| HOME | HELP | FEEDBACK | SUBSCRIPTIONS | ARCHIVE | SEARCH | TABLE OF CONTENTS |
Biophys J, December 2002, p. 3162-3176, Vol. 83, No. 6


*Department of Chemical Engineering,
Graduate Program
in Molecular Biophysics, and
Department of Materials
Science and Engineering, The Johns Hopkins University, Baltimore,
Maryland 21218 USA
| |
ABSTRACT |
|---|
|
|
|---|
This paper introduces the method of live-cell
multiple-particle-tracking microrheology (MPTM), which quantifies the
local mechanical properties of living cells by monitoring the Brownian motion of individual microinjected fluorescent particles. Particle tracking of carboxylated microspheres imbedded in the cytoplasm produce
spatial distributions of cytoplasmic compliances and
frequency-dependent viscoelastic moduli. Swiss 3T3 fibroblasts are
found to behave like a stiff elastic material when subjected to high
rates of deformations and like a soft liquid at low rates of
deformations. By analyzing the relative contributions of the
subcellular compliances to the mean compliance, we find that the
cytoplasm is much more mechanically heterogeneous than reconstituted
actin filament networks. Carboxylated microspheres embedded in
cytoplasm through endocytosis and amine-modified polystyrene
microspheres, which are microinjected or endocytosed, often show
directed motion and strong nonspecific interactions with cytoplasmic
proteins, which prevents computation of local moduli from the
microsphere displacements. Using MPTM, we investigate the mechanical
function of
-actinin in non-muscle cells:
-actinin-microinjected
cells are stiffer and yet mechanically more heterogeneous than control
cells, in agreement with models of reconstituted cross-linked actin
filament networks. MPTM is a new type of functional microscopy that can
test the local, rate-dependent mechanical and ultrastructural
properties of living cells.
| |
INTRODUCTION |
|---|
|
|
|---|
It is unclear whether and how the
nonhomogeneous spatial distribution of cytoskeletal polymers such as
F-actin, microtubules, and intermediate filament and their auxiliary
proteins, leads to local variations of its mechanical properties. This
is partly because in general there is no direct correspondence between
the structure/organization and the mechanical behavior of a complex fluid. This is also because most current methods cannot readily measure
the local mechanical properties of living cells (Tseng et al., 2002
).
Electron microscopy (EM) combined with immunocytochemistry and cryo-EM
techniques have successfully been used to obtain detailed insight into
the distribution and molecular interactions of macromolecular arrays in
situ (Jarnik and Aebi, 1991
; Schoenenberger et al., 1999
; Penman,
1995
). However, EM has not been extended to quantify the degree of
spatial heterogeneity of networks, does not measure physical properties
(e.g., cytoplasmic viscosity), and does not allow live-cell
investigations. This last limitation can partially be alleviated by
using correlative light and electron microscopy, which combines the
live-cell capabilities of light microscopy and the superior spatial
resolution of EM (Svitkina and Borisy, 1998
). Confocal laser scanning
microscopy can visualize the three-dimensional organization of
cytoskeletal elements in situ (Vassy et al., 1997
; Baschong et al.,
1999
) but makes use of fluorescent dyes that can affect intermolecular
interactions and does not measure physical properties. Indeed,
visualizing the actin cytoskeleton by fluorescence microscopy does not
quantify its organization; e.g., enhanced fluorescence intensity of the
F-actin may not necessarily mean enhanced heterogeneity. Magnetic
tweezers were recently developed and used to probe the
frequency-dependent viscoelastic moduli of living cells (Bausch et al.,
1999
; Wang and Ingber, 1995
). However, large (magnetic) beads were used
(1.3 µm) to reach a high enough probing force, and the
specific/nonspecific interactions between the beads and subcellular
structures were not characterized; moreover this approach is ill suited
to probe the local subcellular response to an extracellular stimulus.
By monitoring the diffusion of small, inert tracer particles via
fluorescence microscopy, Ragsdale et al. (1997)
probed the
micromechanical properties of fibroblasts. However, many hypotheses
were made to compute the cytoplasmic elasticity, and no global cellular
response was obtained.
To monitor the local mechanical heterogeneity of cytoplasm and
the viscoelastic response of living cells, we introduce a new functional microscopy, multiple-particle-tracking microrheology (MPTM)
(Tseng et al., 2002
). MPTM collects and analyzes the distribution of
Brownian displacements of imbedded microspheres in the cytoplasm of
live cells to spatially map its local viscoelastic properties. The
approach can be intuitively understood as follows. The thermal energy
kBT creates a random force
of order-of-magnitude
kBT/a on each
microsphere, where a is the radius of the microsphere. This
minuscule force (
1 pN) creates a local dynamic deformation of the
viscoelastic medium in the vicinity of the particle, which controls the
particle's displacement, itself measured by video particle
nano-tracking. By using a generalized Langevin equation of motion for a
microsphere in a viscoelastic milieu (Xu et al., 1998a
), mean squared
displacement profiles are transformed into compliance profiles and
viscoelastic parameters, which describe the local viscosity and
elasticity of cytoplasm.
We illustrate the use of MPTM by investigating the changes in the
mechanical properties of cytoplasm of Swiss 3T3 fibroblasts upon
microinjection of purified
-actinin.
-Actinin is a ubiquitous actin cross-linking/bundling protein found in skeletal muscle, smooth
muscle, and non-muscle cells (Critchley, 1993
). Rheological methods
applied to in vitro models of actin filament networks containing
purified actin and
-actinin, which in many ways mimic the somewhat
heterogeneous actin cytoskeleton of non-muscle cells, suggest that
-actinin promotes the formation of stiff and viscous F-actin
networks (Wachsstock et al., 1993
). Quantitative ultrastructural studies of F-actin networks in vitro further predicts that
-actinin enhances the heterogeneity of the actin cytoskeleton (Tseng and Wirtz,
2001
), but less so than fascin, another actin cross-linking/bundling protein (Yamashiro et al., 1998
; Apgar et al., 2000
). In contrast, the
mechanical function of
-actinin's association with actin filaments
in vivo has not been directly demonstrated.
-Actinin microinjected
into cultured non-muscle cells localizes to stress fibers and focal
adhesions (Izaguirre et al., 2001
), which suggests that
-actinin
stabilizes the actin cytoskeleton. The fact that
-actinin is
expressed in concert with a multitude of other actin cross-linking
proteins such as fascin greatly complicates the relatively simple
picture provided by in vitro models of F-actin networks. Here, we test
whether microinjected
-actinin enhances the elasticity, viscosity,
and degree of heterogeneity of cytoskeleton in live cells in a manner
similar to
-actinin-cross-linked actin gels in vitro.
In the first part of the paper, we describe MPTM, a new cell mechanics
method that quantifies the local mechanical properties of live cells.
By tracking the thermally excited displacements of fluorescent
polystyrene (PS) particles embedded in the cytoplasm of Swiss 3T3
fibroblasts, distributions of mechanical compliance are generated and
statistically analyzed. Analysis of the shape of the compliance
distributions yields markers for the degree of mechanical heterogeneity
of cytoplasm, which are compared with those obtained with reconstituted
cytoskeletal networks. Particular attention is paid to the effects of
particle surface charge and size on the apparent mean compliance and
compliance distributions of the cytoplasm. In the second part of the
paper, we use MPTM to investigate the mechanical function of
-actinin. We determine that microinjected
-actinin greatly
increases cell strength but also enhances the degree of subcellular
mechanical heterogeneity.
| |
MATERIALS AND METHODS |
|---|
|
|
|---|
Cell culture
Swiss 3T3 fibroblasts (American Type Culture Collection, Manassas, VA) were cultured at 37°C in 5% CO2 in Dulbecco's modified Eagle's medium supplemented with 10% bovine calf serum (Life Technologies, Gaithersburg, MD). All measurements were performed at 37°C in 5% CO2 in an incubator mounted on the inverted microscope used for the multiple-particle-tracking (MPT) measurements. Cells were grown on 35-mm glass-bottom dishes coated with poly-L-lysine (PLL; MatTek Corp., Ashland, MA).
Cytomechanics from multiple-particle tracking
To measure the local mechanical properties of cytoplasm, we
modified the in vitro method of MPT introduced by Apgar et al. (2000)
.
Yellow-green fluorescent PS microspheres (Molecular Probes, Eugene, OR)
were microinjected into the cells and used as local probes of
cytoplasm. The diameter of the microspheres was either 0.10 µm or
0.20 µm as specified. These microspheres were either carboxylated
(negatively charged) or amine modified (positively charged) as
specified. Cells microinjected with carboxylated or amine-modified
microspheres were verified to continue to grow and divide normally more
than 16 h after microinjection; moreover, cell morphology was
unchanged compared with (neighboring) non-microinjected cells, and
microspheres were passed to daughter cells. Cells microinjected with
microspheres of different charge and size were examined in the same
manner and within 10 min from each other as follows. Microspheres were
microinjected following a modification of Beckerle's method (Beckerle,
1984
) using the Eppendorf Transjector 5246 (Brinkmann Instruments,
Westbury, NY). Fluorescent microspheres were extensively dialyzed
against Dulbecco's PBS and subsequently diluted in Dulbecco's PBS to
a final particle concentration of 1011
particles/ml solution. This solution was filtered through a 0.22-µm filter and stored at 4°C. The osmolarity of this solution was measured with a Wescor VAPRO vapor pressure osmometer (Wescor, Logan,
UT) and found to be 285 mmol/kg, which is in the acceptable range for
animal cells (Freshney, 1994
). Borosilicate microneedles with a
0.3-µm inner diameter and 0.4-µm outer diameter (World Precision
Instruments, Sarasota, FL) were back-loaded with 10 µl of the
microsphere solution using micropipettes (Brinkmann Instruments). Cells
within an area inscribed with a diamond-tipped pencil were
microinjected at 37°C in a humidified, 5% CO2
environment. After microinjection, cells were immediately washed with
fresh media and incubated overnight in tissue culture medium.
The cells microinjected with the fluorescent particles were placed on
the stage of a microscope at 37°C. Movies of the fluctuating fluorescent microspheres were recorded onto the (large) random-access memory of a PC computer via a silicon-intensifier target camera (VE-100
Dage-MTI, Michigan City, IN) mounted on an inverted epifluorescence microscope (Eclipse TE300, Nikon, Melville, NY) (Leduc et al., 1999
). A
×100 Plan Fluor oil-immersion objective (N.A. 1.3) was used for
particle tracking, which permitted an ~5-nm spatial resolution over a
120-µm × 120-µm field of view, as assessed by monitoring the
apparent displacement of PS microspheres firmly attached to a glass
coverslip with the same microscope and camera settings as used during
the live-cell experiments. The thickness of the cell where microspheres
are located is much larger than the diameter of the probe microspheres.
Long-range interactions between the microspheres and the cell membrane
could occur via hydrodynamic interactions, but those interactions are
screened to within a mesh size of the cytoskeletal network, which is
~50 nm. The microspheres that we probe are not right at the cell
edge; for instance, microspheres are rarely located within filopodia.
The microspheres were allowed to diffuse throughout the cells
overnight. If the cell thickness were similar or smaller than the bead
diameter, they would be mostly excluded from those (too thin) areas.
Movies of fluctuating microspheres were analyzed by a custom MPT
routine incorporated into the software Metamorph (Universal Imaging
Corp., West Chester, PA) as described (Tseng and Wirtz, 2001
). The
displacements of the particle centroids were simultaneously monitored
in the focal plane of the microscope for 20 s at a rate of 30 frames per second. Between 12 and 42 particles per cell were tracked
for a total of ~120 microspheres. These cells were chosen to have a
similar shape and size as assessed by phase-contrast microscopy. Past
that number of microspheres and number of cells, the shape of the mean
squared displacement (MSD) distribution did not change with the number
of probed microspheres and cells. Individual time-averaged MSDs,

r2(
)
, where
is the
time lag, were calculated from the two-dimensional trajectories of the
centroids of the microspheres. We recently demonstrated that

r2(
)
is proportional to
the local compliance,
(
) = (
a/kBT)
r2(
)
,
of the specimen due to the small local force created by the fluctuating
microsphere (Xu et al., 1998a
). Here,
kB is Boltzmann's constant,
T is the absolute temperature of the specimen, and
a is the radius of the probe microsphere. From

r2(
)
data,
ensemble-averaged MSDs,


r2(
)
, compliance
values,
(
), diffusion coefficients, D(
), and
MSD distributions were computed.
Viscoelastic moduli from particle tracking
All of the mechanical information is contained in the amplitude
and the time-scale dependence of the compliance. However, for the sake
of completeness, frequency-dependent elastic modulus G'(
)
and loss modulus G"(
) were computed from
time-lag-dependent MSDs as described (Mason et al., 1997b
). Neglecting
inertial effects, which become important only at microsecond time
scales, and assuming that the fluid surrounding the probe particle is
incompressible, the viscoelastic spectrum G(s) is
approximately given by:
|

r2(s)
is the
unilateral Laplace transform of

r2(
)
. This Laplace
transform is computed over a limited range of time scales, which create
errors as large as 12% (Mason et al., 1997b
) and G"(
) are the real and imaginary
parts, respectively, of the complex modulus G*(
), which
is the projection of G(s) in Fourier space (Mason
et al., 1997b
r2(
)
and the local
viscoelasticity, consider the displacements of a microsphere in a
viscous liquid and in a Hookean solid, respectively. For a viscous
liquid such as water or glycerol, the MSD of a microsphere of radius
a in a liquid of viscosity
0 is
described by 
r2(
)
= 6D0
(particle diffusion in three
dimensions), where D0 = kBT/6
0a
is the constant diffusion coefficient of the microsphere (Berg, 1993
r2(s)
= 6D0/s2,
we obtain G(s) =
0s and the complex modulus is
G*(
) = i
0
. Therefore, G'(
) = Re(G*) = 0 and
G"(
) = Im(G*) =
0
, as expected for a viscous, nonelastic
liquid (Ferry, 1980
. Therefore,

r2(s)
= A/s where A = kBT/
G0a
is a constant, G(s) = G0 and G*(
) = G0. Hence, G'(
) = G0 and G"(
) = 0, as expected
for a Hookean solid that exhibits negligible viscosity (Ferry, 1980Fluorescent labeling of actin cytoskeleton
Fluorescence microscopy was used to illustrate the heterogeneous organization of cytoskeletal actin in Swiss 3T3 cells. Cells were fixed in 3% paraformaldehyde in PBS (Life Technologies), made permeable with 0.1% Triton X-100 (Sigma, St. Louis, MO) in PBS, and labeled with rhodamine phalloidin (Molecular Probes). Fluorescently labeled cells were observed with a ×100, oil-immersion objective (N.A. 1.3) mounted on a Nikon Eclipse TE300 inverted microscope. Images were acquired with an Orca II CCD camera (Hammamatsu, Bridgewater, NJ) controlled by the Metamorph software. Specimens were mounted in Antifade (Molecular Probes) to minimize photobleaching.
Phase-contrast and differential interference contrast microscopy
The subcellular organization and morphology of live cells were revealed using either phase-contrast microscopy via a ×100 oil-immersion Plan Fluor lens (N.A. 1.3) or differential interference contrast (DIC) microscopy via a ×60 oil-immersion Plan Apo lens (N.A. 1.4; Nikon). These lenses were mounted on a Nikon Eclipse TE300 inverted microscope. Images were acquired with an Orca II CCD camera (Hammamatsu) controlled by the Metamorph software (Universal Imaging Corp).
Protein purification and microinjection
-Actinin was purified from chicken smooth muscle as described
(Xu et al., 2000
). A 2-mg/ml
-actinin solution was injected into
living cells 1 h before the MPTM measurements following published methods (Freshney, 1994
). We estimate the final concentration of added
-actinin in the cells to be ~2 µM, which is smaller than the
total concentration of endogenous
-actinin. Cells without added
-actinin, which serve as controls, were examined via MPTM, then
microinjected with
-actinin, and reexamined 1 h after microinjection.
Nonspecific binding to microspheres
To asses the nonspecific binding of injected carboxylate- and amine-modified microspheres, we collected extracts of Swiss 3T3 cell lysates and incubated them for 24 h in the presence of the particles. The resulting suspensions were separated by centrifugation and analyzed by SDS-polyacrylamide gel electrophoresis and Pierce's bicinchoninic acid (BCA) protein assay kit. The BCA assay is used for the colorimetric detection and quantitation of total protein by monitoring the purple-colored reaction product of the well-known reduction product of Cu2+ to Cu1+ by protein in an alkaline medium (the Biuret reaction) using a unique reagent containing bicinchoninic acid (Pierce product 23225). A standard curve and equation for protein concentration versus absorbance was generated using the BCA kit on standard BSA samples of known concentration in concert with all unknown samples and plotting the measured absorbances at 562 nm against the known concentrations.
| |
RESULTS |
|---|
|
|
|---|
In this paper, we present a novel method, MPTM, to quantify the
micromechanical properties and the intrinsic degree of mechanical heterogeneity of Swiss 3T3 fibroblasts. We then apply MPTM to test
whether and how the F-actin cross-linking protein
-actinin affects
the mechanical properties of cytoplasm.
MPTM of living cells
The spatial variation of the mechanical properties of the
cytoplasm of Swiss 3T3 fibroblasts was assessed by statistically analyzing the distribution of displacements of microspheres imbedded in
cytoplasm. Fluorescently labeled, 0.1-µm-diameter carboxylated (negatively charged) PS microspheres were microinjected into 10 cells,
which after a 12-h incubation, dispersed throughout the cytoplasm. We
verified that the microinjection process did not affect normal cell
growth and division in all tested conditions, and after division,
daughter cells carried microspheres (data not shown). The centroids of
the microspheres were monitored via time-resolved video light
microscopy with ~5-nm spatial resolution and 33-ms temporal
resolution (Fig. 1 A). Fig. 1
B shows examples of 20-s-long trajectories of microspheres
localized to the lamella (a) and to the perinuclear region
(b) of a Swiss 3T3 fibroblast. We note that the shape of a
random walk is intrinsically anisotropic (Haber et al., 2000
; Berg,
1993
), and therefore, anisotropic features such as those displayed by
the trajectory of particle a does not necessarily mean that
nonstationary events (e.g., global cell motion and subcellular
streaming) are occurring during particle tracking (see more below). We
note that these cells were plated on PLL and can be considered immobile
during each 20-s movie capture. From the time-dependent coordinates
[x(t), y(t)] of each
microsphere, we computed the MSDs,

r2(
)
=
[x(t +
)
x(t)]2 + [y(t +
)
y(t)]2
, where
t is the elapsed time and
is the time lag or time scale (Tseng and Wirtz, 2001
; Apgar et al., 2000
). These MSDs were
transformed into time-scale-dependent compliance profiles, which
describe the potential for cytoplasm to deform when subjected to the
local force
kBT/a created by
the thermal fluctuation of the probe microsphere. The
time-lag-dependent compliance of the cytoplasm in the vicinity of the
microspheres a and b are shown in Fig. 1
C, which illustrates the variations in the mechanical
properties at different locations within the cytoplasm. The
distribution of local compliance measured at a time scale of 0.1 s
is shown for illustration in Fig. 1 D. This general
approach, particle nanotracking and computation of the cytoplasmic
compliance from the MSD, was automated to monitor and analyze the
motion of ~120 microspheres per tested condition. We tested the
effect of particle surface charge and size. These MSD profiles produced
mean compliance values, compliance distributions, and distributions of
local viscosity and elasticity.
|
Swiss 3T3 fibroblasts grown on PLL in the presence of serum displayed
extensive F-actin bundles as detected by fluorescence microscopy (Fig.
2 A), which are distributed
relatively heterogeneously throughout the cell (Hall, 1998
). Using the
methodology illustrated in Fig. 1, MSDs were collected in five cells
and pooled (Fig. 2 B). At small time scales, most MSD
profiles showed a quasi-plateau (defined here as a slower-than-linear
increase of the MSD). This behavior is a hallmark of elastic trapping,
whereby the microspheres are transiently prevented from readily
diffusing through the cytoplasm due to the nonzero elasticity of their
surrounding microenvironment. This effect is also observed when the
same (negatively charged) microspheres are imbedded in reconstituted
actin filament networks (Palmer et al., 1999
) and intermediate filament
networks in vitro (Ma et al., 2001
). At intermediate time scales, the
MSDs grew linearly with time (Fig. 2 B). This behavior,
characterized by 
r2(
)
~
, means that the interactions between the microspheres and their
subcellular microenvironment are mostly viscous as in the classical
Stokes-Einstein case. Finally, at long time scales (
10 s),
MSDs grew slightly faster than time, a signature of activated
transport, a behavior shown also by some outliers at earlier time
scales (Fig. 2 B). The ensemble averaged MSD weighted by the
number of microspheres per cell,


r2(
)
, adopted a
qualitatively similar profile (Fig. 2 D). This ensemble
averaged MSD characterizes the global mechanical response of the cells
and is used in our statistical analysis (see below). Mean MSDs were
calculated for each cell in which the number of probe microspheres
varied between 12 (cell 1) and 42 (cell 3) (Fig. 2 C).
Cell-to-cell variations of the mean MSD were relatively large and may
be due to the difference in the cell cycle coordination (Fig. 2
C). These results show that the cytoplasm of Swiss 3T3 fibroblasts plated on PLL in the presence of serum is mostly elastic at
short time scales and viscous at long time scales. This means that
these cells will elastically resist rapid shear deformations but not
slow deformations.
|
The mean effective diffusion coefficient, D(
), of the
microspheres was directly computed from


r2(
)
. The existence
of nonstationary effects during particle tracking is readily detected
by the shape of the MSD and is eliminated by curve fitting. To extract
the mean diffusion constant D, in which we are primarily
interested, and the mean directed velocity v of the
microspheres, the polynomial


r2(
)
= 4D
+ v2
2 was
fitted to the ensemble-averaged MSD


r2(
)
(Qian et al.,
1991
). This functional form contains both a random diffusion component,
4D
, which dominates at short time scales, and a
directed-transport contribution,
v2
2, which
dominates at long time scales. From the fit, we found an average
velocity of v
6 nm/s, which is much larger than the overall cell migration speed (data not shown). We note that, in contrast to conventional wisdom, the mean diffusion coefficient, D(
) = 

r2(
)
/4
(having
subtracted the directed transport component), was not constant and
strongly decreased with time before reaching a plateau at long time
scales (Fig. 2 D). This important result stems from the fact
that 

r2(
)
increased
less slowly than linearly with
. This
-dependence, 

r2(
)
~ 
where
< 1, describes a
subdiffusive behavior (Chaikin and Lubensky, 1995
; Saxton, 1994
), which
is presumably due to the elastic nature of the microfilament-rich
microenvironment in the vicinity of the microspheres (Yamada et al.,
2000
).
The local compliance,
(
), which describes the propensity of
cytoplasm to locally deform (i.e., the inverse of stiffness), is
directly proportional to the MSD (see Introduction). The
ensemble-averaged compliance (total number of tracked particles was
114), 
(
)
= (
a/kBT)

r2(
)
(corrected for directed transport as described above), which is the
mean of all measured compliance profiles, showed a slow increase up to
a time scale of
0.3 s (Fig. 2 D
inset). This weak time dependence of
(
) describes a
viscoelastic microenvironment. Past
0.3 s, the
compliance increased linearly with
(Fig. 2 D
inset), a signature of viscous behavior for which
(
) =
/
where
is the viscosity (Ferry, 1980
). The
distribution of compliance values measured at a time scale of 0.1 s was wide (Fig. 2 E) and further widened at long time
scales (Fig. 2 F). We shall show below how to rigorously
analyze the shape of compliance distributions to quantify the degree of
micromechanical heterogeneity of cytoplasm. But we first investigate
the effect of particle surface charge and size on the apparent
subcellular compliance.
Effect of particle surface charge and size
We probed the dependence of the apparent subcellular compliance and its distributions on particle size and surface charge. First, we compared the MSD profiles and compliance distributions obtained using 0.2-µm-diameter carboxylated microspheres with the measurements described above, which were obtained using 0.1-µm-diameter carboxylated microspheres. The MSD profiles of the larger particles (Fig. 3 A) were qualitatively similar to those obtained with the smaller particles (Fig. 2 B; compliance is proportional to MSD). Here again, most MSD profiles displayed a quasi-plateau at short times scales and a linear increase at long time scales. As expected, however, the amplitude of the MSD and associated diffusion coefficients (Fig. 4 C) of the larger particles were smaller than those of the smaller particles. The ensemble-averaged compliance profiles corresponding to the two radii overlapped over the entire tested time range, a result that is expected when the microspheres do not modify the local mechanical properties of the cell and do not directly interact with their surrounding microenvironment (see more in Discussion). Similarly to the 0.1-µm particles, cell-to-cell variations of the mean compliance measured by the 0.2-µm particles were relatively large (Fig. 4 A). Moreover, the distributions of compliance obtained with the 0.2-µm probes were similar to those obtained with the 0.1-µm probes (Fig. 5 A and Fig. 2, E and F). Finally, the shape of the compliance distributions was similar: the relative contributions of the highest compliance values to the mean cytoplasmic compliance for the 0.2-µm and 0.1-µm microspheres were nearly identical (Fig. 6; see more below). Amine-modified microspheres and carboxylated microspheres, which were embedded in cytoplasm via endocytosis, also displayed directed motion. Hence, endocytosis cannot be used to introduce beads to probe cell mechanics (data not shown).
|
|
|
|
To further asses the nonspecific binding of injected carboxylate- and
amine-modified microspheres, we collected cell lysate extracts and
incubated them for 24 h in the presence of the particles. The
resulting suspensions were separated by centrifugation and analyzed by
SDS-polyacrylamide gel electrophoresis (not shown here) and the Pierce
BCA protein assay kit. Using ~3.6 × 1013
particles per experiment, we found that in the presence of cell lysates, the carboxylate-modified particles bound ~7.2 × 10
14 µg of protein/particle whereas
amine-modified particles bound ~1.07 × 10
12 µg of protein/particle. Considering
actin as a model protein (~43 kDa), the mass of one actin molecule is
7.14 × 10
14 µg; thus, the
carboxylate-modified particles bound only 1 actin molecule per
microsphere, and the amine-modified microspheres each bound an average
of 15 actin molecules.
The shape of the compliance profiles obtained using positively charged amine-modified microspheres was dramatically different both at short and long time scales from those observed with negatively charged particles. First, the extent of the displacements was much smaller at short time scales, which suggests the existence of strong interactions between the positively charged microspheres and their microenvironment (Figs. 3 B and 4 B). Second, at long time scales, the MSD rapidly grew faster than time, a strong evidence that amine-modified microspheres underwent saltatory directed motion (Figs. 3 B and 4 B). Indeed, positively charged particles often underwent bursts of directed, nonrandom motion through the cytoplasm (Fig. 3 C), possibly due to coupling of the microspheres to microtubule-based motor proteins. This type of large and rapid unidirectional intracellular movements were absent when negatively charged particles were used. Fitting of the apparent diffusion coefficient yielded directed (nonrandom) velocities that were on average ~20 times higher than found with negatively charged particles. Due to this effect, the compliance distribution measured with positively charged, amine-modified particles was wide and skewed as measured by the bin distributions (Figs. 5 B and 6; see more below). These results suggest that a positively charged surface promotes nonrandom saltatory motion, which prevents the rigorous computation of the cytoplasmic compliance, at least at long time scales (see more in Discussion).
Degree of micromechanical heterogeneity
We observed relatively large cell-to-cell variations, but the
shape of the compliance distribution did not vary when compliance values of more than four cells were pooled. To quantify the dispersion of the local compliance, we analyzed the compliance distribution in
terms of bin distributions. The direct comparison of the shape of
distributions that have different means may be somewhat misleading when
one only considers absolute statistical parameters such as skewness and
standard deviation. Therefore, we introduced markers to quantify the
relative degree of micromechanical heterogeneity of the cytoplasm of
living cells: the relative contributions of the 10%, 25%, and 50%
highest compliance values to the mean compliance (Fig. 6). These
contributions should be exactly 10%, 25%, and 50% for a perfectly
homogeneous liquid, which is what we observed when 0.1-µm-diameter,
carboxylated PS microspheres were dispersed in a homogenous aqueous
solutions of glycerol (Fig. 6 inset). These markers should
become close to 100% in a highly heterogeneous milieu, which is
observed, for instance, in a highly heterogeneous actin filament
network in the presence of a high concentration of the F-actin
cross-linking protein
-actinin (Tseng and Wirtz, 2001
) and fascin
(Apgar et al., 2000
) and in concentrated DNA solutions (Goodman et al.,
2002
). Here, we found that the contributions of the 10%, 25%, and
50% highest-compliance values to the mean compliance of live cells
were nearly identical when probed with particles of diameters 0.1 µm
and 0.2 µm. This further suggests that carboxylated beads do not
affect the mechanical properties and their distributions in live cells.
These contributions were more than twice as high as measured in
glycerol (Fig. 6 inset), which is expected given the
heterogeneous nature of the actin cytoskeleton (Fig. 2 A), a
major contributor to cell viscoelasticity (Yamada et al., 2000
). These
bin contributions were, however, much lower than observed with the
positively charged probes (Fig. 6). Therefore, our results show that
not only the amplitude of the mean compliance but also the relative
distribution of compliance values did not vary with particle size for
negatively charged microspheres.
Viscoelastic moduli of living cells
To further analyze the mechanical heterogeneity of cytoplasm, MSD
traces were transformed into frequency-dependent viscoelastic moduli
using Laplace transformation (Mason et al., 1997b
; Xu et al., 1998a
).
The time lag dependence of the compliance of a viscoelastic fluid
reflects the local viscoelastic properties of that fluid.
(
) ~
for a purely viscous liquid (e.g., water),
(
) = constant for a purely elastic solid (e.g., steel), and
(
) ~ 
with 0 <
< 1 for a
viscoelastic material (e.g., F-actin networks (Palmer et al., 1999
)).
Here, each
(
) trace was transformed into a frequency-dependent
elastic modulus G'(
) and viscous modulus G"(
) =
(
)/
where
(
) is the dynamic
viscosity (see Materials and Methods). As expected from the compliance
data, we found that elastic and viscous moduli were frequency dependent
(Fig. 7) and displayed large local
variations (bars in Fig. 7, A and B). For comparison, the viscosity of a glycerol standard (nominal viscosity 1 P), which is homogeneous, only varies between 0.92 and 1.08 P (Apgar et
al., 2000
); the elastic modulus of a 1-mg/ml F-actin solution varies
between 15 and 25 dyn/cm2 (at 1 rad/s) (Palmer et
al., 1999
). The cytoplasm behaved like a viscoelastic solid when
subjected to high rates of deformations (second columns in Fig. 7,
A and B). In contrast, as the compliance grew
almost linearly with time at long time scales, the loss modulus became
larger than the elastic modulus at low deformation frequencies. This
means that the cytoplasm behaved like a viscoelastic liquid when
subjected to low rates of deformations (first columns in Fig. 7,
A and B).
|
MPT mapping of the physical properties of cytoplasm
The physical properties of cytoplasm were mapped to specific regions within cytoplasm by combining MPTM and conventional DIC microscopy or phase-contrast microscopy. DIC microscopy shows the morphology of Swiss 3T3 fibroblast plated on PLL with superior contrast (Fig. 8); phase-contrast microscopy reveals the position of the microspheres with respect to intracellular organelles and nuclear/plasma membranes (Fig. 9, A and B). For each measurement, probe microspheres were microinjected 12 h before the MPT measurements, a time that allowed the microspheres to disperse throughout the cytoplasm (Figs. 8 and 9). To show variations in the physical properties of a single fibroblast plated on a PLL substratum, the measured compliance values were normalized by the maximum value and color-coded according to their amplitude between 0 and 1 (Fig. 9). Subcellular regions of small compliance (i.e., high stiffness) were color-coded blue, whereas regions of high compliance were color-coded red (Figs. 8 and 9 A).
|
|
MPTM data can be further analyzed by computing the compliance as a function of the relative position (0.0 < rrel < 1.0) of each particle with respect to the nuclear and cell membranes (Fig. 9 B). Here, rrel = 0.0 denotes the nuclear membrane and rrel = 1.0 denotes the plasma membrane as detected by phase-contrast microscopy. By using conventional phase-contrast and MPTM in concert, one can investigate the variations of the local compliance as a function of both time scale and the relative position of the microspheres in the subcellular region between the nuclear membrane and the cell surface (Fig. 9 C). By pooling compliance data of four randomly selected cells, we found that the perinuclear region, here defined as the subcellular region for which 0.0 < rrel < 0.25, was typically more compliant (i.e., less stiff) than the lamella, here defined as the subcellular region for which 0.25 < rrel < 1.0 (Fig. 9, D and D').
-Actinin enhances the stiffness and micromechanical
heterogeneity of cytoplasm: a direct demonstration
Using MPTM, we can directly assess the effect of F-actin
cross-linking proteins on the mechanical behavior of non-muscle cells by adding exogenous
-actinin to cytoplasm. The F-actin
cross-linking/bundling protein
-actinin is known to enhance the
stiffness of F-actin networks in vitro (Xu et al., 1998b
; Wachsstock et
al., 1993
; Grazi et al., 1993
), a result that has not been directly
tested in living cells. Here, we test this model of
-actinin-mediated stiffening in living cells by microinjecting
purified
-actinin into control cells and subsequently using MPTM.
Following the method presented in Figs. 1 and 2, we monitored the
trajectories of a large number of 0.1-µm-diameter carboxylated PS
microspheres and analyzed the time scale dependence and amplitude of
the corresponding compliance profiles (Fig.
10 A). Mock injection of PBS
led to no significant change in both the mean and distribution of MSDs, i.e., no change in the micromechanical properties of the cells (data
not shown). The extent of the displacements of the probe microspheres
imbedded in cells microinjected with
-actinin was typically
significantly smaller than in control cells (Fig. 10 A).
Globally, the time dependence of the compliance was slightly less
pronounced than the controls (Fig. 10 B). The extent of the short-time-scale quasi-plateau of the average compliance was slightly enhanced, which suggests that filaments were (partially) prevented to
move for longer time scales than in the control cells (Fig. 10,
A and B). Cytoplasmic compliance was also greatly
decreased; i.e.,
-actinin induced a dramatic stiffening of
cytoplasm, particularly at low rates of shear (Fig. 10, A
and B).
|
Moreover, the distribution of compliance values in
-actinin-microinjected cells was much more skewed than in control
cells. Bin-partition analysis indeed showed that the contributions of the 10%, 25%, and 50% highest-compliance values were significantly higher than those displayed by the control cells (Fig. 10
C).
-Actinin-injected cells displayed F-actin staining
that was more intense but not obviously more heterogeneously
distributed than in control cells (not shown).
| |
DISCUSSION |
|---|
|
|
|---|
MPTM, a new functional microscopy
We have introduced a new functional microscopy, MPTM, which probes
the local micromechanics of living cells. To the best of our knowledge,
no other approach delivers the instantaneous mapping of the local
mechanical properties of a cell. Other cell-mechanics approaches either
require detachment of the cell from its substrate (e.g., micropipette
suctions), do not measure frequency-dependent moduli (e.g., AFM
(Radmacher et al., 1994
)), or do not probe local properties (e.g.,
magnetocytometry (Wang and Ingber, 1995
)). MPTM measures not only the
mean cytoplasmic stiffness but also its subcellular distribution. This
approach is based on the statistical analysis of the MSDs of particles
distributed throughout the cytoplasm. Because they constitute a
relative marker, bin contributions of the compliance distributions can
be compared directly with those obtained in reconstituted cytoskeletal
networks or in other cells. MPT complements existing biophysical
approaches, including light and electron microscopy, by quantifying the
micromechanical heterogeneity in living cells. This paper focused on
Swiss 3T3 fibroblasts and showed that the viscoelastic moduli of these
cells depend on the frequency of the deformation. We further explored
the capabilities of MPTM by mapping the micromechanical properties of
the (soft) perinuclear region and the (stiffer) lamella of Swiss 3T3
fibroblasts. Finally, using MPTM, we demonstrated for the first time
that the cross-linking protein
-actinin could stiffen the
cytoskeleton and regulate its degree of heterogeneity in a manner
identical to in vitro systems.
We found that the cytoplasm of fibroblasts behaves generally like a
stiff elastic material when deformed rapidly and like a soft viscous
liquid when deformed slowly. This behavior qualitatively matches the
viscoelastic behavior of reconstituted actin filament networks in the
presence of cross-linking proteins (Sato et al., 1987
; Wachsstock et
al., 1994
; Bray and White, 1988
; Xu et al., 2000
). This viscoelastic
behavior is particularly well suited to regulate cell migration (Bray,
2001
). Activated processes, including the dendritic nucleation of actin
at the leading edge and the contraction of the actomyosin machinery at
the trailing edge of a motile cell, dominate the dynamics of
cytoskeleton at the periphery. Those fast processes create large
dynamic deformations of the cortical cytoskeleton, which generate
membrane protrusions at the cell periphery and contractions at the
trailing edge. Our results suggest that the cytoplasm will resist quick
subcellular deformations such as those generated when the cell body,
pushed and pulled by its dynamical periphery, crawls rapidly on its
underlying substratum. Vice versa, the cytoplasm will soften in a
slowly moving cell subjected to slow subcellular deformations, which in
turn would enhance cell movement. This autoregulating mechanism for
cell motion, the cytoplasm being stiff when the cell moves rapidly and
soft when the cell moves slowly, consumes no energy because it is
entirely passive.
We tested positively and negatively charged surfaces, using amine
modification and carboxylation. In aqueous solutions, the carboxylate
group displays a low nucleophilicity, and chemical groups that
specifically react with carboxylic acids are rare. The carboxylated
surface is also highly hydrophilic, which provides an ineffective
surface for protein adsorption via hydrophobic interactions.
Carboxylated microspheres have successfully been used to probe the
local micromechanical properties of gels and networks. Quantitative
agreement between particle tracking and diffusing wave
spectroscopy microrheological methods using carboxylated microspheres and macrorheological measurements using a rheometer has
been shown for a wide variety of complex fluids and cytoskeletal arrays
in vitro. These include gliadin suspensions (Xu et al., 2002
),
concentrated DNA solutions (Mason et al., 1997a
,b
), aqueous solutions
of polyethylene oxide (Mason et al., 1997b
), poly(vinyl alcohol)
aqueous solutions and chemically cross-linked gels (Narita et al.,
2001
), and actin filament networks over a large range of concentrations
(Palmer et al., 1999
). In contrast, many reactive groups are able to
couple to amine-containing molecules. These reactions occur via
acylation or alkylation and are often rapid, forming stable primary
amide or secondary amine bonds (Hermanson, 1996
). Our MPTM data at
short time scales indeed suggest that the amine-modified microspheres
used in our experiments are tightly bound to cytoplasmic structures,
which artificially reduces the extent of the displacements at short
time scales. Similar results were obtained with microspheres that were
deposited on the apical surface of cells and allowed to undergo endocytosis.
MPT offers numerous advantages over single-particle video and laser
deflection tracking, recently introduced to probe the local
viscoelastic properties of complex fluids (Mason et al., 1997b
; Yamada
et al., 2000
; Gittes et al., 1997
). Single-particle tracking, which
measures local viscoelastic properties one particle at a time, is
unsuitable to monitor fast spatiotemporal reorganization of the
cytoskeleton, during, for instance, cell migration or cell division
(Tseng et al., 2002
). Figs. 8 and 9 show that MPTM is able to provide a
global picture of the local stiffness of a single cell, a feat that
cannot be achieved by single-particle tracking. Moreover, MPTM provides
quantitative markers of the degree of mechanical heterogeneity of
cytoplasm. Laser deflection particle tracking can probe only a very
limited range of displacements, ~0.4 µm (Mason et al., 1997b
;
Yamada et al., 2000
), which prevents mechanical measurement at low
frequencies (or long time scales), frequencies that are relevant to
important cellular activities, including cell migration and cell
spreading. Instead, MPTM probes more physiologically relevant (low)
frequencies, over a large field of view, while preserving a superior
spatial resolution.
The moduli of Swiss 3T3 fibroblasts measured here by MPTM were similar
to those of COS7 cells measured by laser deflection single-particle
tracking (Yamada et al., 2000
). Moduli measured by AFM and the
micropipette aspiration method tend to be higher, but these techniques
may probe different mechanical properties (Hoh and Schoenenberger,
1994
; Davies et al., 1997
). Micropipette aspiration methods, in
particular, measure the global properties of cells, mostly subjected to
large deformations. AFM can probe the local elasticity of cytoplasm
(Rotsch et al., 1997
; Domke et al., 1999
; Matzke et al., 2001
) but does
not measure the frequency response of the cell, and current rates of
scanning prevent measurement of the global cellular response to rapid
cellular activities.
Given the fact that the magnitude of moduli measured in Swiss 3T3
fibroblasts by MPTM and in COS7 cells by laser deflection particle
tracking are similar, we focus our discussion on the degree of
mechanical heterogeneity. We reanalyzed the compliance distributions
obtained in COS7 using endogenous organelles as local viscoelastic
markers (Yamada et al., 2000
). We find that the contributions of the
10%, 25%, and 50% highest compliance values to the mean compliance
is 31%, 42%, and 69% at a time scale of 0.1 s. These
contributions are remarkably similar to those found in Swiss 3T3
fibroblasts grown in similar conditions, which further supports the use
of exogenous carboxylated microspheres as markers of cytoplasmic viscoelasticity.
Besides probing the mechanical function of actin cross-linking proteins
as shown in this paper, MPTM opens a realm of possibilities. Live-cell
MPTM can be applied to quantify the degree of polarization of
intracellular viscoelasticity in migrating cells subjected to
chemoattractant gradients (Parent and Devreotes, 1999
) or in the
polarized cells of complex epithelia (Coulombe et al., 2000
), two
systems our group is currently investigating using MPTM. MPTM can be
used to probe the micromechanical heterogeneity of cells subjected to
extracellular factors (e.g., growth factors and lysophosphatidic acid) and various extracellular-matrix substrata (e.g.,
fibronectin and collagen), which cause cytoskeletal network
reorganization by the activation of small GTPases (Burridge and
Chrzanowska-Wodnicka, 1996
). MPTM can also be used to monitor the
spatiotemporal mechanical response of cells subjected to mechanical
gradients of the substratum (Lo et al., 2000
).
Mechanical function of
-actinin: a direct live-cell
demonstration
The effect of
-actinin on F-actin network mechanics has been
studied extensively in vitro.
-Actinin has been shown to enhance the
elasticity of reconstituted F-actin networks (Wachsstock et al., 1993
;
Grazi et al., 1993
) while increasing their degree of heterogeneity
(Tseng et al., 2001
; Tempel et al., 1996
). To the best of our
knowledge, however, no work has directly quantified the effect of
-actinin on the mechanical properties of live adherent cells. Here,
using MPTM, we demonstrate that
-actinin can regulate the local and
global mechanical behavior of fibroblasts. Exploiting the fact that
MPTM provides local information, we find that the distribution of
compliance in
-actinin-microinjected cells is significantly
different from the control. Unlike MPTM, fluorescent staining of
F-actin does not clearly determine that the increase in mechanical
heterogeneity is due to
-actinin-mediated reorganization of the
F-actin network. This shows that although fluorescence microscopy is
very useful to document gross features of the cytoskeleton, it is
unsuitable to quantify the cytoplasmic degree of mechanical heterogeneity. Our live-cell MPTM measurements corroborate previous rheological and particle-tracking measurements conducted in vitro, which show that
-actinin enhances the elasticity (Sato et al., 1987
)
and the degree of heterogeneity of reconstituted F-actin networks
(Tseng et al., 2001
). Our measurements also support previous demonstrations of the
structural and mechanical functions of
-actinin (Pavalko and Burridge, 1991
; Rivero et al., 1999
). Our MPTM
measurements in living cells therefore suggest that reconstituted networks constitute useful models of F-actin networks in non-muscle cells. Our results also suggest that different levels of expression of
-actinin would directly enhance the stiffness of cells and therefore
affect their shape and propensity to deform during cell-migratory events. Following up on the present work, we recently found that an
equimolar mixture of
-actinin and the actin cross-linking/bundling protein fascin synergistically produced F-actin structures that were
significantly stiffer than cells microinjected with
-actinin and
fascin separately (Tseng et al., unpublished results).
| |
ACKNOWLEDGMENTS |
|---|
We acknowledge financial support from the National Science Foundation (CTS0072278 and NIRT CTS0210718) and NASA through a graduate training grant (T.P.K.).
| |
FOOTNOTES |
|---|
Address reprint requests to Dr. Denis Wirtz, Department of Chemical Engineering, Maryland Hall 221, The Johns Hopkins University, 3400 N. Charles St., Baltimore, MD 21218. Tel.: 410-516-7006; Fax: 410-516-5510; E-mail: wirtz{at}jhu.edu.
Submitted March 18, 2002, and accepted for publication September 30, 2002.
Y. Tseng and T. P. Kole contributed equally to this paper.
| |
REFERENCES |
|---|
|
|
|---|