels are very unlike effects on a
simpler voltage-gated channel, Shaker. In Shaker, reversible stretch
activation (Gu et al., 2001
) depends on increased activation rates that
produce a hyperpolarizing shift of the G(V) and
no change in Gmax (Tabarean and
Morris, 2002
). By contrast, for N-type calcium channels, stretch
increased Gmax but did not shift
G(V) or alter the rate of activation. Because we
reliably detected small changes in the rate of N-type activation during
run-up, temporal resolution was not an obvious problem. In calcium
channels, as in Shaker and sodium channels, gating charge movements are tightly coupled to pore opening (Olcese et al., 1996
); accordingly, if
stretch facilitates gating charge movements, one might expect all these
voltage-gated channels to make qualitatively similar changes in
activation during stretch. The picture that is emerging is, however,
more complex than that. Voltage-gated sodium and potassium channels in
squid under hyperbaric conditions (Conti et al., 1984
) and Shaker
channels in oocytes (Meyer and Heinemann, 1997
) activate faster at
atmospheric pressure than when compressed, as if the channels expand
during voltage activation. Expansion in the plane of the bilayer would
be consistent with the responses of recombinant Shaker to stretch
(Tabarean and Morris, 2002
). Nothing, however, in the responses of
N-type channels suggests that they expand during voltage gating. The
conundrum is deepened by the fact that in a mammalian sodium channel
(
-subunit only), activation rates are not reversibly stretch
sensitive even though stretch can irreversibly affect other aspects of
the channel's behavior, making the anomalously slow-gating
-subunit
gate in the way it normally does with the
-subunit present (Tabarean et al., 1999
). Likewise, we found that stretch that irreversibly changed inactivation of N-type currents (whole-cell conditions) had no
impact on activation rates. Thus, whatever is signified by the
reversible mechano-responses of Shaker and of squid channels, we have
to conclude that in neither N- nor T-type calcium channels (nor
skeletal muscle sodium channels) do the voltage sensors feel membrane
tension in any appreciable way.
We can rule out the possibility that auxiliary subunits somehow
prevented the calcium channels from responding to stretch like Shaker,
first, because T-type currents arising from an
1I subunit alone showed no stretch-sensitive
activation and, second, because N-type currents through
1B subunits were stretch sensitive with or
without the auxiliary subunits. The mechanosensitivity of N-type
current thus differs qualitatively from that of the inherently
mechanosusceptible homotetrameric membrane protein Shaker. Finally, we
emphasize that our results for the T-type channel were for one
construct and should not be used to assert that all T-type channels are
insensitive to stretch.
The mechano-responses of N- and L-type calcium channels bear
little overall resemblance to those of bacterial osmotic-valve stretch
channels (Sukharev et al., 2001
), where elevated membrane tension alone
(albeit at near-lytic levels) can change
Po from zero to near unity, or to the
two-pore domain K+ channels of excitable cells
(Patel et al., 2001
), for which the same is true at somewhat lower
tensions. These K+ channels would broadly coexist
in central neurons with N-type calcium channels. Evidence that they
perform physiological mechano-tasks has not been forthcoming, but in
vitro, we note, they respond to the same range of mechanical stimuli
shown here to act on N-type calcium channels.
Stretch and increased Gmax for N-type channels.
Stretch transiently increased
Gmax for N-type channels, and the
effect could be elicited repeatedly. The apparent increase in the
number of channels was not caused by membrane addition because even
when cells inflated twofold, their plasma membrane area remained fixed.
Inflation-induced smoothing of excess surface area (Solsona et al.,
1998
; Raucher and Sheetz, 1999
) inevitably involves disruption of
long-range plasma membrane structure. How, at fixed membrane area,
stretch might abruptly yet transiently (seconds, not minutes or hours)
increase the density of functional N-type (but not coexpressed T-type)
channels is difficult to fathom. Because some channels traffic to the
surface in mechanically specialized domains (Martens et al., 2001
), one
possibility is that a subpopulation of channels sequestered in lipid
rafts is reversibly recruited during stretch to the pool of operating
channels. Such a scenario is envisaged for c-Src tyrosine kinase
inhibition of volume-regulated anion channels, which seems to require
compartmentalization of the kinase to membrane subdomains (Trouet et
al., 2001
).
Another possibility is stretch reactivation of channels lost to
run-down. Mechanisms suggested for Ca2+ channel
run-down include proteolysis (Romanin et al., 1991
), dephosphorylation
(Ono and Fozzard, 1992
; Costantin et al., 1999
), and washout of the
cytoplasmic factor calpastatin (Kameyama et al., 1998
), which
evidently can target calcium channel subunits (Kepplinger et al.,
2000
). Because stretch-induced Ipeak
sometimes exceeded initial values (e.g., Fig. 3 A), invoking
a reactivation mechanism would imply that at the time of whole-cell
access, some channels were in a down-modulated state. The fact that
cell-attached patches (where run-down is not a factor) show the
stretch-induced increase in peak current, however, tends to undermine
the stretch reactivation idea.
Single-channel recordings of calcium currents before, during, and after stretch showed that NPo increased reversibly with stretch, with no obvious change in the single-channel current amplitude. This suggests that the change may be kinetic, but our data did not let us rule out the possibility that stretch transiently increases N (the number of operational channels) as the macroscopic currents seem to suggest. This idea is testable at the single-channel level, but long-lasting unitary events from BAYK 8644-treated L-type channels or an N-type mutant that makes prolonged openings will be needed.
Mechanical stimulus
Pressures applied under whole-cell clamp ranged from 2 to 15 mmHg
(i.e., 267-2000 N/m2), which, assuming spherical
geometry and applying Laplace's Law (T = Pr/2) would correspond to membrane tensions of 2-9 mN/m. For most biological membranes, lytic tensions are ~10 mN/m (Morris and Homann, 2001
). Only in cells that visibly inflated with pressure either immediately or within tens of seconds did we obtain
mechano-effects, but more precisely what this means in terms of
mechanical changes at the plasma membrane we do not know.
Stretch-Ipeak increases correlated not
with pressure but with the extent of cell inflation. They also
coincided temporally with inflation. By contrast, stretch acceleration
of inactivation began as soon as pressure was applied, even when
detectable inflation did not occur until many seconds later (e.g.,
Figs. 3 B and 7 A). This suggests that distinct
mechanical perturbations underlie effects on peak current and on
inactivation kinetics. Plasma membrane is not a classic Hookean solid;
concepts of stress (reversible extension) and strain (irreversible
extension) in response to applied force are not rigorously applicable.
Membrane-associated structures at various size scales (e.g.,
individual membrane proteins, lipid rafts, and membrane skeleton) will
respond in many fashions to the same applied pressure and healing, or
mechanical memory, may be a factor. Consider several possibilities:
stretch-disruption of long- or short-range membrane skeleton complexes
(Lee and Discher, 2001
), stretch flattening of caveolae (Dulhunty and
Franzini-Armstrong, 1975
), stretch regulation of a membrane kinase
(Kimura et al., 2000
), stretch dissociation of heteromeric channel
subunits, and stretch alteration of the membrane ceramide content (Chik
et al., 1999
). Each could be reversible or irreversible, depending on the state of the cytoplasm.
The reversibility of stretch-induced increase in Ipeak was difficult to evaluate in whole-cell recordings not only because of run-down but also because deflation after a positive pressure pulse could be slow. However, the reversibility of this phenomenon was confirmed in cell-attached recordings where application and release of membrane tension is more straightforward.
Before leaving the topic of our mechanical stimuli, we should discuss
the possibility of unintended cell swelling. Cell swelling immediately
after whole-cell access was suggested by Langton (1993)
as a way to
explain run-up. That can be excluded here because 1) in our experiments
detectable cell swelling after whole-cell access was rare, whereas the
run-up was invariably present (unless high-speed pulsing was used); 2)
if, for a minute or so after going whole-cell (i.e., beyond the usual
run-up time) the membrane was left unclamped (and hence rather
depolarized) before applying the standard protocol (
90 mV with 5-s
inter-episodes), a run-up of Ipeak was
still obtained; and 3) high-frequency protocols applied right from the
outset prevented run-up. We think therefore that run-up reflected a
slowly recovering gating mode in the N-type Ca2+
channels and was not a cryptic stretch effect caused by post-access swelling.
Do effects of stretch on inactivation cancel the effect on activation?
Unlike classic Na+ or
K+ channel inactivation, N-type
Ca2+ channel inactivation shows almost no voltage
overlap with steady-state activation, so during trains of brief pulses,
inactivation occurs predominantly from intermediate closed states
(Patil et al., 1998
). We found that stretch significantly enhanced this
process. Additionally, stretch transiently accelerated inactivation
from the open state, exacerbating a process occurring spontaneously
with time under whole-cell conditions. Finally, stretch irreversibly
left-shifted inactivation (Fig. 6, B and C),
again exacerbating or amplifying a spontaneous process. If these
effects of stretch on inactivation were to occur in vivo would they
overwhelm the stretch-induced increase in N-type current? We conclude
that they probably would not from our finding that during voltage clamp
excursions mimicking repeated bursts of action potentials, stretch
accelerated the development of the calcium current and increased its
overall magnitude at the AP peaks. Cell-attached experiments suggested
that with intact cytoplasm, stretch would have little impact on the
rate of inactivation, and this might mean that stretch impacts on net calcium entry could be appreciably greater than seen in whole-cell recordings. The stretch-induced left-shift of inactivation that we
report (whole-cell) developed progressively, however, so it may be that
for cells subjected to prolonged mechanical trauma (e.g., Agrawal
et al., 2000
), a progressive left-shift of inactivation could
counteract calcium loading via the channels. Hyperbaric depression of
synaptic transmission is specifically dependent on suppression of
synaptic N-type calcium channel activity (Etzion and Grossman, 2000
);
perhaps the complex mechanosensitivity of N-type channels contributes
to this pressure phenomenon.
In immature neurons, where N-type calcium channels are a prerequisite
for directed migration (Komuro and Rakic, 1992
), growth cone membrane
tension might be high due to traction forces (Lamoureux et al., 1998
).
Of particular interest are the L- and N-type channels located near
load-bearing focal adhesions, which appear to regulate actin-myosin
dynamics and the remodeling of the load-bearing membrane skeleton
(Zimprich and Bolsover, 1996
; Archer et al., 1999
). It is intriguing to
consider that when dendritic spines contract (Halpain, 2000
), membrane
tension would likely change not only in the postsynaptic membrane (as
discussed by Korkotian and Segal, 2001
) but also in the adherent
presynaptic membrane. Although our results suggest that the modulation
by stretch of N-type (and L-type) channels near mechanically active
synapses and growth cones is a possibility, it will be an interesting
challenge to determine whether such channels in situ mediate
stretch-induced increases in calcium influx.
| |
NOTE ADDED IN PROOF |
|---|
|
|
|---|
A recombinant L-type
-subunit cloned from human smooth muscle
has also just been reported to be mechanosensitive (Lyford et al.,
2001
)
| |
ACKNOWLEDGMENTS |
|---|
We are grateful to Dr. Steve Barnes for comments on the manuscript and to Dr. Petro Doroshenko for use of the frame grabber.
This work was supported by operating grants to C.E.M. from the Canadian Institutes of Health Research, NSERC (Natural Sciences and Engineering Research Council) Canada, and the Hearth and Stroke Foundation of Ontario (T3461).
| |
FOOTNOTES |
|---|